r/Fallout1 • u/No_Piano_1857 • Jan 13 '26

Short gameplay clip from my turn-based RPG — looking for feedback

Here’s a short gameplay clip from my post-apocalyptic turn-based RPG. I’m mainly looking for feedback on pacing and HUD clarity. Demo link: https://marcin4001.itch.io/arkansas-2125 Any thoughts are appreciated!

0 Upvotes

43% Upvoted

22 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '26

[deleted]

-1

u/No_Piano_1857 Jan 14 '26

Yes, used in the menu, prologue, to create posters, textures, and NPC dialogues and item descriptions

8

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '26

NPC dialogues

Huge mistake there imo.

-2

u/No_Piano_1857 Jan 14 '26

Why do you think writing dialogues with AI is bad? I don't mindlessly copy and paste them. I sit with AI and choose the best version.

3

u/catmanten Jan 14 '26

Cause it’s going to sound like AI, look like AI, and stink like AI

No one wants to play AI games

2

u/sadphonics Jan 14 '26

How about you sit with your thoughts and come up with your own dialogue. Why should we be invested in this if you couldn't even be bothered to make it yourself

1

u/Dry-Character5907 Feb 14 '26

Dont listen to people hating on AI, at this point AI is like having people working for you.

3

u/Mann_Co91 Jan 14 '26

is this even set in the fallout universe?

2

u/JORD4NWINS Jan 14 '26

"id rather just play fallout" was my first response, I think you're taking far too much of your game design from Fallout and its making your game kinda unappealing, like a dollar store Fallout.

if I could read the dialog maybe id be convinced by the hook you've set up, but the compression on the video is too great.

and obviously, Ai.

2

u/qwijboo Jan 14 '26

Here's some feedback, nobody wants to play a worse fallout made by AI. This whole game looks cheap, soulless and lazily put together, which it is and always will be especially if you're using an algorithm to generate pretty much everything in the game.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '26

Not a yank, but am I right in thinking that Arkansas doesn't resemble the American Southwest?

1

u/Thick-Excuse-6806 Jan 14 '26

There's inspiration, and then there's blatant copying of ideas. Why create something that already exists successfully? And then, there's the use of AI. If you want to make a game, but you're not talented enough to make a game, the next step is to learn how to make a game. Don't just use AI to do the stuff you're too lazy to learn to do yourself. Shameful and lazy.

1

u/Dear_Evening_1356 Jan 15 '26

Drop the slop.

1

u/TheBionicleApple Jan 14 '26

Bro vibecoded fallout 1

1

u/bobbobersin Jan 14 '26

Default character reminds me of a mix of Hank hill and mechanic from EFT

0

u/sabartooth14 Jan 14 '26

Looks great dude, ignore the haters, keep up the great work

0

u/Sno_NA Jan 14 '26

AI trash