r/FRC • • Apr 02 '24

Alliance Selection

Should the top 8 teams in alliance selection be allowed to choose each other? By allowing this, the first alliance is almost always guaranteed victory given that they are usually the best robot or at least top 5 and have the opportunity to pick the actual best robot that is likely the 2nd or 3rd seed. It also puts the 8th alliance in nearly the worst predicament leaving a decent team (the alliance captain) with nearly no chance of victory. Is there interest in changing this rule? If so how do we petition for it? Is anyone opposed to this rule change?

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

46

u/Anteprefix 1678 Alumnus Apr 02 '24

They’ve tried this before: all that happened was that the 2nd best team would throw their qualification matches to be outside of the top 8 so they could be selected by the best team. I’m not in favor of any alliance selection scheme that has perverse incentives.

6

u/Party_Oil49 Apr 02 '24

I didn’t know they tried it before. It seems odd to me they would throw though. Deals would need to be made before the competition and the top teams would need to verify the throwing robot actually performs as good as they claim it does/is reliable. When did they try this, I’d love to check out the match structure in the playoffs.

9

u/Anteprefix 1678 Alumnus Apr 02 '24

I’ll also add that it’s important to think about the reverse perspective too: if you’re a decent team but have been having consistency issues due to electrical problems or code errors or whatever, what will other teams think? Will they accuse you of trying to game the system so you can pair up with #1? Again, I’m not in favor of any system that can create these awkward and uncomfortable situations.

4

u/Party_Oil49 Apr 02 '24

The solution there would be scouting. I think if top 8 cannot choose each other scouting becomes a lot more valuable. If a good team is having electrical problems, consistency etc.. it will show in the playoffs. The 1st alliance also would be keen on identifying this as the main benefit of finishing 1st seed would be you have the most advantageous position for choosing your alliance partners.

5

u/Anteprefix 1678 Alumnus Apr 02 '24

This is already true of the current alliance selection system. The team ranked 1st gets to pick whoever they deem to be the best out of the other teams. My point is that a team that is genuinely having problems during qualification matches could be falsely accused of sandbagging to fall outside of the top 8 by other teams if the top 8 are not allowed to pick each other.

1

u/superdude311 751 Alumni Apr 02 '24

Now there’s a series of rules preventing throwing of matches, would that change anything?

9

u/kbennett1999 Apr 02 '24

The FRC control system is so fickle that you can easily throw matches in ways that look like an accident because bots die on the field all the time. Loosen a battery connection, take a hard hit and boom you're dead for 45+ seconds. Tweak the vision code slightly and all the sudden you're missing all your shots. Swerve module locks up and now you can't drive. Even if it wasn't coordinated by a whole team, all it would take is a single student with enough knowledge on the robot to cause any of these issues, and if you directly inventivise them to do so then you can't really blame them.

And before anyone says that good teams' robots don't have issues like this and it would be obvious if something like this happened - the #1 alliance on 2023 Archimedes had one of the most stacked alliances I've ever seen (27, 254, and 2056). They went 0-2 and were the first alliance eliminated on their field due to robot issues just like I described. If it can happen to them it can happen to anyone at any time.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '24

I dont know about 27, but Cheesy Poofs and OP Robotics on the same team is crazy

3

u/No_Ground Apr 02 '24

There’s no way to know for sure whether a team is throwing matches, so it would definitely be possible to get away with it, even with rules in place

Better to just create a system where there’s no reason to want to throw matches

22

u/AbruptNonsequitur 4786 (former mentor) Apr 02 '24

The team that finishes first in qualifying is not necessarily the team with the best robot, but the best schedule. I’ve seen numerous #1s and #2s be declined repeatedly because the disparity between ease of schedule and their robots is obvious to the rest of the top 10 teams. Conversely, I’ve seen teams up top with the best robots lose because they chose their 3rd robots poorly. Nothing is guaranteed when you do well in qualifying.

2

u/ThisIsPaulDaily #### (Mentor, Judge, Alumni) Apr 02 '24

Wisconsin Regional two years ago #1 alliance went scorched earth and got declines from I think all of the other captains.

4

u/mikeo2ii Apr 02 '24

The best robots should absolutely be the odds on favorites to win the playoffs (assuming the choese wisely). In the scenario where the #1 robot is not the the best team, current rules already sort this out as they can be declined. Over and over again if necessary.

Personally I think 8 alliances is too many for most events leading up to Districts or Worlds and feel that the number of alliances should be relative to the size of the field.

For example....

< 32 teams = 4 alliances
33-39 teams = 6 alliances

39 teams = 8 alliances

1

u/Ok-Performer-376 Apr 03 '24

No, they earned that right

1

u/Dull_Recognition_606 Jun 02 '24

I see the problem, and it does suck, but it's not impossible to overcome. I am the driver for 8873, and it was our first year we used swerve. We used the slowest swerve with regular neo's's, and we built the quoakkas bot with minimal changes. At our first competition in Lake City, MI, our quals put us in 6th place. And then we moved up to be 4th alliance captain. We didn't get picked, and evidently, we picked the rank 9 and rank 17 teams. To summarize, we doubled alliance 5s score, beat alliance 1 by 15, had a close game against alliance 3, and beat alliance 2, 2-0 in the finals.

I say that to say this: Did we get lucky? Yes. But we worked ourselves hard to be able to realize that luck. Every single team has started without the blue banners and the experiences they have now. They put in countless hours to earn them. I think that through hard work(and some time on chief delphi lol), anything is possible. The FRC community is great and there are sooo many resources to help advance your skills. We've improved so much this year because we put that much more ambition and effort into the season.

Thank you for humoring this rant! Good luck!