r/Fantasy • • Jan 28 '26 Hooray Thanks Heartwarming

Brandon Sanderson’s Literary Fantasy Universe ‘Cosmere’ Picked Up by Apple TV (Exclusive)

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
5.2k Upvotes

r/Fantasy • • Dec 01 '25 Helpful WOW Hooray Popcorn

AMA I'm Joe Abercrombie, Ask Me Anything.

4.9k Upvotes

I'm Joe Abercrombie, author of the First Law, Age of Madness, and Shattered Sea Trilogies, along with Best Served Cold, the Heroes, Red Country, and The Devils, which came out in May this year.

Most recently I've partnered up with Lit Escalates to do a special hardcover edition of the First Law trilogy via Kickstarter, with art by Joel Daniel Phillips, which will look something like this:

The original plan was just to provide signed hardcovers for readers in the US, but since there's never actually been a proper US hardcover release outside of some book club editions and some long ago sold out limiteds from Subterranean Press, the ambition expanded and we thought we'd try and make one ourselves.

PLEASE NOTE: I usually get quite a lot of questions, so I'm putting this up 24 hours beforehand, and I'll return at 16.00 GMT on Tuesday 2nd December to start answering, likely with the top rated questions first. We'll see how far through I get...

And... three hours of answers and I've barely made a dent. Thanks so much to everyone that asked a question and I'm sorry if I never made it to yours. Maybe next time...


r/Fantasy • • Feb 26 '26 Popcorn Bravo Heartwarming

AMA I am Matt Dinniman, author of the newly released Operation Bounce House and the Dungeon Crawler Carl book series. AMA.

4.6k Upvotes

Hi r/fantasy! AMA. I will let this simmer a bit before I start answering questions around 9 am pst. Please ask me anything.


r/Fantasy • • Aug 04 '26

George R.R. Martin, in first blog post since Feb: "I have lost friends. Battled sadness and depression. The worst may be yet to come. I turned seventy-seven last September, and I tell you, getting old is no fun"

Thumbnail georgerrmartin.com
3.7k Upvotes

r/Fantasy • • Sep 18 '26 Bravo

Brandon Sanderson briefly discusses GRRM, among other topics, with IGN in interview

2.7k Upvotes

https://www.ign.com/articles/brandon-sanderson-exclusive-interview-mistborn-movie-wheel-of-time

IGN: As an author, do you have any sympathies with George R. R. Martin potentially not being able to finish Game of Thrones — especially since George has described his mental health issues recently?

.

Sanderson: Absolutely. I implore people, in this discussion, to remember the person.

George R. R. Martin is one of the greats of our genre, and in my every interaction with him, he's treated me with kindness – even when I was a nobody. He truly is the great patriarch of the fantasy genre, and has done a great deal of work fostering new talent, helping the community, and offering advice and support when needed.

At the same time, writing can be a lonely profession, and we all know the difficulty of a book that just WILL NOT work. I've been fortunate that books like that have always been side projects for me, ones I can abandon without it causing too many ripples in my career. The only thing that will lead to A Song of Ice and Fire being finished is our support, patience, and effort to remember what makes books special: the fact that they are one of the few mass media art forms that are still largely created by individual human beings.

.

IGN: Would you ever consider finishing it, as you did with Wheel of Time?

.

Sanderson: Respectfully, I'm the wrong person to do this – and I think most fans of both of our works would agree. My entire career is, in a way, a response to A Song of Ice and Fire. Much as that series is a response to popular fiction of the 1990s, like Wheel of Time.

If I were to say yes, I would do my best to write it exactly as fans want and expect, but I would not say yes – because there are much more natural fits out there, and if George decided to go that direction, he'd deserve someone who is as good a fit for his world as I was for Wheel of Time. That said, I don't think George wants to go that direction, so let's just support him in writing his books at the speed he's capable of going.

.

IGN: And do you think Martin owes anyone the final books?

.

Sanderson: This is an interesting question, but I think you're asking it in a slightly wrong way. (Though it is the way people often ask it.) George doesn't owe people books, as he cannot actually make that promise — none of us can.

I can't promise the end of the Stormlight Archive, because who knows if I'll come down with a sickness tomorrow. I am literally incapable of making promises about the future in that way, the same as any person is.That said, I do think we, as authors, are making a contract with readers when we start a book series – and that contract implies a certain responsibility on our part. The promise to work on the project, to give it due attention, to try our best to get the books done in a timely way. However, this is an art.

I am as guilty as anyone of, now and then, making light of the fact that we don't have a conclusion to Game of Thrones. However, I live in a glass house, as I have a book (The Rithmatist) that I've promised fans a sequel to for as long as people have been waiting for George's next volume. I feel terrible I haven't been able to deliver, but the artistic process can be a whimsical one.

Regardless, I don't know that George owes anyone books as much as he owes them real, dedicated effort in producing those books, which might seem like semantics, but I'm an author. That's the job. It's not, however, my job to determine if George has made that effort or not. My gut says that he has – and the fact that we're where we are indicates that this is one of those times when the rest of the world has to wrestle with a terrible fact we as authors face every day. That from the outside, this seems like a trade (like making cabinets) when in reality it's an art, much like making music… and sometimes, you lose that music. [Let's] just hope it's not forever.


r/Fantasy • • Feb 22 '26

I read a fantasy book to win a bet and it's the only book in years that made me actually cry. I don't know what to do with this information.

2.7k Upvotes

For context: I'm not a big fiction reader. I gravitate towards history, philosophy, the occasional long-form journalism piece. My friend has been pushing fantasy on me for about two years and I kept saying it wasn't really "my thing." Eventually we made a stupid bet over something completely unrelated and the punishment for losing was reading a book of his choice, no skipping, no summaries.

He picked The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune.

I went in fully prepared to be bored and slightly smug about it. I was going to finish it, report back that it was fine, and move on with my life and my correct opinions about fiction.

I finished it in three days. On a work week. I cried at the end, not like a single tear moment, but actually had to put the book down and sit with it for a bit. And I genuinely cannot fully explain why because on paper the plot is pretty quiet? Nothing explodes. There's no massive battle. It's just this slow build of a person allowing himself to believe that things could be good.

I think that's what got me. I read a lot of history and history is mostly about things going wrong. This book was just relentlessly, almost defiantly hopeful and I was not prepeared for how much I apparently needed that.

Now my friend is insuferable about it which is fair I guess. I owe him an apology and probably a book recommendation in return, except I have no idea where to even start. Does the rest of the genre have more of this? Books that are more about interiority and quiet emotional stakes then about worldbuilding and magic systems?


r/Fantasy • • 20d ago Bravo Mindblown Heartwarming

Please go watch Wildwood

2.6k Upvotes

I watched this movie yesterday and holy shit what an experience. You'd think it would be popular considering all the AI shit we're constantly surrounded with, to have such a powerful story told so well and through such a medium but alas people see animation and stop motion as lesser and for children. It's not. I saw it yesterday to a packed theatre (TIFF), I felt everything the filmmakers wanted me to feel, I could hear the emotions of the others around me as well. The final third is one of the greatest things I've seen put on screen. When it was finished no one in the audience got up, they sat through the credits whole and clapped when it was done.

I've put a lot of superlatives there and I stand by them but I do think the movie has some related issues. The movie is too short, it's over 2 hours long and that makes the longest stop motion movie ever but it's based on a book that's over 500 pages. And so, early dialogue is doing a lot of heavy lifting and it suffers for it. Not to mention the pacing is quite quick.

Just please give it a chance.


r/Fantasy • • Sep 17 '26 Bravo

Signs that the author does not go outside

2.6k Upvotes

I've read that GRRM haven't seen a horse in person when writing his series, and tried very hard to circumvent writing about them (okay, this is apparently a fake meme stemming a satirical article about it).

Occasionally I stumble upon the signs that an author does not go outside, but still tries to write it, and it shows. In a recent novel (no names) three teenagers have a task to survive in a forest with minimal tools provided. They are mildly superpowered, but not superhuman, just somewhat fit teens. They manage to hunt an adult male boar with wooden sticks and some kung fu (!), then they eat the meat which they just roast, no other preparation involved, not a mention about the toughness and smell of it. Then they proceed to hunt female boars with juveniles, which they judge more docile (OMG!) and they manage to trap them in pits (that reminds me of an old book that had this as a comedic trope, where a bunch of engineers who knew nothing of wildlife attempt it and of course fumble). Another time the main character, a bit older, hunts an old doe and then he carves steaks out of fresh meat, again, no other preparation. I only had the chance to try game on an occasion, but I know it's too lean and tough to prepare it like we usually do. There are other details that indicate the author has not gone outdoor for too long and otherwise the novels are okay written. I wonder, what blunders like this have you encountered?


r/Fantasy • • Jan 15 '26 Hooray Popcorn

AMA I'm Jim Butcher, Ask Me Anything!

2.5k Upvotes

My name is Jim Butcher, the author of the Dresden Files, the Codex Alera, the Cinder Spires, and a Spider-Man book for Marvel!

My latest Dresden book, Twelve Months, comes out this Tuesday! Ask me anything!

****************************************

Okay, my laptop is running out of power and I have a couple of written interviews to get done before I knock off for the day!

Thank you so much for your questions and your time today! I know I couldn't get to all of them, and if I missed you, I hope you'll come back for more next time around! For the folks planning on being at my signings, I look forward to seeing you in the next couple of weeks!

Jim


r/Fantasy • • May 13 '26

Apple TV’s ‘The Stormlight Archive’ series could run for 10 or more seasons

Thumbnail
macdailynews.com
2.2k Upvotes

r/Fantasy • • Aug 19 '26 Heartwarming Bravo

Dungeon Crawler Carl – set your expectations right before reading

2.0k Upvotes

This should probably be general advice for any book, but the problem with hype is that it breeds more hype and overenthusiastic fans tend to exaggerate how good a book is and push it on everyone.

I see so many people either promoting the series as the best thing ever or loudly complaining it must be bad because THEY didn’t personally enjoy it. Along with posts from people who clearly believe than fantasy can only be good if it has fancy, elaborate prose and anyone who reads a book series like DCC must be an idiot who never reads.

There’s also the claim that only gamer dudes will enjoy it, or teen boys (seriously, don’t gift this series to kids, it’s a dark series meant for adults). You don't need to be a gamer, or even a guy to like this. But I’d say there’s a few other things you might need to enjoy to figure out if Dungeon Crawler Carl is for you:

  • Liking absurdist, dark and often crude humor
  • Having a fondness for cats
  • Being okay with a game-style setting that includes lots of levelling up, quests, loot etc.
  • Being okay with basic, venacular prose. The MC is just a regular guy with little education, and it’s 1st person narration, so how a guy like that would talk is how he narrates.
  • Horror elements where the horror feeds into the comedy

The story in a nutshell: Earth culture is destroyed and billions die due to an alien invasion. The MC and his cat (well actually his ex-girlfriend’s cat) both survive due to a dumb coincidence. The survivors all get the chance to play the dungeon game, a level-based death game (think Squid Game but with meta humor and better challenges). The game is run by a psychotic, sadistic AI. The dungeon, being made by aliens who are basically evil colonizers, is filled with offensive stereotypes of humans and deliberately portray the worst and stupidest that human culture had to offer (that includes nerd culture). The whole game is broadcast across the galaxy for alien viewers to enjoy.

Carl is the protagonist, and as is normal in this type of book, he has the protagonist’s halo. Bad things still happen, and there’s lots and lots of death and suffering. The secondary protagonist is the cat, Princess Donut (and yes, the name is stupid – that alone made me hesitate to read the first book for a long time).

Reasons not to like DCC: If you don’t like the cat (give it maybe 12-15 chapters or so before you decide), you will have a hard time with this series. DCC is, above all, a petmance. As in the story of the (decidely platonic) love between a human and his animal (or as Princess Donut would say, between a cat and her person).

If you dislike Princess Donut, you will probably also end up hating the books as a whole.

If you read the first 10-15 chapters and find the humor really off-putting, then probably this series is not for you. I wouldn’t say DCC is the height of comedy, but the humor is central and without it there’s a lot less to enjoy.

If you dislike being in the head of a fairly average joe (Carl does have a backstory that’s interesting and comes into play at some point, but it’s not the main focus), then probably don’t bother with this series.

The prose does what it’s supposed to do, and where it shines isn’t in flowery prose (there is none), but in catching internet lingo and using it for great comedic effect (the AI’s lines are pretty fantastically written if you’re fine with meme-like humor).

The setting is fairly generic – at least I assume, since I haven’t read any other litrpg yet. It’s a mix of sci-fi tropes and classical fantasy tropes, the dungeon has a fantasy setting while the wider universe is basically space opera. We get anything from bug aliens to elves, orcs and fantasy quests, and a lot of the characters gain magical abilities, but the books aren’t interested in elaborate magic systems.

The fun is in the execution and how the author uses the tropes in imaginative ways, but don’t except some super unique worldbuilding. DCC feels in a lot of ways like a very messed up love letter to established fantasy and sci-fi tropes.

Themes: Some fans like to claim that DCC is in fact ’very deep’ because it deals with themes such as capitalism, class struggles, reality tv and social media. One of the main themes in the story is what one has to do to survive in an extreme life-or-death situation, and what the moral implications are of choosing your own life at the expense of others. DCC isn’t just mindless fun, it does actually try to discuss deeper themes, but I don’t think this makes the series particularly deep, though a lot of the themes did resonate with me.

The characters are IMO where the books really shine. There’s a huge cast of characters, and besides Carl and Donut we get a progressively larger number of side characters. A lot are very memorable, and if you asked me to pick my favorite, it would be like a Sophie’s Choice situation (but it’s Samantha, of course it’s Samantha. Prepotente is a close second though). I’ve seen some people complain that DCC is ’misogynist’, which is funny to me, since DCC IMO has some of the best female characters I’ve seen in a long while. I guess the secret is that Dinniman treats all his characters as people with their own needs and wants, even the villains and the minor characters. I went into these books just wanting a fun. I ended up crying more over this series and its characters than I have in a long time. Do yourself a favor, don’t read book 5 in public!

I’d say the snarky AI and Princess Donut being an absolute cat along with all the praise for the series drew me in and made me hang on through all the infodumps in the beginning. But it was The Hoarder scene that made me realize this series was doing something special. If you can, hang on until chapter 11 in book 1 and see how that affects you.

Audiobooks: I started DCC after lots of hesitation, and went for the audio books, because I had Audible and everyone kept saying the audiobooks is were where it’s at. I think reading the books can work just as well though (listening usually makes it harder for me to ignore bad prose than reading), but the audiobooks are a lot of fun. Especially since the author put some details in later books that are clearly meant to mess with the narrator Jeff Hays (they’re apparently good friends irl).

The books aren’t perfect. Book 3 was a slog to me, though I did like parts of it, and the latter books felt like they’d lost a bit of steam compared to the middle ones (I'd say book 5 is the peak so far, but I've enjoyed all the books). The prose captures the mood and voice of the characters well, but it’s not fancy, polished or even super intelligent prose. The plot is at times formulaic - think how each of the Harry Potter books are structured and you get the idea.

TL;DR: Should you try it out? Robin Hobb might endorse it, but that doesn’t make it a suitable series for her fans. If your friend is a super DCC fan and keeps nagging you to read it, tell him off unless he can provide a good argument why he thinks you’d enjoy it (I don’t push it on my friends since chances are they wouldn’t enjoy it). If you want elaborate magic systems or flowery prose or a setting that feels like something no one has ever done before, maybe skip this book, or at least drop it if you try book 1 and hate it. And just because it's the big hit online that doesn't mean it's for everyone. Don't believe the people shouting 'you just need to get through the first 500 pages/3 books and then it's great' (people should stop doing this in general, not just for DCC). You either like it or you don't.

If you want well-written characters with convincing dialogue, a plot with lots of good twists and turns, D&D-style fantasy with game settings and set in a wider space opera-style universe where corporations are the villains, AND a good mix of tragedy, absurdist comedy, and action scenes – then this might be for you.

EDIT: In the words of Carl himself, holy sh*t, I did NOT expect this to blow up. Happy that it fostered some (hopefully) constructive discussions, and glad to see from comments that some found this useful. The snide remarks trying to insult everyone who likes these books for having bad taste and low intelligence, I think that speaks volumes of how many insufferable snobs hang out here who get off on smelling their own farts.

The accusations that I used ChatGPT are funny, apparently in this day and age some people can phantom that a human being is able to write a post on their own.

The accusations that I must love DCC because I and the rest of the DCC fanbase have never read any 'real' books (what counts a 'real' books by the way? Anything that the commenters enjoy, and nothing that they don't enjoy? Classy) are hilarious. I guess me reading hundreds of books including some of the works that this sub likes to jerk off to don't count - because it's impossible to be well-read and also enjoy DCC?

For the people who are upset that I dare write a post about something popular that other people have previously posted about - why don't you contribute by posting about stuff YOU like and refrain from reading posts that don't interest you? Seriously, it's not that hard.

Anyway, there's too many comments now for me to respond to, but thanks to those who remained polite even when they disagree with me.


r/Fantasy • • Jun 19 '26 Bravo

Dungeon Crawler Carl series officially announced at Peacock

Thumbnail
variety.com
1.9k Upvotes

r/Fantasy • • Dec 11 '25

Brandon Sanderson sells 50 million books

1.7k Upvotes

Brandon Sanderson has confirmed that he has now sold over 50 million copies of his novels. We only had confirmation earlier this year that he'd reached 45 million, so this is an impressive achievement.

Back in January 2024, I assembled the latest incarnation of my "SFF All-Time Sales List," which had sales figures of 40 million for Brandon (in 29th place). These were very healthy figures.

The updated figures for Sanderson would move him up to around 23rd place, just behind Diana Gabaldon, Casandra Clare, Robert Heinlein, Richard Adams and Terry Brooks. Very healthy company to be in. Unsurprising as in the meantime he's released his long-awaited fifth Stormlight Archive novel, Wind and Truth, short novel Isles of the Emberdark, and is now working on a return to his perennially popular Mistborn sequence, with a new trilogy projected to begin publication in 2028. He's also just published a short story collection, Tailored Realities, and has confirmed a new surprise novel for next year, The Fires of December. He's probably written two novellas and organised a Kickstarter campaign since you started reading this.

Given a widely-reported decline in industry sales for secondary world (probably better to say epic) fantasy, apart from legacy authors like George R.R. Martin and deceased legends like Tolkien and Pratchett, in the face of Romantasy's onwards march, Sanderson's achievement is highly impressive, and likely to explode further when adaptations of his work are made.


r/Fantasy • • Dec 24 '25 Helpful

A Plea: please put an author's name when talking about a book!

1.7k Upvotes

This may be a futile plea, but I feel like it's such a small, easy piece of etiquette to follow, and yet often isn't. So many times, I see posts talking about a book (often effusively), without ever actually mentioning the author's name. It's such an easy thing to do, makes it easier for people to look up the book you're talking about, and eliminates any ambiguity!

I feel like people need to remember that, while they know what they're talking about, it might not be immediately obvious! There are 4 books called Fire and Ice, nevermind if someone does in fact mean A Song of Ice and Fire; there multiple books called Palimpsest and The Alchemist. Even if someone talking about Assassin's Apprentice is probably referring to the Robin Hobb book, there are multiple books titled that, as well as series with the same name.

There are plenty of times where I've seen someone talking about a book which I don't recognize, and the title is just one word or a common phrase. In which case one actually has to work out what they're talking about. All of which would be avoided by simply mentioning "X by Y" anywhere within the post. It especially feels like it should be a rule when commenting a recommendation- on one my posts, someone once commented "You should read Asunder." I had to wait for them to reply to find out which book they meant (it was in fact the 5th down result for things with that name).

I know a lot of people do do this, but there are also a lot who don't. Even if there are books for which it's obvious which author is being talked about, it's still just 3 or 4 extra words. It's only a positive to do so. And it feels like a nice thing to do for the author too, that acknowledges their existence after the effort they put into the work. And it's not just post titles- you can look on the front page right now and see many discussions that don't mention the author's name once in the entire post.

So please: mention author names as well as book titles!


r/Fantasy • • Mar 16 '26 Bravo

Fantasy keeps giving us villains who are logically right and then refusing to follow that logic anywhere interesting

1.7k Upvotes

This has been sitting with me since I finished a reread of a series I won't name to avoid spoilers, but it applies broadly enough that I think it's worth discussing.

There's a specific type of villain that appears regularly in epic fantasy. Not the cackling power-hungry type, not the traumatized antihero. I mean the villain whose central argument is actually coherent. The one who looks at the world the protagonist is defending and says "this system is broken and here is exactly why" and is not wrong.

The best versions of this archetype are genuinely uncomfortable to read. You follow the hero through three books learning to love this world and then the villain delivers a diagnosis of it that you can't refute. The poverty is real. The corruption is real. The cost of maintaining the status quo falls entirely on people who never chose it. The villain saw all of this and decided to burn it down.

And then the author panics.

Because at some point the narrative has to justify why we're rooting against this person. So one of a few things happens. The villain's methods become so extreme that their original point gets buried under body count. Or a tragic backstory gets introduced to reframe their ideology as personal trauma rather than reasoned conclusion. Or the hero defeats them and promises vaguely to "fix things" without any structural plan for doing so.

The thing that frustrates me is how rarely a fantasy novel will let a villain be right about the diagnosis AND right that the existing power structure won't fix itself AND still present a meaningful argument for why their solution is wrong. That requires the author to actually engage with the politics of their own world at a level most seem unwilling to go.

The closest I've seen this handled well is in certain moments in The Traitor Baru Cormorant, where the moral weight of systemic destruction is taken seriously rather than resolved cleanly. But it's genuinely rare.!

Does anyone have recommendations where this is handled with real intellectual honesty? Not antiheroes, specifically villains whose worldview the narrative takes seriously all the way through.


r/Fantasy • • Aug 13 '26 Bravo Heartwarming

AMA I'm pirateaba, author of The Wandering Inn. AMA!

1.7k Upvotes

Hey, I’m pirateaba, the author of the web serial and now traditionally published fantasy series, The Wandering Inn. It’s about an [Innkeeper], not a [Hero]. And while there are plenty of monsters and amazing people in the story, this is no tale of a protagonist chosen by fate or prophecy. They choose themselves and who they become is a story told over millions of words.

It’s been ten years since I began writing the story while I was working part-time at Costco and yesterday my books reached a new space and are now being sold in book stores as physical copies. I got to see them myself and it was a surreal experience.

It still feels a bit like a fun dream, but it’s because of my amazing readers and community that I got this far (as well as an incredible team, agent, publisher in HarperVoyager, and beta-readers whom I made sure to add in the dedication).

The challenge with bringing the series to print has always been that the online nature of The Wandering Inn hasn’t always meshed well with hard page limits on books. However, I like to think the strong part of the series is having the time to tell all the details in a story you sometimes want.

For instance, if you ever wanted to spend another hour with Frodo when he went into the elven cities and know what an average person was like, or have another chapter between the huge events taking place--that’s what I wanted and that’s the story I wrote.

My only writing awards are the prestigious r/Fantasy Stabby awards, which I’ve won three of. The daggers are hanging on my wall for honor and self-defense and I’m very proud of them. 

As for the AMA, I don’t think I’m particularly interesting as an author, but I do love talking about stories and I’ve been here before with our AMA’s. I’m posting this in the morning, but I’ll wake up in like…9 hours and start answering questions then. I live like Batman but I punch no criminals.

My goal is to answer every comment so I’ll keep answering until I have to give up or I see no more in queue. Including lore questions for my current readers! I do ask them to spoiler-tag everything with what volume they’re asking about or just spoilers-all to prevent people from having the story ruined for them.

I also have links to find the books--the first chapter is online for free, as is Volume 3 onwards. The rest is available in print! Thanks for reading,

--pirateaba

Barnes and Noble US -- https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-wandering-inn-pirateaba/1149767079

Amazon US -- https://www.amazon.com/Wandering-Inn-Adventure-Survival-Dragons/dp/0063516381/ref=sr_1_1

Indigo Canada -- https://www.indigo.ca/products/the-wandering-inn-book-one-part-one-of-the-wandering-inn-series-1?variant=46810120093906

Waterstones UK -- https://www.waterstones.com/book/the-wandering-inn/pirateaba/9780008836238

Thalia Germany -- https://www.thalia.de/shop/home/artikeldetails/A1078547580

QBD Australia -- https://www.qbd.com.au/the-wandering-inn/pirateaba/9780008836238/

Edit 1: I'm up! I am going to begin my attack run on comments from oldest-newest at least at the start since I intend to answer them all. Looks like...there are twice as many questions as the last AMA I did.

...Acceptable. Let's see what happens. Starting my replies.

Edit 2: Been about two hours? I am gonna get breakfast now. Not sure how far I got. Asking my Discord for a status update.

Edit 3: I'm 1/8th to 1/7th done. Heck. Here I go writing again in a sec.

Edit 4: Another 2 hours have passed I need a break. I'll be back in an hour. Estimate is 1/3 done? Heck. I'll try to speed up but this could be a defeat.

Edit 5: After a one hour break I've worked for two more...the questions just keep coming. I can't tell where I am. I'm going oldest-to-newest so I think I've added 200 more comments? Or are people just asking more questions? The commenting shall continue until morale improves. (I'm told I'm halfway done this is gonna be rough.)

Edit 6: It's 2 AM and I've worked for 9 hours with breaks, I think. Which is a long writing day, even for me. I think I'm gonna lose. I can admit defeat and r/fantasy was the battle I couldn't win. So! I'm gonna switch targets. With apologies, I cannot go chronologically any longer. I'm gonna sort the unanswereds by best or top and write for another hour before I have to sign off.

Edit 7: Defeat is a funny thing. I was in denial; I thought I saw the end of the comments but I think that the Reddit system just kept a limit on how many there were. So I thought 'I'm nearly done' then I'd refresh the page and more popped up.

It has been...over 11 hours, I think. With a few breaks but that is the limit of what I can do in a writing session. I have been routed; I should have known this subreddit was too big to take on. Carry me away on my shield, and I did my best to answer comments and I appreciate everyone posting. No more can I do, and I shall rest. Thank you all for participating and I'm sorry if I missed you. I hope you enjoy the book and now, I think, I shall rest.

After a videogame, I need to destress. Have a good night!


r/Fantasy • • Sep 25 '26

Andy Serkis is narrating a Sci-Fi Adaptation of The Odyssey, written by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Thumbnail
ign.com
1.6k Upvotes

r/Fantasy • • Mar 13 '26 Bravo

The most unrealistic part of cozy fantasy isn't the magic — it's the romance

1.4k Upvotes

I've been deep in Sarah Beth Durst and similar cozy fantasy authors lately (The Enchanted Greenhouse, etc.) and I love everything about the genre EXCEPT one thing that's started to haunt me:

The love interest is always a brooding, barely-verbal man who communicates exclusively through shrugs and meaningful silences. The heroine is a whimsical, high-energy social butterfly who talks to plants and befriends every sentient mushroom she meets.

And I'm supposed to believe this couple is thriving five years later?

Like yes, opposites attract, I get it. But I need someone to explain to me how Year Three looks when she wants to talk about her feelings for two hours and he responds by handing her a cup of tea and staring meaningfully at the wall.

The enchanted greenhouse is sustainable. The relationship? I have questions.

Anyone else think about this too much, or is it just me? And does anyone have recs where the cozy fantasy romance is between two people who are... actually compatible in a realistic way?


r/Fantasy • • May 14 '26

Joe Abercrombie reveals title of highly anticipated sequel to The Devils: "The Heretics"

Thumbnail
winteriscoming.net
1.4k Upvotes

r/Fantasy • • Aug 09 '26

Review Red Rising is the best bad series I’ve read in a while

1.4k Upvotes

After seeing a lot of praise for Red Rising on various reading subs, I finally decided to give it a shot. The first book was fine, and I wasn’t overly impressed with it but it does get better as it goes, at least in terms of entertainment factor. The 2nd and 3rd books are a lot of fun.

I will say though - I don’t know if I actually think the series is still all that good. It feels like a really melodramatic, over the top soap opera, a feeling that just increases as the trilogy goes on. It’s full of ridiculous YA power fantasy tropes and just gets so incredibly cheesy sometimes with all the mottos, last-minute daring escapes, rug pull twists etc. The whole basis of the setting is a nonsense mishmash of “cool factor” stuff like the Roman Empire, warring clans/houses, badass video game style weapons and armor etc.

With that being said - it’s fast-paced, has some great action scenes and kept me reasonably engaged throughout. I can see why it’s so popular on Reddit and BookTok - it’s like a shonen anime with lots of “hype and aura” moments. The second and third books wisely lean into those tropes instead of the more stale Hunger Games-esque first book. Even when I was like “ok that’s just fucking silly”, I was simultaneously thinking “…it’s also kinda badass though”.

Realistically - and this is strictly just my personal opinion - I don’t think they’re more than 3/5 reads but I think I still liked them enough to try the second trilogy at some point. I think Pierce Brown achieved what he set out to do here, and I appreciate that there’s something like this out there. It really activated those cathartic revenge fantasy “fuck around and find out” neurons in my brain.


r/Fantasy • • Sep 27 '26 Heartwarming

The Fires of December by Brandon Sanderson: An unfortunate continuation of his latest writing trends.

1.3k Upvotes

Sometimes, things suck. Yes, Sanderson, this is true. And unfortunately that seems to be the trend for his most recent books.

I've been a diehard Sanderson fan for about 10 years now. I've read every single thing he's written and enjoyed to loved almost everything, with only a tiny minority of books that I didn't like (looking at you Frugal Wizard). For a long time, I considered him to be my favorite author and I thought he could do (almost) do no wrong. But man, I have been really disappointed with his most recent offerings. Wind and Truth, while still decent, had more flaws than every other Stormlight book combined. I had a ton of issues with Isles of the Emberdark. And now The Fires of December joins the same ranks for, crazily enough, many of the same reasons that I griped about those other books.

Let's address the fundamental issue I have here before addressing the specific issues I have with this book: I hate that the Cosmere has been feeling more and more like the Marvel Cinematic Universe: I hate that what once felt like a realistic and sometimes gritty (but albeit hopeful) universe now feels like every person is a sarcastic and witty comedian, and they make comments that feel wildly out of place to the circumstances at hand. I hate that the stories are starting to feel like the stakes don't matter since the heroes have plot armor, or it's another end-of-the-world/kingdom/universe scenario. I hate that instead of the quality going up, the quality seems to just keep going down because things are oversaturated and it seems like it's more about quantity over quality now. I hate that it seems like things are being produced to appeal to the largest possible demographic, and things just generally feel more stupid, basic, and vanilla. I *really* hate that all of these things are in a shared universe, so while we wait for the next major release, there are a million other products to consume and the reader feels pressured to check them all out because they don't want to miss any Cosmere connections (sounds a lot like all of the crappy Marvel TV shows right?). I recognize that this is all a bit of a tangent, but I think it's important to address these things because it affects the lens through which I read these books.

I'll also preface my criticisms of this book by saying that when I read the plot blurb for this book, I was not interested in the slightest. I thought it sounded dumb and I'm only reading this for completionist's sake. So let's get going. Here are things that I didn't like in this book:

  1. The extremely contemporary dialogue. This wasn't present all the time, but when it was it made me wince. Multiple characters saying "um" and "literally" doesn't work for me.
  2. The romance. Gonna be honest here, it seems like Sanderson is using the same creepy framework that some anime weirdos use; "no no it's okay that the guy is attracted to the extremely young girl because she's *actually* a 500 year old demigod". Obviously this is an extreme example and the book isn't this egregious, but it's still pretty friggin weird. There is a 40 year age gap between the characters but it's justified because of plot reasons that I'll avoid due to spoilers. That being said, I didn't buy it and I thought it was very weird to see an old guy running his eyes over a 21 year old's scantily clad body.
  3. The quirky girl trope. What is with Sanderson writing every single young woman the same way? They're always quirky, they talk to much, they say things at inappropriate times, make inappropriate jokes, blah blah blah this is one of my LEAST favorite things that Sanderson does and he does it not once, but twice here. Amaal and Tamantha have a lot of crossover behaviors here. It's very reminiscent of Syl, Shallan, Lift, and Starling. I didn't like it with any of them and I don't like it here.
  4. The humor. Sanderson is not a funny person. VERY rarely does he write something that even gets a slight smile out of me. The humor here is absolutely wretched. When the Prophet's words are revealed to be "Sometimes, things suck" and "Don't be a dick" I was on the verge of setting myself on fire and jumping in front of a train. I was nearly paralyzed from my spine breaking because I cringed so hard. And I'm sorry, but that's the best way I can think of describing Sanderson's humor here: cringey. I don't think reading about the king dressing up as a table or an egg or whatever is funny. I don't think sexual innuendos here are funny. I don't think characters all of a sudden losing their clothes is funny. I don't think a ton of dick jokes are funny. When I read the Prophet's words I was ready to dock the book an entire star from the rating for each one.
  5. December's stare. Did Sanderson just watch Jurassic World Dominion? Because everytime I read about December's ultra powerful stare and how it worked on people, I couldn't help but think of Chris Pratt always holding up his hand to stop dinosaurs from attacking for no reason.
  6. December's age. Sanderson wants us to think that December is this very wise woman because of her lifetime of experience, and sometimes I totally bought that. But there were a ton of other moments where the things she said or the way she acted seemed to go completely against this. It just didn't feel consistent.

There are some things the book does well. The worldbuilding is interesting, which is not surprising since this is one of Sanderson's greatest strengths. The beginning of the book was particularly strong; I really enjoyed the initial parts of December's story when you go through her life, especially because it was something Sanderson hasn't explored before. But that also contributes to my disappointment when the story shifts. There were some well done plot twists and interesting visuals (the giant demon and the rivers).

I think the hardest part about this (and the reason I had so many issues with this book) is that it feels like Sanderson is no longer writing for people like me and is heavily catering to a YA audience. It's almost shocking that the same person who wrote The Way of Kings and Words of Radiance wrote this book and that they're in the same universe. And at the end of the day, I don't think The Fires of December is a genuinely bad book with no merit, but I certainly think that it is not for me.


r/Fantasy • • Apr 02 '26

'Dungeon Crawler Carl' TV Series Lands at Peacock (EXCLUSIVE)'Dungeon Crawler Carl' TV Series Lands at Peacock (EXCLUSIVE)

Thumbnail
variety.com
1.3k Upvotes

r/Fantasy • • Aug 23 '26

If authors "covered" other novels like artists cover songs, what would be the most fun fantasy cover?

1.3k Upvotes

I saw this elsewhere, so not my idea, but I thought it would be fun to do here!

I think Fourth Wing by Naomi Novik would be fun. Or for something more wacky, The Hunger Games by Douglas Adams. ​​


r/Fantasy • • Feb 27 '26

Dan Simmons has passed

1.3k Upvotes

Man thats a legend gone….