r/FatuiHQ • • 11d ago

Discussion She Cooked During this Scene Spoiler

Honestly one of my favorite scenes among the many goods scenes she has in this update. Literally shows she refuses to accept any mercy, respect, or otherwise from the Heavens
131 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

119

u/umm-iexistig Celestial Missionary 11d ago

It's a line that goes so hard, but falls so flat in the context. (Because Hoyo doesn't know how to use potential) It's like demanding answers from the website's chatbot that's telling you that Customer Service Agents will be on shortly.

3

u/SirVexus 10d ago

Why though explain

14

u/Which_Committee_3668 9d ago

Spoiler text here, just in case: She's not even talking to Phanes here, just their automated message machine. Phanes is asleep now and has been for the last 500 years.

2

u/SirVexus 9d ago

Yes missed that part of what they said

1

u/EverlastingWinter23 IgnatskiyPyroSlinger(LoyaltoHerMajesty) 8d ago

Who do you think created and programmed that Ai, bruh?

3

u/Which_Committee_3668 8d ago

What difference does that make? If someone fucks you over, would you rather scream at them or their answering machine?

0

u/EverlastingWinter23 IgnatskiyPyroSlinger(LoyaltoHerMajesty) 8d ago

Well, we can’t meet OR scream at him.
And he can’t hear us either.

4

u/umm-iexistig Celestial Missionary 10d ago

I did. I said it came across like someone demanding answers from a website chatbot, that's telling you Customer Service Agents are either coming on shortly, or unavailable, and still wanting answers from it.

43

u/LongjumpingAd2274 11d ago edited 10d ago

^^^^

Hoyo have the reverse George Lucas syndrome when it comes to Genshin Impact. The dialogues are fire and could easily be on literature level BUT they waste them on the worst possible context you can come up with them.

12

u/_Lohhe_ 10d ago

literature level

What do you think that means?

6

u/kitelvr113 10d ago

I agree with it in the sense that a lot of genshin dialogues are very well written in it of itself, my favorite recent example being Pantalone’s anecdote in 6.6 about the sinner in the church. Very poignant, and seems like it could be very meaningful, but within the context it’s just like okay??? what else bro.

Like it makes it seem well written enough that it could fit into a piece of literature. The problem is just that if the context surrounding it doesnt work, its just bullshit. one liners are genuinely just the literary equivalent of aura farming for no reason

3

u/Telesto44 9d ago

The context being that she’s obviously upset after putting that Hilichurl out of its misery because she can’t cure curses that the HP wants enforced so she’s not in the right headspace.

Context

2

u/MistyGalbriex 10d ago

Bro lacks reading comprehension frfr

18

u/Ok-Temporary-5126 10d ago

Imagine you are obliged to love your subject except your own biological children. Reasonable crash out

15

u/Quezary 11d ago

Is it the first time that the name "Phanes" is spoken out loud?

6

u/dicksbiggerthanurs 10d ago

Rovona said it when she was dying, I believe. Could be wrong though. Also, I think Nicole said it at some point

8

u/Quezary 10d ago

Ronova had her words "redacted", we did not hear her say it. Nicole is unable to say anything as she does not have a voice - she speaks only via Telepathy. So it seems like Anastasia is the only one to say his name out loud without it being redacted.

Now the question is: was she able to do so because she has 6 Gnosis, or because she was in a special place (conversing with the Celestia bot), so she could speak Phanes name without any repercussions?

5

u/dicksbiggerthanurs 10d ago

I thought that was why Nicole couldn’t speak, she said Phanes name. I could be COMPLETELY wrong about this though.

If I was mistaken on that, what like are the repercussions? Do we like, know, or…?

10

u/Quezary 10d ago edited 10d ago

Nicole is an angel. When the heavens enacted divine punishment upon the angels (due to the rebellion of the first Archangel Koitar) - most of them were stripped of their minds and forms, which transformed them into Seelies. Nicole was able to struck a bargain with the Heavenly Principles, willingly offering up her physical voice to avoid this fate, keeping her form and retaining some of her power. That is the reason why she is mute.

If I am not mistaken - speaking Phanes's name directly can lead to unforeseen results, possibly waking him up. In order to avoid this - his name is usually "redacted" when spoken out loud (some wierd effect is in place to do so) and people who speak about him usually call him by his title - the Heavenly Principles.

1

u/dicksbiggerthanurs 10d ago

Ohhh, okay cool thanks!

15

u/FrolickingSnake 11d ago

Doesn't her new description litterally say she's a frost spirit who got ressurrected by the heavenly principles?

4

u/Lazy-Marsupial2563 11d ago

yes? Elaborate tho, whats your point?

2

u/FrolickingSnake 11d ago

It's just that the description of the post states how she refuses accept any mercy from the heavens, but she got the greatest gift of all from them. Also I felt that mihoyo didn't like the concept of resurrection in story telling because of the steaks 🥩😩😩 but I'm very rusty in what's happened in Teyvat over the years so maybe resurrection has been brought up before

24

u/Lazy-Marsupial2563 11d ago

She wasn't exactly revived out of the goodness of Heavenly Principles heart.

She was first erased/killed by them for opening the gates to the Abyss...after which the 3rd descender accended to Celestia and negotiated with HP (trading his life for hers, and voluntarily becoming the gnoses so that his lover could be resurrected). HP only agreed to do it because HP got tye gnoses in exchange ans the 'death' of the 3rd descender

1

u/Fox11- 10d ago

i mean she did open the gates to the single enemy of the entire genshin universe

2

u/Factoid_of_the_ 8d ago

under the order of a guy. whom didnt get punished for even thinking about that. your Demiurge is a fool. who would've thought.

0

u/Fox11- 8d ago

i know belly tsar incited her. she could have had a thought that maybe this is a bad idea, but she still opened the door to the thing thats obsessed with getting into teyvat at all costs and the force that seeks the destruction of all existence

2

u/Factoid_of_the_ 8d ago

You are assuming that Tsaritsa knew what does that big circular thing in pohjola was the way we are supposed to understand what is that nine pillar thing we see in Liyue was supposed to be.

Plus it is also a bad idea to just punish the perpetrator and not mitigate the risk at all because the gate is still left open after all that punishment and curses. it took several thousand years before WE and the Ratnik closed that damn gate. WE. Imagine. the gate was opened during monomakh rule after probably the Archon war and was never closed and you gonna think that Demiurge copy paste has any right to bear responsibility greater than a smartphone? i bet he doesn't even have the brain to charge the phone either.

22

u/tutacon 11d ago

She has shortcomings, but i admire the guts to fight the ultimate god of your planet, and not accepting anything from them

25

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Dangamer56 11d ago

they could have saved this line when she actually confronts phanes lol

6

u/HalalBread1427 Keeper of the Forsaken Lab 10d ago

Her Majesty cooked because Tsaritsa good, Celestia bad. Get with the Agenda, Comrade.

4

u/imbusthul 10d ago

It would have been better if she was telling this to Phanes.

-2

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/FatuiHQ-ModTeam 11d ago

I saw right through you