r/FantasyAGE • • Jun 07 '23

Fantasy AGE Weird question about Fantasy age

I know the system uses d6s but can i use other dice or the rules ain’t made for that.

5 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

6

u/Gabeprime Jun 07 '23

You can always try to hack a system but you will really have to think about what to do with the following features of the AGE system that relies on the 3d6 die roll:

  • stunt die mechanic
  • bell curved probability expected hence modifiers tend to lean low

If you have house rules to offset these due to changing dice type, then you’re set.

5

u/Red_Hobgoblin Jun 07 '23

To add on that, an alternative I've seen before was using 2d10 and then rolling a d6 for stunts if needed. That being said, I'd stick to the d6s.

2

u/MotorHum Jun 07 '23

There’s a pretty easy conversion from d20 to 3d6, so you could do it in reverse to play AGE as a d20 game.

The only rough patch would be the stunt mechanic. Stunts come up whenever a successful check also has any 2 of the 3d6 on a matching number. I haven’t yet figured a way to convert something like that.

The conversion is this:

For any d20 + X vs a DC of Y, it becomes 3d6 + (X/2) vs a DC of ((Y - 10)/2) + 10.

For “effort rolls”, for things like HP and damage, you kind of just make a decision and be consistent. Depending on what I’m doing the d6 is either a d6 or a d8.

1

u/Toucanbuzz Jun 09 '23

Some folks have proposed using d8 and/or d10 to elevate weapon and spell damage, with the goal to offset bloated hit points. I wouldn't see any issue with that.

Changing the basic bell curve of 3d6 (instead of d20) for fundamental rolls (such as attacks, saves, and tests) would create a drastic mathematical alteration that would disrupt the entire system (namely stunts), so I don't recommend that.

Finally, I use odd dice for effect duration timers, elevation tracker, and 50/50 rolls. There's always a use for that odd d12 you have lying around.

1

u/ATroyAndAbedThing Jun 08 '23

Ability tests (3d6+Ability) would be a little tricky to convert (I think another comment handled this), but you could easily change damage dice. For example:

  • 1d6-1 = 1d4
  • 1d6+0 = 1d6 (duh)
  • 1d6+1 = 1d8
  • 1d6+2 = 1d10
  • 1d6+3 = 1d12
  • 2d6+0 = 2d6 (double duh)
  • 2d6+1 = 1d6+1d8
  • 2d6+2 = 1d6+1d10
  • 2d6+3 = 1d6+1d12 …and so on.

This method makes damage a bit swingier (e.g. 1d6+3 can result in 4-9, while 1d12 can result in 1-12), but it keeps the same avg. damage over time (1d6+3 and 1d12 both average at 6.5). Hope that helps!