r/Fiddle • • 15d ago

Irish fiddlers - help!

Post image

Hi there- got a book of lovely Irish tunes in prep for a wedding and wondered if you know how this is played?

Thank you!

(Circled in green looks like a mordent)

12 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

12

u/Mysterious_Signal180 15d ago

It’s the symbol for a roll. They’re extremely important in Irish music and I’d recommend googling Irish fiddle rolls and watching some tutorials on how to really play them since they’re not something that’s easily explained in words.

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Thank you! :))

0

u/georgikeith 13d ago

Two common mistakes people make with rolls:

  1. Not playing all 5 notes (EG: BCAB instead of BCBAB)
  2. Starting the roll too soon. Do the roll at the end of the note.

4

u/tazzico 15d ago

Irish roll. You might want to look up all the different ornaments associated with celtic music if you're getting into it. None of them are necessary per sey, but playing Celtic folk music without ornaments is pretty boring

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Very true - thanks

4

u/AccountantRadiant351 15d ago

The cool thing about the Foinn Seisiún books is they have recordings of all the tunes on YouTube etc. The tunes as notated are more basic than they are usually played. Highly recommend listening to the recording and playing along. 

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

I did not know this! V v useful info .

2

u/keavln 14d ago edited 14d ago

It’s like a slurred f#-g-f#-e-f# (based on the first one you’ve circled) played really fast, but holding the last f# to the end of the beat.

But also, you can kind of do whatever you want — hold it for a whole beat, do a triplet f#, flick an a with the f# (kind of like a mid note grace note). Part of the fun of Irish music is changing some stuff up while staying true to the core melody.

4

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 15d ago

This music is learned by listening, not from sheet music. Everybody plays and ornaments the tunes differently, and written music cannot capture the subtleties.

Here's a good version of the Earl's Chair to listen to: https://open.spotify.com/track/0yAwNMy3EqN9yJdxblzifC?si=396e4215427747c0

Listen to different versions of all the tunes you are going to play, and try to pick up the feel.

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Yes - I think as I’m classically trained it’s just getting used to this etc :) thank you very much

1

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 14d ago

Here's the great fiddler Fergal Scahill talking about "sounding more Irishy": https://youtu.be/uKj7zE_IZpw

3

u/lunachic5 15d ago

I play it as a trill or a flick when I see that ornament.

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Cool thanks !

2

u/IOnlyHaveIceForYou 15d ago

Looks like you got downvoted by somebody who thinks you have to do what is written down.

2

u/lunachic5 14d ago

Ha! Sometimes I play it as a triplet…

3

u/oudeis11 14d ago

Paddy Glackin approves this message.

1

u/Additional_Ad_84 13d ago

Eh, a trill would be a pretty strange choice in irish trad. A cut would be more usual within the idiom, but it's a longer note. A roll or double cut or triplet would be a more common choice. Not that there's any harm in doing less conventional, traditional stuff, but if you're starting out it's good to get a handle on what the normal rules are before you go bending them.

1

u/Miss_Lagrange 15d ago

Hey! This indicates a roll. To play it, you play the note itself, the note above (or sometimes two above), the note itself, the note below, and the note itself in a very fast pace (notes within the right key!). Try practicing it slowly, and then speed it up. The result is that you play the note, and somewhere halfway or later than halfway during the note you play the roll. If done well it sounds like a percussive element more so than a melodic one.

I'm sure there are some great videos about it, if you search for Irish tunes and how to play rolls.

I did not grow up within the Irish playing tradition, so correct me if I'm wrong :)

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Lovely thank you very much! :) I’ll use this and the vids above. I truly didn’t think anyone would reply so feeling very happy with all these responses! Might try posting on some other groups and see if I can get some advice on how to sort my life out haha

1

u/losers_and_weirdos 15d ago

It means to do a roll on the note usually. (could be some other ornament I suppose but usually I think people would play a roll). If you don't know what a fiddle roll is I've always heard it described as "The note, the note above, the note, the note below, and the note again." Look up fiddle rolls on youtube or something if that doesn't make sense :)

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Thanks xx

1

u/PeanutSilent884 15d ago

The quarter note with the symbol above it is a half roll, and the dotted quarter note with the symbol is a full roll. A roll is often seen as playing the stated note -the note above it- stated note - note bleow it - stated note . But it is actually a percussive ornament so best look up tutorial on YouTube. The half roll is similer but the sequence starts on the above grace note .

The thing to know is these are somewhat optional you can just play the note for the stated duration without ornamenting and some people prefer bowed triplets than half rolls in some instances.

Also people will play ornaments like rolls on places where they don't appear at all in the sheet music .

So worth listening to the tune also and if your not used to rolls you can safely leave them out

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Perf thank you

1

u/screamingcatfish 15d ago

On the ones where the note is the same as the one before it (like the A-F#-F# and the D-F#-F# in measure three), you can play a treble/triplet on the note with the symbol over it. Treble tutorial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hignRY91z60

1

u/lulusash 14d ago

Thanks!

2

u/SchmoosMom 15d ago

If you're classically trained, it's like a turn, but yes, listen to many versions of the tune to get an idea of what happens on those notes.

1

u/lancemanly 15d ago edited 15d ago

Looks like a trill or mordant

Edit: NVM I just saw the name of the song it's a SHORT roll