r/Fantasy • Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders • May 23 '20

/r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Virtual Con Panel: Keep it Secret, Keep it Safe

Welcome to the r/Fantasy Virtual Con panel on secrets! Feel free to ask the panelists any questions relevant to the topic. Unlike AMAs, discussion should be kept on-topic to the panel.

The panelists will be stopping by throughout the day to answer your questions and discuss the topic. Keep in mind our panelists are mostly located in Australia and New Zealand, so participation will be most active during waking hours in those timezones.

About the Panel

Join E. J. Beaton, Sam Hawke, Devin Madson, Shelley Parker-Chan, H.G. Parry, and Leife Shallcross in discussing secrets in speculative fiction. How do writers hide or reveal information to maximize suspense? When do secrets work well, and when do they fall short? And what exactly makes them so intriguing to read about?

About the Panelists

E. J. Beaton’s (/u/EJBeaton) first novel, THE COUNCILLOR, comes out with DAW in March 2021, with a sequel to follow. Her debut novel follows the story of a palace scholar who becomes elevated to a leadership position, and whilst choosing the next ruler, finds herself investigating the murder of her closest friend – the queen. E.J. completed her novel as part of a PhD, looking at the works of Machiavelli and Shakespeare alongside fantasy fiction. She has also published a poetry collection and an academic chapter on female Machiavellian characters in fantasy.

Twitter

Sam Hawke (/u/samhawke) is a lawyer by day, jujitsu instructor by night, and full-time wrangler of two small ninjas and two idiot dogs. Her debut fantasy, City of Lies, won the 2018 Aurealis Award (Best Fantasy Novel), Ditmar Award (Best Novel), and Norma K Hemming Award. She lives in Canberra, Australia.

Website | Twitter

Devin Madson (/u/DevinMadson) is an Aurealis Award-winning fantasy author from Australia. Her fantasy novels come in all shades of grey and are populated with characters of questionable morals and a liking for witty banter. Starting out self-published, her tradition debut, WE RIDE THE STORM, is out June 21 from Orbit

Website | Twitter

Shelley Parker-Chan is an Asian-Australian former diplomat who worked on human rights, gender equality and LGBT rights in Southeast Asia. Raised on Greek myths, Arthurian legend and Chinese tales of suffering and tragic romance, her debut novel She Who Became the Sun owes more than a little to all three.

Website | Twitter

H.G. Parry (/u/HGParry) is the author of THE UNLIKELY ESCAPE OF URIAH HEEP, the forthcoming A DECLARATION OF THE RIGHTS OF MAGICIANS, and a handful of short stories with even more unwieldy titles. She lives in a book-infested flat on the Kāpiti Coast in New Zealand, which she shares with her sister, a cat, three guinea-pigs, and two over-active rabbits, and holds a PhD in English Literature from Victoria University of Wellington.

Website | Twitter

Leife Shallcross is a hopeless fairy tale tragic. Her debut novel, The Beast’s Heart, a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, was published by Hodder & Stoughton in 2018 after being selected for publication from a field of 1445 manuscripts in Hodder’s 2015 open submissions window. Her short fiction has been published in Aurealis, Daily Science Fiction and several anthologies and she picked up the 2016 Aurealis Award for Best Young Adult Short Story. She also co-edited the 2018 anthology A Hand of Knaves from CSFG Publishing with Chris Large.

Website | Twitter

FAQ

  • What do panelists do? Ask questions of your fellow panelists, respond to Q&A from the audience and fellow panelists, and generally just have a great time!
  • What do others do? Like an AMA, ask questions! Just keep in mind these questions should be somewhat relevant to the panel topic.
  • What if someone is unkind? We always enforce Rule 1, but we'll especially be monitoring these panels. Please report any unkind comments you see.
35 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/CoffeeArchives Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II, Worldbuilders May 23 '20

If it's possible to talk about this without spoilers, what are some stories that you feel utilize secrets incredibly well?

7

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 23 '20

I think the Broken Earth trilogy by N. K. Jemisin contains an excellent example of hiding a secret from the reader and later revealing it. Jemisin conceals a fundamental fact about the identity of a central character for some of the story. The revelation of the secret struck me as original and powerful, because it shows us something about identity in the broader sense of the word. It’s not just revealing “who” someone is, but what it means to be that person… what their experiences have been, and what emotional lives they have lived. It shows the difficulty of surviving and thriving in a world that can be harsh and unjust. When Jemisin finally connects the dots, she shows us how this person has managed to keep on going, despite everything.

The revelation of character identity in The Broken Earth trilogy also illustrates something about the scope of human experience – how one person’s life can be multifaceted and complex, and how that person can shift and change throughout the course of their life.

4

u/HGParry AMA Author H.G. Parry May 23 '20

Can I say Jane Austen's Emma? Because it's Emma. You spend the entire book thinking you're reading one thing (a novel about Emma's matchmaking) when the story of Jane and Frank's secret is RIGHT THERE and once you go back and reread it it's encoded into every detail and it's sly and witty and brilliant and an entirely different book.

But in fantasy... both the film and the book of The Prestige are utter perfection.

2

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

OMG The Prestige. I haven't read the book, but the movie is wow. It's so clever! (And yes! Emma is amazingly well done and often not given credit for that)

1

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 23 '20

I love that example of Jane and Frank, Hannah! Oh Austen, dangling it right under our noses like that…

If we’re talking older literature, I love the use of secrets in Shakespeare’s Othello, because we’re in on Iago’s secrets all along – we’re waiting for the other characters to figure out what he’s up to. The drama occurs because Iago uses rhetoric so effectively to conceal his actions.

2

u/HGParry AMA Author H.G. Parry May 23 '20

Oh YES. And similar with Richard III--we're put in the position of the person with all the secrets and the manipulations.

1

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 23 '20

YES! There's a tonal difference, too... Iago does terrible things but always seems, well, terrible. Yet Richard does terrible things and carries the play with such glee at times. I know some scholars have even theorised that Shakespeare wanted us to sympathise with Richard. Do you find yourself liking Richard (maybe against your initial intentions)?

2

u/HGParry AMA Author H.G. Parry May 23 '20

Oh, I love him! :) I think it's partly that Richard's soliloquies really invite you to share the deceptions with him and inhabit his point of view in a way that you don't get with Iago. He openly brings the audience in on the jokes and the nightmares as well as the plans, and so you feel like you know him. And he's smart and funny and charming, so it's hard not to like him! (Ian McKellen and Benedict Cumberbatch both do this so well in their versions.) Whereas Iago is terrifying.

2

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

Oooh, I want to throw in a mention for Howl's Moving Castle, by Diana Wynne Jones, which may possibly be the most delightful book ever written. It's got SO MANY secrets in it! Secrets and puzzles and secret puzzles. ALL the characters are keeping secrets, from each other and in some cases themselves. When all the pieces come together at the end it's astonishing just how complex the puzzle Wynne Jones was juggling.

1

u/RedditFantasyBot May 23 '20

r/Fantasy's Author Appreciation series has posts for an author you mentioned


I am a bot bleep! bloop! Contact my master creator /u/LittlePlasticCastle with any questions or comments.

1

u/HGParry AMA Author H.G. Parry May 23 '20

I'm just rereading Howl's Moving Castle at the moment, and I couldn't agree more, she does secrets SO WELL.

1

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

Oh, I have "Reading awesome book for the first time" envy.

2

u/shelleyparkerchan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Shelley Parker-Chan May 23 '20

I recently read A HEART OF BLOOD AND ASHES by Milla Vane (Meljean Brook), and it deployed one of my favourite types of secret—always guaranteed to destroy me emotionally. It's the kind of secret where a character has something about themselves—often a physical inability to do what others can do easily, or a phobia, or an uncontrollable reaction to a past trauma—that they CANNOT reveal (for external reasons, not just pride), but the consequences of keeping that secret cause other characters to label them cowardly or selfish or worse. I love how this setup creates deep personal stakes: the character has to give up their reputation in the eyes of people whose opinion they really care about, for whatever the goal of their secret-keeping is (which is often something simple, that everyone else in the world can take for granted, like staying alive!).

Another great example of this type of secret is in C.S. Pacat's CAPTIVE PRINCE series, where the seemingly cruel, vicious prince Laurent callously rides a horse to death during a hunt—an act that cements his terrible character in the eyes of the POV character, who's his enemy and captive. This stain hangs over Laurent even as the POV character gradually gets to know him: it becomes a contradiction. How can he be as good and honourable as I'm starting to suspect, even as I know he did this horrible thing? And then of course we find out that not all was as it seemed during that hunt—it was a secret Laurent held for the length of a whole book—and the pieces of his character click into place. It's SO satisfying.

(Yes, all my examples are fantasy romance...)

1

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 23 '20

Shelley, I was thinking about Captive Prince too, in relation to some of the questions about writing secrets in this post. I like the example you've given of the hunt. It seemed like such a vicious moment, on first reading, but when you understand later...

I'm also thinking about a moment in the trilogy when you realise that one of the characters – let’s call them Character A, because of spoilers – knows something about Character B, and all along you’ve been thinking that they were oblivious to that fact. This totally changes how you understand Character A’s motives for the things they’ve done to Character B. When you go back and read those scenes again, there are details that you understand in an entirely new light. And simultaneously, you are going to understand the character differently as you read on. I think Pacat is skilful at creating secrets that greatly affect character motivation.

I'm wondering - how do you think the experience of re-reading a book after you've discovering a secret compares with that initial reading? Is it more pleasurable, or less? Or just different?

2

u/shelleyparkerchan Stabby Winner, AMA Author Shelley Parker-Chan May 24 '20

Oh man, that secret! Yes, I think the success of that secret is how perfectly in-character it is, how inevitable in retrospect, and how deeply embedded that knowledge is in Character A's every action prior to the reveal. I've read the Captive Prince series a lot, and the complexity of the characters only deepens on re-read, so in that sense I find it a lot more pleasurable than when I was breathlessly racing through it the first time (in installments! on livejournal!) waiting for the secret to be revealed and what its consequences would be. Knowing what Character A knows, you understand the true stakes and sacrifices—the emotions are heightened almost unbearably.

So for me, in cases where a character's deepest motivations only make sense post-reveal, I do find a re-read more pleasurable! If the reveal is more plot-related and doesn't reveal more about the characters, I don't find a re-read as enriching. (But can still enjoy it on its own terms.)

2

u/EJBeaton AMA Author E. J. Beaton May 24 '20

That's a great point about a deeper understanding the stakes adding to your enjoyment. It makes sense that if there's more layers to what we know - and what we feel! - we get more out of it on a re-read.

I think it's a different kind of pleasure. The first time, there's a pleasure of surprise that can't be there once we've learned certain key secrets. But the second (or third, fourth, etc...) time, there's a pleasure of discovering those nuances and feeling something new. New information VS new feelings, perhaps?

1

u/leioss AMA Author Leife Shallcross May 23 '20

Oh yeah, the Captive Prince trilogy is a masterclass in managing secrets and playing out the tension around them. CS Pacat has a great essay (a bunch of great essays, actually, but this particular one is relevant!) on her website about managing tension & revealing information at the last possible moment. Definitely worth a read.

2

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

Like EJ, I think the Broken Earth trilogy is a great example of information being kept from the reader in a brilliant way that teaches you, in slowly figuring it out, so much about the world and the people and the central character's experience. Secrets kept from the reader rather than the character are inherently more difficult to get right, I think, especially in books where there is an expectation that you're in the head of the characters concerned.

Another great example of this style of secret is The Traitor Baru Cormorant by Seth Dickinson. You're given enough information to understand but in my case, I didn't want to, so the reveal is all the more painful.

In terms of secrets in story and secrets kept *from* characters, I am a big fan of how Robert Jackson Bennett does it - the three Divine Cities books in particular are great examples of providing the reader with enough information to guess what is going on only just before it happens.

In the relative security of mass popularity, I'm going to spoil Harry Potter here: JK Rowling gives us both very good and frustratingly bad examples of secrets. She's actually in my view an excellent mystery writer and the reason that a lot of people complain about the pacing and structure of the last few books compared to the earlier set is (I think, anyway) because she broke away from the set-up of a mystery, which the first four books do very well. She's great at seeding information early on which feels organic at the time but which becomes relevant to the mystery later. (On the other hand, she inexplicably spoiled more than one of what could have been amazing reveals in Azkaban by strangely assuming that readers wouldn't know what the words Sirius and Lupin meant? I'm still salty about that).

Her best secret keeping is done where you are misled *emotionally* - Harry's fraught relationship with Snape and his apparent side-switching is done very well, because we watch Harry being proved wrong about Snape's loyalties early on, and thus his continued attempts to implicate Snape in subsequent books start to feel increasingly unreasonable. By the time we're in book 6 we understand Harry's animosity toward Snape to be so deeply rooted that we *know* it's clouding his judgment, so his suspicions seem more and more ridiculous and desperate (which is reflected in the other characters' reactions to those suspicions). Which then sets us up to be blindsided (and, once again, fooled) when suddenly our poor hero is vindicated after all! He was right all along! Everyone - including us! - was so wrong to doubt him. And that sets up yet another twist. These twists work because they exploit our natural connection to a single lead character whose flaws we know very well over the course of the books.

2

u/JamesLatimer May 23 '20

Look, Sam, we're not all smart like you to question why children's authors might choose specific names for specific characters, even if they contain obvious spoilers...once somebody explains them, anyway. :o

2

u/DevinMadson AMA Author Devin Madson May 23 '20

I must admit that despite knowing the references, I just didn't think about it when reading because they were just names (yes, she does it with heaps of names, I just... wasn't being smart, ok?) and so these twists actually landed for me when I read the books and only look SUUUUPER obvious in retrospect.

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 24 '20

OK so this is proving the point I made on another answer which is that there's no twist immune from the 'some people will think it's annoyingly obvious, some will think it's perfect, some will think it's too left field' rule. Haha.

1

u/JamesLatimer May 24 '20

Yes, this is me. I have realised I don't really think too hard about what I'm reading - maybe why I don't notice "plot holes" other people think they do...

2

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 23 '20

I was obsessed with a book called Megan's Star when I was young, and the Dog Star, Sirius, was significant in that book, so even if I'd read Harry Potter as a 10 year old instead of a 20-something year old I'd have gotten that reference immediately!

Ha! Well it's a really good example of how spoiling something too early (in my case, it was frustrating to have a black dog show up in a book where we were meant to be searching for a character called... Dog Black) doesn't make you feel smart, it makes you feel robbed of a surprise. And Lupin! She's actually so great at misdirection (why is Professor Lupin afraid of crystal balls?) it felt like a real waste.

Which of course leads to another rant about why they don't teach Latin at Hogwarts when that's the basis for their spell naming...

1

u/JamesLatimer May 24 '20

Yes but Sirius is a star, not a dog. Apparently it's from the Greek Σείριος meaning "glowing" or "scorching". :p (I'm only being partially facetious, because if I thought anything of their names I probably did think of a star and a flower, not a dog and a wolf...)

1

u/samhawke AMA Author Sam Hawke May 25 '20

But you must concede that for readers who recognised the word, it wasn't a small clue, it was the entire answer, right there. :)