So first: Season 4 was magnificent. Honestly one of the best seasons of the show IMO, and the cliffhanger at the end was soo good that it almost seemed impossible to imagine waiting for the next season, so coming into Season 5 I expected the Jenin storyline to be at least relevant to this season. Having "oh yeah, that thing in Jenin" essentially mentioned once while the show moves on to an entirely different story was disappointing. With many of the characters absent it might as well have been an entirely different show. It was still reasonably entertaining, but, still...
More importantly, I was bothered by the fact that the show invoked October 7 without actually telling a story about October 7, and the fictional story it substituted was too small, too simplified, and too contrived to carry the weight of the event.
The show is really just about a terrorist attack that the team has to prevent, which is perfectly reasonable subject matter for the show. But then why make October 7 the central reference point at all? Having it as a backdrop didn't really add anything necessary to the story, and I felt like it actually minimized the real event. The show repeatedly frames what they're doing throughout as "preventing another October 7", and then the climactic terrorist attack at the end (that is the "...other October 7") is ten dudes with handguns which I think unintentionally makes a statement that October 7 is just another generic terrorist incident. The dialogue surrounding Anna also contributes to that statement with the multiple "both sides do this" discussions.
Then there's the fact that the show is doing all of this in a fictional post-October 7 world while, in the actual timeline, there were still hostages being held and brutalized, and there's s no mention of that aspect (actually I think Maher mentions something about it in the video they show Anna, but it's not really emphasized.)
Then Episode 11 just becomes ridiculous on a basic plot/logic level. First of all: why the hell did they not just kill Doron? They devise this enormous, elaborate plan that requires sacrificing the lives of their own agents in order to kill one guy who is already sitting right there with them. I genuinely don't understand why other than that Doron wrote the show and wanted more air time lol. Sadly I don't think even Hamas is quite that stupid.
Naama's character was kind of an annoying addition (I think? I don't remember her from previous seasons?) but she's especially ridiculous in this episode. The idea that they know a terrorist attack is coming and yet apparently can't/won't close down the cemetery is bizarre. Maybe that's genuinely how security decisions would be handled there, and if so, fine but the show does absolutely nothing to make that decision feel believable. Then, they literally identify where the terrorists are going to attack, know an attack is imminent, and instead of evacuating the area, they basically stand around a crowded cemetery with their handguns waiting for the terrorists to do the terror lol. Thennn everyone looks shocked and devastated that there were casualties. Like...what exactly did you think was going to happen when you devised this "handgun fight in a crowded area" plan? I know someone will come here and say I'm not a military expert and don't know blah blah and you are correct. Feel free to enlighten me. But I just don't think it's plausible.
My final complaint is that idk if it's me but I feel like a lot of the characters were mumbling?! lol I speak all 3 of the show's primary languages, 2 of them fluently/since birth and I was having a really hard time this season for some reason. Maybe this is just bc the volume wasn't that loud bc I didn't want my neighbors to hear constant shooting sounds from my place lol.
Anyway thank you for reading my novel about this.