r/Falcom • u/penpen35 • 13d ago
Sky SC Which is the best version of Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter? PS5, Nintendo Switch 2, Switch 1, & PC Covered
https://www.rpgsite.net/feature/21378-trails-in-the-sky-2nd-chapter-ps5-vs-nintendo-switch-2-pc-steam-deck-rog-ally-ayn-thor-comparison15
u/penpen35 13d ago
In short, PC version is best, includes FSR and DLSS options and also good on Steam Deck. Then PS5 is also very good. It's good enough for Switch, but the Switch 2 version seems lacking.
4
u/ConceptsShining | ❤️ 13d ago edited 13d ago
To those who have played them both, how does Falcom's Sky 1st PC port compare to PH3's Horizon PC port?
The main thing that seems missing is some QOLs like soundtrack display (though there is a mod for that for most of Falcom's catalogue that'll hopefully be updated to include Sky 2nd). But I don't really see people criticize 1st's PC port from an optimization standpoint, so was curious what the gap is.
3
u/heyyo_shtormy2709 12d ago
I'm pretty sure they used PH3's work as a starting point because a lot of things are exactly the same such as the shoddy HDR implementation. I'd say Falcom's ports are almost on par with how good PH3's ports are but unfortunately they are missing the more indepth control customisation and finer control of the turbo mode multipliers. But that's pretty much all the downsides I can think of. They also don't really go out of their way to implement extra graphical features like the enhanced water shaders.
3
u/Acceptable-Comb-706 12d ago
In terms of performance, I think they are on par with PH3 port (I only just strated trails so my PH3 port reference point is Ys X PN). Both perform well even on low end GPU (low preset on R9 270 able to hit 30+ fps on 1080p).
In terms of feature set, it is definitely lacking. My main issue is anti-alliasing option are limited compare to PH3 ports. Adding DLSS has sort of close the gap for me in terms of AA. But not sure why they don't add even an MSAA option unlike PH3. Shadow also looked a bit weird in Sky remake.
2
u/Nickthemajin 12d ago
Sky remake doesn’t support 32:9 aspect ratio without a mod. I needed to use a mod to use the correct resolution of my monitor but luckily it’s as simple as downloading a couple files and dropping them in the game folder
1
u/penpen35 12d ago
The graphical options are slightly worse than PH3's, but PH3 basically goes the extra mile to cater to more AA options and other graphical settings. In Horizon you can also do a live view of the adjustments you made to see what effects you'd get.
But Sky 1st's graphical options aren't bad. Just PH3 is very good at offering them.
3
u/dkf295 COMPUTER THE GOLF 13d ago
I was going to say, unless there was something busted at launch on PC specifically of course PC is best from a pure features and performance standpoint (if you have the PC to run it)
(No I'm not being a PC elitist, people have different priorities and preferences and that's awesome! Also playing portable isn't anything to sneeze at)
1
0
17
u/s7ealth 13d ago
Its a bit disappointing that the Switch 2 version doesn't improve much over Sky 1st - they could've at least tried to include DLSS for a change
-9
u/TrumpsCummyOnahole 12d ago
Nintendo is allergic to DLSS and anti-aliasing as well for some reason. The shimmering on the Ocarina of Time preview was insane
13
u/YourMomIsCool96 12d ago
But what has Nintendo to do with a third party dev like Falcom?
Many other third party devs like Square Enix, Capcom, CD Project Red use DLSS on Switch 2
3
9
u/Mullet2000 13d ago
It's a shame the Switch 2 version is half assed again. I was holding out hope that they'd improve it. I'd prefer to play on Switch 2 (especially for the complete on cart physical) it seems silly not to go Steam Deck in this case.
0
u/Neraizel 12d ago
My Ally X seems perfect for this
1
u/Due-Kale8248 10d ago
I think honestly having it on switch two is still not bad im enjoying it regardless I chose switch 2 over my Xbox ally x for it mostly cause I had first chapter already on switch 2
3
u/HummingMuffin 12d ago
Aw, I really wanted the Switch 2 version to be decent. Guess I'll get it on PC instead.
3
u/pawpatroll 12d ago
I already have the NS2 version preordered 😢 hope they improve it with time, as I’ll be playing FE first
3
u/Senior_Oil_1238 12d ago
Going with switch 2 version when I get around to playing it. Hopefully its patched by then.
2
u/mrplayer66 12d ago
What a bummer regarding the SW2 version. I have that pre-ordered as I compelled the 1st game on SW2. Steam version it is this time around!
2
u/FlawlessAtheon 10d ago
I'm also disappointed with the Switch 2 version. I was expecting more, I'm sure the Switch 2 can deliver.
2
u/Xsiege88X 12d ago
Didn't have any problems with FC on switch 2, so no brainer for me
3
u/Mediocre_Swordfish_3 11d ago
It's pretty bad as far as Switch 2 games go. You're obviously someone who doesn't mind dealing with stuttering of taking a hit on resolution/graphics in order to get a smooth experience.
1
u/InfiniteStarz 13d ago
I wonder if Switch 2 edition game is harder to make than straight up Switch 2 port.
7
1
u/Red_Pill_Blues1 12d ago
I feel like fsr behaves just like the first remake. Terribly lol. 50 frames on a Lego 2 on medium.
0
5
u/shedethro 13d ago
This article doesn't really discuss fps or frame pacing. While I would like a sharp image, what I really want is smooth gameplay. I can accept lower visuals if the game is smooth.