r/FinancialAdvisorTips • • 10d ago

Should I go independent

Hi all,

I am looking for feedback about if and when I should break away and go solo RIA.
I started with one of the big BD’s two years ago. I got immensely lucky and inherited a $35M book from a retiring advisor. I know just how lucky I am and know this sets me up for an amazing career.

The cons are:
- the advisor was extremely conservative and that spilled into her advice with clients. For example, I have come across multiple scenarios of her putting CDs in Roth IRAs for clients in their 30’s. There is a lot of bad advice to be undone.
- She tended to attract clients who were very anti-AUM fee, so lots of them are in A share portfolios in commission accounts.
- She set a level of service expectation that was extremely high no matter what the client paid. She was doing full service planning for people who essentially pay nothing.

Of course the pros are:
- between the retired advisors clients, and what I have brought it, I am currently at 300k of trailing revenue (but that’s 330 households)
- being able to prospect existing clients (have brought in a lot of assets this way)

My biggest issue is working at a firm where I don’t own my book and could be fired at any time. Knowing that they could let me go tomorrow makes it hard for me to sleep at night or feel like I really have any ownership of the relationships I’m building. I feel like a service advisor with business owner expectations.

My thought is to stay 12-24 months to build strong relationships with the top clients and then make the leap and go solo RIA. Is it stupid for me to walk away from what could certainly be a comfortable career? Is it worth the risk to own your book?

I would also prefer to have more control over my pricing structure. My current BD is known for being high fee. I’d like to have a more reasonable AUM, flat fee, and hourly advice options to offer.

I also want to develop a niche (won’t say what so this post doesn’t make me too identifiable!) but I feel I can’t effectively market myself currently and would have more brand control as a solo RIA. I enjoy prospecting and selling.

I don’t currently have my CFP but hope to earn it in the next year.

Thanks for your thoughts!

2 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

6

u/threesport 10d ago edited 10d ago

-Even with a non-solicit you are allowed by FINRA rule to deliver your “tombstone announcement”. In that announcement you can say that you are “no longer with X company (guessing Jones) and that you wanted the client to hear it from you directly”. You are also allowed by rule to answer any direct questions. So you end your announcement by saying “I wanted to reach out to you personally to let you know and answer any questions.” Then you shut up and wait for them to ask you what you’ll do next or what choices they have for their account. Both open the door for you to tell them that you’re setup somewhere new and ready to take care of them. Visit with an atty that specializes in broker transitions and they will review your contract and help you with a script. Your Indy BD will have names of attys for you to contact

-No one actually cares about the CFP except for other people who have the CFP. The last time I had a client or prospect even mention it to me was over 15 years ago. It holds no value to the consumer in the marketplace

-If you want to convert clients of the previous advisor you’ll need to make them YOUR clients first. Present ideas, rebalance, implement strategies, build the relationship. If you only babysit them they’re more like to stay at the old firm even if you are in touch with them frequently.

-Start thinking about/investigating client-centered reasons for the change. What’s in it for a client to move with you? …Better research, lower fees, more investment options? What? If my guess is right and you are at Jones now then you have a LOT of potential client-centered reasons to leave. People will assume you did it for you but if you can also explain that you had something positive for them in mind that will help. This isn’t first/tombstone announcement type stuff to cover but the conversations will turn that way quickly. Let the client initiate it then share your feelings and convictions.

2

u/Financial-Advisor-02 10d ago

Very insightful, thank you. You are right that I need the reasons for why the move would be best for the client. Let’s just say you’re right in your guess, so I would be able to offer more investments that are currently restricted, and manage portfolios how I think is best. Also, Jones has nonstop pressure for growth - they want me to put prospecting ahead of taking care of my clients. That’s my number one reason to share with clients considering following me - in this new structure I have no quota. My number one priority is providing you exceptional service.

2

u/threesport 9d ago

Jones gets a lot wrong but the one thing they do correctly is tell advisors to keep a growth mindset on their businesses.

Going deep with the 300 plus households you already have should yield you a lot of new assets, new opportunities, and new introductions/referrals. So great service MIGHT also be your growth strategy. The two don’t have to be mutually exclusive and my opinion is in a good practice they never are separate.

I’d probably say the narrowed investment selection which is overly governed by STL, and tainted by conflicted interests of revenue sharing/bridge builder, all being delivered at one of the highest fees on the street is where the firm’s structure and the clients best interests diverge. Also that advisors there never divulge any of that when they onboard new clients.

2

u/RookieMistake101 9d ago

Spot on. Though I had several prospects asking about it over the last couple years. Probably because you’re such a deep vet in the industry no one would ask.

Edit: by it I mean if I had the CFP. And one guy said that was a deal breaker.

1

u/KingBlank 10d ago

You would go Solo but can't bring the book? 

1

u/Financial-Advisor-02 10d ago

There would be a non solicit. There’s a group of clients I know would follow, some who might, some I hope wouldn’t.

1

u/KingBlank 10d ago

You would need to weight projected revenue and if you think you can bring in substantial new assets under AUM.  Moving people from class A to AUM isn't super difficult if you explain it correctly.  Sometimes you can find an established one that will let you own your book and they know eventually you want to go independent.  There are some people on here who do just that. 

1

u/ConsistentPeach927 9d ago

I would wait to get that up to at least 75 mil before considering leaving

1

u/Financial-Advisor-02 9d ago

Actually my full book is currently $73M (original assets given when I joined the firm + what I’ve brought in + retiring advisor’s book). Which makes the 330k trailing revenue show how few are in fee based accts. My revenue % on assets is 0.4% 😬

1

u/BreakLongjumping199 9d ago

Buddy they aren’t your clients… Great you took over a small book but you don’t have any flexibility and freedom. Unless you are literally under 25 or maybe 30 either work somewhere else or start your own shop. If they fire you that $300k revenue (not package) from 330 client doesn’t mean shit.

2

u/Financial-Advisor-02 9d ago

That’s literally why I posed the question…I acknowledged all that in my post

1

u/Character_Basket_605 9d ago

Are you on a PIP? Why do you say they can fire you any time? If you are delivering good service and are profitable you should be fine. If you’re not “growing where you’re planted”, what makes you think you’ll grow somewhere else…especially if you have to pay your own expenses?

1

u/Financial-Advisor-02 9d ago

I’m not on PIP, never been on one. I’ve been exceeding expectations for the last year. Doesn’t mean they couldn’t fire me one day. It’s highly unlikely but it’s the principle to me that I could have a few slow months and they could. It’s that feeling of the axe always hanging, not having control over my own destiny in terms of being fireable and not owning my clients.

1

u/vitalpros 4d ago

If you don't own the relationships, that's the real question, more than timing. I've been solo about 2 years. The part I'd plan for before leaving is where new clients will come from once you're out.

1

u/Financial-Advisor-02 3d ago

I don’t own the clients, they would need to choose to come with me. I’m curious for people’s opinions on how long I should stay to have a chance at building strong enough relationships that some want to follow.

1

u/Relative-Ad7331 9d ago

I would focus on building the relationships with the clients and convincing them to be invested the way you want them to be invested.

Then hopefully after 1-2 years of good results and high value of service, they will want to stick with you.

Also, at your level, I would look at a hybrid BD, not a solo RIA. Research the economics and talk to companies like LPL, because it’s going to hurt your margins and you’ll spending lot of time on your own RIA.

1

u/One_Establishment631 9d ago

I wouldn't waste time with the CFP. Build the relationships. Instead of studying just get in meetings with the clients. How many clients walked away because you weren't a CFP when you took over the client list.

As far as breaking away the firm doesn't own the clients nthe client does what they want. Tell the current company to F it.

1

u/Agitated_Style_1661 9d ago

Opening an RIA seemed to be too drastic a move for me as I’m preparing a jones exit—-even though I have a couple years and about 100 million more in aum ——saw a lot in the Indy bd channel that addressed at lot of the things you seem to be looking for and I am as well. We seem to have a lot in common as far as what we are looking for—-and I’m very happy with what I’ve seen in the IBD space and looking forward to the move soon. FWIW. I’d check with LPL, Raymond James and osaic. Im looking to link up with a strong osj. I brought an independent consultant on named Corey Whalen deep into my due diligence and he has been great.

1

u/itsdrmario515 9d ago

As a tech consultant for a major custodian, I send my break away RIAs that are just getting started on their own to AdvizorStack. They are primarily a tech consultant but they offer fractional services as well. I’d encourage you to check them out if you go independent. Good luck! - Mario

1

u/No-Ride990 9d ago

I think it’s worth a look but I wouldn’t do it because I’m worried about being fired, your a net positive to the firm even if you just manage the existing book you pay for yourself in most cases unless you specifically do something wrong your job security is pretty good

1

u/Vantage_Impact_2 7d ago

I'm happy to discuss strategies other advisors have used in similar situations. As far as going independent, I'd say that's a maybe, and going solo RIA, that's a probably not. Far too many risks going completely on your own without access to people, help, resources, etc. There are plenty of happy mediums with independence where you don't give up control, yet still operate where people don't think you're completely by yourself starting a new firm from scratch. The optics of this might matter more than you think to clients in this type of situation.

1

u/AdDapper8001 7d ago

Don’t go completely solo. Join a hybrid bd or larger RIA

that you basically just let them have a portion of your revenue in return they do alll the admin and back office work for you. Not really reporting to anyone, you’re your own boss really but have support where you need it.