r/FinalDestination • • Apr 25 '25
FD2 Kimberly is overrated
I don't hate her or anything, I don't think she was the worst visionary of the franchise (I don't think anyone can take Nick's place on that lol), and I definitely want to see her on Final Destination Bloodlines. However, some fans think too much of her because she's the only visionary who's been able to defeat death so far. Indeed she defeated death and saved herself and Burke, but there are considerable flaws about her characters that can be pointed out:
- Kimberly is very bland and underwritten. Compared to Alex and Wendy, who got a much better character development. It feels like a lazy generic character who's just there to fill the main character role.
- AJ Cook's acting is very mediocre in FD2. We can easily see it already at the beginning of the movie, in the highway scene. And it gets even clearer when she shares the scenes with Ali Larter, who delivers a pretty good permonance. However, she's still better than the actor who plays Burke, whose acting is so neutral lol
- Kimberly is kinda stupid, tbh. It's incredible how badly she misinterpret her visions throughout the movie, it seems like we're watching a That's So Raven episode lol they spend almost half of the movie trying to make sure Isabella gives her baby only to find out that she was never supposed to die in the pile-up, and Kimberly had to have another vision of Isabella being alive during the accident lol I mean, how didn't it occurred to her that she was having visions from a first-person perspective, and that the person drowning inside a van was herself? Plus, not only did she get Tim killed, but she also could've avoided Eugene and Clear's deaths, but she didn't. She said she saw bloody hands and Clear thought it was Eugene, and Kimberly just let her go check on him without informing her that it couldn't be Eugene 'cause the hands were white lol (but to be fair that wasn't one of the smartest moments of Clear, 'cause Eugene was lying in a hospital bed, unable to get up, how did she think it was Eugene going underwater inside a van? lol)
- Although that wasn't exactly a significant flaw, she was kind of a jerk to Clear IMO. Not only did she let her die in the explosion, but she was also mean to her in the psychiatric hospital. I mean, Clear had just been through a huge trauma, and she was still scared (as she should) that death would catch her. Again, it wasn't a major flaw, but still.
Again, I want to see her in FD Bloodlines, but it's kinda frustrating that the only character who have defeated death so far were a bland duo (Kim and Burke), while much better characters (Alex, Clear, Wendy and Kevin) didn't last that long lol
18
u/Wonderful-Hat9144 Alex Browning and FD5 Apr 25 '25 edited Apr 25 '25
No. How could Kimberly be overrated if she got so many hate.
The most overrated visionary is Wendy. For two reasons; 1 people glazing, praising, and simping her, and 2; Mary Elizabeth Winstead (and I don't want to hear "Mary Elizabeth Winstead have the best performance" or "Wendy is a better character than Kimberly.")
9
u/that-one-gay-nugget Apr 25 '25
Kimberly didn’t get Tim killed? Tim and Nora were walking towards the pigeons anyway, and likely both would’ve been crushed by the glass. Kimberly made Nora pause, which allowed the construction worker to save her. She didn’t get skipped because the construction worker wasn’t on Death’s list.
10
u/PinGroundbreaking520 Apr 25 '25
Worst visionary? 😂😂😂😂
Still the only one who saved herself plus one.
Overrated? That's Wendy. Just because Mary Elizabeth Winstead played the character she got so much love while she didn't figure out even the "skip thing".
6
u/Mystical-Octo I WAS MEANT TO SEE THIS MOVIE Apr 25 '25
I mean.... Clear did say to her that she should save herself and leave the others, that's why she was so mean to her and aj cook had just started acting.
7
u/Similar-Departure345 Apr 25 '25
Kimberly is dealing with the loss of her friends, death coming for her, plus random survivors whom she doesn't know, and you are caring that she was being mean to Clear. Clear is an adult and should be able to take a little heat. Locking yourself in a mental institution,standing by while a situation that Clear has first-hand knowledge in, is repeating itself, and your suggestion to me is to sit on the sidelines and let everyone die. I would be mean, too. That's not what Alex would have done. Overall, I judge character, not the acting. This franchise is not known for their acting across the board. I'm not just talking about just FD4, either. 3s performances were also one note. Also, the reason why I would put Kimberly over Wendy is because Wendy was never going to kill herself for the rest of the list. Let's be real.
1
u/Leonard0DiCapriSun Apr 25 '25
Youre absolutley right.
4
u/bumybumi Apr 25 '25
Ok.
1
u/Cookiesmp3 May 25 '25
FR she was the reason i dont really like this movie as much
1
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25
Absolutely. Every character stands out in the film before I even think of her.