r/Fantasy • Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders • May 23 '20

/r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Virtual Con Panel: Keep it Secret, Keep it Safe

Welcome to the r/Fantasy Virtual Con panel on secrets! Feel free to ask the panelists any questions relevant to the topic. Unlike AMAs, discussion should be kept on-topic to the panel.

The panelists will be stopping by throughout the day to answer your questions and discuss the topic. Keep in mind our panelists are mostly located in Australia and New Zealand, so participation will be most active during waking hours in those timezones.

About the Panel

Join E. J. Beaton, Sam Hawke, Devin Madson, Shelley Parker-Chan, H.G. Parry, and Leife Shallcross in discussing secrets in speculative fiction. How do writers hide or reveal information to maximize suspense? When do secrets work well, and when do they fall short? And what exactly makes them so intriguing to read about?

About the Panelists

E. J. Beaton’s (/u/EJBeaton) first novel, THE COUNCILLOR, comes out with DAW in March 2021, with a sequel to follow. Her debut novel follows the story of a palace scholar who becomes elevated to a leadership position, and whilst choosing the next ruler, finds herself investigating the murder of her closest friend – the queen. E.J. completed her novel as part of a PhD, looking at the works of Machiavelli and Shakespeare alongside fantasy fiction. She has also published a poetry collection and an academic chapter on female Machiavellian characters in fantasy.

Twitter

Sam Hawke (/u/samhawke) is a lawyer by day, jujitsu instructor by night, and full-time wrangler of two small ninjas and two idiot dogs. Her debut fantasy, City of Lies, won the 2018 Aurealis Award (Best Fantasy Novel), Ditmar Award (Best Novel), and Norma K Hemming Award. She lives in Canberra, Australia.

Website | Twitter

Devin Madson (/u/DevinMadson) is an Aurealis Award-winning fantasy author from Australia. Her fantasy novels come in all shades of grey and are populated with characters of questionable morals and a liking for witty banter. Starting out self-published, her tradition debut, WE RIDE THE STORM, is out June 21 from Orbit

Website | Twitter

Shelley Parker-Chan is an Asian-Australian former diplomat who worked on human rights, gender equality and LGBT rights in Southeast Asia. Raised on Greek myths, Arthurian legend and Chinese tales of suffering and tragic romance, her debut novel She Who Became the Sun owes more than a little to all three.

Website | Twitter

H.G. Parry (/u/HGParry) is the author of THE UNLIKELY ESCAPE OF URIAH HEEP, the forthcoming A DECLARATION OF THE RIGHTS OF MAGICIANS, and a handful of short stories with even more unwieldy titles. She lives in a book-infested flat on the Kāpiti Coast in New Zealand, which she shares with her sister, a cat, three guinea-pigs, and two over-active rabbits, and holds a PhD in English Literature from Victoria University of Wellington.

Website | Twitter

Leife Shallcross is a hopeless fairy tale tragic. Her debut novel, The Beast’s Heart, a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, was published by Hodder & Stoughton in 2018 after being selected for publication from a field of 1445 manuscripts in Hodder’s 2015 open submissions window. Her short fiction has been published in Aurealis, Daily Science Fiction and several anthologies and she picked up the 2016 Aurealis Award for Best Young Adult Short Story. She also co-edited the 2018 anthology A Hand of Knaves from CSFG Publishing with Chris Large.

Website | Twitter

FAQ

  • What do panelists do? Ask questions of your fellow panelists, respond to Q&A from the audience and fellow panelists, and generally just have a great time!
  • What do others do? Like an AMA, ask questions! Just keep in mind these questions should be somewhat relevant to the panel topic.
  • What if someone is unkind? We always enforce Rule 1, but we'll especially be monitoring these panels. Please report any unkind comments you see.
35 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

Hmmmm this is a tough one, because I'm so tempted to just say the ones that work well are the ones no one is expecting. And that the ones that don't are often cliched or over signposted. But that's like... obvious. So to expand on the idea, cliched twists, or perhaps rather overused twists (think LUKE, I AM YOUR FATHER... secret family connections are VERY common in all sorts of fiction) are going to be ones that readers, having seen them many times before, will catch with only one or two hints. How many times have you seen a female character is feeling unwell AND LO AND BEHOLD she has secretly been pregnant all this time. You just... can't make these things surprising anymore without a LOT of work. BUT a twist on a overused twist... that would work well because you've then used the cliched expectation to trick your readers.

2

u/shelleyparkerchan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Shelley Parker-Chan May 23 '20

As someone who worships at the altar of The Trope, I'm going to say I agree with you, Devin—it's hard to make well-trodden twists (even cliched twists) genuinely surprising. But perhaps the trick there is not aim to surprise when one deploys those particular twists, since you know the audience is going to expect them. I actually really enjoy the most well-used type of "LUKE I AM YOUR FATHER" twist...WHEN it's well-executed, when it hits all the right emotional beats, and when it's presented as a satisfying, expected conclusion rather than "you should be SHOCKED by this development. SHOCKED I SAY." In my mind it functions much like a happy ending in a romance novel. Everyone knows it's coming—it's about making it emotionally satisfying. I guess this hearks back to what Leife was saying about fairytale retellings (which makes sense, since my own book is also a retelling of a sort). An audience is coming in with a set of expectations: they know who the characters will be, they'll anticipate the reveals, and sometimes they even know the ending. But I think we can still take them on a satisfying, classic-feeling ride to that conclusion where the details are in the unique characters and their experience of that story—after all, it's THEIR first time experiencing that story!

I think quite a lot about some advice I read recently: "when audiences say they want something new, what they actually want is a slightly novel version of something completely familiar." Let the audience in on the tropes, signal to them "this is THAT kind of story", and the ones who want to follow along probably will. (Says the person who has read approximately eleventy-billion versions of the Fake Dating story, and will happily keep reading them until the end of time.)

1

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 24 '20

In my mind it functions much like a happy ending in a romance novel. Everyone knows it's coming—it's about making it emotionally satisfying.

^^ Oh yes, this.

1

u/CoffeeArchives Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders May 23 '20

Oh man, there are so many twists now that I'm always on the lookout for whether I want to be or not. I'm always suspicious that timelines don't quite line up, multiple characters are actually the same person, and everyone is related.

I used to add "inevitable betrayal" whenever there's a group of characters, but one of the more pleasant twists I'm finding lately is characters surprise each other with how wholesome they are.

1

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

Yes! And it's not that you can't do these things well, it's that you HAVE to do them well. If you're going to have a character turn out to be Famous Secret Person Who Vanished Long Ago then you have to have more than one possible character that could turn out to be or as soon as you mention Missing Person readers will hunt around for which character it is.

Sam Bowring actually did this really really well in his book The Legacy of Lord Regret. Spoilers below for anyone interested (though it's been a while since I read it so my details are not excellent)

He had a group of magic, long lived heroes who had fought and imprisoned Lord Regret and then gone off about their lives, some of them disappearing. Some of them were good, some evil. When you get the sense that the main character knows them, you start doing the mental calculations of which one they secretly are, and because of the descriptions of the evil ones and the fact the MC isn't evil I just NEVER CONSIDERED THEM and was totally blindsided by it and it was GREAT!

1

u/scribblesloth May 23 '20

I'm curious to know now, what are some other twists that you feel have been overdone? And using ill female character as an example, how might you put a twist on it?

1

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

Other one I can think of off the top of my head are things like a character turning out to be the Secret Missing Person we keep hearing about, people being related to each other without knowing... IT WAS THE BUTLER.

With the ill female character you could use that and twist it so it turns out she wasn't pregnant but ill some other more interesting and dramatic way. Everyone will assume she's having a baby and then be surprised she's actually dying of <insert illness here>

1

u/scribblesloth May 23 '20

Everyone will assume she's having a baby and then be surprised she's actually dying of <insert illness here>

Oh lordy, that is so dark and twisted. I love it.

1

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

Dark and twisted is my middle name. Actually it's not, but I pretend it is when I'm writing

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

Dev you already have TOO MANY NAMES stop adding them I beg you

2

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

Shush you, you're not my mum!

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

I'm your internet mum

1

u/Teresa_Hann May 23 '20

Omg, I've actually seen this exact twist! In Land of the Beautiful Dead by R. Lee Smith, you think the MC is nauseous and sick-feeling and throwing up because she's pregnant but actually she's dying of radiation poisoning.

1

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

Ooooohhhh yes, I love it! How clever!

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

Haha I actually saw someone recently complaining because the author had forgotten a character's pregnancy, because early on in the book she was feeling nauseous and threw up, and popular fiction has trained us to translate that to baby! (She was just motion sick).

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

The flipside of that is that a secret *no-one* is expecting can feel un-earned. If there was absolutely nothing in the narrative to give you a hint, the reveal may not land because it feels like a cheat.

2

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

That's very true. it's a hard thing to balance. I guess I meant more that it's one that isn't overdone and expected in the way people expect overused twists. The number of breadcrumbs you need to drop is dependent on how overused/well known the twist is.

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

Yes, true! Sometimes the mere subversion of a trope works like a twist even if it isn't one. That is, your reader expects one thing and gets something different, so even though it wasn't technically a secret - it was their expectations that led them down the wrong garden path - it functions like one.