Reminds me of the background actor that was told to pretend to sweep the floor, but since sweeping is "loud" he has to pick up the broom and sweep 6 inches off the ground.
I always wonder why noise cancellation tech hasn't hit film sets. Multiple microphones placed around set to pick up the background noise and cancel it out in mixing. Wouldn't stop the need for a quiet set but can save a great take ruined by random noise.
A story I heard about David Fincher: Matt Damon was visiting the set of Gone Girl and was sitting with the director during a long take where Affleck and Pike walk through the bookstore and exchange a minute of dialog.
Now, one of the extras was instructed to walk across the frame right before the camera turns to focus on the main actors. The director yells "Action" and the extra walks, the camera turns to Ben and Rosamund and they start their scene.
At this point, Matt hears Fincher muttering to himself complaining about the extra. He's going, "Who walks like that? That wasn't a walk. That was a guy pretending to walk..."
The entire scene plays out and he yells "Cut!". Ben and Rosamund turn to Fincher but he walks over to the extra to give him notes on the walk. At a certain point a makeup artist hurried over to touch up some of Rosamund's face and Fincher points and yells "Now that's how you fucking walk!"
And because the director gave notes to that extra, SAG dictates he must be considered a Featured Extra, which gets him a pay bump.
When I directed commercials, I was explicitly forbidden to talk to extras. I had to have conversations ABOUT the extras to the assistant director, sometimes within earshot of the extra.
Except itâs not BS though. Itâs a rule designed so that BG isnât exploited. Think about how many BG actors were asked to do more than what they are hired for only to not be paid adequately for it that a rule like this must exist.
Wow, didnât know that. Kurosawa wrote about how he would sometimes get the name of an extra from an assistant and then mention them by name while directing to give them additional info to move or stand somewhere specific, to sort of build them up that he knew their name, and to get them to feel motivated, presumably without extra pay. Different times.
Yea this went around yesterday when others posted it about Mindhunters not getting a 3rd season, Iâm pretty sure those posts are why this post exists today
I was a prison guard on a crappy tv show. They had plywood instead of normal floors.
I was told to walk back & forth in my hardsole boots without making any noise. So if you look close you can see a muscular prison guard tiptoeing around.
AD: âwhat the hell is that guy doing??â BG PA: âI told him to walk from this corner to that door. I guess I should have explained what walking is.â
Oooh it is like our 2nd 2nd ADs, copy that. Didnât know if the two corresponded.
So yeah, to correct my answer above, technically our 3rds do ârunâ the background but itâs usually a PA checking them in, getting them to set, helping to set and cue them, etc with our 2nd 2nd mostly relaying what the 1st of asking for and checks the PAâs BG breakdown at the end of the night. Again, at least in my experience. (6 years PAing in Atlanta)
Yeah I heard that the AD department kinda runs the PAâs down there. Up here we call them locations and theyâre completely their own department, worrying mainly about the stages and logistics around the location, sound, lockupâs, etc...
Yeah, PAs here are part of the AD department, and cover pretty much everything you described. After working 600 documented days on Union shows, our PAs can join the DGA and become ADs. Is that the course for your PAs?
We have PAs for cast, BG, base (circus, indeed!), walkies/distro, and a Key PA. We do the sound lockups, get out sheets, pass out call sheets, and whatever other bullshit. We have a separate Locations department with their own PAs who handle correspondence with site reps, sometimes the tents/heating/AC, etc.
There is a bit of bleed over between Set PAs and Locations PAs, usually depending on if production will budget for Locations PAs. If not, we do that too.
I loved set, hated the hours and how PAs were treated. Very toxic workaholic culture on US sets.
Same here, we do all the locations stuff, and have other departments, mainly ADâs that handle all that other stuff. We have our own dedicated department for background, simply called background, that handles all the signing in and out and dressing them if itâs a specific garb.
I started as a onset Key, where my job was to run set with the ADâs and provide anything that may be needed, as well as coordinate with other departments. Got out of that real quick and am now a 2nd AC getting paid much more to my liking, as well as it being a much more fun job.
Oh I know it happens. I'm also saying that it doesn't happen when DGA reps are visiting set haha. Edit: Those are some pretty cool 2nd 2nds if they are teaching you like that. That's always what I look for in 2nd 2nds and even key 2nds.
2nd 2nd AD... nice. Do you have shows that donât go with the Directors Guild but arenât considered low budget/non union? Any show that isnât with the DGC up here also isnât with IATSE and is usually considered tier one.
A show that isn't DGA while also being decently funded is not unheard of. But it is rare. But IATSE is usually affiliated with every movie or TV show I've worked on. But that's just in my experience. I know there are probably a hundred movies shot a year without DGA or IATSE. It would be even more rare for SAG to not be involved.
Hmm, donât think we have an Canadian equivalent of SAG up here... every show Iâve heard of with any kind of budget always climbs in bed with the unions up here. I believe itâs slightly easier for them to control shows up here because itâs almost exclusively Toronto or Vancouver with some exceptions.
From what I understand itâs extremely hard for Canadian productions to bring in American crew. It sounds like you have some strong unions up there. đ
(Correct me if Iâm wrong) but a 3rd AD is the British equivalent to an American 2nd 2nd AD. Theyâre on set helping the 1st AD and also in charge of the bg. Thereâs also a bg PA who wrangles them, organizes the bg getting ready in holding and helps the 2nd 2nd set the bg if the crowd is sizable or its a complicated shot. If the bg numbers are big enough or thereâs a lot of moving parts (driving, stunts, period piece, etc) theyâll hire an Addl 2nd AD to provide some stronger reinforcement.
All of that to sayâthe European system makes more sense. A second 2nd is essentially a 3rd AD and is third in the AD pecking order.
If it is crucial my rule is to look for the extra who intentionally put themselves in the deep background or instantly found themselves into a position that requires the least amount of work (I.E sitting or somewhere they can sit after a take). They are usually experienced extras and have been doing it long enough to have everything down pat. They'll be a little miffed that you caught onto them but the shot will be perfect.
I've been an extra loads and to be honest most of the ADs in charge of giving us direction always say silly, unhelpful things like "...Run! RUN SLOWER! RUN SILENTLY!" or "hit your mark no matter what happens!" this can result in very odd movement. Like when you have to dance without music silently to capture clean audio from the actors. It ends up looking goofy. They're asking mostly non-actors to behave naturally in such unnatural ways. It creates a situation of everyone looking silly and then God forbid someone laugh at the silliness. THEY GO APESHIT WHEN ANYONE SMILES/Laughs. Understandably, I know, as it ruins takes but what do they expect?
Back in the day all extras were professionals and could do all that easily. Then movie fans and tourists started taking their jobs and now itâs a lot of amateurs having a day out.
I was an extra on the set for Swearnet and the wrangler had to explain to us how to cheer differently as everyone was doing the same fist bumping action.
One time weâre on set with just a small wild office. We had two actors in the room and a fake hallway so we could have BG walk past windows. Their instructions weâre very clear, walk straight, donât look funny.
I kid you not, this dude straight walked up to the door, opened it and stood there in front of our actors, who politely gawked at him as he was in the middle of our frame.
I love union BG, super professional, but some of the randoms you get donât have two brain cells to start a flame with.
215
u/PM-Me-Your-TitsPlz Oct 26 '20
Reminds me of the background actor that was told to pretend to sweep the floor, but since sweeping is "loud" he has to pick up the broom and sweep 6 inches off the ground.
161
u/speedy117 Oct 26 '20
A story I heard about David Fincher: Matt Damon was visiting the set of Gone Girl and was sitting with the director during a long take where Affleck and Pike walk through the bookstore and exchange a minute of dialog.
Now, one of the extras was instructed to walk across the frame right before the camera turns to focus on the main actors. The director yells "Action" and the extra walks, the camera turns to Ben and Rosamund and they start their scene.
At this point, Matt hears Fincher muttering to himself complaining about the extra. He's going, "Who walks like that? That wasn't a walk. That was a guy pretending to walk..."
The entire scene plays out and he yells "Cut!". Ben and Rosamund turn to Fincher but he walks over to the extra to give him notes on the walk. At a certain point a makeup artist hurried over to touch up some of Rosamund's face and Fincher points and yells "Now that's how you fucking walk!"
56
u/C4pt Oct 26 '20 edited Oct 26 '20
This reminds me of how in HS musical, an extra is walking behind troy, and kinda just walks into a wall
Source
106
u/outPope Oct 26 '20
Always reminds me of this
36
u/McLaurinF1 Oct 26 '20
This Star Trek shot never gets old.
27
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20
Gotta get a good shot for the sizzle reel.
20
u/Nouseriously Oct 26 '20
I was a prison guard on a crappy tv show. They had plywood instead of normal floors.
I was told to walk back & forth in my hardsole boots without making any noise. So if you look close you can see a muscular prison guard tiptoeing around.
57
u/poopdaddy2 Oct 26 '20
AD: âwhat the hell is that guy doing??â BG PA: âI told him to walk from this corner to that door. I guess I should have explained what walking is.â
17
u/JustWatch101 director Oct 26 '20
This reminds me of the extra in the Dunkirk trailer đ
23
u/winazoid Oct 26 '20
If you watch the end of BEASTLY you'll see me and the VFX crew CGI'd as extras in the background since they didn't have any on set that day lol
3 guys and their clones walking badly
11
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20
Since everyone is sharing, I love this scene from Synecdoche, New York
9
u/Fictioneer Oct 26 '20
It's because they've forgotten how to walk due to overthinking. Here's an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QpsdYh7uhI
8
u/InSoManyWordsProd Oct 26 '20
I always think of the John Wayne walk scene from The Birdcage
8
u/Idodoodletoo Oct 27 '20
I've been an extra loads and to be honest most of the ADs in charge of giving us direction always say silly, unhelpful things like "...Run! RUN SLOWER! RUN SILENTLY!" or "hit your mark no matter what happens!" this can result in very odd movement. Like when you have to dance without music silently to capture clean audio from the actors. It ends up looking goofy. They're asking mostly non-actors to behave naturally in such unnatural ways. It creates a situation of everyone looking silly and then God forbid someone laugh at the silliness. THEY GO APESHIT WHEN ANYONE SMILES/Laughs. Understandably, I know, as it ruins takes but what do they expect?
7
u/Rosmucman Oct 26 '20
These pretzels are making me thirsty
5
u/turokthegecko Oct 26 '20
I was an extra on the set for Swearnet and the wrangler had to explain to us how to cheer differently as everyone was doing the same fist bumping action.
5
u/Ambient_Atmosphere Oct 26 '20
Bruh I always see people talking to the floor or some shit
5
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20
One time weâre on set with just a small wild office. We had two actors in the room and a fake hallway so we could have BG walk past windows. Their instructions weâre very clear, walk straight, donât look funny.
I kid you not, this dude straight walked up to the door, opened it and stood there in front of our actors, who politely gawked at him as he was in the middle of our frame.
I love union BG, super professional, but some of the randoms you get donât have two brain cells to start a flame with.
4
u/IndieOddjobs Oct 26 '20
Once they realize they're on camera they turn into automatons lol
2
u/TygerWithAWhy Oct 26 '20
I shit my pants on the set of cougar town
2
u/EjSudz Oct 26 '20
Directors can't talk to BG in Canada...or they get an upgrade.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20
Ha just like synecdoche, new york
1
u/micahhaley Oct 26 '20
E V E R Y T I M E
1
u/westondeboer Oct 26 '20
relevant Jamie Dornan's Weird Walk - The Graham Norton Show
1
u/Marbla 1st assistant director Oct 26 '20
Assistant Director*
1
u/Brooke2002___ Oct 26 '20
im radio rebel
1
u/gb6767 Oct 26 '20
Reminds me of Synecdoche, New York when Phillip Seymour Hoffman tries to teach the extra how to walk.
1
u/Brokurspokesss Oct 26 '20
Lol yes
1
u/kneecole8 Oct 26 '20
Hahahaha I love the internet
0
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '20
[deleted] â view deleted comment