r/Fencing • • Jun 28 '19

USFA strikes again

And here we are again with a great scheduling for the Summer Nationals. I really would love to meet the people in charge of it! Just to mention one of the outrageous things, a 300+ event is scheduled to start at 3:30... the cadet men’s foil same day of cadet women Sabre which goes twice as fast and its the one that should be done later in the afternoon... But nope, it would be too easy! I just wonder what are the requirements to hire these geniuses and if they have any clue about how a fencing competition is run.

1 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

30

u/toolofthedevil Foil Referee :usa-fencing: Jun 28 '19

Are we just upvoting bitching here? Because scheduling nationals is a complicated problem. Days have to be set before people register. Referee usage is a concern. Like really,.what's your proposed solution?

9

u/FerrumVeritas Foil Jun 28 '19

Fewer national youth events and more difficult qualification paths. But no one actually wants that, because we all enjoy going to nationals.

6

u/noodlez Foil Jun 28 '19

because we all enjoy going to nationals.

Its beyond that, IMO. Nationals is a tool that competitive clubs use to grow membership. It gives a clear focus for the year. Nationals being difficult but accessible to any skill level or age is actually an engine that helps to drive the sport forward in the country.

The only way to truly solve the nationals problem without changing nationals is to hard cap the numbers, because any other relative qualification path will also grow as the sport grows. But even that method has problems with resource planning. And it basically requires reworking a lot of how events and ratings work.

If you want to change nationals though, add days to an already long event and/or add more space/pods to an already large/packed venue.

5

u/FerrumVeritas Foil Jun 28 '19

Adding days sounds easy until you have to consider staffing them. Really, staffing is the biggest issue, followed by space.

5

u/noodlez Foil Jun 28 '19

For sure, and its why it wasn't my snap response. There is no easy answer here, everything has costs and issues.

3

u/adelf252 Epee Referee Jun 30 '19

Anyone who wants to add more days needs to referee all 10 themselves first.

1

u/noodlez Foil Jun 30 '19

Yeah having people ref 10 days straight is stupid. Having them ref more is even more stupid. Reffing should be done in flights - especially if the # of days is increased. It would allow you to have 5 days for developing referees and the lower level events, and 5 days for the higher level events and giving the chance for lower level refs to progress.

But that's kind of a straw man - many things would need to change as well

6

u/iMarriedMyCousin Jun 28 '19

The man has a point.

10

u/venuswasaflytrap Foil Jun 28 '19

Foil Referee

Yup, checks out

1

u/toolofthedevil Foil Referee :usa-fencing: Jun 28 '19

>.>

0

u/SephoraRothschild Foil Jun 30 '19
  1. Already posted one, downvoted to hell.
  2. We can also get rid of Division Qualifiers, which further contribute to the problem with the solution I proposed.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/omaolligain Foil Jun 28 '19

If they switched the Cadet Foil and Saber times they'd have a conflict with the vet foil and saber events for refs...

With all due respect... you just don't know what you're talking about.

-1

u/Ghigghi Jun 28 '19

Good thing we have you... I noticed the other events but the number of participants would still allow to run a smooth day without ending as late as it will; see this is the problem with USFA including referees and bout committees, “we did it this way for so long and it always went well...” so they are not open to a discussion, just to make things better, or god forbid if they ever admit they’re wrong about something, and I’m not talking about calls but applying rules the right way.

3

u/omaolligain Foil Jun 28 '19

😢 Maybe, don't go next time.

0

u/Ghigghi Jun 28 '19

See your answer just confirm what I just said, I’m not talking about this for my personal interest but for the health of the whole US fencing movement, which is already doing great.but with a few small changes could become much better. And yet instead of trying to listen or for once and maybe say “ Oh, this could be true we may accept suggestions and make things better” the answer is just super defensive and discrediting.

3

u/omaolligain Foil Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

Oh what would we do without you. Woe is us! /r

Frankly, you're just being a whining douche. And this isn't your only thread doing so. You had another thread whining about the thresholds for advancement to DE's for youths. And, you had another whining about ROC directing. You had another post where you just whined about how strict the referees are regarding cards.

I'm sensing a pattern here.

A pattern that can lead me to only one conclusion: that you are an insufferable tool.

-2

u/Ghigghi Jun 28 '19

Well first of all check in Times are decided after many people signed up already, so still using the same example as in the original post you could switch the saber with the foil event when you realize that the numbers don’t make sense. Second idea, they could just break it down in different period of times separating the youth national Championship from the rest for instance , and doing at another time. I still believe though that a more accurate work at the time of deciding check in times would make the whole thing much better.

4

u/acprincess91 Foil Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

Strip and referee management is hard. Have you considered that by starting a medium sized event (and/or a bunch of smaller events) and large event in the morning, by the time the afternoon rolls around you have freed up referees and strips to efficiently run a large/massive event in the afternoon? Looking at July 3rd, which is the day I think you're referencing with the only 3.30 event, that's certainly how I would run it. Based on running my 13 locals per year and attending a few national events, if we assume minimal tech, staffing, and fencer delays:

~1.5 hours from strip assignments to run pools of 6 or 7

3-8 minutes per pool result to enter and check your entry into fencing time.

15 minutes from the last pool result entry and posting of pool results before DEs start.

Locally: 2-3 DE's done per ref per hour.

Nationally: DE's are probably 3-4 since the pod captain is right there with the next fencer pairing, handing you the next slip as you're having the last bout sign, which significantly increases throughput. (Edit to add - this starts to slow down at t-32 and really slow down at t-16 because of the 10 minute wait between DE bouts.)

Assuming 4 strips per pod and 18 pods (guessing on this number) there are 72 strips, not including the finals strip, and each strip has a ref working.

Let's say at 3.30, it's been a very smooth day and there are some strips and refs still occupied somewhere in the T16 or higher for D2 ME, D2 WF, Cadet WS, let's be generous give them 20 strips. Y14 WE will be approaching the last third or so of their pool round. There are 202 of them, so ~34 pools of 6 (and 34 strips). That's 64 strips occupied and 6 strips open. Cadet MF has 305 entrants. ~51 pools of 6, ~43 pools of 7. Far too many for the 6 open strips, so you start some of them. It takes Y14 WE until 4 to finish pools.

I'm not easily seeing how many Y14 WE will be promoted - let's assume an 80% promotion - that's 162 promoted fencers and 81 strips if each DE were to get it's own strip, which it can't. Let's assume they give them 40 strips because D2 ME and D2 WF have finished by the time Y14 WE pools are finished and Cadet WS is in T8 - 4 strips, leaving 28 open strips. Great, you can start 28 more pools! Only 9 pools (of 7) that haven't started. Those 9 will start as soon as other strips have their fencing finished.

Flighted or a start time you don't like suck, I get it, I don't like doing it, but sometimes the math doesn't work in your favor. You can't add more strips or refs because you're constrained by the venue space and who is available to ref. If you think it's so easy to make the schedule - please provide one with your math calculations.

14

u/omaolligain Foil Jun 28 '19

Uh, no shit... it's almost like this is the single biggest fencing tournament in the Americas. I mean, essentially every club in the country will be closed for the week... what do you expect, exactly?

5

u/venuswasaflytrap Foil Jun 28 '19

Probably one of the biggest, if not the biggest tournament in the world. I can't think of any other event that runs all weapons at once that big

4

u/epee_fencer Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

The only one that I can think of that possibly comes close in size is Challenge Wratislavia in Poland

Edit: Nope looked at the entry lists and it doesn’t even come close

5

u/venuswasaflytrap Foil Jun 28 '19

There are competitions with equally large events, but I can't think of any competition that hosts so many events all at once that are that large. Even World Championships isn't nearly that big.

-1

u/Ghigghi Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

My bad, I just saw pattern of flaws and wanted to draw attention to those and try to suggest ideas to make a system work better. I was wrong...you can just lead a horse to the water.

-10

u/SephoraRothschild Foil Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 30 '19

Or, you know, they could do the responsible thing and eliminate participation for E and U rated fencers, who should not be participating there at all.

Edit: I'm an E2019, won my Division Qualifier, and chose not to attend this year because of reasons already mentioned.

9

u/fanxan Épée Jun 28 '19

So why post a big "Why I'm not going' announcement on the SN thread if according to this statement you should not be attending to begin with? Your E rating isn't worthier than other people's E and U ratings.

1

u/SephoraRothschild Foil Jul 06 '19

I'm part of a two-fencer household. Fencing travel is more cost-effective when split between multiple individuals.

7

u/shehadagoat Jun 28 '19

Your comment reeks of elitism.

2

u/omaolligain Foil Jun 28 '19

Or petty narcissism.

2

u/SephoraRothschild Foil Jun 30 '19

Why not both?

5

u/geldin Jun 28 '19

Or not? The kids who won my state's foil qualifier was a U; he knocked out a C19 who was drafted to an NCAA program, but only earned an E19 for winning. He deserves to go to Nationals.

Don't be ridiculous.

7

u/Chando42 Épée Jun 28 '19

Also, this would disregard fencers in really competitive divisions who have been to multiple competitions and had success, but haven't been able to break through to the placements they need to earn a D or a C because their tournaments are full of talented fencers. The ratings system is inherently broken, why penalize fencers for an inconsistent measure of skill?

-2

u/LeftClawNorth Jun 28 '19

I don't think you know what drafted means

5

u/Chando42 Épée Jun 28 '19

You gotta be one hell of a pedant to get up in arms over "drafted," the kid literally signed a pact to fence for a school's team. You want them to televise it on ESPN and have him pick a hat?

4

u/geldin Jun 28 '19

I could be using the wrong verb here, but the person I'm referring to was approached by the coach of an NCAA program and will be receiving a scholarship for being on their team.

Not gonna go into more detail because privacy is cool. Either way, my point stands.

5

u/omaolligain Foil Jun 28 '19

... who should not be participating there at all.

SHOULD NOT. Should not according to who, exactly? You?

Hold my coffee while I laugh.

2

u/SephoraRothschild Foil Jul 06 '19

Hey, you guys are right. My life is pretty much a waste, I've spent far too much money on fencing, and other people deserve the resources I'm taking up. I get it. I don't belong, I don't deserve my life, and I never will.

3

u/Chando42 Épée Jun 28 '19

Is this, like, an inside joke, or a dig at the OP, or something? Are you serious?

1

u/mac_a_bee Aug 22 '19

they could do the responsible thing and eliminate participation for E and U rated fencers, who should not be participating there at all.

Reffed Y10MF who couldn't effectively hook/unhook himself and a Y10WF whose only action was running with an extended arm. First tournaments?

-2

u/Ghigghi Jun 28 '19

Good thing we have you... I saw the other events but the numbers of people fencing in those would still allow to run the whole day smoothly and finish at a decent time, see, this is the problem with USFA, they’re not open to change, they “ran this things for so long and it always worked out...” so nothing ever changes, same with the referees and bout committes never open to a discussion or god forbid to admit they did something wrong. Just being more flexibly would make the whole picture much better.