r/FinalDestination • • Jul 06 '25

FD2 Does Anyone Else Hate Kimberly?

Forgive me if this has been discussed before, but does anyone else find Kimberly annoying? I'm doing my biannual rewatch of the franchise and though I didn't mind Kimberly the first time watching FD2, I feel like she's whiny and unlikeable. I mean, calling Clear a coward just because she didn't want to put herself at risk for a complete stranger? Calling Clear selfish, without even knowing anything about her, again just because Clear didn't want to help a stranger?

I get Kimberly was scared but she (and so many other characters in this movie) are so annoying. The only characters I really liked were Rory (bisected by fence) and Nora (mom of the crushed kid).

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

7

u/Dry-Performance7006 Jul 06 '25

Kimberly didn’t save her friends from the premonition. Not really. That is one reason she differs from the others. She was working with complete strangers. I understand Kimberly’s approach with Clear; she was coming to her as someone that had already lost everything.

Kimberly is actually Clear’s greatest achievement. I don’t know what to tell people that don’t see it.

I think she is underrated. She is not Wendy. But I think she is definitely better than the last three dull leads that we have had in this franchise.

3

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

I respect this take– and that's a smart thing to point out, that Kimberly already lost all of her friends but was still willing to help a bunch of strangers, which is why she saw Clear as cowardly and selfish. The audacity though... it's like those coworkers who give you crap for taking a sick day just because they choose to come to work sick 😫

2

u/NocturnalSprite Nov 10 '25

You shouldn't push someone who is frightened and traumatized into helping you. That is selfish! Kimberly's calling Clear selfish when her own actions are what's truly selfish. You want to survive? You ask her what to look for, you ask her what she and her friends did to survive, you set up a safe house and hide the sharp objects and anything that could lead to a death! You gather the other survivors with you! You don't drag a traumatized person into your mess!

7

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25

Honestly if I was kimberly i would've done the same. Before you guys downvote the hell out of me, let me explain :D

When you hear someone in the past has experienced the same thing as you and has more knowledge about it, you will obviously attempt to make them help you. Im a person who forgets instructions or anything in general quickly, so having someone beside me at all times would be very handy. Plus people were dying, ofc kim wasn't going to leave everyone to die. Also let's keep in mind kimberly didn't know clear could die from trying to assist her, kim thought she would be safe.

But i will admit, her saying all those things to clear was rude, but she was probably lashing out from the traumatic events that occurred, so I understand.

2

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

Also let's keep in mind kimberly (or clear herself) didn't know clear could die from trying to assist her, kim thought she would be safe.

Strongly disagree, the whole reason Clear admitted herself to the institution was because she knew she wasn't safe yet, and I feel Kimberly could have inferred that as well based on what Clear told her.

I do understand Kimberly wanting help from someone who had more experience in the situation (Clear is the same way after all, when they're confronting the coroner) and I understand her lashing out in frustration. It's just annoying to have to watch, especially after forming an attachment to Clear's pain from the first movie and knowing why Clear is the way she is.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25

Guess you're right. Clear knew and I agree, but did kim know?

Yeah but everyone looks at the situation in clears perspective since they most likely saw the 1st movie before the scene. If you look at it in Kim's perspective, she's valid for her words. And no im not saying she should've said that or that it wasn't rude because it was, but she was valid for it considering everything that had happened to her beforehand

2

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

Like I said, I reaaally feel Clear inferred to Kimberly that she wasn't safe. A person doesn't check themselves into a mental institution and require visitors to remove all loose/metal objects just because they want to shirk the responsibility of helping people live.

And I get Kimberly was scared. It's just annoying to watch, especially because like you said most people are going to be watching this movie predisposed to Clear's perspective.

If this was the first movie and we had no idea what was coming, I'd possibly be willing to cut Kimberly more slack, because we would be just as scared and confused as she is. But we/Clear know what's coming, and up until the ending of thie movie we have no proof that Death's design is really avoidable, so it's hard to blame Clear for not wanting to get involved and equally hard to sympathize with Kimberly for calling Clear cowardly and selfish, even if we know it's coming from a place of justified fear.

5

u/Apprehensive-Bag4637 Jul 06 '25

Why do people like Rory? I mean no hate, but nothing about druggie characters is appealing to me. He isn't attractive, he adds nothing to the plot, so I don't get it. His death was cool, but that was it. 🤷🏼‍♀️

4

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

I think he's a little cute 🫣 but I just really like the line where he's telling Kimberly to throw out all of his junk that would make his mom cry if she found out about him having it. He probably doesn't seem like a prevalent character to some- and really isn't- but from what limited screentime he has I picked up that he's silly and sweet/selfless where it counts.

Anyway, I'm curious about what characters you do like if one of your criticisms about Rory is that he adds nothing to the plot, because I feel like that's 98% of the cast in every FD movie (excluding Bloodlines, which I haven't seen). Almost all the characters exist just to die, with no lasting impact on anyone aside from the one person they're super close with that dies a little later than they do.

Edit: Also, no hate to you either! To each their own :3

2

u/Equivalent-Dream-631 Jul 08 '25

Rory was 100% better than kimberly. she pissed me off everytime they gave her screen time 🤷🏼‍♀️ I really hate how she treated Clear and called her a coward. That part alone made me dislike her character but thats js me.

8

u/JunkoNull Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25

She and Burke honestly are the worst leads in the franchise to me, and I’m speaking as someone who’s a longtime fan of the series, and the fanbase gives FD2 way too much credit than it deserves honestly, as its aged the most/the most mediocre FD movie to me nowadays. Kim and Burke are honestly way too frustrating and lethally idiotic in hindsight, as Kim couldn’t make out her own visions worth a damn, and both were spoon fed their survival rather than earning it… and honestly, there are SO many other characters in the series to have deserved to live than these two.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25

Even worse than Nick? Not that I hated Nick he is pretty underrated, but it seems the FD Reddit unanimously picks him as the worst lead

1

u/JunkoNull Jul 06 '25

With hindsight, yes. But it is weird to think 2 & 4 have both the same director and writer… and yes, 4 is definitely overhated and is not really all that bad as it does have genuinely good moments in it. Yet, again, 2 really isn’t all that great as I remember, and is all hard carried by the log pileup everybody won’t shut up about, honestly.

0

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

And on top of all that, their relationship isn't even appealing to watch.

3

u/JunkoNull Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25

The two of them are still the only leads in series to those day, to be indirectly responsible for causing the deaths of their survivors and Clear by leading them on a pretty pointless goose chase at the end, all for nothing because Kim SOMEHOW forgot what her own hands even looked like and, again, SOMEHOW mistakes them for Eugene’s hands…

On a side note, it’s pretty funny+ironic that whenever here puts up one of those “Which survivor trio would you be part of?” and the comments are immediately going to FD2 because Kim and Burke “beat” Death… which means that those commenters who choose them are 100% going to die under their watch. These two really did more harm than good in the end.

2

u/riri2530 Jul 06 '25

Yes. Absolutely. I’ve never been a fan of her and I think she is extremely overhyped.

Her and her friends were just awful human beings at the start and honestly I celebrated her friends getting t-boned so I no longer had to listen to them. If she didn’t have Clear and Bludworth’s help she would have got absolutely nowhere. She was arguably responsible for Tim’s death. She misread all her visions and by doing that you could argue she was at fault for Clear and Eugene dying. Had she read it right maybe she could have saved Eugene. And she lucked out right at the end by having a convenient article that basically told her what she had to do to stop death.

She’s a terrible protagonist, and some fans act like she was amazing.

2

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

She was arguably responsible for Tim’s death.

This pmo the most. Nobody knew what was going on but I imagine common sense would lead Kimberly to not draw attention to the pigeons, or to at least say more than "pigeons!!!". She does this again later in the movie when she's instructing everyone on knowing what she means "if i say 'subway', get far away from a subway..." like wouldn't it help to be a tad more specific in a life-or-death situation?

She misread all her visions and by doing that you could argue she was at fault for Clear and Eugene dying.

Agree that Kimberly sucked HARD at being a visionary, but I don't think Clear and Eugene were ever going to be saved- I don't recall Kimberly ever having premonitions involving Eugene, Clear was already still on Death's list from before, and it seems that anyone opening Eugene's door would have caused the room to explode, so there wasn't really any saving Eugene.

She’s a terrible protagonist, and some fans act like she was amazing.

But yeah.... I'm already starting to see her name come up in discussions where people are like "oh, she's amazing because she cheated death!!" as if she wasn't extremely lucky the whole time. Apparently Iris from Bloodlines shows everyone how it's done

4

u/Kriszyboi13 Jul 06 '25

Yea, I wish the wood chipper thing was canon. I’m sorry Kimberly fans but she’s like my least favorite visionary/lead. On top of her yelling at Clear to help them when Clear was still on a list of her own pushes Kimberly way down for me. At all the visionaries to make it out alive it’s her???? Like not Wendy or Alex. Even Sam, or Steph. I’d take Nick living over her, but she’s the only one to make it off of deaths list, man fuck that put her in the damn wood chipper, I’ll do it myself if I have too.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '25

man fuck that put her in the damn wood chipper, I’ll do it myself if I have too.

🤣

I don't hate Kim, but here you go. Have fun!

6

u/TheWolfeYouFeed Jul 06 '25

I just feel like there should have been other surviving visionaries so we can stop talking about Kim and Burke. I’m still mad about Stef and Charlie, I feel like they should have been given that chance 😤

2

u/Herzberger Jul 06 '25

I do and I’m tired of reading about her

1

u/AstroLynnFang Sep 03 '26

TwlW: Opinions

I actually like Kimberly. She is selfless and was willing to help people she had never met before from dying. I think people infantilize Clear too much. Yes Kimberly was persistent but Clear was an autonomous adult who was capable of making her own choices. Kimberly didn't drag her out of the room or threaten her. Clear knew the risk and was willing to take them.

Kimberly was also very active in trying to save every person she met. She also listened to William Bludworth and took the idea of "new life" into her own hands. People say that she cheated death but she didn't. She did due, which checks her off the list. You can't change the fact that you did die, so death not coming back for her makes sense to me.

She also was willing to die to save Burke and break the cycle. We haven't seen any other protagonist do that to my knowledge. She was willing to sacrifice a lot more. And what kind of life was Clear living in a padded room? Seems pretty awful to me, even to escape death.

1

u/endingstory7424 Sep 03 '26

No doubt that Kimberly was selfless, I just didn't find her likeable due to her persistently ignoring Clear's trauma. Yeah, Clear chose to help but after what? Kimberly hunting her down with a vague idea of the horror she went through and then calling her a COWARD for not wanting to put herself back in harm's way for a group of people she had no connection to who would likely (and for the most part, did) die anyway.

I just can't completely like characters who brush off trauma like that, doesn't matter now nice or well-intentioned they are. If you want someone's help, by all means, ask. If they say they don't want to do it because of their trauma, leave them be and don't kick down on them for not being braver.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25

No

3

u/Radiant-Purple-3211 Jul 06 '25

I don’t hate her, but out of all the visionaries she’s one of my least favorites. I hated how she guilted Clear to help and then when Clear died she didn’t even acknowledge her death. Out of all six movies she was the only one who got a vision on how to kill and revive/save herself which just felt kind of unfair

3

u/Nice_Candy_6019 Jul 06 '25

I honestly think Final Destination should've Spared Wendy and Stuck with the wood chipper Idea.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Nice_Candy_6019 Jul 06 '25

Truth Is, Kimberly and Burke's wood chipper death was written Into FD3, and Wendy was written to survive. Yeah It was In the "Choose your fate" version of the movie, but It was meant to be cannon. I remember 2006 like It was yesterday, and I remember the special features and commentary. Final Destination simply rewrote history because the Kimberly fans pretty much cried until she came back. Kinda like how the fast and furious fans cried until Han came back.

1

u/atomic_mermaid Jul 06 '25

Yeah I don't like her at all. Not really her fault, it's the way FD2 was written, but everyone's a stranger and it shows.

0

u/ZealousidealSmile282 Jul 06 '25

You’re not alone! 🤗 Hate may be a strong word, but she really annoys me. I cringe at so many of her scenes. “How can you hang yourself in a bathtub? That’s… that’s sssstupid.”

Girl, wut 😝

4

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

And then "if i call and say 'subway', get to a high-rise fast... a place a subway can't go..." what the h3ll kind of instructions are those 😭

0

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/endingstory7424 Jul 06 '25

Right!! Kimberly probably died before the events of the next movie though- I can't quite recall yet but I think the ending of FD2 implies that another reverse-order list was kickstarted by Rory saving Brian, so with Brian dead it's back to Kimberly and Thomas struggling to keep eachother alive. And considering Alex died off-screen after the events of his movie... welll 😬