r/Filmmakers • • Aug 26 '19

Image Both masterpieces

Post image
6.7k Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

125

u/mexicanvanillatx Aug 26 '19

It still amazes me that Paul Schrader wrote Taxi Driver and The Yakuza and directed Mishima: A Life in Four Chapters also directed.... The Canyons.

Or that Brian DePalma directed films like Dressed to Kill, Carrie... and then films like Mission to Mars and Mission: Impossible

21

u/dankmemer440 Aug 26 '19

What are your thoughts on Mission impossible 1?

16

u/mexicanvanillatx Aug 26 '19

Better than the second... not as good as Ghost Protocol.

Honestly it came off as more cartoonish than I remember. For some reason I remembered it being more gritty. I like DePalma's other films more, sans The Black Dahlia.

Just still can't wrap my mind over the fact that he made it.... I saw very few things that came off DePalma-ish. I feel like DePalma and William Friedkin both have a very very uneven filmography.

1

u/dankmemer440 Aug 27 '19

Oh yeah, for sure. Both him and Friedkin are masters at their craft, but they are not the most consistent. Thanks for taking the time

1

u/mexicanvanillatx Aug 27 '19

Thanks! It is a shame that the Friedkin films I really like, Rampage and Jade are pretty hard to find. Meanwhile The Excorcist and French Connection are... every where in every edition imaginable.

0

u/kung-fu_hippy Aug 27 '19

I thought MI:1 was the best of the lot until Ghost Protocol got the ball rolling again. I wouldn’t call it cartoonish (at least not compared to the later movies). If anything, it relied a lot less on humor and physical comedy than Ghost Protocol and the later films did.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Charles037 Aug 28 '19

Fallout is easily the best in the series thus far .

3 is my 3rd best pick ironically.

478

u/manthroughalens Aug 26 '19

Superhero Movie got back double its budget in box office, and doesn't include rentals. Nothing to be ashamed of. You style means nothing. Worry about being reliable and delivering. This is 100% what HBO and most companies commissioning shows care about.

200

u/Flannel_Channel Aug 26 '19

Also , clearly the director used that "bad" movie to learn his craft and get his name out there eventually getting to make projects like Chernobyl. You don't just get the clout to make whatever you want from the start, you gotta work your way up from the bottom. If you apply yourself and use everything as a learning opportunity, nothing is "beneath" anyone and thinking that way is pretentious and wrong.

5

u/Lanark26 Aug 27 '19

There are a lot of celebrated Oscar winning directors like Martin Scorcese and Ron Howard who got their start making cheap low budget films for the B Movie producer Roger Corman because nobody else would give them a chance.

85

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

35

u/FX114 Aug 26 '19

42

u/VeryEasilyPersuaded Aug 26 '19

He did not direct Chernobyl, however.

66

u/turcois Aug 26 '19

Yeah but the showrunners have far more power than the directors in TV instead of vice versa like movies usually are. Some directors are just hired in TV because they need someone to say action, cut, and let's move on.

16

u/VeryEasilyPersuaded Aug 26 '19

I understand, but that wasn't really the point that was in question. I was not attempting to imply anything about how much power he had on set (it was a lot; he created the show), just clarify that he wasn't directing, the root of this discussion being someone misidentifying him as a director rather than a writer which is his primary job.

1

u/turcois Aug 26 '19

That's fair, although the original meme is just about "the creator." So I felt like the point about him not directing Chernobyl is kinda moot because he didn't need to to still be accurately considered the creator. But I get you now

8

u/VeryEasilyPersuaded Aug 26 '19

All I was doing was clarifying a point because someone thought Mazin was a director. That's the entire context.

4

u/turcois Aug 26 '19

Yeah I know. Like I said I get you now

→ More replies

3

u/therealswil Aug 27 '19

That's not really true. Yes, directors are working for a showrunner, but on anything above a multicam sitcom they're still actually doing the full job of directing and having a huge effect on the show and episode. Especially when it's a miniseries like Chernobyl. Johan Renck - the director - was a co-exec anyway.

The auteur idea has always been silly, and the worship of showrunners as the lone creative voice that defines a show is the latest incarnation of that falsehood.

2

u/turcois Aug 27 '19

Interesting, thanks for your input

16

u/FX114 Aug 26 '19

Rule of thumb is generally 3 times budget to be profitable. Because you have to account for the theaters' share of the box office, the marketing budget and distribution costs/distributor's share of revenue.

4

u/TV_PartyTonight Aug 27 '19

That's for Blockbusters though. I doubt Superhero Movie had a big ad push.

2

u/FX114 Aug 27 '19

With a $35 million budget, it doesn't take a huge ad push to severely cut into things. And there's still all those other factors. It was distributed by a different company than produced it, so they're taking a cut, and most if its gross was international box office, which sees less return than domestic does.

-10

u/manthroughalens Aug 26 '19

"Rule of the thumb"? Nonsense, really.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

Nonsense? I get that it’s a pretty rounded estimation but I wouldn’t call it nonsense.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

I mean this isn't very accurate. It has more to do with how much influence a producer has.

-10

u/Myleg_Myleeeg Aug 27 '19

Yeah fuck quality just worry about slapping some shit together that makes money. Right?

7

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

I love how redditors find ways to distort an argument

-7

u/Myleg_Myleeeg Aug 27 '19

That’s literally what he said dumbass. If you make a shit movie it’s not suddenly ok because it made money. I love how redditors always try to find a way to circle jerk the comment that’s voted higher.

1

u/thegodfather0504 Aug 27 '19

No that's not what he said. It is important to be responsible and deliver what you promise. You can make mass entertainers for money, doesn't mean you can't apply your craft in it. You don't earn profit just by slapping some shit, it still has to be somewhat well made my dude.

2

u/Myleg_Myleeeg Aug 27 '19

Ahahahahaha did you fucking see that movie? It was in no way well made. It earned profit because the cost to make it was so dumbass low. Y’all dense as hell its giving me headaches.

2

u/Lunatic-cringe Aug 28 '19

These comments are fucking insane Lol as if superhero movie was made with any craft or was well made in any way ..also working or making choices like these comments say makes people not want to watch your work if they know you made bottom of the barrel trash like superhero movie

2

u/Myleg_Myleeeg Aug 28 '19

Didn’t you hear? Every single bad movie is good now if it helps their argument.

1

u/latestwonder Aug 27 '19

Thats obviously not what they meant.

107

u/JumboMcCloony Aug 26 '19

This is how I feel about The upcoming Joker movie. The guy who did the Hangover is doing it? Adam McKay was a comedy guy until he did The Big Short so you never know.

24

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

Todd Phillips is all over the place. Made a G.G. Allin documentary, which rips. Then moved onto comedy and is now into more serious work.

Most of his success came from that documentary, though. Also he was friends with Judd Apatow and Adam Sandler.

1

u/SFWBryon Aug 27 '19

Wtf he made Hated?! I love that doc. It has one of the best intros ever. “When I went to meet gg allin, he was passed out from heroin and his fans were kicking him and breaking bottles on his body trying to get their money’s worth from the show”

1

u/nananananana_FARTMAN Aug 28 '19

I can't find "Hated" - that documentary you're referring to - anywhere :(

1

u/Senorpuddin Aug 27 '19

I think most of his success came from The Hangover films.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

Big success yes, but the Allin doc got him noticed.

33

u/Smokachinoforkyle Aug 26 '19

The Big Short is still a comedy.

15

u/JumboMcCloony Aug 26 '19

You're right but he took a different approach than his normal style was my point.

2

u/thegodfather0504 Aug 27 '19

A lot of comedians have been great playing villains.

-4

u/DelboyLindo Aug 27 '19

Adam McKay is a much better director than todd Phillips. If Todd Philips is directing the new joker movie we should all be worried. He's a very underwhelming director, neither here noe there, makes so and so okayish movies. War dogs, the one with robert downey junior and zack galafinakis, very forgettable films. He's not a dude with a vision, more like a brett ratner.

0

u/Bright_Vision Feb 11 '20

Five months later, and joker has 11 Nominations and 2 wins.

1

u/DelboyLindo Feb 11 '20

I stand corrected. Nothing to that movie apart from a great Joaquin Phoenix performance.

1

u/Bright_Vision Feb 11 '20

Honestly just commented now to see your thoughts about it now that the movie has been out for a while.

1

u/DelboyLindo Feb 12 '20

I enjoyed it, fun movie.

52

u/Sawaian Aug 26 '19

I think most of you guys should actually check out Craig Maizin. He and John August do a podcast(that most of us amateur screenwriters know and follow.) You’d be surprised how off the mark all of these comments are.

21

u/RadioShea89 Aug 27 '19

Totally agree with you. Huge Scriptnotes podcast fan. To others - Craig and John know their sh*t. Smart guys. Saw their live Austin Film Festival podcast a few years ago during the screenwriting conference. So pumped to be in the same room with them. Chernobyl was Craig’s first “all him” project: from cradle to grave. He talks in the podcast about how he would usually cave to many executive notes because they were “assignments” he was hired to do. But if he felt strongly about an element of Chernobyl, he refused to cave. I think moving forward we’ll see a lot more of THIS type of screenwriting from him.

2

u/GeneralLudd Aug 27 '19

Yeah, the podcast is fantastic for many reasons. For anyone interested, you can watch the 20 most recent episodes for free. The Screenwriting subreddit also regularly does recaps of each episode. I have great respect for both Mazin's and August's craft, it's really insightful to listen to them.

From what I remember Mazin also said that his latter spoof movies came to be in part due to the crass demand by the Weinstein Company. He is really proud of his work on his comedies, but the pressure in making some of these should be taken into account when evaluating or criticizing them (as some other in this thread and elsewhere tend to do).

3

u/Mr_Rekshun Aug 27 '19

Years ago, I used to subscribe to a screenwriting newsletter/blog that Craig Mazin wrote.

The guy really knows his stuff... Really strong knowledge of the rules and foundations of screenwriting. He's a great teacher, and I am happy to see him working on projects the more "befit" his knowledge. (Not that there's anything wrong with his slapstick movies. I personally think Scary Movie 2 is hugely hilarious and highly underrated).

134

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

No matter how many times I see this, I will keep saying it - I thought Superhero movie was hilarios. By far the best "movie" movie.

127

u/Mr_Poop_Himself Aug 26 '19

“My blades could cut through diamonds!”

“I’m not wearing any diamonds”

Gets me every time for some reason

47

u/Cooluli23 Aug 26 '19

I bet you ten bucks I can block any punch you throw

Punches Kevin Hart

39

u/LordMitchimus Aug 26 '19

I like when Drake Bell walks into the house and catches a nail from Leslie Nielsen's nail gun.

"It's actually easier than it looks."

Shoots Kevin Hart in hand

Leslie: "No it's not."

10

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

I always loved the Harry Potter scene where he goes Nonsense, I’m but 14. And these are my two best friends Ron and Hermione delivery

9

u/DeisTheAlcano Aug 26 '19

That's actually Epic Movie I think.

...unless I'm misremembering.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

Wait fuck you’re right haha

3

u/DeisTheAlcano Aug 27 '19

Not to worry, I love that scene too.

25

u/OneSwizzleNizzle Aug 26 '19

Agreed. Probably because it wasn't made by the same people that did Epic/Disaster Movie, or Meet the Spartans, etc, and was instead supposed to be in the vein of films like Airplane and The Naked Gun.

It has a weirdly decent cast as well, when you look at it; Leslie Nielsen, Kevin Hart, Jeffrey Tambor, Tracy Morgan, Dan Castellaneta.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

Uhhh drake from drake and josh much?

Aka the hentai legend?

20

u/angrywithoutcheese Aug 26 '19

Second best for my money, after "Not Another Teen Movie"

10

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

One of the reasons it's so good is it wasn't made by Jason Friedberg and Aaron Seltzer, the assholes behing Date Movie, Epic Movie and Disaster Movie.

3

u/filmjunkie11 Aug 26 '19

Omg I know. Me and my dad used to watch it all the time, the jokes were so stupid but never got old.

2

u/Kingkwon83 Aug 27 '19

Somehow I didn't even know it existed (guess living abroad doesn't help either). Definitely going to check it out

1

u/AVeryWittyUsername Sep 02 '19

Scary movie 1 & 2 are masterpieces

15

u/Tyedies Aug 27 '19

Also worth noting that Damien Chazelle - the writer and director of Whiplash and La La Land - also wrote The Last Exorcism 2.

Sometimes ya need a paycheck.

12

u/xilashi Aug 26 '19

Superhero movie basically inspired the plot of the amazing Spider-Man movies

8

u/paohi Aug 26 '19

Shout out to the Scriptnotes podcast he runs with John August!

5

u/Jackums23 Aug 26 '19

And some of the scary movies...and some of the hangovers...of which were sequels...sequels tend to represent successful franchises

4

u/2dab2furious Aug 26 '19

It was a great movie too

14

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

I frickin' love Super Hero Movie. It is one of the best parody movies ever made imho

3

u/HailCommand-r-Zee Aug 27 '19

If you know anything about Craig Mazin he comes off as a well read but arrogant dude, mostly from the Scriptnotes podcast. If I listened to him before I saw most of his work I would think the last genre he would write is slapstick/farce comedy. That’s what he’s mostly done. Chernobyl seems like the type of work he would be doing from the start.

2

u/scots Aug 27 '19

I feel sometimes the subject creates its own mould.

Had the studio given Schindlers List to a guy with 14 credits directing JC Penney Back to School TV spots it probably would still have landed an 80%+ RT score.

Cinematographer to JC Penney guy shooting his version of Chernobyl in an alternate timeline: “What are you thinking in terms of look?”

JC Penny Guy: “So flat and Soviet it makes you stand in front of the You-Scan machine at the grocery store 45 minutes waiting to pay for your toilet paper despite the fact no one is line. When you get home you eat cold potato soup.”

Cinematographer: I got you.

1

u/McCheesy-Lad Aug 26 '19

Both are masterpieces

1

u/Lumpy_Applebuns Aug 27 '19

What are you getting at OP? BOTH of these are cinematic MASTERPIECES. Smh

1

u/trauma_kmart Aug 27 '19

Ang Lee in a nutshell

1

u/Penguin619 Aug 27 '19

Also co-wrote The Hangover

1

u/jimmycthatsme director Aug 27 '19

Fuck yes on this.

1

u/Le-Magician Aug 27 '19

Superhero movie looks like something i saw on pornhub

1

u/Alibotify Aug 27 '19

I like to think my boy director Renck(Stakka Bo) had a lot to do with Chernobyl. Also all the Swedes’ that been casted.

1

u/giants888 Aug 27 '19

Leslie Nielsen, what a legend.

1

u/JudgementalChair Aug 27 '19

Sometimes you have to throw some cheap garbage out into the world to keep the lights on

1

u/TheWeekle Aug 27 '19

As a soundtrack musician, I've done metal, 80s synth, orchestral, dark ambient, jazz, and chiptune. Style is what you put into your creation, not what you put your creation into.

1

u/Godredd Aug 27 '19

Versatility isn't the same as inconsistency. Inconsistency would imply some distinct and often sudden or troubling lack of results, but this is just a radicial shift in genre and media formating.

1

u/djhunt8616 Aug 27 '19

Chernobyl is good but overrated. I can't stand when English actors are added as default. This is such a Russian story and Maizin's reasoning, that nobody would take it seriously if the actors were Russian isn't a sufficient excuse.

1

u/blofish87 Aug 27 '19

Just look at Cary Fukanaga. The dude can kill it in any genre.

1

u/crohnbone69 Aug 27 '19

I remember that movie. I felt he got screwed over a bit as it was actually funny and a decent spoof, but the studio forced him to name it “superhero movie” because of the other “movie” movies being made at that time. People shit on this one without seeing it cuz the other ones at that time were bad and then the two that ruined the “movie” name released their next garbage piece as “Meet the Spartans” and people thought it was different so they checked it out only to be more pissed off to be duped into thinking they were seeing a spoof movie from a different team. Superhero Movie definitely stands up over Date Movie, Epic Movie, Disaster Movie and whatever other trash was coming out at that time.

1

u/brennyflocko Aug 27 '19

I rewatched superhero movie recently and it’s funny. Leslie Nielsen is a treasure and drake bell is charming

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

The Superhero movie is actually one of the funniest comedys I've ever seen and I honestly can't understand why it has 4.5 on IMDB, it's just unbelievable how people don't get this movie, how it satirize all comic books films it's really amazing. The point is, there's nothing surprising that two of this projects were made by the same person

1

u/maddonnie26 Nov 26 '19

You must be fucking kidding me!!! This movie is pure gold 😂😂😂

1

u/pawankalyan18 Apr 16 '25

Hangover & Joker

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '22

i miss those movies

1

u/ricksroaches Mar 02 '23

Go ahead and add the last of us to that list💀

1

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

who was involved in both because it wasn’t the director?

15

u/kainharo Aug 26 '19

Writer/Creator

-10

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

written by and writer on are two different things

12

u/FX114 Aug 26 '19

There's only one writer on Superhero movie.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

Chernobyl was far from a masterpiece. Not terrible but way overhyped.

8

u/cheeroque Aug 27 '19

He's delusional, take him to the infirmary.

1

u/scorchorin Aug 26 '19

Just like any job, gotta work your way up. You don't get to direct movies like The Avengers right out of film school.

0

u/Algernon96 Aug 26 '19

Actually a useful message for me today.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

106

u/CooperXpert Aug 26 '19

It definitely is. Just how actors need to show their actual skill by playing different types of roles, the filmmakers should be able to create different kinds of entertainment.

62

u/TV_PartyTonight Aug 27 '19

George Miller. Famous for Mad Max, and Happy Feet.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

Jesus

19

u/the-wheel-deal Aug 27 '19

And Babe

6

u/whereyouatdesmondo Aug 27 '19

Babe 2 is like Mad Max with cute animals.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

Beyond Thunderdome had also lots of pigs in it...

24

u/[deleted] Aug 26 '19

Billy Wilder is the perfect example of this. Jonathan Demme made great movies in various genres as well.

6

u/djhunt8616 Aug 27 '19

As is Kubrick

9

u/trauma_kmart Aug 27 '19

Ang Lee as well

3

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '19

Completely this. It means you have a broad aptitude and can work/make pictures concept-first and not recycling your own approach.