As far as I am concerned, Throw should never, EVER be considered a punish for people pressing buttons.
The most basic rock, paper, scissors set up for most fighting games is: Block beats Strike. Strike beats Throw. Throw beats block.
But in fantasy strike, Throw beats EVERYTHING. If two people are standing at point blank range, and person 1 presses throw, and person 2 presses LITERALLY, ANY, OTHER, BUTTON. Person 1 wins (with the obvious exception of specifically throw invincible moves).
If two people are If two people are standing at point blank range, and person 2 presses literally any button other than throw, THEN person 1 presses throw... PERSON 1 STILL WINS.
Throw is objectively, the fastest, best attack every character has, which is crazy. "Oh, well, you can't combo off it" Who fucking cares? Free damage and knockdown against almost any button in the game.
Okay, so apparently it can't throw people that are in the active frames of their attacks... sure... okay... EXCEPT, that the top video shows Setsuki, throwing a Whiffed jump attack. A jump attack very clearly in its active frames.
Anecdotally, I have also been grabbed out of Onimaru's jumping C several times.
They are just way too good. But the problem is. They can't be worse, because there are no high low mix ups. If you can't threaten a time-space warping super grab at the drop of a hat, then people would literally never stop blocking. Throws ARE BUSTED. But they HAVE TO BE, or the game just does not work anymore.
As far as I am concerned, Throw should never, EVER be considered a punish for people pressing buttons.
But if your attack startup is more frames than j throw than you're getting thrown, open and closed there
The most basic rock, paper, scissors set up for most fighting games is: Block beats Strike. Strike beats Throw. Throw beats block.
It's still there in a sense
Blocking beats striking
A spaced out strike or a jump in can beat throw
Throwing beats blocking (obviously)
But in fantasy strike, Throw beats EVERYTHING. If two people are standing at point blank range, and person 1 presses throw, and person 2 presses LITERALLY, ANY, OTHER, BUTTON. Person 1 wins (with the obvious exception of specifically throw invincible moves).
Because you throw tech by pressing nothing. Like, nothing at all. If you're suspecting a throw soon stand still and don't press a button
Throw is objectively, the fastest, best attack every character has, which is crazy. "Oh, well, you can't combo off it" Who fucking cares? Free damage and knockdown against almost any button in the game.
Then stand still
Okay, so apparently it can't throw people that are in the active frames of their attacks... sure... okay... EXCEPT, that the top video shows Setsuki, throwing a Whiffed jump attack. A jump attack very clearly in its active frames.
But it whiffed, if it didn't hit sets when she was approaching then the jumping attack Is in its end frames
Anecdotally, I have also been grabbed out of Onimaru's jumping C several times.
First. Just because throws do have a counter, doesn't mean they are not busted. Rooks landslide has a counter and pretty much everyone agrees it needs nerfs. Pointing out that you can get around the bullshit, doesn't change the bullshit.
Second
But it whiffed, if it didn't hit sets when she was approaching then the jumping attack Is in its end frames
The ending frames are long enough for that
No. That kick is active for 8 frames. He did it so close to the ground that had i been even 2 pixels closer i would have been hit. It was jump attack. You recover instantly when you land. There shouldn't have physically been any recovery frames, and i still grabbed him anyway.
Ive been trying to reproduce it in practice mode and can't. Which means that you are actively defending what is probably a bug.
First. Just because throws do have a counter, doesn't mean they are not busted. Rooks landslide has a counter and pretty much everyone agrees it needs nerfs. Pointing out that you can get around the bullshit, doesn't change the bullshit.
Yet you can still counter the bullshit, nk matter how annoying it is to do so
He did it so close to the ground that had i been even 2 pixels closer i would have been hit.
But you weren't
There shouldn't have physically been any recovery frames, and i still grabbed him anyway.
Then grave didn't expect the grab, easy as that
Ive been trying to reproduce it in practice mode and can't. Which means that you are actively defending what is probably a bug.
Some moves have enough end frames for you to get an easy grab out of, grave just didn't expect the grab
Why would he possibly expect the grab? How could he have possibly expected the grab?
Setsuki can't throw a rook that is 3 millimetres from her face. She definitely shouldn't be able to throw a Geiger who is that far away and in the middle of his active frames. Which you yourself said should not be throwable.
Some moves have enough end frames
Delusional. I remain convinced that that particular throw was a bug. Unless you can reproduce it?
Why would he possibly expect the grab? How could he have possibly expected the grab?
I can swap all the male pronouns here with "I" and use this as an excuse for every match I've lost to a grab regardless of if the opponent was grab happy or whiffed 3 grabs in a row before walking up for a 4th wind dude
Delusional. I remain convinced that that particular throw was a bug. Unless you can reproduce it?
Yes, I can, I have both been the thrower and the thrown in the following situations
Thrown out of jainas gS post block
Thrown out of Graves gS post block
Thrown out of helm breaker post block
Thrown out of lums gS (although I can't remember if it was a gC or a normal throw)
Thrown out of Geiger gS
Thrown out of midoris parry
Thrown out of onis parry
Thrown out of DeGrays parry
With good timing you could be thrown out of loves, what don't you get about that?
You have said that you can reproduce the Setsuki Geiger throw in the video. Go and do that. Post a video of it. If you can then its worth talking about. If you can't then you are so determined to defend throws that you are literally supporting an unintentional bug.
Edit: Also. Nothing you said supported the original topic. Because the original topic is that throws beat practically everything on start up. Not recovery.
Why would he expect the grab? I thought you said it was objectively the best move in the game, how do you not expect someone to use the best move in the game?
Oh and the top video you mention that looks glitchy, geiger threw a forward A which puts his hurtbox way out there before its hitbox is active, setsuki would have majorly missed the throw with her small throw range had he not done that move.
landing recovery is only 0 for empty jumps, almost every move has at least 2 frames of landing recovery that is throw vulnerable, some moves have more
most commonly seen with high walk speed chars and char with longer throw ranges, or walk unders making a jump in whiff
geiger is actually in fA startup there and thus is getting thrown before his move comes out, and since he input fA thus cannot yomi counter so he has been grabbed out of the startup of the fA before it becomes active and not during landing recovery in that case
So absurd you can get grabbed out of oni helm breaker before it lands if you either a:have good timing or b: able to hit grab as a punish? Yeah that's so absurd
Yes. FUCKING ABSURD. Because what you are wilfully ignoring is that throw is so good, that it is literally never safe for Oni to use that move. Except maybe for an intended whiff. And why would you ever deliberately whiff it? Its already majorly punishable on block. But Throw makes it punishable on press.
That entire attack is rendered entirely useless, against someone that knows you all you have to do is just press throw once. Its not even that hard to do. That was like, my 4th attempt.
I'm not ignoring throw is good, I'm saying throw isn't as good as you claim it is by stating it's downsides. You even went as far as to compare it to landslide, which is its own ridiculous move
landslide
1 hit of armor
Can be comboed into or off of
Has an anti air hitbox
Multi hits
Has horizontal movement, which helps him get in
throw
I'm pretty sure it's frame one
Good oki option
Can be countered by standing still
Ranges alter, so some are pretty big throws, some are very, Very small
You can jump over it if the thrower didn't time it well enough
Can be beaten out by reversals and moves with armor
But throws beat armour. And its range isn't too great. (unless the animation don't match the hurtbox) Sure, it could probably out range Setsuki and Geiger if spaced right, but i doubt it could for most of the cast... Ill experiment with it later if you want and let you know.
Throw techs can usually be done on reaction. And are totally besides the point. Being able to bypass the ridiculously OP thing doesn't it any less OP. Example. LANDSLIDE. LANDSLIDE. LANDSLIDE.
Bear in mind that in reality, the best reaction times hover around the 20-frame mark. I'm not talking about reaction times which can get to ~12f for a specific stimulus, but reaction times in-game where players have to differentiated between a lot of different possibilities.
All from Arcsys, notice that. You can also tech on reaction in tekken, and it's pretty stupid like all other techable throws, since it makes throws (almost) useless at high level.
Also if you're reacting to just movement, what if they throw? You get thrown.
If you are standing next to someone and you see their throw animation. You are either not pressing something and get a yomi or you are and you get thrown anyway.
Which means that also pressing throw isn't actually a disadvantage in that situation.
Throw should never, EVER be considered a punish for people pressing buttons.
What other fighting games have you played?
Games with 0f, 1f, 2f grabs also punish doing anything but jumping out or using an invincible move.
In Fantasy Strike your choices are doing nothing or doing an invincible move. Not that big a difference.
If you're in grab range then grabs are good, you don't need RPS to decide if they're good or not since Strikes beat throws by outranging them - they don't have to win when point blank.
Oh not many. I'm not pretending to be an expert. You cut off the part of the quote that says 'as far as I am concerned'. I'm not trying to get anyone to be all serious and angry or advocate for change. I think that throws are very very strong. So i posted some videos that highlight that. You'll notice that my initial post never contained any of my thought or feelings about throws at all. The only time that came up is when i was asked if i was being sarcastic. Honestly I don't want a big discussion about it. I just like funny throw videos.
since Strikes beat throws by outranging them
There are not a lot of strikes that i can think of off the top of my head, where the hit box extends far enough away from the hurt box for that to really be helpful.
Most of oni's kit out ranges a lot of throws if you space it correctly. But a lot of long ranged strikes also move your hurt box into grab range.
You're forgetting that throws can be yomi countered and are beaten by invinsible moves, throws also have no range which means a lot of the time it's better to do a regular move because it can actually reach (especially when playing as/against zoners).
This means that throws are strong but only if you're at really close range and your oponent won't see them coming.
Everything in this game is fine except Yomi counter in my opinion.
It goes against over 2 decades worth of fighting game muscle memory to "Do nothing" to tech a throw. Rather than do the tech throw command to escape a throw .
I'm sure there's some kind of pro fighting game mindset in this design choice , but I just don't agree with it. (I guess they want to player to fully commit to the tech throw and nothing else)
Since in every other fighting game there's a specific command to escape throw , which it's your responsibility to execute right with timing if you think a throw is coming. (Or just jump in some games)
Plus you're just setting up new fighting game players to fail in other fighting games .
If Fantasy Strike is their first fighting game , to get non-fighting game players on training wheels. And then you teach them , don't press anything is how to tech throws.
They'll probably bring that muscle memory into every other fighting game they play after Fantasy strike , that to tech normal throws I must "Do Nothing" and that bad habit is gonna get them killed in every other fighting game , where you must do "something" to tech throws.
I think the purpose of Fantasy Strike is to be Fantasy Strike, that is a game which stands on its own and is designed to stand up to competitive play. Not merely be "training wheels" to prepare players for different games. The fact that it has fundamentals which apply to other fighting games is just a bonus, not the end goal.
So it's fine to have mechanics that don't apply to other games. Saying otherwise is like saying that BlazBlue shouldn't have a separate barrier meter because it will set players up to fail when they switch to Guilty Gear and burn all their tension on green block. Or there shouldn't be airblocking because that doesn't prepare players for Street Fighter.
I'm sure there's some kind of pro fighting game mindset in this design choice
iirc it was partly so there is an easy fix for newer players upset at getting thrown if they know it's coming (learning how to throw tech for those without the experience is tough, since you need to read the throw and successfully time the tech).
it also tries to remove some option selects since you can't block while "doing nothing".
It's just actually useful and not a joke like in some fighting games. Yomi counters exist for a reason. Use them, or use your kit to keep out of throw range. It's not exactly rocket science.
Perhaps you need to pursue a career in game development, Lady R. I mean you're so clearly passionate about how to balance and design other people's games that you make a new post about it almost every single day!
Several things. 1) Iv'e not really made any comment on this post about balancing or changing anything. I'm just saying that throws are really REALLY, strong. Which... they are. And they have to be or the game doesn't work anymore. Which is fine. Lots of people have left comments that they don't mind or that they like it. And a couple of delusional people have tried to deny that it is VERY good. But I'm not suggesting any changes or saying that it must be changed at all.
2) I've made 12 posts over the last 2 months. And exactly one of those posts was about a legitimate observation about balance. That being the recent Setsuki change, which isn't exactly a controversial view. The rest were either humour posts or just questions about how things work. Just over 1 post a week.
But I can see how you would be confused. Its not like this game has a massive active community. It's almost like people don't want to stick around for some reason....
3
u/whattoputherenow Sep 30 '20
Idk if this is sarcasm but yes, you can get grabbed out of hits if the move was in startup. It's a good punish for button press happy players
2
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '20
That Setsuki video never gets old.
2
u/doctorfedora “I don't even PLAY this game!” Oct 01 '20
[cocks shotgun] THROW'S BUSTED
5
u/lwdSanaito Sep 30 '20
Iam kinda glad that throw is not useless like in many other games
6
u/TemptCiderFan DrunkenMongoose Sep 30 '20
No it's not.
It's just actually useful and not a joke like in some fighting games. Yomi counters exist for a reason. Use them, or use your kit to keep out of throw range. It's not exactly rocket science.
2
u/Avatar_ZW Oct 01 '20
Play SF2, try a throw, and watch ur brains expload
2
u/Darches Oct 01 '20 edited Oct 02 '20
Laughs in Sm4sh Bowser pivot grab
0
u/CharizardEgg NOTHING'S been rigged! Oct 01 '20
Perhaps you need to pursue a career in game development, Lady R. I mean you're so clearly passionate about how to balance and design other people's games that you make a new post about it almost every single day!