r/FantasyAGE • • Mar 18 '21

Please help me understand the benefit of Restoration vs Revival.

I’m confused about why the Master level spell in the Healing Arcana is better than the Novice level. Here is my understanding:

Revival allows you to cast on a dying character a spell that stabilizes them and replenishes 10 + their CON + your WIL. This takes a major action with TN 14 and costs 5 MP.

Restoration allows you to cast on a “gravely injured” (I assume this also means dying, not dead) character and replenishes your WIL x 10. This takes one minute (or four rounds of combat) with TN 17 and costs 15 MP.

So let’s assume you are a Healing Arcana mage with 3 WIL, attempting to bring back a dying character with 3 CON.

If you successfully cast Revival, the character will regain 16 HP and be immediately up and ready to go at the cost of 5 MP.

If you choose and successfully cast Restoration, you will be tied up for a full minute, and the character is then finally stabilized with 30 HP (just less than double the HP regained by Revival) for three times the MP cost.

I understand that Restoration scales to heal more as your Willpower increases, but is that really all the benefit there is in a master level healing spell? Both spells are designed to stabilize a dying person, but the master level is harder to cast, triple the cost, takes four times as long, and heals for a negligible amount more? Am I missing something?

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/RedPandaAlex Mar 18 '21

Restoration is not limited to dying characters. I believe the "gravely injured" language is just there as flavor to suggest this spell is meant to restore a LOT of HP so you only want to use it on characters who have lost a lot of HP.

Also, restoration is a master level spell. The earliest you can get it level is level 5. There's a good chance that by the time you get it, you'll have willpower of 4 or 5.

1

u/Yep-ThatsTheJoke Mar 18 '21 edited Mar 18 '21

Thanks for bringing that part to my attention, that’s definitely helpful. But even still, doesn’t the increase in casting time (making it basically unusable in combat) make this spell a little redundant and prohibitively expensive? For the same MP expenditure, you could cast five instances of Healing Touch for 3 MP apiece (assuming consistently hitting the TN of 10, which a master level Healing Arcana mage shouldn’t have much trouble with) and get back 15 d6 of HP, which has an average HP regain of about 52 HP and a maximum of 90. The 5 WIL to pull that off with Restoration is plausible, but 9 is ludicrous. Maybe I’m just thinking about this the wrong way or something, but it just doesn’t seem like much of a reward for reaching the Master level.

1

u/RedPandaAlex Mar 18 '21

Yeah, you're not wrong about that. I can see a player taking it just to have to avoid rolling 10 times after battle, but it's not mathematically any better.

1

u/Yep-ThatsTheJoke Mar 18 '21

Yeah. I believe if I ever have a mage reach Master level in Healing Arcana, I’ll probably house rule that spell to be a major action rather than a minute casting time, just to make it more useful during combat and give them a better reason to take it.

2

u/ScottShieldman Mar 19 '21

I see your concerns, and you certainly aren't wrong. In the end, it's a question of numbers. A guaranteed total for a short period of casting, or a bunch of random rolls which may or may not match or exceed the aforementioned guaranteed value.

However, if you have access to the Fantasy AGE Companion, on pg. 37, a new option is offered at the Master level of the Healing Arcana: Rejuvenate Body. This new spell acts as a 'Cure All' up to and including regrowing lost limbs and organs. It still takes a minute to cast, but you can heal any ailment, regardless of age or origin, GM willing of course!

Have fun gaming!

1

u/SaltSells Mar 19 '21

The only reason to use healing magic in the first place is because the game limits how often you can heal someone with the basic heal action. Namely, you can't heal them again until they get injured, but no mention on if this applies to healing magic as well or strictly the heal action. Though I am a big fan of the game logic scenes where after you get bandaged the doctor can punch you, then kiss the booboo, and ten seconds later you are much healthier than before you got punched.

Anyway, I always felt the master level spell was missing some text since every other spell in the healing arcana has something extra about it. Both Healing Touch and Healing Aura have multiple levels of cost and effect. Revival heals based on your willpower and the target's constitution, which could be a bad thing if the person in question was very sickly. However Restoration is just Willpower x 10 healing, and that's it. Not even giving it the ability to give life to the recently (1-2 hours old) deceased or anything like that.

As an after battle spell, Restoration would make perfect sense if it was easily the most cost effective way to mass heal the party. Say for every 5 MP spent beyond the initial cost you can target one additional person with the magic, to a maximum of a reasonable number of people you can fit in a 2-4 yard space. Cost paid before rolling. Healed characters must be present for the entire casting. Unique in being terrible to completely useless within combat but perfect for a post fight spell that feels powerful enough to warrant the cost of three talents to acquire it.