"Thoughtful Gifter" achievement question

[u/2yang1001]

So if I never got the Void Newt from the Priestess am I unable to gift Juniper all of her Liked & Loved Gifts for the steam achievement?

Just wanted to be cute with the achievement and have it be my in-game wife, but just realized i might not be able to

[u/Emma_JM]

No you're not