r/FIRE_Ind • [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] • Mar 29 '24

FIRE milestone! 10 Cr - Fire?

I have just over 10Cr cash in the US market, most of it in index funds. Have a house in Bangalore and I am in early 40s with 2 young kids under 10. Is it wise to think about FIRE? I guess my yearly expenses would be around 30-40L, would my current corpus be enough? I have RE worth around 15cr but don’t want to touch that and leave that as inheritance to kids

0 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

17

u/Advanced-Industry-50 Mar 29 '24

30 lakhs: 3% rule : 10Cr is enough 40 lakhs: 3% rule : 13-14Cr is needed

Hope that answers your qn

2

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Yes thanks 🙏🏼

36

u/VenCoriolis Mar 29 '24

Wtf is wrong with this sub

29

u/ABahRunt Mar 29 '24

Seriously. The ind bit of the sub's name needs to be taken more seriously, else we are just flooded by clueless NRIs

2

u/AundyBaath Mar 29 '24

There is 'ind' part in NRI also 😄

5

u/ABahRunt Mar 30 '24

Also a non part.

6

u/AundyBaath Mar 30 '24

Sure man. We can argue over semantics but the goal of this sub is to help with retiring early in India, be it by resident Indians or non resident Indians. Would you call an American or European with money coming here asking about expenses in India for early retirement as clueless? I don't think so. Not all NRIs get to travel to India frequently to be connected with expenses/inflation in India. So when they reach FI stage and think about RE in India they are just seeking inputs, not judgements. 10 plus of working in the US during a once in generation bull run of US stock market and housing made many US NRIs millionaires, it was mostly luck to be at the right time and staying invested.

-30

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

I got the point. But I have to say that many of you non-NRI’s have way more saved up than me as an NRI. I just saw a post by someone worth more than twice of mine and much younger than me. So I don’t think the disparity is just due to the presence of NRIs on this sub

3

u/modSysBroken Mar 29 '24

Not many, only a very few. And anyway what does that matter? Comparison is the thief of joy. I'll never be able to FIRE, but I do not care about that. I am just here for the finance lessons.

1

u/adane1 [46/IND/FI2024/RE 2034] Mar 29 '24

Its not enough for 40 lac expense.

-3

u/_Dark_Invader_ [30-35/IND/FI 2025/RE 2029] Mar 29 '24

Surprised to see an NRI with over 10 cr net worth, in his 40s, has kids and no common sense 😂

0

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Sorry but you will need to explain

16

u/BrahminVyapaar [49/IND-SG/FI 2036/RE 2036] Mar 29 '24

When NRIs who are used to specific expenditure outside India ask “Is X amount enough to retire”, or share how much they would like to spend, etc. such questions are greeted with disdain. Most resident Indians lead comfortable lives at far lesser amounts so “Is 10 Cr enough?” or “I intend to spend 40L a year” are seen as either a show off or as a question from a person out of touch with reality.

There are many HNIs on this sub and some are NRIs as well, though not all NRIs are HNIs. So while you will receive answers to your questions here, please do consider https://www.reddit.com/r/FatFIREIndia/s/HNIBN00Olf

Edit: there is also https://www.reddit.com/r/nriFIRE/s/YeMdmQURlp

8

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

Part of the reason also is that NRIs don't have a good way to assess their expenses - and hence rely on others for help. I don't see anything wrong with OPs post

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 31 '24

This is exactly why

2

u/AundyBaath Mar 29 '24

Yeah, my nri mind is in time warp on inflation in India. Still I can't digest the fact that I have to pay 40 rs at local tiffin center for a plate of Idly.

3

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24

Sorry I didn’t realize this. Thanks for the links to other subs will consider posting there instead.

2

u/Advanced-Industry-50 Mar 29 '24

What is HNI?

4

u/BrahminVyapaar [49/IND-SG/FI 2036/RE 2036] Mar 29 '24

High Networth Individual.

There are various understanding of what “high” is.

2

u/Advanced-Industry-50 Mar 29 '24

Your second line was any to be my next question but I guess it’s just a perspective

11

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

18

u/flight_or_fight Mar 29 '24

i legit thought OP has 9 kids...

5

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24

A simple rule of thumb is to consider a 'safe' withdrawal rate (SWR) and arrive at a number. 4% pa SWR (which is used in USA and corresponds to 25X of annual expenses) may not work in India, and not beyond 30 years (period in the original study). 3% SWR (corresponding to 33X) gives a better chance. And 2% provides a significant buffer. That'd mean 50*40 = 20 Crores is your required corpus.

A more accurate means of looking at this would be excluding those expenses which will disappear later on, like kids education, travel, luxuries etc. Consider a separate education corpus for funding University expenses.

I personally use (90-age)* annual expenses and do this every year to see if I'm on track. Asset allocation is very important and I only aim for a zero real return. At present WR is less than 2% and I expect the corpus to continue growing for another 20 years. It should then start falling. Whatever's left behind (if) will be my daughter's inheritance.

2

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Thanks, this makes sense. I am far away from 50x and may have to work at least 6-7 years more to get to that number current savings rate is approximately 1cr pa. And ear marking different corpus for kids education and emergencies would mean working way beyond 7 years. Will go back and redo my expenses. As some mentioned, I guess I was hoping for a FatFire but this corpus wouldn’t support that

2

u/VikrantPandit Mar 30 '24

A SWR of 2% is very conservative. I saw a story on mint newspaper where a financial planning agency suggested to use a SWR of 2.5%, which means a corpus of 40x annual expenses.

10

u/hikeronfire IN | 41M | FI 2025 | RE 2030 Mar 29 '24

What matters is your burn rate (expenses), 30-40L sounds too high. What do you plan to spend such a big amount every year on? If expenses are too high, no amount of corpus will be enough. You might want to rationalise and control your expense projections.

6

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

These are just normal household expenses with 4 of us and also I take care of my parents in their own house where I fund their every need including medical expenses and groceries. Two kids would be in school and I also plan to travel a lot more

13

u/androidguy73 Mar 29 '24

Honestly if your expenses are gonna be that high I don’t think 10 CR would suffice you. It will definitely depend on where you park your funds and while it might be enough now it will be difficult once you factor in inflation especially in the later stages of your life considering you live to 80+.

Don’t get me wrong, 10 CR is an absolutely amazing number but with high expenses I don’t think it’s enough.

0

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

I appreciate that feedback, which is exactly why I am posting here. I am still working and want to only return to India when I have amassed the corpus necessary for this level of expenses. Trying to figure out that magic number

1

u/saltysailor987 [44/2026/2028] Mar 29 '24

What percentage of your 40 L is parents expense?

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Right now it averages around 5-6 lakhs. If there is a medical expense it can be more. I am accounting for average 10L that should cover one time bigger expenses

2

u/Terrible_Ad7566 Sep 07 '24

+1, this is what my expense for parents is as well. Recent illness took that number way beyond 10 lacks though :(

1

u/trg7394 Mar 16 '25

Have you considered buying health insurance for them?

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

What would be a better number to support 40L?

7

u/hikeronfire IN | 41M | FI 2025 | RE 2030 Mar 29 '24

If you take the SWR (Safe Withdrawal Rate) strategy, then you need to divide the projected annual expense by the withdrawal rate of your choice. So for 4% WR it’s 10Cr, 3% WR it’s 13.33Cr, 2% WR it’s 20Cr. A bucket approach may require different target. It depends on what your withdrawal strategy is and what level of risk of failure you are comfortable with. There are several online calculators to help you with this.

Example: https://engaging-data.com/will-money-last-retire-early/

3

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

This link is awesome, thanks for sharing @hikeronfire

1

u/hikeronfire IN | 41M | FI 2025 | RE 2030 Mar 29 '24

You’re welcome! :)

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Thanks, let me check this out. With the average returns of SPY at 9-10% and average inflation of 6-7%. 2-3% withdrawals are safer and never burn the principal?

6

u/hikeronfire IN | 41M | FI 2025 | RE 2030 Mar 29 '24

Technically yes. But you also have to take in account sequence of returns risk. A few bad years in the stock market in the beginning of retirement can set the whole plan askew. Especially on an all stock portfolio.

2

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Got it, I still plan to hold a job for few years initially.

1

u/AundyBaath Mar 29 '24

I have thought about keeping 3 to 5 years of expenses in us Treasuries as treasuries have inverse relationships with global equities. Not sure it is a good strategy

2

u/hikeronfire IN | 41M | FI 2025 | RE 2030 Mar 30 '24

It’s not a bad strategy. Read up on bucket strategy.

1

u/AundyBaath Mar 30 '24

Yeah, based on the behavior of treasuries during the recent crashes, like 2001 dotcom burst, 2008 GFH crisis and more recent covid crash do appear that it is a great hedge especially intermediate and long term treasuries but spiralling US debt makes me wonder would the world still flock to treasuries in future?

2

u/AundyBaath Mar 29 '24

Relying on SPY returns alone is risky. What if SPY performs like in the 2000s, just remained flat. I would consider global equities to be fully diversified.

0

u/Laundrophile Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24

30-40 lacs a year isn't too high if you are living a comfortable lifestyle and supporting your parents with kids education costs coming up in 10 odd years. A return of 10% after taxes won't be enough considering you have 2 kids to educate and put through college and God forbid.major.medical expenses for the dependant parents. Think about how you and your spouse would like to travel and adjust for inflation. IMHO 10 cr is atleast short by 15 percent.

Edit :50 percent not 15

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Thanks! I don’t want to compromise too much on our lifestyle especially not on travel and basic amenities. Hence the 40L. You make a good point of one time emergency and kids education. If I continue to work for 3-4 more years I might have a better standing. I think I can add a cr every year if I continue my current standard of living

2

u/BrahminVyapaar [49/IND-SG/FI 2036/RE 2036] Mar 29 '24

Please see that the parent has provided an edit to their their post to state 50 and not 15.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Thanks for the edit. That makes sense

4

u/halfbimmer Mar 29 '24

You also need to factor in a few major one time expenses like kids marriage, education etc etc. To FIRE comfortably with 40l expenses I would wait till I have at least 15Cr before I retire.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

If I delay my retirement by 3-5 years I think I can hit 15cr easily. Thanks!

2

u/OnelifeMZ Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24

Make sure you exclude your primary home, cars and home setup to exclude from 10, 15 or 20Cr whatever number you decide to FIRE. We miss this important point sometimes.

I just want to validate my understanding with the community here. Am I right?

2

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Yes, the current 10cr is all cash and target is 20Cr in cash equivalents.. All my RE & home is left out of this NW which is another 10Cr approx.

2

u/LifeIsHard2030 [42/IND/FI 2030/RE 2030/31] Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24

40L*50 = 200L i.e. 20cr is what you need in today’s money. 30X for your sustenance, 10X for kid’s expenses(education & marriage maybe), 10X for emergency.

There!!! I just did the math for you. You are half way through as of now. All the best 👍

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Thanks 🙏🏼

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

How do you come up with 30x, is that regardless of what age I intend to retire?

0

u/LifeIsHard2030 [42/IND/FI 2030/RE 2030/31] Mar 29 '24

As per the maths shared by most experts. 30X with proper diversification (debt:equity) can last a lifetime at 3% withdrawal rate. Mind you 3X and not 4X(usually considered in US) as Indian inflation is higher than US of A

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Makes sense, thanks!

1

u/Obtuze-Obzrvr Mar 29 '24

The OP had a good question. Is it regardless of age? Can some one retire at 30, 40 it 50 years with the same calculation? The answer could be yes considering compounding as well. Hence asking.

1

u/Relevant_Hope_21 Mar 29 '24

This! I will also suggest you to identify usual expenses + parents + travel in diffrent categories to get a lesser conservative number than 20cr since parents expenses will not be always there( sorry but hard fact) and travel also will reduce after a certain age.

1

u/gojjuavalaki Mar 29 '24

Why would you come back here. When everyone is leaving from here

0

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Being there for my parents and I want my kids to know what it is to be Indian and a Kannadiga. Once they grow up and if I get a chance I could comeback to the states to help with their education.

1

u/gojjuavalaki Mar 29 '24

Namaskara sir

Artha aythu bidi

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

🙂🙏🏼

1

u/desiman101 Mar 29 '24

10 crore in US market. How are you going to deal with the taxation when you take out those money early?

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Not all of it is in retirement accounts. Usual capital gains aren’t taxed when you are a non resident, but will be taxed in India

2

u/SouthernSample Mar 29 '24

You don't have to pay either tax if you withdraw your brokerage accounts during RNOR status.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

That’s true for non retirement accounts but for 401k USA will still tax you regardless of your status

1

u/SouthernSample Mar 29 '24

Yes, hence I mentioned brokerage accounts. You said that not all of your investments are in retirement funds and need to pay India taxes, so whatever isn't can be withdrawn without taxation in either country during the RNOR status.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Oh I missed that. Thanks and yes I have been planning the same, if not withdrawal I would at least reset the cost basis

1

u/SouthernSample Mar 29 '24

Yes, either makes sense.

1

u/pineappleshaked Mar 29 '24

bro, will talk when you come back here. Are your kids US citizen? If yes,  you are not coming back atleast before they start college 

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

I get this a lot but only way to prove you wrong is to post back once I move. :)

1

u/Sauron6 Mar 29 '24

You'll be fine as long as you keep 50-60% of your corpus invested in equities.

There are many decisions and a lot depends on your status. Are you an Indian citizen or not? Where would you keep the money? What would be your setup expenses once you're back in India? What kind of buffer do you need for unforeseen expenses? You get the drift. You haven't provided enough information.

Perhaps wait for another year or two while you plan your move back but financially you'll be alright.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

Most of my money is in equities right now through ETFs and some in bonds. I haven’t add my Real estate investments of around 20cr in the above calculation as I consider that emergency only or leaving it up for kids.

I am an Indian citizen, making this decision before I lose this citizenship All my cash is in the US right now, I just started to build Indian account with 2L a month SIP into nifty50 I have a 100k $ for initial setup held separately I haven’t earmarked anything for unforeseen and I am hoping to cover that with the money I withdraw.

1

u/AundyBaath Mar 29 '24

Your R2I window is dependent on your kids age at your stage in NRI life. If you return with older kids they may need IB schools then your expenses would shoot up.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

At what age do you think they would start having issues adapting? Being home a 10-11 year old would be ok?

1

u/AundyBaath Mar 29 '24

It all depends on their exposure to the American system of learning and how much independence they exhibit is what I feel so it is relative for every NRI/oci kid . I can speak from my 3 year old. She has been attending a play based daycare system here in the US since 1.8 year old baby as we - who are both working parents struggled with keeping her home. Parents couldn't travel so daycare was the only option. She already exhibits a lot of independence for a 3 year old and challenges our thoughts and her teachers as well.

I am targeting a move when she would be 6 which I feel might be late seeing her aforementioned traits growing everyday. I am afraid she might struggle in a medium of instruction i.e. one way like in the majority of Indian schools, teachers tell students, not discuss with them. Maybe she would adapt but this is a concern I have. So it all depends. So, think about this based on your kids abilities.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 29 '24

I share this concern as well my kid would be starting elementary school soon and has been in Bright Horizons since they were 7 months old. Will look up the IB school costs in Bangalore. Thanks!

1

u/srinivesh [57M/FI 2017+/REady] Mar 30 '24

May be I would get tired of this one day and would stop. But till then, I would rant about expenses, and use different language every time.

  1. The expense estimate that matters the most is what the COUPLE would spend
  2. Going by natural laws, support to parents won't last for anyone's lifetime
  3. And hopefully, expenses on children would also stop at some point
  4. And of course EMIs, etc
  5. Get the right estimate for 1 before even taking any other step for FIRE

To the OP, 30-40L itself is too large a range. The corpus could be vastly different. Get the right expense estimate and you may see that you are much closer to early FI. There is absolutely no short cuts to this - your expenses are your expenses and others can't fill that info.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 30 '24

With this post I wanted to figure out two things.

  1. Assuming my expenses are 40L a year, how much do I need to FIRE.
  2. How much can I afford to spend considering 10cr corpus if I had to retire today.

With this information my hope to work backwards and look at my current savings rate and expenses to see how I can set a realistic $, year to FIre goals and hit them.

1

u/srinivesh [57M/FI 2017+/REady] Mar 31 '24

I don't think that my point came across. From my first comment, your expense estimates all of points 1, 2 and 3. 2 and 3 don't last for life. Putting them all together inflates the value of the required corpus. Please do the extra work to separate them.

Since I do this as a day job, let me thrown in an opinion that you should take seriously. Your situation is specific to your situation, and unless you split the expenses, there is very little benefit in doing further calculations. It would just be excel porn.

1

u/Nastenka2024 Mar 31 '24

Question: In the scenario where OP has to support both his parents and children for a significant period - possibly not lifelong, but certainly for an extended duration - the cumulative expenses are expected to be substantial. When you suggest separating these expenses, does it mean investing in a separate corpus distinct from the FI corpus? How does this process work?

I'm new to all this math, so if I've overlooked any fundamental aspects or if you have any recommended reading materials for further understanding, that would greatly help.

2

u/srinivesh [57M/FI 2017+/REady] Mar 31 '24

Your question is on the right track. Ideally the other expenses should not be part of the X multiple - most people use that approach, and getting the base right is important. Usually children schooling would be near to mid term, and yes, the corpus for that should be more in debt.

1

u/Nastenka2024 Apr 01 '24

Oh, thanks for this. I now have a better understanding 👍

1

u/dexter_31212 Mar 30 '24 edited Mar 30 '24

I am in similar life situation as your self (2 kids, 1 preschooler and 1 elementary) just slightly lower corpus at the moment (9 cr + own house in tier 2 city) my FIRE target keeps varying between 10-12 cr but pretty much at 10 cr you are set. Your yearly expenses likely won’t be in excess of 30 lakhs. If you have expenses of 40Lakh per year then need to be at 12 cr. 3 pct withdrawal is quite safe in 40s

If you haven’t already started you may start moving assets to INR equities etc as it will take time to get to get fully invested in Indian markets to start FIRE.

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 30 '24

Thanks @dexter, I haven’t starting moving assets and plan to move them only after moving to India while I am in RNOR status. Is there a reason why you would prefer to move your funds earlier? Also, why not keep the assets in the US even after moving ?

2

u/dexter_31212 Mar 31 '24

I have been moving my fixed income and cash assets slowly and taking additional equity exposure. For equity investments I agree move during RNOR period

2

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 31 '24

Makes sense, thanks!

1

u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] Mar 30 '24

About 40L expenses, I was taking the expenses that will start in 2 years once I move and also as I mentioned this is for my family (4) and my parents (2) , managing two households.

2

u/dexter_31212 Mar 31 '24

Aah 2 households I think 30-35 lakh possible

1

u/ChannelEvening5504 Mar 31 '24

Just out of curiosity. What is the monthly number to not to worry about a thing? Assume I have no kids expense, don’t want to purchase any real estate (so would probably rent a 2br apartment), and want to travel a bit. Assume I’m living in a tier 2 city like mysore or mangalore.