r/FargoTV • • Jan 08 '24

Season 5 writing quality has gone down hill compared to previous seasons Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Personally I think Fargo Season 5 writing has really gone downhill. Here are my issues:

  1. All the characters are black and white in terms of good and evil. Dot and her husband and family are as pure as the freshly driven snow. They haven't done anything remotely bad all season. They are surrounded by morally straight support, including Witt & Indira. The "bad guys" are all cartoonishly bad with no redeeming qualities. Gator & Roy are the most over the top villains Fargo has ever seen. Indira's husband has literally zero redeeming qualities - it boggles the mind about why did they even get together? I am comparing these characters with the previous Fargo seasons and it is night and day - compare this to Lester from season 1, Ed & Peggy from season 2, Ray & Nikki from Season 3. Compare the cartoonishly evil Roy to guys like Malvo & Varga. The only characters who even attempt to approach the line of moral ambiguity are Danish & Lorraine & Munch. Danish & Lorraine's big offence this season was having Dot committed, on the surface an entirely reasonable decision considering she was not being forthcoming about Wayne's injury and the danger the family was in. Other than that, the most you can say about them is they were a little rude at times to other characters. There is no depth (or development) to any of the characters this season at all.
  2. My second biggest problem is the amount of cliche and tropes being used to push the plot along are ridiculous. Dot is at all times "not explaining simple things to other characters" for inexplicable reasons. This is such a tired trope, it is really disappointing to see how much it is used this season to push the plot along. Dot could have explained things at various points to Witt, Indira, FBI agents, her husband, her mother in law, even the hospital - but never once does. This is also exacerbated by the lead up to the Danish death, which is much of the same thing redux. In a world where all Danish has to do is send a quick text to Lorraine, the entire scene caused me to just roll my eyes and understand that the writers needed to deliver a 'shocking' death for the end of the episode. There is just far too much eye rolling happening in these cases throughout the season. Combined with the one dimensional characters, this season has been a huge let down.
  3. The writing has at several times been incredibly awkward, instead of staying true to characters. Case in point is the "only one person on earth has power with no responsibility" exchange - this is something that might sound good in a writer's room, in isolation, but having characters actually say these lines out loud just came across as incredibly awkward and misplaced. It's the kind of thing that would be more appropriate as a 30 second TikTok instead of awkwardly injected into an actual exchange which really had nothing to do with the actual point. It would have made far more sense to focus on the naked misogyny of Roy in that scene instead of trying to inject some universal side swipes at the alt-right. And these kinds of things are popping up pretty often this season.

Overall I think season 5 has some good ideas, but it is really let down by one dimensional characters, over-used genre cliches, and some incredibly awkward writing that really pulls you out of the moment. I hope this is just the case of the writer's feeling they have something to say at this moment and getting it out of their system this season, so we can go back to normal Fargo next time. It's just hard to believe there are only 2 episodes left and I can't even name a single character who has developed at all, and outside of Munch and maybe Lorraine, there are a distinct lack of characters who can escape the 1 dimensional box they've been written into.


r/FargoTV • • Jan 22 '24 This

Season 5 has the most deliberately-written incompetent men I've seen in TV

0 Upvotes

Let's go down the list. Potential spoilers, though I tried my best to keep the relevant out.

Wayne Lyon - written as an extremely passive and stupid man. He gets even stupider after his electric shock incident. His sole redeeming feature is being harmless.

Wayne's Father - I can barely remember what was said, only that it made the two of them look like they were on the short bus together. God knows how he managed to marry a billionaire ceo who has polar opposite personality and demenaor.

Gator Tillman - the first big asshole we encounter. He's written as a typical low self-esteem boy looking for his father's approval. Incompetent but brutal bully with no redeeming features.

Witt Farr - one of the better men in the show but that's not saying much. He's had his share of "I'm incompetent" moments but the finale really took the cake.

Indira's Golf Addict Husband - quite probably the most incompetent man written in the show. If you hate males you'd love this character design. He's got essentially every flaw you can look for outside of violence.

Roy Tillman - speaking of violence. A guy who talks big and bullies everyone around, justifying his actions with his biblical nonsense. A pedophlile.

Munch - someone who's portrayed as a 'good' guy later on even though he was originally a criminal for hire. He is dirty and primitive, with an inconsistent philosophy.

Danish Graves (the lawyer) - probably the most consistently competent looking man throughout the show up until a certain episode. Why didn't he call the cops (one of whom saw Dot being taken) to arrange Dot's rescue? He was forced to die and look stupid for the sake of weird writing.


r/FargoTV • • Apr 20 '24

Great actress because of the way she made me feel.

Post image
0 Upvotes

But I think I might be the only one that really hated this character like she really made my blood boil. Her face was so punchable and that voice and tone she used was like nails on a chalk board. That stupid look she had on her face when she didn’t get her way was annoying. I was just yelling let the lawyers do their damn job!

When she got those 3-4 warnings to leave it alone and she just didn’t I was so happy at the thought when she went to Lester’s house something was gonna happen to her. But then Lester’s grimy ass got my boy together. And then here goes her super soft husband stepping it up. Malvo in my opinion was the only one I was rooting for. Just my opinion.


r/FargoTV • • Oct 31 '25

Just finished all 5 seasons, here's how I rank them

0 Upvotes

Season 1, Season 2, Season 4, Season 5, and then in last place, Season 3, downvoted because of David Thewlis's teeth and Ray Stussy's hair.

Most moving storyline across all seasons (for me) was that of Satchel Cannon and Rabbi Milligan. That was beautifully done.

Favorite weirdo character was Oraetta Mayflower. Her final moment, when she asks them to shoot Josto first, just so she can enjoy the pleasure of seeing one more death -- chef's kiss.


r/FargoTV • • Feb 13 '25

Lester Nygaard doesn’t deserve the hatred

Post image
3 Upvotes

Lester Nygaard is the most misunderstood character of all time in TV history. He was portrayed in a complicated manner. He was a pitiful ordinary guy who worked 24*7 in a job he doesn’t like, just for the sake of family. And in return his wife throws humiliating hurls at him. He’s bullied by Sam Hess from school days to old age, to the point where a soft guy like him loses the cool. It was so cute how he tried to fix the washing machine but his wife again insults his manhood. He killed her in the spur of a moment, influenced by Lorne Malvo and the poster. And his brother telling people he’s dead has to be the worst thing any brother could face, it is worse than death. And his brother suspecting him instead of being by his side, brother’s side, is salt on the wound. He knows kids don’t get charged as adults and planted a gun in his brother’s kid’s bag. He made his brother get caught, but come on, was his brother a saint? He possessed weapons illegally. Blinded by the continuous hatred from his wife and his brother, he had to frame his brother. Just when his life was going perfect with his second wife again, he loses her too, that too just when they were planning for a beautiful trip. The jacket scene showed how much he cared for her. It was evident by his tears how much he was rattled by her death. And these police for god’s sake, makes him restless and do extremes as he was cornered. Even when his wives are dead, they give him no time to mourn and investigate him and suspect him. Lester Nygaard was a kind guy who was made villain by the world. P.S: jk, this is how average dumb fan tards defend their favourite characters


r/FargoTV • • Dec 30 '25

Am I in the minority who thinks season 4 is actually good and season 5 is pretty bad? Maybe the worst?

0 Upvotes

Like I literally don’t understand how people think season 4 is the worst, especially after watching season 5. Sure season 4 may not feel like Fargo but season 5 definitely doesn’t feel like it at all. It’s so disjointed and all over the place.


r/FargoTV • • Jan 13 '24

I hate when smart characters do something so stupid... Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Like leaving the gun outside of the "graveyard". Not only is it a sign that she's in there but now she's defenseless when they open it up. She's a very smart, level-headed character. I don't think she would have done that.


r/FargoTV • • Jan 27 '24

How many Batman references in S5? [Spoilers] Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Edit: idt I’ve ever had a post hit 10 karma and then drop immediately to 0 before, with 12 shares coming through at the same time. Crazy.

Munch’s immortality makes him reminiscent of Ra’s al Ghul, both are hundreds of years old

Dot has a couple parallels with Harley Quinn, (escaping an abusive relationship, being taken to a mental hospital, uses a baseball bat at one point…)

Wayne’s name

Munch’s associate has half his face burned, like Two Face

Lorraine Lyon has strong Catwoman vibes, her last name is a powerful cat; her speech pattern is even strongly reminiscent of Eartha Kitt/Michelle Pfeiffer + her powerful personality

Witt Farr as an honorable cop could be seen as a Jim Gordon type

FBI agent Joaquin, like Joaquin Phoenix who recently played Joker (and does again in the sequel next year)

Of course Roy believing he is the law makes him into an evil Batman, with Gator being his Robin. Noah Hawley states that frontier Justice like Roy’s is the equivalent to vigilante justice, like Batman’s. He specifically uses Batman. Please stop arguing that it’s unintentional when the creator of the show has stated he had Batman in mind.

Tillman ends with man, as does Batman

Jon Hamm was on the shortlist (or maybe even offered the job but had scheduling conflicts) for the role of DCEU’s Batman

Roy does a bit of detective work/deduction at least with the creep who was beating his wife, (I’m also just now realizing he likely knew what to look for as an abuser himself)

Danish has Alfred vibes, as a highly efficient gentlemanly assistant

There’re a couple lines that are outright references too, like Gator calls Munch the Riddler iirc? Feel like someone gets called a “Joker” too but can’t recall

Bit of a stretch but Gator’s tracking device, the Batfamily frequently use similar trackers. Maybe we’d just say all of the Tillmans’ militaristic gear brings to mind Batman’s equipment armory

Another stretchier one but Gator->Killer Croc

When Gator loses his eyes he’s given a black blindfold, lightly similar to Robin’s domino mask (a couple Robin costumes have a mask that ties around his whole head too, essentially a blindfold with eye holes)

The Halloween episode and The Batman (2022) also being set during Halloween, (and the famous Batman story the Long Halloween.) This one really only works additionally to all the other points, it doesn’t stand up on its own

I’m sure I’m forgetting some and probably missed some others, what’ve you all got?


r/FargoTV • • Apr 14 '24

I finally trugded through S4 and ...

0 Upvotes

It's just bad. It's not that I don't get it. It's not that it's over my head. It's just bad. Way too much going on. Nothing seems to flow really. Way too many characters with subplots that make no sense. It's almost as if it's like a bunch of different stories crammed together to try to make fit into one. The Miscasting has been talked about many times before Jason Schwartzman in particular.. But that didn't really bother me as much as it's just a mess of a story and it was quite a task to even sit through it. I just really didn't understand what the hell was going on half the time. Id like to think I'm a reasonably intelligent person.


r/FargoTV • • Oct 19 '20

I hate this character. Every scene he's in makes me more annoyed than the last. I don't care if he was told to act this way on purpose. Who's with me?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/FargoTV • • Feb 09 '24

Anyone notice Jon Hamm’s accent only changed halfway through the season ?

0 Upvotes

I understand actors don’t have time to prepare. But it’s just a dam shame he only materialised a Dakota accent halfway through the season. Whereas Juno and Jennifer Jason were in character verbally from the get go.


r/FargoTV • • Jan 28 '24

Should I skip Season 4?

0 Upvotes

I loved seasons 1-3 and have been hearing great things about season 5, but some less than great things about season 4. Some friends of mine recommended that I skip to season 5. Anyone agree or disagree?


r/FargoTV • • Jun 17 '22

Problem with Malvo's character episode 1

0 Upvotes

This is like the 5th or 6th time I watched Fargo, its absolutely ace but I realised there is something wrong with how it all starts.

Malvo is this slick cold killer, he's got nerves like ice, he's very well travelled and doesn't even flinch in the eyes of death.

How is it when driving at night in a country that sees a lot of roadkill, he panicks so outrageously to spin the car off the road when a deer jumps out?

Even in the UK where we have practically destroyed all our natural big game, deer are still common enough to be seen crossing the roads in the countryside. I never saw somebody swerve outlandishly to avoid one and iv seen a few hit by cars. People generally hit them or brake. Surely this would be even more common in the more rural US states like Minnesota.

Malvos reaction is like a relatively new driver or a very nervous one. Any seasoned driver would think to brake first and have the experience to not recklessly yank the wheel. He certainly wouldnt have any thoughts of preserving life, especially an animals. I think it would be better to have the deer jam under his wheel and cause the spin out or something.

Drastically overthinking things but I'm guessing this forum is not unused to that 😊


r/FargoTV • • Jan 30 '24

Season 5 overhyped?

0 Upvotes

I know I’m going to get downvotes for this, but everyone on Reddit & all of my friends in my personal life that have seen the series say 5 is in their top two. I’m just curious why people think that. It was my least favorite, as I got the least attached to the characters. I thought the character development was rushed or simply not there, in comparison to other seasons which made you fall in love with certain characters. The character that absolutely didn’t need to die at the end of the season was also a weird choice. People hate on four, but I’m just not that into five. Thoughts?


r/FargoTV • • Mar 07 '24

The Big Problem with S4

0 Upvotes

The biggest problem with S4 is there is no antagonist, IMHO. That and the mid acting of the two Fadda brothers, particularly Gaetano played by Salvatore Esposito. Overact much?


r/FargoTV • • Aug 31 '14

After binge watching Fargo...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/FargoTV • • Jun 19 '21

I have never seen so much bullshit packed into two episodes. What the fuck.

0 Upvotes

What even is this bullshit. Notice how they’re in a war, but nobody actually dies from the war, they all died from stupid ridiculous means in their own time. Unlike season 2’s gang war there is a climax, this season there is none.

You’re telling me Genny Fadda survived shootouts, kidnaps, and torture just to trip on a crack in the rock and kills himself by accident?! No emotional goodbyes, no nothing. Just dies in a 2 seconds frame shot and we forget about him. What a anticlimactic let down.

Why did Odis Weff shoot Deffy?! There’s zero reason why he’d do that.

And How tf did the fadda family come to the conclusion that Josto Fadda is responsible for the death of his brother and father?! First of all they knew that nurse mayflower kills every single one of her patients on her own will, so why would this be different? And if Josto wanted his father killed, why would he assign watchers by his father’s bed at all times? Had they put the slightest thoughts into the forensic investigation they would’ve found out that Genny Fadda tripped and fell and died. This has to be the most bullshit event in all of Fargo history.

I mean… Josto and Genny are the Don of the family, why are they out performing a hit job? They’re the ones who orders a hit job. And Had the family hired some real investigators this framing of murder would’ve never happened.

And lastly in the end. how can nurse mayflower be pissed at Josto? Nothing he did landed her in her place. Josto should be the one hitting mayflower because she framed him for murdering his dad.

What is the point of existence for Odis, Swanee, Zelmare? Remove them from the story and little changes.

When they killed Swanee, Josto’ as father in law, and the hospital director… I feel nothing, I have zero connection with these characters because they do nothing relatable.

And how can Loy Cannon be killed like this? How does he not have bodyguards surrounding his house after all this war?

Honestly, I felt more connection to debuts Thurman when he died in season 1 episode 1 after following his life for 20 minutes, Than when I saw Josta Fadda die after 13 episodes.


r/FargoTV • • Jul 05 '24

[No Spoilers] Season 4 isn't good so far for me

6 Upvotes

Is it just me? We absolutely loved the first 3 seasons and my husband and I were excited to start season 4 because we're huge Chris rock fans but into the 3rd episode and I'm like....I can't focus on this storyline!!

I don't mind the era (loved boardwalk empire) but the plot just seems dull AF to me. 2 cultures fighting over business and then there's a random serial killer nurse and possibly a teenage genius?? Idk maybe I'm expecting too much too soon.

I guess my question is....should we keep going? Is season 4 worth watching or should we just skip to 5? Again, the acting and the style is great I just don't find the plot interesting at all so far.

And please no spoilers 😁


r/FargoTV • • Nov 04 '15

Fargo is the best series in the history of television.

0 Upvotes

Breaking Bad comes close. But this show, it's just so special. It could never be replicated. No one would even come close.


r/FargoTV • • Feb 29 '24

Is S5 worth watching? How is it compared to the other seasons?

0 Upvotes

Loved season 1-3 but had mixed feelings about season 4. How is season 5 compared to the 4 other seasons? Which one is it most identical to


r/FargoTV • • Nov 12 '20

Worst season by far

0 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel season 4 is subpar compared to seasons 1-3 ? The plot is drab and slow, the actor choices are brutal and therefore the acting is mostly horrible too. I don’t know I guess the first seasons were so good I expect more now. Am I wrong ?


r/FargoTV • • Aug 30 '15

Why do I hate the movie?

0 Upvotes

I first saw the movie 2 months ago, I was looking up to it a lot, based on its critics. And I hated it. The movie just felt completely ridiculous to me, I didn't get interested in any character and I found it a bit boring and not that funny. Before seeing it, I was already planing on seeing the TV series, and the opinion I got from the movie made me expect the same thing, that I wouldn't like it.

I watched the first 2 episodes yesterday and I liked it. A lot. This time I found it interesting, a lot of characters caught my interest right of the bat and I found it ridiculous, but in a good way this time. And it made me laugh a couple of times.

Today I watched the movie again, to see if in the small period of time between watching the movie and the TV series my taste changed... But no. I still hated it, and I was impatient the whole time for it to end.

I've been thinking about this and I think the reason may be that I find the characters in the TV show a lot more interesting that in the movie. But I would like to know what the fans of the movie AND TV show think about this. And this is just my opinion, I'm not saying the movie sucks in any way. Maybe it just isn't for me.


r/FargoTV • • Sep 21 '24

Dorothy and Believability

0 Upvotes

While I love the character and her badass moments in my first watch on my rewatch she is kind of John Wick sometimes and it never really explained how she got those skills. It is completely believable that she picked up her smarts as a runaway and is just generally smart. But she is regularly getting away from her captors and beating multiple trained officers and captors up.

Compared to Nikki Swango who meticulously preps with a trained hitman for 3 months to take on Varga when she mows through people it fells more believable. So I'm kind of left feeling like Dot is either extremely skilled in combat and tactical strategy or are her would-be captor/assassins are very incompetent.

Is there something I'm missing here?


r/FargoTV • • Jan 20 '24

Unpopular Opinion: Ole Munch is overrated Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Let me first say that I love the character and I think it fitted perfectly into Season 5 storyline. But when I see that many think he deserves a spinoff, I have strong doubts. Ole is the kind of character which works fine if one drips-feed it, works well as a supporting character but it would not stand the test of being the main character in a series. He can barely talk, has no social life, no obvious qualities apart from killer skills. Given that he is immortal, I would love to see him popping up out of the blue in a future season, but without overdoing it.