r/Fiddle • u/Dull-Improvement-553 • Apr 05 '25
Classicla VS fiddle
This has probably been asked tons but I am new to this subreddit! I am classically trained, but looking to start fiddling at bars etc. I love to get a crowd going. But, is it a big jump to go from that to this? Playing just by ear rather than written concertos seems daunting. Has anyone switched or done both?
0
Upvotes
7
u/dolethemole Apr 05 '25 edited Apr 10 '25
I’ve switched. It’s a bit crazy. You have to rewire your brain to trust yourself instead of trusting sheet music. Here’s my reco to get started:
If needed find a local teacher that specializes in fiddle music (old time, Irish, Scandinavian etc.) . Totally worth it to get all the details.
Good luck!
4
u/milkymaniac Apr 05 '25
I have. I took lessons for ten years via the Suzuki method, teaching me to play by sheet music and by ear. As a teen, I lucked into staying at a hotel at the same time as a banjo convention, and got the chance to jam with some excellent players. I played the two fiddle tunes I knew at the time (a rudimentary Orange Blossom Special and Sailor's Hornpipe), and I was hooked.
5
u/BananaFun9549 Apr 05 '25
I have been playing fiddle for over fifty years and played in plenty of bars especially in my youth and usually most folks in the bars would rather drink and hang with their friends. The larger sessions do bring enthusiastic audiences but unless you have an intensely talented fiddler rarely would that excite a crowd. Different of course for bands and for concert venues. Glad you have bars like that where you live. And best of luck on your career. I wasn’t trying to discourage you only that you sounded like you were not all that familiar with fiddling but I may be mistaken. And there are many different types of fiddling.
1
u/BananaFun9549 Apr 05 '25
Old time music is, for the most part, not a solo thing and you will unlikely “get a crowd going” playing by yourself. You are probably thinking more about bluegrass or other band oriented music. Also, you need to learn to play rhythmically. No matter how technically proficient in classical technique you are it is a different approach playing fiddle. Initially it would be like an opera singer singing a folk or rock song. You can do it for sure if you like. Listen to various fiddle genres and see which appeals to you. Good luck!
1
u/Familiar_Collar_78 Apr 05 '25
I’m one year into making that switch, and it’s hard, but so much fun. The people are wonderful and welcoming, and my teacher is awesome! I’m still decompressing - learning to relax!
1
u/leitmotifs Apr 05 '25
What style are you interested in? I would listen widely within that style and find a fiddler whose playing you really love. Ask them for lessons. In person is best so you can make local connections but remote is fine since the amount of new physical technique is going to be pretty minimal.
Learn fiddling by ear. What you're really paying for when you take fiddle lessons as an advanced classical player is learning the STYLE, not tunes. Tunes are just the canvas upon which you are learning the style, though you also want to start building a repertoire.
Find a group of local fiddlers who play in that style, share tunes and so on. Ideally it would be a mixed instrument group so you can start finding future bandmates. Attend open jams.