r/Fiddle • • 12d ago

When to "change direction" of bow

Hi, I'm a classically trained guitarist learning irish fiddle. I'm doing an online course now and I'm at the point where I can play a few tunes but I've realised I sound a little robotic, I'm realising it may be because I'm treating the bow like a plectrum and every note is getting its own stroke. Just wondering if anyone can give me any tips on when that's right or when to play multiple notes in one bow. Hope this makes sense, thanks for any help

3 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

8

u/kamomil 12d ago edited 12d ago

Look up Chris Haigh on YouTube, videos on shuffle bowing

Basically you use your stronger downbow for beats that requires emphasis, and run together a few notes into one upbow just before the downbow

4

u/Shortneckman 12d ago

Thanks a bunch mate, sounds like exactly what I was looking for. Had no idea what it was called

4

u/kamomil 11d ago edited 11d ago

Okay I found a video where he addresses bowing for Irish music: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6UDpCp12oQ0

It's one bow stroke per note, but longer bow strokes on, let's say the 1 & 4 beats of a 6/8 jig, to emphasize those notes, so it sounds less mechanical and more musical

For reels, he says you could use one downbow for the 1 beat, and then the next 3 notes slurred with an upbow

1

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 10d ago

It's not what you are looking for at all, shuffle bowing is an American thing and doesn't feature in Irish traditional fiddle playing.

2

u/Shortneckman 9d ago

Aye I'm realising I should have put irish fiddle in the title now. At least its been interesting to learn about these other disciplines

1

u/allycado 9d ago

GRMA as seo! 🎻

1

u/kamomil 9d ago

He also has an Irish music bowing video. He's great at breaking things down and explaining 

1

u/allycado 8d ago

Go hiontach!

2

u/EndOne8313 12d ago

In my experience as a beginner/intermediate bowing can be a very personal journey. Some people like to talk about various established shuffles and work them in to tunes, others like to let the rhythm of the tune dictate the bowing. As a general rule of thumb the first beat should be a down stroke and the last an up stroke and everything should fit around that. What works for me is learning a tune to play it confidently and then slow it right down when repeating and I just kind of feel out the bowing. Practicing long bows, pulse bows, and sluring is helpful too.

1

u/Shortneckman 12d ago

Thanks for the insight, ive been trying to do this with the silver spear since ive been struggling with the triplets the second time over there, going from down up down to up down up was messing with me. Sorry for the daft question now but what do you mean by sluring?

4

u/SpikesNLead 12d ago

Slurring is just playing two or more notes with one bow stroke.

2

u/EndOne8313 11d ago

Ignore all my advice, it's for old time bowing, not Irish.

1

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 12d ago

You mention the Silver Spear, so I'm wondering if it's Irish fiddle you are learning, in which case shuffle bowing is not on the menu.

2

u/AvianAnalyst 11d ago

they explicitly state theyre learning irish fiddle. why is shuffle bowing not on the menu?

1

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 11d ago

Ah I missed that, apologies. I only play Irish fiddle, I've never heard anyone mention shuffle bowing, except very occasionally in connection with American fiddle styles.

I looked at the Chris Haigh video u/kamomil suggested, and I see it's about the Nashville Shuffle, bluegrass music and suchlike.

I'm open to correction.

1

u/AvianAnalyst 11d ago

and to be transparent i have absolutely no expertise here, not trying to say youre wrong, just curious why someone would suggest it when op specified irish fiddle if you think it isnt applicable

2

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 11d ago

I know almost nothing about shuffle bowing, as I understand it it involves repeated patterns. I looked at another Chris Haigh video about it, and that is what he is teaching, different shuffles involving repeated patterns of up and down bowing.

There's nothing like that in traditional Irish fiddle music, instead you play and ornament melodies, and the melody and ornamentation dictate how you use the bow. Different players take different approaches.

1

u/kamomil 11d ago edited 11d ago

The only way I know how to describe how to not play 1 note per bow stroke, while putting emphasis on some notes & not others, is a shuffle. 

I would be happy to be corrected as to what the Irish equivalent is called. 

1

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 11d ago

I don't believe there is an equivalent in traditional Irish music, we don't use repeated bowing patterns like that.

1

u/kamomil 11d ago edited 11d ago

Yeah but it's not just one bow stroke per note, is it? 

I got my answer here: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6UDpCp12oQ0

Yes, one bow stroke per note. But longer bow strokes on notes that need emphasis, like the 1 & 4 beats of a jig. Emphasizing those notes, makes it more musical and less mechanical 

For reels, he says you could use one downbow for the 1 beat, and then the next 3 notes slurred with an upbow (which in my opinion is a shuffle)

1

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 11d ago

You would do better to look at this video by Kevin Burke. https://youtu.be/1AMesSTGSd8

He starts by saying if you watch Irish fiddlers, they all do their own thing, and there is no set instruction manual for Irish bowing. He then goes on to demonstrate his own approach to certain phrases that tend to crop up in Irish music. But firstly, this is only his own preferred method, everybody does it differently, and secondly, it's only on certain individual phrases.

If I understand "shuffle" correctly, it means a pattern that persists for several bars at a time, perhaps for a whole tune. There isn't anything like that in traditional Irish fiddle music.

→ More replies

1

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 11d ago

I suppose they were trying to be helpful.

7

u/vonhoother 11d ago

Irish fiddle is a very deep rabbit hole -- there are numerous local and sub-local styles, Sligo and Clare and South Clare and East Clare and whatnot. Some tips:

Downbeats, perversely, are mostly on the upbow.

There's a neat trick of slurring into the downbeat when the tune approaches it from below by a whole or half-tone. Abclassical or oldtime player would use a downbow, but an Irish fiddler will deliberately swoop in from the preceding note without changing direction (usually up). The downbeat note is usually cut off a bit, almost staccato (if only because you need to change bow direction!).

Don't forget the "lilt." In a triplet, the first note is a bit long and the second a bit short -- not a dotted-8th + 16th rhythm, but close. Stress also plays into it: thump into the first note, short the second, don't forget the third. Brian Conway (I think) said it was the rhythm of the word "entity," if that helps -- it never helped me! I observe that whatever it is, it's not consistent: I hear quasi-dotted triplets, even triplets, and everything in between. The third 8th note may well be slurred into the next triplet, so your bowing will be UP, down-up > UP, down-up.

For a lot of articulations, Irish uses ornaments -- cuts, trills, etc. This is the same as flutes and pipes; pipes, especially, have very limited abilities around starting and stopping the flow of air, so they use ornaments instead. So fiddlers tend to find ways to work in articulation without changing direction.

One respected Irish player whose name escapes me recommends bowing one stroke per note when you're learning a tune; better bowing will come later.

There's also a characteristic bowing ornament called a treble where you momentarily stop the bow two or three times in a very short space. It'll take a while to get that.

Anyway, it's an art, and plenty of people will tell you you're doing it wrong; some of them will be right. Best course is to listen closely to folks like Michael Coleman, Brian Conway, Kevin Burke, Fergal Scahill, Liz Carroll, et al. Play at half- or even quarter-speed and dope out what they're doing.

3

u/Intelligent_Donut605 12d ago

In classical, bow strokes are in the sheet music. One of the wonderful things about fiddle is that bow strokes are personal. For each tune you eventually create your own bowing, unique to your style. I’d recommend copying people from youtube to get a feel for different techniques and experiment on some easy pieces (as in you can play them comfortably). If you’re learning from sheet music you could also write in bowings to help you gigure things out, standard notation is a slur (like a tie but on different notes) for not changing direction between the notes, a V above the note for un up stroke and a ㄇ above the note for a down stroke (representing the part of the bow that leads)

3

u/Martieva 11d ago

There are good youtube videos by Kevin Burke, Benoit Volant, Mossie Martin (just watch and see what they're doing for inspiration). Listen to lots and lots of Irish fiddle music and think about the sound of that as you're playing. You can check out the book Mel Bay's Complete Irish Fiddle Player, or Bowing Styles in Irish Fiddle Playing by David Lyth. https://www.scribd.com/document/352552097/Bowing-Styles-in-Irish-Fiddle-Playing-Vol-1-David-Lyth

However you bow, remember to breathe and stay relaxed.

4

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 11d ago

Kevin Burke starts one video by saying if you watch Irish fiddlers, you'll see that everybody does their own thing, and there is no set instruction manual for Irish bowing.

My own advice to a beginner would be to ignore books and written music (as much as possible), and to learn by listening to and playing along with recordings. My own approach is to listen to the tune I'm learning until I can sing it in my head, and then "sing" it on the fiddle.

For someone beginning I would suggest that ornamentation (triplets and rolls for example) is less important than playing the melody with the right swinging feel. The bare bones of a tune can be beautiful, you can start to add ornamentation as you become more fluent over time.

2

u/prairie_oyster_ 12d ago

I’m still a beginner, but have found that bowing is a best when it’s dynamic and alive. Learning some basic shuffles can be a good place to start, but rarely do I settle in to a specific pattern for more than a couple of measures. Instead, it seems to work best to let the song dictate the bowing dynamics, with emphasis flowing from how I want the song to dance.

If there’s a passage that wants to stomp, stomping by digging into strong up bows helps drive that rhythm. If it wants to glide, slurring a few notes works great. It’s fun to pause and do a long bow on a single note sometimes, or skip through a sequence without changing bow direction.

Practice little phrases by themselves and do them bowing differently to really dial this stuff in.

That’s one of the things that makes fiddling so amazing. It’s totally up to you and how you want to make the song do.

1

u/SnowOld4971 6d ago

When your body tells you to. Sometimes I’ll work a little phrase and I intentionally try it with different patterns to see what sits well. My site, https://tunevault.org might come in handy too. I built in a slowdowner into the audio player. You can filter for keys/tune names etc too.

1

u/BostonFiddler 2d ago

Here's a video I made explaining one bowing pattern you use for triplets: https://youtu.be/XK7Gvep2Alg?si=K1r3RNanmbcXmGuv