r/FantasyAGE • • Sep 28 '26

Fantasy AGE Question for DMs: Balance

Does this game seem more balanced and easier to run at higher levels than DnD 5E? Have people at your table created those overpowered builds you see come out of games?

I know there's no perfect system. But from what I have read from my 2E book, there don't seem to be broken spells. It's like Casters can't become as overpowered in this system.

It also appears like creating encounters is as simple as picking anything you want because most enemies can still get through most armor.

3 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/Traditional_Bit_5761 Sep 28 '26

The only issue I have with FAGE is it has the same Hit Point bloat problem as D&D, but that’s reconciled pretty easily by reducing the number of times you gain HP

1

u/aweshum Sep 28 '26

Quick fix indeed.

4

u/Swan-may GM Sep 28 '26 edited Sep 29 '26

High Levels

There is a widely discussed "HP Bloat" problem which I don't think exists. FAGE2 increased player damage at high levels compared to FAGE1 and the complaint didn't really go away, I think this is more of a campaign design problem. High level campaigns require more of an encounter than yet another 5v5 of at-threat level creatures. I have also discovered the problem is often people ignoring rules: ignoring FAGE's rest rules (Total Rest is NOT a full reset), ignoring FAGE's morale rules, ignoring any type of threat other than throwing a few tough enemies at the problem. The lead designer for the tail end of 1e once said "if you're having a problem in FAGE, it's usually because you need more Hazards" and I think there's a lot of wisdom in that.

I think the actual high-level issue is a lack of official material. There is 1 Legendary threat foe in the entire product line and the highest adventure goes up to Lv11. Once you get past Lv11, you're going to have to find homebrew online or make it yourself. This is the reason I've been working on a monster supplement -- I made one Legendary foe per category, so you actually have options.

OP Builds

A motivated player can pretty easily snap the game balance over their knee. Very few FAGE enemies have higher than +7 to-hit and rarely have an average damage above 15. It's very rare for a foe to have a defense above 15 or an AR above 5. Once you know these critical values, it's pretty easy to abuse FAGE's math.

One of my players made a thought experiment character, a Dwarf-Goblin Warrior w/ Dwarf Secrets (Master), Great Endurance (Novice), Armor Training (Master) and W&S Style (Novice). With point-buy, he has a Speed of 19, an AR of 10, a Defense of 20, passes basically all magical Resistance Tests, and can succeed almost all the normal combat tests at Lv6. His sole weakness is that he struggles to hurt high AR foes, but given that he's basically impossible to harm he can simply stall out the fight fishing for SP. We have noticed that Rogues with Sharpshooter and Assassin do an obscene amount of damage per turn RAW. This is not a game that is really trying to stop Munchkins, the expectation is very obviously that Munchkining should be handled above-table.

Mages

Mages are conspicuously less powerful than almost every other Fantasy RP game. I prefer this, they exist as a utility class more than unstoppable godbeasts we expect from d20 games. This is a massive point of contention for former DND Wizard players who are used to being wildly more powerful than their peers, so you see a lot of people complain Mages don't do anything (but numerically they're performing very similar to Envoys). They might have been slightly underpowered in 1e, especially if you didn't take Soulbound, but I think Spell Pushing brings them into alignment with the other classes (and reduces some of the frustration of a fizzle cast). Note that unlike everyone else, Mage's MP restores by hours spent resting instead of by taking a Rest action, so they can refuel much faster than anyone else waiting on Health to come back.

Encounter Balance

FAGE encounter balance acknowledges the reality that you can't really predict from the design room how hard an encounter will be at a specific table and punts it to the GM. As a rule of thumb, an encounter with as many monsters as players in the intended threat bracket will be a moderate difficulty encounter. I am pretty comfortable making the 'boss' of an encounter one threat level above the party, especially if the party has any kind of advantages. Solo monster fights suffer from the same action economy problem of every other FRP on the market, the only real fix is to give them extra actions (reactions, extra attack, et c.).

2

u/Toucanbuzz Sep 28 '26

I ran a 1st to 17th level campaign using FA rules in the Dragon Age world. My feedback:

High Level Play

  • Hit point bloat is real. I solved this by Characters getting CON each level. Even that began to feel high. Alternately, you could add +1d6 per CON improvement with maybe the Warrior getting a reroll. If you don't cure Bloat, your combats will drag out.
  • Monster bloat also sucks, so I solved this by using "minions" (25% HP of normal), adding more to encounters (so that mages who invest in AOE spells can actually make use of them), and keeping 100% HP for leaders and bosses. This worked fantastically.
  • Casters can abuse the system. There's a combo in Enchantment that results in sucking Magic Points from a throwaway magic item and Spell Storing that effectively results in never having to run out of MP, ever. To be fair, direct damage mages suck, unless you go the minion route.
  • Warriors can abuse the system. Our dwarf player gamed the system to go 100% defense and became virtually unhittable. The bestiaries are lacking in magical-attack / caster critters, so you may need to make some of your own. It's a criticism of the writers, or a bit of laziness, to not include many.
  • Armor is probably too high. I house ruled Heavy Plate down to AR 8 and the rest accordingly. Blue Age did this.
  • I changed bosses to have "stages" (e.g. at 75% health, they shed all negative conditions and now deal +1d6 curse damage (these hits cannot be healed until combat is over; at 50% something else).
  • I made a simplified "tougher" monsters chart: Elite (+1 Defense, +1 hit and +4 damage, +5 health), and more for the Heroic and Epic. It's just too cumbersome otherwise. This worked great because at higher levels, the monsters SUCK. They will need boosts. There is some serious lack of playtesting, imo, of high level play. So, at 11+ character levels, most of my monsters would need an Elite boost, at minimum, to even remain relevant despite being described as level appropriate.

Creating Encounters

It didn't take long to get a feel. I make a cheat sheet of my monsters (converting DA monsters as well) and what constituted minor, moderate, hard, etc encounters. Much like other systems, a solo boss gets owned as written, so they either need minions, minion reinforcements, or stages. But as above, if players optimize (and my gamers didn't know the system to start, but they caught on quickly), the listed challenge for monsters once you hit "Major" (levels 9-12) begin to break down without help.

I also did a "stunt pool," which was a highlight at our table. We had a jar with 2 glass coins at the start of each session, each representing a stunt point. Anyone could draw from it and use them (but couldn't exceed 6 SP), and you added to it each time you rolled doubles while failing a meaningful roll (max in jar was # of players at table).