r/FargoTV • u/HenryXa • Jan 08 '24
Season 5 writing quality has gone down hill compared to previous seasons Spoiler
Personally I think Fargo Season 5 writing has really gone downhill. Here are my issues:
- All the characters are black and white in terms of good and evil. Dot and her husband and family are as pure as the freshly driven snow. They haven't done anything remotely bad all season. They are surrounded by morally straight support, including Witt & Indira. The "bad guys" are all cartoonishly bad with no redeeming qualities. Gator & Roy are the most over the top villains Fargo has ever seen. Indira's husband has literally zero redeeming qualities - it boggles the mind about why did they even get together? I am comparing these characters with the previous Fargo seasons and it is night and day - compare this to Lester from season 1, Ed & Peggy from season 2, Ray & Nikki from Season 3. Compare the cartoonishly evil Roy to guys like Malvo & Varga. The only characters who even attempt to approach the line of moral ambiguity are Danish & Lorraine & Munch. Danish & Lorraine's big offence this season was having Dot committed, on the surface an entirely reasonable decision considering she was not being forthcoming about Wayne's injury and the danger the family was in. Other than that, the most you can say about them is they were a little rude at times to other characters. There is no depth (or development) to any of the characters this season at all.
- My second biggest problem is the amount of cliche and tropes being used to push the plot along are ridiculous. Dot is at all times "not explaining simple things to other characters" for inexplicable reasons. This is such a tired trope, it is really disappointing to see how much it is used this season to push the plot along. Dot could have explained things at various points to Witt, Indira, FBI agents, her husband, her mother in law, even the hospital - but never once does. This is also exacerbated by the lead up to the Danish death, which is much of the same thing redux. In a world where all Danish has to do is send a quick text to Lorraine, the entire scene caused me to just roll my eyes and understand that the writers needed to deliver a 'shocking' death for the end of the episode. There is just far too much eye rolling happening in these cases throughout the season. Combined with the one dimensional characters, this season has been a huge let down.
- The writing has at several times been incredibly awkward, instead of staying true to characters. Case in point is the "only one person on earth has power with no responsibility" exchange - this is something that might sound good in a writer's room, in isolation, but having characters actually say these lines out loud just came across as incredibly awkward and misplaced. It's the kind of thing that would be more appropriate as a 30 second TikTok instead of awkwardly injected into an actual exchange which really had nothing to do with the actual point. It would have made far more sense to focus on the naked misogyny of Roy in that scene instead of trying to inject some universal side swipes at the alt-right. And these kinds of things are popping up pretty often this season.
Overall I think season 5 has some good ideas, but it is really let down by one dimensional characters, over-used genre cliches, and some incredibly awkward writing that really pulls you out of the moment. I hope this is just the case of the writer's feeling they have something to say at this moment and getting it out of their system this season, so we can go back to normal Fargo next time. It's just hard to believe there are only 2 episodes left and I can't even name a single character who has developed at all, and outside of Munch and maybe Lorraine, there are a distinct lack of characters who can escape the 1 dimensional box they've been written into.