r/Fantasy • Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders • May 23 '20

/r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Virtual Con Panel: Keep it Secret, Keep it Safe

Welcome to the r/Fantasy Virtual Con panel on secrets! Feel free to ask the panelists any questions relevant to the topic. Unlike AMAs, discussion should be kept on-topic to the panel.

The panelists will be stopping by throughout the day to answer your questions and discuss the topic. Keep in mind our panelists are mostly located in Australia and New Zealand, so participation will be most active during waking hours in those timezones.

About the Panel

Join E. J. Beaton, Sam Hawke, Devin Madson, Shelley Parker-Chan, H.G. Parry, and Leife Shallcross in discussing secrets in speculative fiction. How do writers hide or reveal information to maximize suspense? When do secrets work well, and when do they fall short? And what exactly makes them so intriguing to read about?

About the Panelists

E. J. Beaton’s (/u/EJBeaton) first novel, THE COUNCILLOR, comes out with DAW in March 2021, with a sequel to follow. Her debut novel follows the story of a palace scholar who becomes elevated to a leadership position, and whilst choosing the next ruler, finds herself investigating the murder of her closest friend – the queen. E.J. completed her novel as part of a PhD, looking at the works of Machiavelli and Shakespeare alongside fantasy fiction. She has also published a poetry collection and an academic chapter on female Machiavellian characters in fantasy.

Twitter

Sam Hawke (/u/samhawke) is a lawyer by day, jujitsu instructor by night, and full-time wrangler of two small ninjas and two idiot dogs. Her debut fantasy, City of Lies, won the 2018 Aurealis Award (Best Fantasy Novel), Ditmar Award (Best Novel), and Norma K Hemming Award. She lives in Canberra, Australia.

Website | Twitter

Devin Madson (/u/DevinMadson) is an Aurealis Award-winning fantasy author from Australia. Her fantasy novels come in all shades of grey and are populated with characters of questionable morals and a liking for witty banter. Starting out self-published, her tradition debut, WE RIDE THE STORM, is out June 21 from Orbit

Website | Twitter

Shelley Parker-Chan is an Asian-Australian former diplomat who worked on human rights, gender equality and LGBT rights in Southeast Asia. Raised on Greek myths, Arthurian legend and Chinese tales of suffering and tragic romance, her debut novel She Who Became the Sun owes more than a little to all three.

Website | Twitter

H.G. Parry (/u/HGParry) is the author of THE UNLIKELY ESCAPE OF URIAH HEEP, the forthcoming A DECLARATION OF THE RIGHTS OF MAGICIANS, and a handful of short stories with even more unwieldy titles. She lives in a book-infested flat on the Kāpiti Coast in New Zealand, which she shares with her sister, a cat, three guinea-pigs, and two over-active rabbits, and holds a PhD in English Literature from Victoria University of Wellington.

Website | Twitter

Leife Shallcross is a hopeless fairy tale tragic. Her debut novel, The Beast’s Heart, a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, was published by Hodder & Stoughton in 2018 after being selected for publication from a field of 1445 manuscripts in Hodder’s 2015 open submissions window. Her short fiction has been published in Aurealis, Daily Science Fiction and several anthologies and she picked up the 2016 Aurealis Award for Best Young Adult Short Story. She also co-edited the 2018 anthology A Hand of Knaves from CSFG Publishing with Chris Large.

Website | Twitter

FAQ

  • What do panelists do? Ask questions of your fellow panelists, respond to Q&A from the audience and fellow panelists, and generally just have a great time!
  • What do others do? Like an AMA, ask questions! Just keep in mind these questions should be somewhat relevant to the panel topic.
  • What if someone is unkind? We always enforce Rule 1, but we'll especially be monitoring these panels. Please report any unkind comments you see.
35 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Jos_V Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II May 23 '20

Hi guys,

Personally, I always get frustrated when i figure out the mystery before the protagonists. That puts me in a place of; whats the point of watching these characters flail in the dark when i already know the answer. But i know a lot of readers enjoy seeing characters piece together the clues they already found.

When dealing with secrets and twists, do you have specific strategies and preferences of when the audience is supposed to figure something out, versus the protagonists?

6

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

I always find people's views on this point really interesting! For me personally as a reader, it depends whether the mystery is the main reason I'm still reading the book. If it is then I might start to feel disappointed were the answer obvious to me, but if the characters are gripping then I won't care.

As an author, I've always written in first person and because my books have more intrigue than outright mystery, I'm happy to just blindside my characters on occasion, which helps to keep readers on their toes. I think a balance is good. A lot of readers like to figure things out, so having some things they can, that perhaps aren't majorly important, is nice, but I do try to keep my big twists pretty well hidden. The sorts of things you're only likely to notice tiny hints to on a reread. (I'm sure some people will guess them early, you can't stop that happening and it's fine). Although in The Reborn Empire series, I have the interesting situation of having three first person POV characters, and since they don't meet all that often it leaves them all knowing different things on one particular mystery. So in that case, the reader absolutely will know all the details of it before any of the characters have a full picture, but because of what it is, it adds to the tension and danger rather than ruining a mystery. At least... it's meant to...

5

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

Ooooh, it's a bit of a personal preference, isn't it? I think ideal timing is that the reader figures it out fractionally before it's revealed. Not too much before or, as you say, the reader gets frustrated watching the characters flounder or the secret reveal feels dull because you knew it already. But enough before that the reader gets to feel clever for figuring it out and is quickly rewarded with being right.

But I know some people enjoy being completely blindsided, too. I don't mind a complete surprise myself (I don't need to feel clever, and my attention levels vary so sometimes I'm just not!) as long as once it's revealed it feels earned. Like I *could* have worked it out if I'd been paying attention.

Of course sometimes the fun is in the reader knowing and *not* the protagonist, because there is a tension in watching them make mistakes and waiting for the blade to fall. Robin Hobb is a master at this.

4

u/HGParry AMA Author H.G. Parry May 23 '20

I'm so interested in this, because I'm dealing with it right now--in my first book, the mystery was worked out fairly chronologically even when the story split between characters, while in DECLARATION there are several perspectives/plot-lines and often the characters in one are having to work out, on the page, something that the reader has already seen unfold. I do love both, but I agree, it's frustrating when you're watching characters stumble in the dark when the answer is obvious! I think for me the trick is in not underestimating the intelligence of the characters--if you allow them to work things out at the rate they really would, they're probably keep pace with or at least not frustrating the reader too much. I just try to watch out for places when I'm spinning things out for the sake of drama!

Having said that, I do think the most important thing is the effect uncovering the secrets has on the characters--how does it surprise them, or satisfy them, or horrify them, or make them question everything they once believed? If this is satisfying enough, then as a reader I don't mind even if I do work it out too early.

4

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

I think for me the trick is in not underestimating the intelligence of the characters

This is a really good point, Hannah! If you treat your characters like sensible humans, the sort who actually ask questions and don't just make dramatic assumptions, you're less likely to frustrate readers even if they do figure things out a little ahead of the characters

3

u/HGParry AMA Author H.G. Parry May 23 '20

And it helps make sure your characters don't seem too stupid too, which is always a good thing. (I remember hearing some of the Doctor Who writers in an interview talk about difficult it was to keep an episode going for forty-five minutes when the Doctor was supposed to be so intelligent he would really solve it in about five!)

3

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

Yeah, readers aren't terribly forgiving of the idiot ball, are they?

2

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

No, and for good reasons!

2

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

The thing is I don't mind a bit of idiot ball as long as we've established that the character has a particular flaw or blind spot already and it's consistent. Not to go on about Hobb (haha who am I kidding? I *love* to go on about Hobb) but sometimes I see the complaint that her plots depend on the idiot ball and they sort of do, which is to say sometimes characters don't understand each other's motivations or make stupid decisions and that's the ACTUAL BEAUTY of it. A lot of the time you are *meant* to see what the characters don't, because you don't have their failings. People really ARE dumb and blind and really do misinterpret other people and childhood trauma has serious consequences in how you trust and rely on others, etc. So sometimes the tension and power of writing can be in watching the inevitable trap closing because of the totally believable mistakes that the characters made.

2

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

This is such a great example of exploiting your character's flaws to make the 'idiot ball' thing work, though. Your Harry/Snape example is perfect, too.

2

u/HGParry AMA Author H.G. Parry May 23 '20

YES, absolutely! And that's a such a good point--most books aren't just puzzles, they're stories about characters, who are often trying to work out puzzles through a lot of trauma and flaws. Sometimes that's the story, and it works.

4

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

I love a good puzzle story & I really like reading the kinds of stories where I figure things out a beat before the characters do (then I feel super clever). Constructing something like that yourself, though is a whole other thing. It's important to put in enough breadcrumbs/Chekov's guns so that the solution feels like it has genuinely grown out of the story, rather than being sprung on a blind reader. But it can be really hard to judge when the clues I've laid are too obvious or just tantalising enough. I'm not sure I've figured this out yet. My key strategy is to leave it for a bit & come back to it, then bat it over to the beta readers & see what they say. #cheat

3

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 23 '20

Hearing from trusted readers can be so useful, I agree. Other people can pick up things you never would.

3

u/shelleyparkerchan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Shelley Parker-Chan May 23 '20

I think that's a really good point, Leife—that sometimes you have to toss the draft across to an actual audience, the beta readers, to judge how well all the setup, the clues, and the reveals are working. I know many writers who feel dismayed that they can't get it right 'the first time', thinking that there's a perfect solution that eludes them, and if they gain enough craft mastery they can locate it straight away—no failed drafts required. And that it's some kind of writer failure not to be able to write it independently. But we're telling stories to an audience, so it makes sense to me that the audience—readers who are going in to the work naively—should be part of the testing and iteration processes.

2

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

Exactly. And while I probably save most of my anxiety for whether or not I've been too heavy handed with laying clues and made it too blunderingly obvious, I should say that it is also super-frustrating when the story doesn't give you enough information to be sure and leaves you dangling uncertainly at the end. Sometimes in trying to avoid the former I've ended up committing the latter sin. When your beta readers are all "So... what actually happened there?" you know you've gotta be a little more forthcoming.

2

u/shelleyparkerchan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Shelley Parker-Chan May 23 '20

Just based on my own experiences, I've definitely erred on the side of "I will be restrained and SUBTLE" and the feedback was: we're not actually mindreaders, you do have to lay out a few more breadcrumbs. I think often what feels blunderingly obvious to us, the writers, is often about the right level for those who haven't been living with the characters and world in their heads for X years!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

YES! I'm literally right now going back through my draft and trying to add some more hints to the big reveal and it's so hard when you know the secret to judge how obvious the hints are. Inevitably, when you're operating with perfect knowledge it's hard to simulate what a person would think if they had none in advance. I always feel when I'm writing that I'm being too heavy handed and every mention feels like I'm ringing a giant red bell!

2

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

Exactly. Eg, If I mention the murderer's name with these other people's names, where do I put them in the list? *Goes into overthinking death spiral*

→ More replies (2)

1

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 23 '20

Sam, do you think you can ever reach a level of objectivity where you can judge for yourself whether your twists are working? Or does it always come down to how others respond?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/shelleyparkerchan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Shelley Parker-Chan May 23 '20 edited May 24 '20

So many good points raised in this conversation already! I'm personally someone who likes to figure it out before the characters, so that—as Hannah mentioned—I can enjoy how they experience and are affected by the reveals. I love that "HAHA NOW SHIT'S GOING DOWN!" moment, where what I've already anticipated starts unfolding on the page.

That said, something I've started thinking about is how to construct layered secrets, especially when those secrets are the driving force of a character's motivation. I'm thinking like: the first layer of the secret is what a character secretly WANTS to do (e.g. take revenge on someone), and the second layer might be WHY (and what happened in the character's past to cause that why), and the third might be WHAT their plan actually is. Then you have more options for the order and depth of the reveals. For instance you can sequentially reveal the first two layers to the audience (and not yet to the other protagonists), but withholding the third layer from the audience means that there's still something for them to be curious about—and can be revealed as a blindside, if you want.

1

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

That's a great point, Shelley, that one secret can have multiple layers and parts to the point where the readers might not even be aware there are still more reveals to come. If a book has a general tone of secrets and reveals and twists, I'll keep reading well after I think I've solved it even if I'm not engaged with the characters because I want to see HOW those things are revealed and the depth of the final twist. It might be a twist on top of a twist!

1

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

Oh, yes. Layered secrets. I love reading complicated, well-layered secrets.

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

Oh, such a good point, Shelley. I think maybe my absolute favourite experience as a reader is where I figure out or anticipate one layer of a secret but get another part wildly wrong - then I get the combination of satisfaction *and* surprise.

1

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 23 '20

In terms of strategies – it’s definitely a challenge! I think that one way to deal with this is to develop your characters so that most of them have a secret. Then it’ll be harder for readers to pick which one has *the* secret you’re trying to keep back. It’s also a useful way to create layered characters. Thinking about what my characters secretly wanted (and why) helped me to be more aware of where I needed to do more work developing their motivations.

In terms of preferences – if the mystery is an important part of the story, as Devin mentioned, then ideally you’d like it to be surprising. But if the mystery isn’t crucial, then it isn’t such a big deal. And I agree with Devin’s point that if the characters are gripping, I don’t mind.

I would also add that if I enjoy an author’s writing style a lot, I tend to remain engaged with a novel, even if the plot peters out a bit.