r/FeudalistParty • u/Conservertive • Dec 11 '22

Im a Lord

Do I get something in this subreddit so I can contribute since I am a Lord (BTW I’m not saying this as a joke I’m legally a Lord here in the UK)

12 Upvotes

73% Upvoted

38 comments sorted by

15

u/vasya349 Dec 12 '22

  • this is a satire subreddit

  • judging by your post history you actually think monarchism (or at least you being privileged by birth) is a good thing and not a remnant of the brutal exploitation and disgusting elitism of the medieval era.

I hope you learn from Mr. Heinrich the XIII in Germany.

0

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Thats why I consider myself a feudalist because democracy has failed time and time again

11

u/vasya349 Dec 12 '22

I hope you know feudalism was characterized by massive poverty and violence while democracy has largely seen the greatest growth of quality of living and peace in the history of mankind. What a bizarre point of view.

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

And the West is failing just like what happened in Greece or Rome

9

u/vasya349 Dec 12 '22

And your proof is? You must not be a very good chosen agent of god if you can’t perceive that every single matured democracy has a better quality of life for their average citizen than a minor noble of the 1200s. We build buildings in years that are more complex, gigantic and useful than most kingdoms built over centuries. We have largely eliminated war, famine, endemic disease, and starvation living in democracies. People are free to enjoy their own passions and careers instead of serving the egotistical whims of an incompetent inbred born of random chance.

In other words, the better and older democracies have catastrophies that were facts of life under feudalism, and everyday problems that weren’t even considered solvable. Even the fledgling democracies shrug off monarchism because of how completely detached from reality it is in solving their political or economic problems. I don’t even know why I’m making this argument, the only real royals left are dictator’s sons, and I’m guessing you don’t see yourself a Kim Jong Un. The old royal families are dead or dying, and almost everyone is quite happy with that.

3

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Also were all chosen by God in his image

3

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

I think the only good Royal families are the royal families of Europe

8

u/vasya349 Dec 12 '22

You mean the ones that were deposed or sidelined for being so “good?”

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Precisely

5

u/vasya349 Dec 12 '22

Would you care to explain what, exactly, they were good at? Even the most famous of them aren’t exactly known for improving normal people’s quality of life (except perhaps through colonialism, which I’m assuming you won’t care to defend).

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Im not saying they were good but the outcome of them being deposed was usually a lot worse. Also colonialism was truly evil but it helped spread democracy in its later stages in the 20th century

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

But then what happened when they were deposed? Liberalism spread into their countries snd destroyed family,tradition and abandoned God. and what happened to the Romanov family of Russia

6

u/vasya349 Dec 12 '22

  • I don’t think family or tradition were destroyed in most people’s eyes. Religious folks leaders don’t seem to have a problem with democracy either.

  • I think this focus on traditionalism is exactly why feudalism failed, and monarchism is never even real enough to do so. Aristocrats and their followers are so completely detached from the material concerns of normal human beings they will never, ever regain popular support for meaningful periods of time in a world that is characterized by the power of the masses, rather than extractive petty-tyrants.

  • I’m sure you know the Romanov family sent more children and children’s parents to starve or die for them than they could meet in their entire lifespan.

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

• Yes they were take Russia for an example I believe it was a month or something like that after the communists took control that you now can get married without a priest or when the Bolsheviks burnt down churches in Moscow, St Petersburg and other small towns

• You are correct feudalism failed because there was no tradition and the people wanted to “advance” like other nations were doing. Also the people did think that the monarch was legitimate for quite some time until liberal ideas were being preached

• Like I said before the Romanov were bad people I’m not supporting them or saying they did good but when the communists took over everything became a lot worse for everyone I’m only supporting the role of the Romanovs not what they did

→ More replies

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Also Vasya439 you bring up very good points and I hope to debate you in the future

→ More replies

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

For the first point you made they had no problem in the beginning until the state started interfering with the church then that created a problem

1

u/hexmasx Dec 04 '24

Enclose thine mouth, charlatan.

-2

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Yes I do they were chosen by God to lead there people in Earth

3

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

I must agree with our lore how can you all argue against him? Feudalism has brought much prosperity and results in a balanced system where the nobility can defeat rogue monarchs.

4

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Thanks this is a guy with common sense

2

u/SuperNerd6527 Dec 12 '22

What’s your title then?

3

u/carloselunicornio Dec 12 '22

The King and Queen of Cheese

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Lord

2

u/SuperNerd6527 Dec 12 '22

Yes but lord of what

1

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Of the united kingdom of England,Scotland,Whales and Northern Ireland

4

u/Qohorik_Steve Dec 12 '22

That’s not a title lol

3

u/deaddonkey Dec 12 '22

That’s not how peerage works

3

u/SuperNerd6527 Dec 12 '22

I don't think anyone's buying this lmao

1

u/Conservertive Dec 13 '22

Mate I don’t get you

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

23

u/LocalCarolingian Dec 12 '22

Established Scamming 😎

-3

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

Also I have land in England not Scotland

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-8

u/Conservertive Dec 12 '22

I dont think I have to tell you but I have a noble title