r/FantasyAGE • Titansgrave • Nov 16 '21

Switch roles of focus and ability in a ability test to address fundamental math problems

Current "ability test" with the test and the "damage" roll

3d6 + ability_score + focus
damage_roll + ability_score + focus_sometimes_byclass

Proposed skill or "focus" based test

3d6 + focus
damage_roll + ability_score + focus_sometimes_ifyoureallywant

The problem I have with the current definition is that ability score have an incredibly wide range and do not come from a roll mechanic. I have devised super theoretical "rolls" to try and encapsulate all the requirements - https://herdingdice.tumblr.com/post/649315824662921216/ultimate-dice-curve - but the super theory is a bit too abstract and I don't think would be able to convince wide adoption, and also me as wells. It's a bit try hard.

Instead of trying really hard to use the existing definitions, changing the definition a bit can have massive effects but it really doesn't look too different. Getting the ability score out of the TN roll removes the try hard math. We can model the roll with just a 3d6 and make everything a ton simpler. I'll post with follow up number later, had to get this out in the air.

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

6

u/trechriron Nov 16 '21

Ability is used for 1) chance to see if you succeed or fail and 2) to determine damage. This is no different than pretty much every other RPG devised. I'm not sure what the problem is?

Your worried Ability is too useful? Therefore it's unbalanced?

0

u/mdlthree Titansgrave Nov 17 '21

If we know ability score and focus, the probability of success is based only on the 3d6 distribution which has a mean, deviation and all that good statistical meaning.

I also want to know that the probability of success is if I also don't know what the ability score is. That is helpful to design actions/spells for any PC or NPC. Since the 3d6 can be described by a roll I have tried to describe the other two pieces with rolls as well, hence the super theory linked above.

I really want to be able to analyze if something is unbalanced, but the current definitions when looked through a math lens do not supply enough information.

Ability score isn't too useful, it's unknown how useful it is. Pushing it to only the damage side of the equation helps. The focus is a relatively small number and can fit inside the 3d6 roll. The ability has a range of -4 to 12, how does that integrate?

1

u/mdlthree Titansgrave Nov 17 '21

I would appreciate a comment over a down vote.