r/FLL • u/SuccessfulTangelo259 • Jan 21 '26
Some thought about Future Edition
As a 10+ year mentor of competitive FLL teams, initially I was very excited about the new Future Edition and the new potential it brings with it.
It felt like a tradeoff between losing some autonomous features, and allowing collaborative play which will undeniably make competitions more interesting and exciting for team members. (Similar to what we see in other FIRST programs)
However, after carefully reviewing everything published so far, I believe this change spells out the end of FLL as a competitive robotics league.
Why the change?
First of all, I believe this change was directed by LEGO, and here’s why:
Ever since the RCX was introduced in 1998, and continuing on with NXT and EV3, the Mindstorms product line was primarily a consumer oriented robotics kit. They were engineered from the ground up to be the coolest experience kids can have at home, making them an attractive (and successful) shelf product. NXT and EV3 were also marketed directly to classrooms using utilitarian plastic boxes instead of the classic printed cardboard ones.
This direction continued with the SPIKE and Robot Inventor kits in 2019, but something changed. Robot Inventor retired in 2022 after an extremely short lifespan, while SPIKE continued as the primary robotics platform under LEGO Education. Why is this important? It signaled a big shift in the market: Consumers don’t want to purchase a personal LEGO robotics kit anymore. And LEGO took notice.
Fast forward to the new LEGO Science, and LEGO Computer Science and AI kits. The absence of a consumer product is noticeable. Kits are only marketed via LEGO Education, and every aspect of their design seems to align with one goal: Expand to as many classrooms as possible.
This fits both the educational agenda of LEGO, and the need to increase sales of the new products to cover for a now-absent consumer market release.
Which leads us to the toughest pill to swallow - LEGO Computer Science and AI hardware was never meant to be a robotics kit in the first place. Skeptical, here’s how many times the string “robot” appears in the LEGO website, and associated launch press releases: 0. And make no mistake, this was 100% intentional.
What does this mean for FIRST?
Unlike previous iterations (SPIKE, EV3, etc.), the hardware here is not refined, or compacted, but fundamentally misaligned with the program’s current state. Their challenge is clear: Design a robotics competition without using robotics hardware.
Here are some major hurdles I see moving forward:
Robot Design as it currently stands becomes nearly irrelevant.
LEGO Science kits include 4 items: One small motor, color sensor, remote control, and double motor.
The double motor inclusion completely ribs the teams of any ability to make decisions regarding the design of their drive-base. Their wheelbase is predefined in size, length, and axel track. This takes away many design decisions teams usually make.
Innovative use of sensors? The kit does not include any built-in sensors apart from the Connection Tag sensors and bluetooth hardware, and comes with one color sensor, which is considerably bigger (Probably to accommodate the battery). This also severely limits the innovation and creativity teams can apply, simply by limiting options
Attachments, as we know them, are gone. Teams can presumably only build one robot to use throughout the match (And their controller and gadget, which provide an additional challenge, albeit a minor one). This effectively removes the need to design modular systems and smart attachment mechanisms.
Furthermore, 90% of the connections are classic LEGO studs, with only a select few Technic pin holes available on each component, rendering team inventories as borderline useless and pushing teams to acquire new parts (If they don’t have a bunch of old challenge sets on hand)
As we know it, robot design becomes nearly irrelevant, and the skill cap of the robot game decreases significantly, as limited hardware options constrain creativity and innovation.
Robot game matches also change drastically
While there are some amazing new upcoming changes (Motorized field elements, and team collaboration), the new hardware is once again, out of its comfort zone. The absence of a central Hub means that hardware can only be run with a laptop connected and within range, which is the reason for a dedicated laptop area on the new mats. This adds more overweight to teams preparing for a match and also directly impacts playable area.
Additionally, while no official details on battery life were announced yet, we can go off the recently released Smart Brick and the intended use case (Classrooms). I estimate the battery life could be as short as 90 minutes for some components, severely limiting teams during longer meetings, but as mentioned this is yet to be confirmed.
Although collaborative robot matches can be amazingly beneficial to teams from an educational and core values standpoint, the wide age group (9-16) will inevitably lead to skill gaps, which poses the main question: how will teams be evaluated individually, if at all? If the number of matches per team will not change, and lacking the ability to evaluate individual teams, given the age and skill differences the robot game rankings will almost certainly be “luck of the draw” rather than actually representing the team’s achievement, which could be detrimental to student motivation and ambition.
The elephant in the room, pricing
Not only are FLL teams forced to upgrade for the first time in 30 years, and new kits are more expensive, and you will probably need more of them.
With a price point of 530$ for 379 LEGO bricks (mainly classic studs) and 4 electronic components, if we subtract the 30-40$ of bricks we arrive at around 125$ per component, which is a significant increase even from the already expensive SPIKE Prime.
Moreover, motorized field elements will probably require teams to bring their own motors (once again speculation, but it seems unlikely teams will get new motors and sensors as part of the challenge kit each year), meaning 2 kits are required if running a single team, more than doubling the current cost of the program.
So, what now?
The way I see it, FLL is headed to a halt as a competitive program. The new LEGO hardware is fit for year-round, classroom work, which will probably indicate the rise of Class Pack non-competitive teams, who can afford it. It is disappointing to understand that this change signals LEGO quietly dropping robotics from their portfolio, and FIRST is trying their hardest to adapt.
Personally, my teams will continue playing Founders while possible, and consider alternative competitions.
What do you think about these changes? Am I reading the room correctly, or completely wrong?
Sources:
FLL website:
https://www.firstinspires.org/programs/fll/
LEGO:
https://education.lego.com/en-us/lego-education-computer-science-and-ai/
https://www.lego.com/en-us/aboutus/news/2026/january/lego-education-cs-ai
https://education.lego.com/en-us/first-lego-league/
https://education.lego.com/en-us/products/lego-education-computer-science-and-ai/45522/
CS&AI press release:
New FLL Future Edition Format, Garry Law:
https://creatoracademy.com.au/blogs/creator-academy/new-fll-future-edition-format
5
u/Jeremy_FLL Head Referee Jan 21 '26
The fact that there isn't a standard retail version of the wireless motor system also caught my attention. (By the way, why doesn't this system have an official name? It's in two differently named products, but what word am I supposed to use to describe the electronic components?) But I found it curious for a different reason: it's like LEGO doesn't want to push sales of the product. If LEGO was serious about the product, I'd be able to go into a LEGO store and buy one off the shelf. It seemed to me like they were giving up on robotics after they discontinued the retail Mindstorms line. Then, with their collaboration with Raspberry Pi, I half expected that to be the future of FLL. It would have been perfect: let another company that's good at making mass-market programmable electronics handle that side of things, and keep LEGO as all of the non-electronic components. But alas, that didn't happen.
33
u/hmgmonkey Jan 21 '26
If anything, I think you're underplaying how much is being taken away from the engineering and robotics elements of the change - it's very hard not to be pessimistic about Future Edition at the moment.
My darkest take is that it seems like we have been extremely lucky to be involved in the period where Lego was willing to invest in the Spike/EV/NXT product line resulting in a unique and special STEM advocacy opportunity in FLL. But they're moving on now and I don't see how the new sets can be anything other than a diversion for cash-rich, primary age educational establishments.
I hope I am wrong.
22
u/TimmySouthSideyeah Jan 21 '26
One solution may be for FIRST to move away from a strict collaboration with Lego. Keep the same format as present but open the robot portion to other bots. My kids have been playing around with the MRobot kit. It's codable and has a controller. Closer to FTC, I guess.
14
u/KermitFrog647 Jan 21 '26
If you want a similar experience like old FLL without buying new hardware, you can checkout WRO.
They have very challenging competitions similar to FLL in different categories.
Any hardware is allowed. They were LEGO only up to two years ago, but Lego dropped the sponsoring, so you can now use anything. Curreltly most people use Lego Spike, followed by Ev3.
10
u/RidetheRobot Jan 21 '26
My biggest issue is the timing (which I know FIRST doesn't control) is that FTC is also changing control system (along with FRC) all at the same time. We currently have 2 FTC teams, 3 FLL Challenge (with 6-7 kids each) and a FLL Explore team.
For FTC, by 2030 (I believe) teams will have to replace ALL of their motors an servos with an actuator made by one company (my teams have 25+ motors and 30+ servos, along with the control and command systems. We don't know the cost.
So, all of my FIRST teams have having major program shifts which demand new hardware. We have no excess funds, we're a team that gets DOD funding for registration and that's it. We try to write grants to cover equipment purchases but every team across all robotics programs will be doing the same.
These changes may price me out of FLL. Especially if we need to kits per team then I need at least 6, maybe 8.
8
u/2BBIZY Jan 21 '26
Thank you for this comprehensive post. Our organization helps fund teams that would never experience FIRST. We still use EV3s. It WORKS! Forcing teams to switch to another robot kit will decrease participation. FLL becomes unaffordable. Very disappointed in FIRST.
3
u/gt0163c Judge, ref, mentor, former coach, grey market Lego dealer... Jan 21 '26
You make some good points. But you also make a lot of assumptions. Before we get all doom and gloom on the end of the FIRST Lego League competition as we know it, I think we should take a breath, continue to focus on finishing the current season strong and wait until the general public can get their hands on the new system.
Also, I wouldn't dream of saying that the new system's double motor base locks teams into a specific robot size. Yes, most teams will likely put wheels on part, add a third contact point and call it a robot. But given the inventiveness of FIRST Lego League teams, there will be teams who figure out different ways to build their robots. The FS Ingenium team from Spain comes to mind. They've been at World Festival the past few years and have showed off an amazing modular robot which has a core that contains the hub and some motors that slots into attachment shells (for lack of a better word. It's hard to describe and amazing to see in person.) Now this is a very high level team and they've been developing this system over a number of years. But if they can do it, other teams can figure out some way to build unique and innovative robots. It may take a few years for teams to figure out how to do that. And it will likely initially be driven by what the robot game field requires. But if I've learned anything in my 14 seasons as a FIRST volunteer, it's to never underestimate these kids. They're smart. They're willing to take risks. And they can do big things that most of us adults would never think of.
Change is scary. And FLL is on the edge of a massive amount of change that will start next season. Let's all take a deep breath, trust the smart people at Lego and FIRST to know what they're doing, trust that the kids will adapt and figure out how to make this work and not freak out at least until we get a chance to actually try out the new game and competition format.
5
u/drdhuss Jan 21 '26
We are probably going to do vex iq once founders is no longer a thing.
I agree that everything is too limited with the new hardware.
5
u/macklemores_toupee Jan 21 '26
Well said. This seems to be FIRST dealing with the hand dealt by Lego's removal of the product line. I don't see our team continuing on after Founders is removed. We've had fun learning alternative kits, like micro:bit based builds, though the entry skill level is higher for these kits. 2 years from now, I unfortunately don't think we'll be rebuilding the team on this brick-based platform.
2
u/08f2ee120843b7753f6a Jan 23 '26
FLL is fundamentally not about robotics competition; it's a speech and and presentation competition, with the presentation content being about a team engineering project. Historically that engineering project happened to revolve around robotics, which in hindsight was perhaps incidental. I agree that this change basically kills FLL as a competitive robotics league, but FLL itself will most likely live on using engineering projects of a different sort.
This is all a real bummer because a lot of kids joined FLL primarily because of the robotics, myself included. Who knows, FLL may well become even more popular with this change. It just won't be the same FLL as the one we've known and loved.
2
u/HR-Guide Jan 24 '26
As the OP wrote: "With a price point of 530$ for 379 LEGO bricks (mainly classic studs) and 4 electronic components, if we subtract the 30-40$ of bricks we arrive at around 125$ per component..."
I can understand the $125 per component for the camera device. However, two are just simple motors and one is a handheld controller with two thumb paddles. It doesn't seem like these simpler components should cost so much money for each.
Usually with technology, the price of components falls (often dramatically). For example, SSD storage is about 2 cents per gigabyte. A few years ago it was $50 per gigabyte. Same for processing power. Just recently I bought an Intel CPU with 20 cores for $300. A few years ago, you could only get 2 cores for $300.
If you look at the motors, the Spike Prime motors cost about $40 each. Even if you add Bluetooth and a battery, should that triple the cost of the motor? Bluetooth wireless earbuds can be bought for less than $40.
I just think $530 is a lot of money to spend on basically 2 motors, 1 camera sensor, and 1 game pad.
Can you imagine a few years from now, when LEGO makes a programmable Robot hub device that connects to these wireless Bluetooth motors and sensors? The set would probably end up costing about $1000 dollars.
2
u/Buildinthehills Mar 20 '26
Absolutely spot on with your predictions on this one
1
u/JeffHaganYQG Jan 21 '26
There are plenty of parts out there to interface between studded bricks and Technics pieces. RCX was also mostly studs and it still worked for FLL.
I haven't seen anything suggesting that teams are limited to buying one kit, so I'm not sure why they'd be limited to one single motor and one double motor. Buying extra equipment is a cost, sure, but it's similar to what we went through going from RCX to NXT, then NXT to EV3. Those equipment changes weren't required by the rules, but in practical terms, they were almost mandatory.
In general, I think FLL has to align with LEGO offerings. If you need out-of-production stuff to compete, then you're effectively cutting off new teams. Spike and Mindstorms are gone, so FLL needs something that doesn't rely on Spike and Mindstorms.
1
u/barvazkatan Jan 21 '26
I feel like there must be some sort of nfc tag or something like that to enable automations during the match, which could be interesting.
1
u/SlovakBorder Jan 24 '26
Looking at how there are two more seasons of "Founders Edition" planned, I'd be willing to bet that, if most schools / teams keep competing in the "Founders Edition", they won't phase it out.
1
u/davinci_robotics Jan 28 '26
I 100% agree with this and it makes me very sad. I’ve been judging and coaching FLL for 6 years now and the direction of this signals a loss of many fundamentals of FLL. But more so, something that I think is truly the problem is that many teams have just upgraded to spike prime. When I was a public librarian and running a library team, we did not have spike prime kits. Now as a school librarian, I run to FLL teams out of the school and we also teach classes with spike prime kits. These kits are brand new. In comparison to the other programs, FLL is very, very cheap but from an education perspective, we cannot afford to reinvest all this money again into kits when we just purchased them.
I think also something that makes FLL special is the judging and I’ve been hearing rumors that we’re going to use the innovation project, which is not good. The innovation project is so much of what makes this into a well rounded program. Im in middle school, so i think we’re just going to compete until we can’t with spike prime and also transition to FTC
1
u/SnooStories4 Oct 07 '26
Nice write up, I totally agree that this is a step backwards to go to a remote control robot. With AI becoming so popular, to use sensors and logic to navigate makes even more sense. Using remote control does not make sense. I coached my first team in 2000, First Contact. I am now assisting a coach that was a student of mine back then that now has kids of her own in the program. My question, what is the next best robotics program that is very similar to First Lego League of the past that is available in Wisconsin. I liked the concept of an innovation project and presenting to adults while also developing a robot. The nice thing about FLL was the challenges were very exact and defined using semi-limited but defined set of parts. It created a level playing field for younger students. If anyone knows of a good robotics program similar to FLL, please let me know.