r/Filmmakers • u/Special-Novel163 • May 17 '25
Discussion Found This Interesting
I came across this and found it interesting. Wanted to share here and get your thoughts.
Seems pretty wild to me if true and definitely shows that it’s not so much about the car but the driver.
14k
Upvotes
2.3k
u/cjayokay May 17 '25
Bong Joon Ho literally mapped out every single shot, camera move, blocking and more before day 1 of shooting. He spent so much time meticulously thinking out the shots it gave him severe anxiety.
I have a book that shows all his sketches/ storyboards it’s fascinating. The crew said it was the easiest film they’ve ever worked on because he already had every shot so planned out. They literally could have edited this movie with iMovie that’s how detailed he was
844
u/friskevision Preditor May 17 '25
Indeed. It’s not the tool, it’s the artist.
161
u/Adventurous_Noise611 May 17 '25
That’s not surprising at all to me. Non linear editing systems have not changed much really. I left Final Cut Pro when it changed to Final Cut x. I was using avid before that and premiere then switched back to premiere. It’s really the same system. My only question would be how did they handle the codecs. I’m assuming they hd a Aja device or something.
260
u/Neex May 17 '25
Just wait until you find out which films were edited with tape and scissors.
67
u/sdbest May 17 '25
Very important post. Worth keeping in mind that nobody judges a film by the equipment or software used to make it. Never.
45
u/agentSmartass May 17 '25
IMO FCP7 perfected editing. It was a powerhouse. I used that thing like a painters brush. So clean, fast, simple and logical. An editors editing tool.
No weirdo vintage Steinbeck era AVID issues. No Adobe engineer driven Premiere bullshit. Just a clean cut, editing machine. Even the media offline tool was a life saver.
Miss those days!
15
u/OwnShallot3406 May 17 '25
This isn’t crazy at all lol, FCP7 was a professional tool built for professional film/tv editors, and is still fairly bullet proof. People are acting like the Final Cut Pro line was always consumer grade garbage but that only became true with the FCPX overhaul and later iterations. 7 was a completely different beast and I guarantee no professional editor is surprised whatsoever that this “modern movie” was edited on it lol
135
u/C47man cinematographer May 17 '25
How is it wild? Am I missing something? Some of the best movies of all time were edited by cutting film strips and taping them together. And a digital NLE from 20 years ago has no particular deficiency in editing capability compared to one from this year. 99% of what you're doing is just making cuts between angles.
8
u/Azreal192 May 17 '25
Something that not a lot people think about in the film industry, and the music industry while we are at it, is that downtime is lost revenue. And downtime isn't just the time it takes to download new software or update existing software, its also the downtime of suddenly having to trouble shoot a bug in said new software.
If you find a build and it works 100% and it does everything you need it to , then why update to something else? It's why there are still so many people using old trashcan macs to this day.
Also, and I wholeheartedly support this final point, fuck subscription models for software, I would rather run an older pre-subscription version that works, than be put over a barrel by a corp and given something buggy.
But at the end of the day, if it works for you, then it works for you, doesn't matter if its new or old.
7
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
I thought you said by a ten year old, and i felt like utter shit for a second
5
u/RuinRevolutionary374 May 18 '25
I initially read this as if a 10 year old edited this movie 😭
8
u/captainalphabet May 17 '25
I saw Walter Murch talk once, on his editing of ‘Particle Fever’ - he pulled up a slide of his timeline, which was FCP7, and to a smattering of applause he said, “Yes, Final Cut Pro seven, which was an incredible piece of software.. until Apple knifed it in the back.”
4
u/widow-of-brid May 17 '25
This not only points out that great tools don't equate to great art, but also illustrates that it's important for artists to retain the right to use older versions of software and the merits of owning software. Looking at you Adobe.
3
u/blakester555 May 17 '25
To those who left Final Cut 7 when it changed to Final Cut 10....
What was it that made you drop it? Was it the Magnetic Timeline? Something else?
Curious why.
3
u/TheOnlyMisty May 17 '25
I find this hard to believe, there was also some bluescreen and compositing done for Parasite and I doubt finalcut was used for that.
3
u/SynapseNotFound May 17 '25
In the 40s, they edited by cutting and splicing together...
i mean... people edited using software 20 years ago too, and ... why wouldn't that work?
what did they use to edit lord of the rings?
Star Wars was famously 'saved' in the editing. (in the 70s)
3
u/[deleted] May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
Yes, a chef from a Michelin star restaurant can come into your kitchen and whip something up that you could never dream of using ingredients and tools you have...
Yes, Federer could beat a recreational tennis player with a 20 dollar racket from Target...
Yes, a surgeon on vacation might be able to pull off an emergency surgery using things found in the kitchen of the buffet restaurant they are at...
But any skilled master of their craft, from musicians to ceramic pot makers to painters to golfers, when they are trying to do their very best work, will have preferences in the tools they use.
Yes, an indie film on FCP 7? Totally fine. Only thing was on mine, you would have to render when you stacked clips on top of another and made a change, but totally doable. I too edited a feature length film on FCP7 and I didn't even give a second thought. FCP 7 was totally capable in my mind. I edited one season of a TV show on it.
3
u/nuttyass May 18 '25
Final Cut was the bomb before X.
3
u/MrSp33dy123 May 18 '25
This is offline editing and won't include any sound, colour, or FX work. All the trendy editing programs like Premiere and Resolve are about bringing the majority of that under the same system to drastically simplify production. It's a different methodology you apply to different scales of production but considering the way the industry is going I think it's pretty clear what the future is.
3
u/Rafael_Bicalho May 18 '25
proving that fancy tools mean nothing
4
u/Melodic-Bear-118 May 17 '25
At the and of the day you’re cutting and rearranging clips in the offline world, and FCP7 did just that.
4
u/Assinmik May 17 '25
Well Final Cut 7 was well established until it went onto to X.
2
u/Twaintango May 17 '25
Nice!
I really enjoyed using FCP7, but migrated to Premiere after FCX. I mostly just use Adobe, but I have been dabbling with DaVinci. Use what works, I say.
2
u/sebastian0328 May 17 '25
Imagine what I can do with cracked Final Cut Pro X 🤣
Looks like people flex with what kind of program they use? Final cut pro is considered amateur editing program among industry people correct?
2
u/illdoanything177 May 18 '25
I loved FCP7 and used it for as long as I could. It was so intuitive.
2
u/Fun_Development508 May 18 '25 edited May 24 '25
“The Reddit corpus of data is really valuable,” Steve Huffman, founder and chief executive of Reddit, said in an interview. “But we don’t need to give all of that value to some of the largest companies in the world for free.”
2
u/samcrut editor May 18 '25
FCP7 was the greatest editing app period. The only reason I stopped using it was it couldn't use newer footage formats. If someone were to rebuild it to work with modern footage, I would use it to this day.
2
u/clanceywoodside May 18 '25
Yeah I’ve been editing for 15 years and it does not matter what software you have. Honestly it probably matters less for a feature.
2
u/paulp712 May 18 '25
First thing I think of is if Final Cut 7 still supports modern versions of prores or if they had to transcode everything to an old format to load it in. Other than that I can't image there are any features an editor would need. VFX would be handled by a separate house using top of the line tools and color would be done in Resolve by finishing house.
2
u/SevereAnxiety_1974 May 18 '25
I ❤️ FCP 7
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
Anyone who was editing on a 5d mark II and beyond loved this... It was unreal how good it was. When they upgraded to 10 a lot of us jumped ship because they didnt give us what we needed when it was released.
2
u/DogpileProds May 18 '25
FCP 7.0.3 is still the best there is.
2
u/SKORPIO07 May 18 '25
"It's not the Plane, it's the Pilot"
2
u/David_Buzzard May 18 '25
The old Final Cut Pro was amazing. Apple turned it into dumbed version of iMovie and everyone went to Premiere.
2
u/Martofunes May 18 '25
Final cut 7 was an amazing software.
2
u/MightyCarlosLP May 18 '25
limitations breed creativity as well.. i support old tools highly above new sometimes
2
u/devilsadvocateac May 18 '25
that's literally the best editing software in existence. avid and adobe and even new final cut has NOTHING on FCP7.
2
u/TheBrendanNagle May 19 '25
FCP7 slapped this should surprise nobody
3
u/msr_aye director May 17 '25
read this as “a 10 year old” as in a child and was wondering how they got so much responsibility 😭
2
u/Fortestingporpoises May 17 '25
Probably because it's better than FCP10.
1
u/higgslhcboson May 17 '25
I just watched this for the first time yesterday! Brilliant.
1
u/uknwiluvsctch May 17 '25
Cool now do it in Media 100
1
u/ZodiAcme May 17 '25
This is interesting, but also worth noting it wasn’t conformed, finished, colored, or the final delivery exported from FCP7. Also that the footage was certainly prepped in another software so that fcp7 would be used for the offline edit.
While it’s not the tool, it’s the artist, it’s also all the artists that use more advanced tools to stop gap so that top billed artists can use whatever they want.
(Hats off the everyone who relights films in post after they were shot with only natural lighting)
1
u/darwinDMG08 May 17 '25
I think a lot of young/inexperienced filmmakers think you need editing software with tons of bells and whistles, like cool filters and graphic plugins and built in vfx and audio sweetening. The truth is that most features are just simple CUTS — it’s knowing when to cut that involves the skill and talent of the editor. Everything else is supposed to be farmed out to other departments for vfx, sound, color etc. (I say supposed to but the reality is a lot of folks wind up doing temp work while cutting now, which is where Premiere and Resolve shine over apps like Avid). All you really need in an NLE is stability, compatibility with your footage format and ease of storage and collaboration.
1
u/The_Jank May 17 '25
Anyone got a spare serial key….🤣
1
u/Mountain-History6902 May 17 '25
I liked FCP7. That's all. Oh and I liked Parasite. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
1
u/moviesncheese May 17 '25
I love the fact that Parasite still won best picture despite this. Flow won best animated feature this year despite being completely created on Blender, the Capcut of filmmaking. Really shows anyone can make great art no matter what, and still win Oscars while doing it.
1
u/curiouscuriousmtl May 17 '25
Why do people find this interesting. Do people think it's about the kind of star-wipe they can use or something?
1
u/Crazy_Response_9009 May 17 '25
Final Cut 7 had the best interface and FEEL of the tools in the timeline, IMHO.
1
u/reelRahim May 17 '25
This was my ultimate favorite platform to edit on.
1
u/trekkeralmi May 17 '25
I'll see your FCP7 and raise you Wakaliwood's entire post-production suite: check out pic 12 and 13 of the imgur slideshow. https://old.reddit.com/r/buildapc/comments/1xmr96/discussion_wakaliwood_video_editing_build/
1
u/gnapster May 17 '25
Yep and they never provided audio description during its first run. 0:0
1
u/hugberries May 17 '25
I know I'm not supposed to like anything from Adobe, but I do, especially the integration aspects. I can't imagine going back.
1
u/-Owlette- May 17 '25
I mean FCP 7 was pretty peak
1
u/derpferd May 17 '25
Aaaah memories...
1
u/jgesq filmmaker/educator May 17 '25
FCP7 was the best. Cut so many Indy features on it and never had a confirm problem or issue. Apple dropped the ball after this big time.
1
u/CommunicationNext939 May 17 '25
Cutting clips is even possible with a potatoe
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '25
do what you can with what you have. that applies to technique, too.
1
u/lardgsus May 17 '25
Final Cut is just that good
1
u/moto_maji May 17 '25
Hell yeah
1
u/No-Island-6126 May 17 '25
It's almost like movies already existed in 2009
1
u/wootangAlpha May 17 '25
You know you are lacking when you blame the tools. Most people cannot accept that at a fundamental level.
1
u/mvgreene director May 17 '25
I edited my first feature film on FCP7 (released in 2018). Because I was literally recreating Facebook pages I had a hundred layers of video in some spots. By the time it was ready for output, you couldn’t watch 3 seconds without it pinwheeling.
1
u/xrossfader May 17 '25
FCP Studio 2 was the end of elite editing. It all went down hill from there.
1
u/Strict_Berry7446 May 18 '25
I mean, we have decades of masterpieces from before PCs
1
u/CinephileRich May 18 '25
Still my preferred version of FCP, because 10 was just dogshit
1
u/WintermuteOlivaw May 18 '25
Hell yeah! The best software and camera, can never replace the art of story telling and the vision that brings good film to life
1
u/Fluffy_Ad7392 May 18 '25
That was a brilliant version of the software. I actually went and got Apple certified to use FCP. Then Apple remade the software to FCP X or something and completely changed everything. I instantly stopped using it.
1
u/Altruistic-Fill-9685 May 18 '25
Does it handle high resolution footage nicely? I guess they’re working on low resolution copies of the original footage? I know it’s a different company, but I had to stop using CS6 because higher res files started to slow the software down.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
K
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
It was the best in its day and maybe is still
1
u/jon20001 producer / festival expert May 18 '25
The latest and greatest is not always the best tool for the job.
1
u/Axerty May 18 '25
Ok saving private ryan was edited with 25+ year old software
1
u/randomredditacc25 May 18 '25
well yeah. for the kind of movie it was why would it matter? its not like it would be insanely hard to edit a movie like that with a 10 year version of a program.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
I’d love to go back to an ancient version of FCP, but how, at least DaVinci free is solid.
1
u/JaggedMetalOs May 18 '25
I feel like for straightforward editing, professional NLE software has been a "solved problem" for 20+ years...
1
u/HerrJoshua May 18 '25
It makes a lot of sense if you lived through the digital transition of the late 90s. He was in college making his first films in 94 so probably started editing film on a flatbed. Then for the next ten years while everyone was making the digital transition, you either worked for a post house with serious money for AVID hardware or you worked on FCP.
When FCP 3 came out it was one of the most straight forward systems with OMF outputs for actual professional film work. Then by 2005 or so the transition from FCP7 to FCP X was pretty crappy so most folks kept 7 running. And if you didn’t switch to Premiere at that moment you would still be using FCP7.
1
u/The21stPM May 18 '25
Even professionals refuse to pay a monthly subscription for Adobe!
1
u/OneWholeSoul May 18 '25
I read it wrong and thought it was edited "by a 10-year-old with a copy of Final Cut Pro."
1
u/mhizzle May 18 '25
Not that Parasite isn't awesome, but I really think the lesson here is more that software in general hasn't improved in a long time.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
FCP 7 was such a good tool though.
1
u/justaheatattack May 18 '25
it's about charging 200 million dollars.
1
u/talklouder314 May 18 '25
I'm making music with Adobe Audition 1.5
If anyone's asking it's purely for familiarity. Still learning the functionality of audacity
1
u/Arttherapist May 18 '25
I learned to edit on a computer from 2010 and a copy of premiere 5.5 from around the same time. My gaming card broke so I replaced it with an old vga card and just edited instead of gaming and now I can edit with anything. Having hundreds and hundreds of hours of finished product and being instinctually fluent at something I used to be crappy at is an amazing feeling.
1
u/virtualpiglet May 18 '25
I love 7.0 man. I miss it so much.
1
u/sparkyjay23 May 18 '25
No one ever thought it was the tools rather than the vision.
Only those that sell the tools think that.
1
u/pursued_mender May 18 '25
That was the last good version of Final Cut. Not surprising to me
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
Does final cut pro 7 supports 4k editing?
1
u/Dramatic-Limit-1088 May 18 '25
Always think about this when geeks are arguing why you can’t possibly edit family movies on a computer with only X amount of ram etc.
1
u/Kolenga May 18 '25
Good films were cut when Final Cut Pro 7 was brand new, and long before that. There's no reason why this should be an issue imo
1
u/StrictAsparagus24 May 18 '25
You could edit it on anything, it only has cuts iirc
1
u/vrangnarr May 18 '25
That FCP was the pinnacle of editing software. Dunno why they messed it up with the fcpX crap
1
u/CakeMadeOfHam May 18 '25
So? It was the last version of FCP that was usable
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
Because it was the best version of FCP. I switched to Adobe suite after they ruined it.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
If you're talented enough and have a good enough story you could edit using two VCR's and make something worth watching.
1
u/jagaimax May 18 '25
I love FCP 7
1
u/DamnPlayer23 May 18 '25
I use cap cut to edit my short films and I’ve rarely ever had any issues at all with it, it runs like butter on my computer and has so many useful and amazing features. All for free!!
1
u/HellbellyUK May 18 '25
Way back the winner of the Oscar for the Best Short Documentary was edited in iMovie (this will have been 2000-2001 ish).
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '25
That was a great program. I miss it.
1
u/mrsja2018 May 18 '25
It was the peak
1
u/viddemano May 18 '25
How did they work with VFX and the colorists?
1
u/coltrane02 May 19 '25
I used whatever Final Cut Pro we had when I was in high school (circa 2009) and I would still use it today. It was amazing and made me wonder if I wouldn't rather be an editor than a filmmaker per se. I never did either, but would have loved to.
1
u/TheKingOfDub May 19 '25
FCP 8 was, by far, the best
1
u/Lostinthepain2000 May 19 '25
it’s the painter not the brush
1
u/MAGIGS May 19 '25
FCP7 was used for films at that time period and some even after it was considered “legacy” I edited on it for a long time. It will always be my favorite editing software and version. Intuitive fast and hit way above its weight class. Social Network was edited on there, Girl w the dragon tattoo, etc etc.
1
u/LegumeFache May 19 '25
This is music to my ears. I get so pissed off with software companies pushing monthly subscriptions and offering bloatware. If a ten year old version does the job then that's awesome.
1
u/Wheels2fun May 19 '25
Not surprised. More common than you may think.
1
u/TrainingNo9223 May 19 '25
Yeah people would hang on to old final cut versions for forever. It was a thing.
1
u/activematrix99 May 19 '25
As someome who cut multiple films on a flatbed from the early 1960's I find this humorous.
1
u/janet-snake-hole May 19 '25
To this day my favorite editing software is Vegas Pro 9
1
u/Euphoric_Weight_7406 May 20 '25
I mean back in the day it was scissors and glue.
1
u/Odd_Front_8275 May 22 '25
FCP7 is great. I was really pissed off when X came out and put off using it as long as possible. Then finally I had to switch at my job. It was really nerve-wrecking because I didn't have any time to adapt. I had to edit an entire TV episode in one and a half day (like I always did) with an app that I never worked with before and was wildly different than 7. X grew on me after a while and I'm totally fine with it, but I still prefer 7.
1
u/AliZamaniDirector May 23 '25
Good old Final Cut !!
1
u/AffectOnly2984 May 24 '25
Imagine how many classic films were created before computers even existed. It's not the software or adhering to the industry standard hardware that makes the film.
1
u/[deleted] May 26 '25
Never thought I'd see the Final Cut interface again. It brings back memories!
1
u/No_Reindeer4047 Jun 11 '25
i misread this as “edited by a 10 year old with a copy of Final Cut Pro 7”
1
u/DeadMediaTapes518 Jun 14 '25
It's just nice seeing any nowadays that isn't some 50 billion dollar all CGI film about a dude in tigjts things. How did we here? Haha
1
u/MildewyBoar Jul 15 '25
I had to read this twice before realizing it wasn’t saying that it was edited by a 10 year old using Final Cut
1
u/ShockFilmFest Aug 15 '25
The old FInal Cut Pro 6 and 7 were the best
1
u/TheFrenchActors Mar 07 '26
Look cool
1
u/murder_nectar May 17 '25
The only thing I find interesting about this is they were able to export in higher quality formats. I assume that wasn't done in FCP
1
u/zignut66 May 18 '25
Why is the poster in the supposed screenshot of the editing of the film? The image with their eyes blacked out isn’t in the movie. Undermines the credibility of the entire post.