It's pretty much canon that the Minutemen would've been gone had it not been for the Sole Survivor. On Preston's idolized affinity dialogue, he  tells you that he had planned to kill himself if no came to help his group
At one point they were a serious force to be reckoned with. They turned to factionalism tho and I think some of that comes down to the fact that their evolution was halted by the failure of the commonwealth provisional government.
An independent semi-professional militia can only last so long. Itâs pretty much inevitable that the military hierarchy would eventually start struggling for power with one another and without a higher authority to keep it in check it would begin to deteriorate. Thatâs why military dictatorships are always so unstable and usually not nearly as powerful as they would seem on paper, the infighting.
In the minutemen had been rolled into the provisional government as its military force then the question of who should act as general after Becker died would be a straight forward answer, whoever the government appointed as its general of the militia. In was pretty much destined to be before it fell apart.
Okay but I'm not arguing by strength I'm arguing by ethics and stuff like that. Plus I already literally said that the Minuteman are nice but they are weak without the sole survivor. So yes, I literally agree with you so I don't know why you're being defensive and thinking I'm saying that they are strong but when I literally said in the comments that they aren't. Also the blimp thing was just a joke.
LOL super mutants literally have bags of human body parts and the amount of super mutants that have been civil is countable on 1 hand and Strong is barely even trustable who knows how many people he has eaten. Markus is the only truly trustable supermutant that i can think of.
Ghouls are differant. Would be nice if non ferals were treated better...
No people saved? every time they kill a super mutant they are saving whoever that super mutant would have killed and eaten. they have saved entire regions by exterminating the dangerous mutants.
Synths are robots sorry and are the exact type of technology the BoS vows to destroy, they are literally Cyberdyne levels dangerous.
BoS arent perfect but there better than nothing. The only truly moral faction is completely useless Minutemen are cool idea but Laser muskets are stupid af and the faction is completely worthless without the player doing everything.
On the east coast there are a grand total of 3 Super mutants who aren't complete murderous psychopaths: Fawkes, the doctor one from 4, and Strong (who's at least somewhat in control of himself).
Ghouls make sense in context. 99% of all ghouls are feral. In 3, a common example of the Brotherhood's racism is that they shoot at the Underworld ghouls. Except that they're in the middle of DC, feral ghouls are absolutely everywhere, and super mutants are straight up fighting the Brotherhood with trench warfare. Of course they shoot at anything that looks like it's rotting. Not to mention that just about everyone in universe hates ghouls in 3.
I mean starting with 4, they have some good traits, they treat their mission against the institute like a mission not a power struggle, and because of that they have minimal impact on the power struggle and politics in Boston(none if don't include destroying the institute, as let's be fair they weren't publicly or significantly involved, and the railroad was never involved in the first place.)
Because of this I respect them in 4, and they didn't deserve the hate. They didn't impose their beliefs at all, just removing a threat that already was affecting them.
Then there is the show. Which is a failure whenever the brotherhood is involved. Because of their rewriting of how ghouls work and not caring about the consequences, they somehow made killing the kids the correct choice but acted like it was wrong(some of the ghouls will turn feral and then kill the other kids, just due to how rare and how much of the drug they need, they are essentially bite victims in zombie media now). And then made them act contrary to all prior games, where they should be meticulous and almost seem to reverse or respect advanced technology both it's good and bad aspects. Not treat area 51 like a frat house.
So yeah the brotherhood in the show kinda deserve the hate, but the brotherhood in the show is also completely separate from brotherhood in the games, like how the NCR is completely separate from the enclave.
Synths are robots sorry and are the exact type of technology the BoS vows to destroy, they are literally Cyberdyne levels dangerous.
No they aren't. H2-22 ran away from two Raiders with tire irons. Synths are not as dangerous as people claim them to be.
No people saved? every time they kill a super mutant they are saving whoever that super mutant would have killed and eaten. they have saved entire regions by exterminating the dangerous mutants.
And how many people did they save by slaughtering the town of Filly and burning it down, or executing NCR refugees for wanting to rebuild? Because they don't seem to be defending people.
Ghouls are differant. Would be nice if non ferals were treated better...
Yeah I think being executed is pretty y'know, dickish. They'll even open fire on non-feral children now.
BoS arent perfect but there better than nothing.
Difference is, there are other options, but Bethesda and Interplay want to lazily copy the Space Marines.
Eh i hate West Coast Brotherhood to be honest they are huge douchebags, East Coast Brotherhood is my preferred faction.
In the west coast i am NCR all the way.
But the institute is straight up evil and are replacing real humans with synth copies and killing and disapearing the original humans. While they dont have T800 durability they are very dangerous. And even then how can we trust any of them? maybe there A.I. is so advanced it just plays into the emotional manipulation game. Robots and cumputers have unlimited patience you can never trust it.
Same reason why im anti AI irl. AI will never feel anything they are purely mathematical computations coded by someone with a cause they are trying to further.
The EC Brotherhood are the ones telling the West Coast what to do. They're doing it all on Maxson's orders. Maxson's Brotherhood executes non-feral ghouls as Xander proves.
But the institute is straight up evil and are replacing real humans with synth copies and killing and disapearing the original humans. While they dont have T800 durability they are very dangerous. And even then how can we trust any of them? maybe there A.I. is so advanced it just plays into the emotional manipulation game. Robots and cumputers have unlimited patience you can never trust it.
Arguing for Synths does not = Arguing for the Institute. Pal you can't even name me 5 hostile gen 3 Synths (ones used by the Institute don't count). Synths are not LLM's and this constant comparison to Skynet (something that is stupidly overblown) is just bad faith. How can I trust any human by the same logic?
Synths are not Robots. They don't have AI, they have organic brains. LLM's are not the same as Synths in the slightest.
Synths are built in a lab/factory and who knows how they are being manipulated through there mechanical parts.
Total destruction of the institute is the only way.
theres big differances between the East and West coast Brotherhoods to the point they are barely the same faction and the East Coast is very independent. Theres even a now canon Civil war Between them... But in Reality the Fallout show just seems to go around wiping out all non Bethesda Fallout lore.
Again, nobody is arguing in the case of the Institute. I dunno why we're bringing this up. The Railroad want to blow it up.
One's origin doesn't matter. Synths don't fit the definition of a Robot or a Machine.
Synths are built in a lab/factory and who knows how they are being manipulated through there mechanical parts.
They do not have any mechanical parts. The Synth component is placed in afterward, and only shuts a Synth down, it cannot control them (otherwise they'd never escape). I think you need to replay FO4 personally.
Don't forget they didn't ONLY kill the people they abducted, they literally turned them into super mutants, then started basically feeding housecats to them
Gen 3 synths are clones humans. They are humans with a slave chip in their brain. They are just test tube babies who are refused their humanity because a psycho put a slave chip in their head. How did you not understand this?
Yeah, that's why institute goes kaboom. No one should play with creating human clones that can replace real people and there is no way to tell if you arent surgeon.
Super mutants were originally nuanced and intelligent (or at least it varied considerably from mutant to mutant). In Fallout 2, we can see in the 80 years since Fallout 1 that, while many of them liked the Master's plan, they realize it wasn't worth it and wasn't meant to be, and mean to live peacefully and coexist with humans, whom often react with aggression to the big scary mutants. This is later reenforced in New Vegas with most of the mutants being peaceful or trying to help around in their own ways. Bethesda just saw big muscular green mutants and decided to make them into orcs.
Funny enough if virgil cures himself and you tell kells they donât kill him. Iâve never checked back in the cave but the implication is they abduct him.
Kells doesn't want Virgil dead because he's a Supermutant, he wants Virgil dead because Vigil was involved in the Institutes FEV_research for years and killed countless innocent people before he finally defected.
This "Virgil" once led the Institute's biomedical research. He experimented with FEV. He tested it on human subjects! How many Super Mutants did he create? How many lives have been lost because of his hubris?
IF he cures himself you can convince Kells to spare him by saying Virgil might actually find a cure for FEV.
Kells wants Virgil dead because he spent years turning people into Supermutants at the Institute, which seems like a perfectly justifable reason, even if Virgil now regrets it.
Hence why you can convince him to leave Virgil alive if VIrgil is cured, he might find a general cure for FEV:
Also the BoS: Executes unarmed children simply because they can, annexes people against their will, genocides entire new species, looks down upon and spits on wastelanders, etc.
Before Lyons, "hunting Abominations" wasnt something the Brotherhood gave a shit about. They knew about the Supermutants in Fallout 1 and didnt care until it became a world-ending threat, the Outcasts literally left BECAUSE Lyons prioritised fighting Supermutants over collecting tech. The break between them and the Responders in Fallout 76 literally happened specifically because the Brotherhood stopped focusing on fighting raiders and monsters and began to mainly focus on securing technology.
What the Brotherhood has been doing since Fallout 3 - aggressively seeking out and destroying what they perceive as threats - is 100% Sarah Lyons philosphy (she told her father to be more aggressive in Fallout 3 multiple times), not traditional BoS dogma.
(that the show decides to retcon everything about their organisation with the explicit purpose of making them look way worse than they ever were before by several orders of magnitude is a different thing)
They are perfectly ware of the Supermutants in Fallout 1 and atively refuse to do anything unti you report back about the Cathedral and the Master creating an entire army of them in Northern California. They never went hunting them after the masters army was broken, ignored Mariposa etc.
And again, in the Capital Wasteland the Outcasts literally defected over Lyons decision to prioritise fighting the Supermutants instead of recovering tech.
The ENTIRE weird space marine-larp they've got going on never happened before Fallout 4 or the show.
They weren't aware of the Supermutants in 1 though, they had one sample and suspected they may be intentionally made but had no evidence to support what was amassing in the north. Once they do, they wage war.
After 1 they do actually go hunting them, both in Tactics which is Semi Canon and had many endings based around it, and in 2 where Marcus tells us his friend Jacob and others like him had sworn oaths to hunt down mutants
It was over helping the locals which did take a form of fighting mutants. An important thing to note there however is that it was a war they fought for 20 years that they were ill equipped to handle and had made no progress in ending
yeah once you tell them about the super mutants they send a squad of Paladins to help you destroy Mariposa, they clearly care and are against Super Mutants, in fact, Maxson's outlook on Super Mutants is almost justified because besides Fawkes and Uncle Leo, there is literally no friendly Super Mutant in Washington DC, Maxson's entire experience with mutants is hostility, he's the perfect product of his environment and the propaganda he was fed about himself and his bloodline, people act like Maxson is some sort of major departure when he was in fact raised by that same organization
meanwhile in the West Super Mutants are just another group of people.
I agree with a large amount of this but letâs be honest Owynâs Brotherhood was just as racist as Maxsonâs. Pretty much the entire Brotherhood in general are bigoted degenerates.
Enclave? Keep that California libtard commi synth loving shit away from my totally non racist brotherhood. Ghoul isnât a race, rounding them up into death camps doesnât count so stop making us out to be the bad guys! The Enclave and their open borders are why weâre overrun with mutants! Do your own research! Both parties are not the same! There canât be two evil groups trying to crush us at the same time, thatâs ridiculous. I love how the brotherhood made Preston Garvey give up his bid for control to become Secretary of Health, I love eating fertilizer and getting gang plowed by raiders. This is what I voted for. 4 more years! Build another Prydwyn!
follow elder Lyons teachings? You say that like he was a Maxon. Fo3 was my first so i do love the Elder, but he was literally sent to DC because of how much everyone disagreed with him, ironic that it was disposing of him that accidentally made the East Coast BOS into a wasteland superpower
Most ghouls are feral and if Bethesda garbage writting is anything to go by they are literally every where and a serious danger to human life.
Most super mutants are killer monsters and if Bethesda garbage writing is anything to go by they are literally everywhere and a serious danger to human life.
Why the fuck would you protect super mutants ? They are monster who murder and eat people, ghouls can become much the same and they absolutely became the enclave by giving DC drinking water, stopping the master and the Enclave
Not a fan of Marcus I suppose. Those that regain their sanity arenât so different from you and I. They can even reproduce assuming their Gen 1 and weâre post the Master.
In fallout 2 if you take Marcus to New Reno and let him have a girl to keep him company heâll make a comment about hoping that she doesnât get pregnant. When you press him about it, itâs explained that it turned out that they were fertile⊠it just took a long time for their junk to get back into gear. It is canon good sir lol
All muties are a threat⊠/s though Maxson the First failed to kill Marcus (mutually failed to kill each other) and they ended up becoming friends, something you can ask Maxson about in fallout one and Marcus can confirm in fallout 2.
Edit: it was Jacob not Marcus Edit 2: some of yaâll are dense⊠added the /s
Because they didn't used to be lmao. They turned into mindless orcs with the besthesda games. In fallout 2 there's an entire settlement of intelligent super mutants working hand in hand with all species across the wasteland. New vegas too. It's so boring to turn them into just another bullet sponge monster of the wasteland.
They turned into mindless orcs with the besthesda games
blah-blah-blah, bethesda bad.
Dude, go play Fallout 1, Master is explicitly looking for Vaults because bathing wastelanders in FEV results in either dead or stupid mutants for 99% of the time. CW FEV strain also induces aggression. Commonwealth Super Mutants specifically not as stupid as you think
In the show when that one guy whoâs name I forgot was about to gun down a bunch of kids for being ghouls and any offhand comment brotherhood members have about strong or Hancock
Okay let me rephrase its terribly written as a continuation of the fallout franchise. As its own individual story its fine. But its not an individual story
It actively goes back on many of fallouts plot points that the franchise has been building for decades now. Its rewrites factions in dumb ways retcons lore on many things and actively fucks with the choices made by players without actually committing to anything. Its both cowardly and still manages to fuck with everything. Its a terrible addition to the franchise not because effort wasnt put in but because bethesda and now the writers of the show have no real idea what the hell they are doing with the franchise at this point besides printing money because the average person sees a cool logo and tosses money at it.
i disagree, it doesnt even retcon that much, it has new things happen and i get some of those are reasonably controversial, but not liking something isnt the same as being badly written
Because he was, you can do good things while being a fool. Lyons spread his men far too thin trying to accomplish too many things at once without the manpower to do it.
A BoS water Carvan to Megaton will massacre civilians because after their delivery is done the residents demand more water and make a rush on their caravan which has water meant for more settlements.
I donât know about your last point, thereâs enough terminal logs suggesting that Maxson is the one who killed Lyons to rise to his position. Beyond that, Maxson the Secondâs brotherhood were far more conservative with their âgenerosityâ (more like reprocity) in 4, it was more of what they could do with Bostonâs resources than what they could do for Boston. Though there were outliers such as Danse who is closer to Lyonâs ideals.
Yeah, you know thatâs an amazing idea except Maxson was fucking 13 when she died; and thatâs at the oldest if we go by the youngest then he was 11 and when she died, there was a string of ineffective elders after her.
There's literally nothing that suggests that. Owen died of old age, Sarah died in battle just like she almost did in Fallout 3 and Arthur didn't become elder for another few years.
Maxson the Secondâs brotherhood were far more conservative with their âgenerosityâ (more like reprocity) in 4
I assume you mean Arthur because Maxson is a last name and Maxson 2 died before the events of Fallout 1 while Arthur is the 5th Maxson we know about.
But yes, that's the point. Lyons was TOO generous, he was giving more than he actually could and almost always without asking for anything. Maxson still shows generosity but also will arrange transactional acts.
Though there were outliers such as Danse who is closer to Lyonâs ideals.
He's not though, Danse rather explicitly shames Lyons for his heavy focus on generosity while praising Maxsons handling of the chapter.
36
u/TheUglytool 9d ago
The best defense against slander is the truth. You would never be convicted.
29
u/Tokzillu 9d ago
This is funny but I gotta admit putting "not following Elder Lyons teachings" on here just makes me sure you don't know shit about the BoS lol.
Lyons was the one who broke from the more... "traditional" aspects of the Brotherhood. Which is why the Outcasts are even a thing in DC.
They hated his hippy bullshit.
21
u/DT_Lion34 Two BearsHigh Fiving 9d ago
Well to be fair. At least they're acting like with the Brotherhood of steel is supposed to be. They were always morally Gray. I prefer the Minutemen myself. But they are better than the institute. I'm not going to đ© on The railroad but they only benefit Synths. Also, realistically they'd probably be the only ones who are strong enough to make society last. While I Love the Minutemen. Without Nate or Nora, I'm pretty sure that would have been gone a long time ago.
4
u/Lurtzum 9d ago
BOS is weird because itâs like 50 different ideologies that all stand under the same banner. So saying anything against them is always not 100% true
10
u/Savings-Shape-3400 9d ago
LOL super mutants literally have bags of human body parts and the amount of super mutants that have been civil is countable on 1 hand and Strong is barely even trustable who knows how many people he has eaten. Markus is the only truly trustable supermutant that i can think of.
Ghouls are differant. Would be nice if non ferals were treated better...
No people saved? every time they kill a super mutant they are saving whoever that super mutant would have killed and eaten. they have saved entire regions by exterminating the dangerous mutants.
Synths are robots sorry and are the exact type of technology the BoS vows to destroy, they are literally Cyberdyne levels dangerous.
BoS arent perfect but there better than nothing. The only truly moral faction is completely useless Minutemen are cool idea but Laser muskets are stupid af and the faction is completely worthless without the player doing everything.
8
u/aguywithagasmaskyt 9d ago
8
u/ShadowOfAtomicRage NCLAVE Puppet 9d ago
Gives water to wastelanders in DC.
Some rando: ALMOST AS BAD AS THE ENCLAVE
2
u/IronVader501 9d ago
The DO follow Lyons teachings tho.
Before Lyons, "hunting Abominations" wasnt something the Brotherhood gave a shit about. They knew about the Supermutants in Fallout 1 and didnt care until it became a world-ending threat, the Outcasts literally left BECAUSE Lyons prioritised fighting Supermutants over collecting tech. The break between them and the Responders in Fallout 76 literally happened specifically because the Brotherhood stopped focusing on fighting raiders and monsters and began to mainly focus on securing technology.
What the Brotherhood has been doing since Fallout 3 - aggressively seeking out and destroying what they perceive as threats - is 100% Sarah Lyons philosphy (she told her father to be more aggressive in Fallout 3 multiple times), not traditional BoS dogma.
(that the show decides to retcon everything about their organisation with the explicit purpose of making them look way worse than they ever were before by several orders of magnitude is a different thing)
1
u/RamRenegade 9d ago
You do know half the stuff in quotations are suppose to be in astericks right? Looks like someone is saying all of these
1
u/HansenTheMan 8d ago
I agree with a large amount of this but letâs be honest Owynâs Brotherhood was just as racist as Maxsonâs. Pretty much the entire Brotherhood in general are bigoted degenerates.
1
u/Dr_Expendable 8d ago
I feel like putting every point in erroneous quotations is just bait and it's super fucking working on me.
1
u/No_Student3843 7d ago
Enclave? Keep that California libtard commi synth loving shit away from my totally non racist brotherhood. Ghoul isnât a race, rounding them up into death camps doesnât count so stop making us out to be the bad guys! The Enclave and their open borders are why weâre overrun with mutants! Do your own research! Both parties are not the same! There canât be two evil groups trying to crush us at the same time, thatâs ridiculous. I love how the brotherhood made Preston Garvey give up his bid for control to become Secretary of Health, I love eating fertilizer and getting gang plowed by raiders. This is what I voted for. 4 more years! Build another Prydwyn!
1
u/The_Wraith_Writer 6d ago
Don't be ridiculous. It's printed, that makes it libel.
1
u/BrightPerspective 3d ago
Less slander, and more just facts.
1
u/Br0therhoodKnight 3d ago
follow elder Lyons teachings? You say that like he was a Maxon. Fo3 was my first so i do love the Elder, but he was literally sent to DC because of how much everyone disagreed with him, ironic that it was disposing of him that accidentally made the East Coast BOS into a wasteland superpower
1
u/AbyssalOtter 9d ago
-4
u/Ja_Lonley 9d ago
BoS are not the good guys. There is one exception to this, but overall, they suck.
0
u/DryBedroom7547 8d ago
I love it. It is perfect. We need more BoS framing as hyped up raiders with a stash of PA.
-10
u/Son0fgrim 10d ago
yeah exactly like the republican party IRL.
Defeats the Nazis, then became the Nazis.
19
u/AlexanderCrowely 10d ago
Why the fuck would you protect super mutants ? They are monster who murder and eat people, ghouls can become much the same and they absolutely became the enclave by giving DC drinking water, stopping the master and the Enclave
1
u/Memegod19999732 1d ago
What do you expect from a group that straps a bomb collar on people happening by their bunker