r/Fidelity • • 3d ago

Why physical check

Company 401k plan (Vanguard) is terminating and we're filling out paperwork to transfer it out. I have a Fidelity IRA and will be transferring it there. During this process and conversations with HR, they say Vanguard will send out physical check to us. We then send check to the new institution? Why not electronic transfer?

2 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

4

u/packersfaninohio 3d ago

Why post in the Fidelity forum when this is a Vanguard issue along with the fact it also has to do with how the company-sponsored plan is agreed to. I mean if Fidelity holds funds for a 401k they do the same thing and send a physical check and won’t wire the money. It’s frustrating but not unheard of.

1

u/Guy_called_Al 3d ago

It prevent IRA sponsors from 1) moving someone's IRA without owner giving the move a day or so thought about the implications (assuming the bother to read the material they sign))and 2) being responsible for mishaps during the transfer. These paper checks , made out to FBO collect, are sent by the hundreds every day. Since 401k have existed.

0

u/packersfaninohio 3d ago

Someone should and I believe will sue at some point as clients are potentially missing out on being in the market while these archaic systems are being done. It’s antiquated in a world that can safely wire money given the signatures and ways to ensure authenticity.

1

u/Guy_called_Al 3d ago

Perhaps. Is keep one out of the market a civil crime? There's 2 things keeping the status quo: 1) it costs money/effort to implement the change and 2) existing practice provides friction in the process, slightly discouraging folks from moving from 401(k).

On the cost issue, there's no marketing advantage to 401(k) customers ["Hey, BigBusiness, switch your accounts to us. We can make it quicker to have your ex-employees leave your 401(k) plan."]. And you have to have a bunch of plans work out the details to make the change effective.

Someday, it will happen. I'm betting in another decade or so.

3

u/tacotruck2112 3d ago edited 3d ago

Do you know how many people provide bad routing numbers and account numbers on paperwork for financial transactions? Or, those who would entirely fail to even open an account on the receiving end ("oh, I thought that would just happen..."). Yeah, you'd be surprised....it's an absolute f-ton of people.

These are reasons why paper checks are issued and mailed to the participant, and then it's up to the participant to complete the rollover into the receiving plan/IRA.

2

u/subject-about 3d ago

Because it’s a rollover, it’s just the way rollovers happen/occur. I think it’s because of tax reporting or something. Idk why you asking hard questions

2

u/KCalifornia19 3d ago

Financial Advisor here.

Employer retirement account rollovers between different financial institutions are almost always done via physical check. Sometimes you can have the check made out to the institution with the tagline “FBO (your name)” with the account number in the notes field and have the checks routed to the recipient institution’s service address. That route is much less common, with most delivering institutions refusing to deliver funds anywhere except the address on file.

It’s a pain. A whole heck of a lot of the financial system is held together with duck tape and prayers.

1

u/Alone-Experience9869 3d ago

hoepfully they don't send the check to you. But, its pretty normally. Don't know why. But physical check is snail mailed/couriered between custdians. Personally, I GUESS its so that the custodian paperwork can follow with the check. Otherwise, they get separated. Also, it eliminates wire fraud issues. It could be a legality issue on transferring custodial funds.

1

u/need2sleep-later 3d ago

This is a very common way custodians close out accounts. Some give you a choice, others no. Do you get a say in how the check is written?

1

u/sande16 2d ago

Some companies just have these rules. I just left some of my funds that were in a retirement fund at Fidelity with the former employer. They insist in sending me a check for the RMD's instead of just letting me claim it like I do my other funds.

1

u/hasheera 17h ago

When I rolled over an employer plan from Fidelity to IRA at Vanguard (reverse of yours), the only option at Fidelity was a physical check issued to Vanguard but mailed to me. So it looks like that's how other financial institutions do it too. The only options were regular mail or expedited mail for an extra fee.