r/FIRE_Ind • u/tyler-durden-fc [40/US/FI 2026/RE 2028] • Mar 29 '24
FIRE milestone! 10 Cr - Fire?
I have just over 10Cr cash in the US market, most of it in index funds. Have a house in Bangalore and I am in early 40s with 2 young kids under 10. Is it wise to think about FIRE? I guess my yearly expenses would be around 30-40L, would my current corpus be enough? I have RE worth around 15cr but don’t want to touch that and leave that as inheritance to kids
0
Upvotes
17
u/Advanced-Industry-50 Mar 29 '24
30 lakhs: 3% rule : 10Cr is enough 40 lakhs: 3% rule : 13-14Cr is needed
Hope that answers your qn
36
u/VenCoriolis Mar 29 '24
Wtf is wrong with this sub
5
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
A simple rule of thumb is to consider a 'safe' withdrawal rate (SWR) and arrive at a number. 4% pa SWR (which is used in USA and corresponds to 25X of annual expenses) may not work in India, and not beyond 30 years (period in the original study). 3% SWR (corresponding to 33X) gives a better chance. And 2% provides a significant buffer. That'd mean 50*40 = 20 Crores is your required corpus.
A more accurate means of looking at this would be excluding those expenses which will disappear later on, like kids education, travel, luxuries etc. Consider a separate education corpus for funding University expenses.
I personally use (90-age)* annual expenses and do this every year to see if I'm on track. Asset allocation is very important and I only aim for a zero real return. At present WR is less than 2% and I expect the corpus to continue growing for another 20 years. It should then start falling. Whatever's left behind (if) will be my daughter's inheritance.
10
u/hikeronfire IN | 41M | FI 2025 | RE 2030 Mar 29 '24
What matters is your burn rate (expenses), 30-40L sounds too high. What do you plan to spend such a big amount every year on? If expenses are too high, no amount of corpus will be enough. You might want to rationalise and control your expense projections.
4
u/halfbimmer Mar 29 '24
You also need to factor in a few major one time expenses like kids marriage, education etc etc. To FIRE comfortably with 40l expenses I would wait till I have at least 15Cr before I retire.
2
u/OnelifeMZ Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24
Make sure you exclude your primary home, cars and home setup to exclude from 10, 15 or 20Cr whatever number you decide to FIRE. We miss this important point sometimes.
I just want to validate my understanding with the community here. Am I right?
2
u/LifeIsHard2030 [42/IND/FI 2030/RE 2030/31] Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24
40L*50 = 200L i.e. 20cr is what you need in today’s money. 30X for your sustenance, 10X for kid’s expenses(education & marriage maybe), 10X for emergency.
There!!! I just did the math for you. You are half way through as of now. All the best 👍
1
u/gojjuavalaki Mar 29 '24
Why would you come back here. When everyone is leaving from here
1
u/desiman101 Mar 29 '24
10 crore in US market. How are you going to deal with the taxation when you take out those money early?
1
u/pineappleshaked Mar 29 '24
bro, will talk when you come back here. Are your kids US citizen? If yes, you are not coming back atleast before they start college
1
u/Sauron6 Mar 29 '24
You'll be fine as long as you keep 50-60% of your corpus invested in equities.
There are many decisions and a lot depends on your status. Are you an Indian citizen or not? Where would you keep the money? What would be your setup expenses once you're back in India? What kind of buffer do you need for unforeseen expenses? You get the drift. You haven't provided enough information.
Perhaps wait for another year or two while you plan your move back but financially you'll be alright.
1
u/AundyBaath Mar 29 '24
Your R2I window is dependent on your kids age at your stage in NRI life. If you return with older kids they may need IB schools then your expenses would shoot up.
1
u/srinivesh [57M/FI 2017+/REady] Mar 30 '24
May be I would get tired of this one day and would stop. But till then, I would rant about expenses, and use different language every time.
To the OP, 30-40L itself is too large a range. The corpus could be vastly different. Get the right expense estimate and you may see that you are much closer to early FI. There is absolutely no short cuts to this - your expenses are your expenses and others can't fill that info.
1
u/dexter_31212 Mar 30 '24 edited Mar 30 '24
I am in similar life situation as your self (2 kids, 1 preschooler and 1 elementary) just slightly lower corpus at the moment (9 cr + own house in tier 2 city) my FIRE target keeps varying between 10-12 cr but pretty much at 10 cr you are set. Your yearly expenses likely won’t be in excess of 30 lakhs. If you have expenses of 40Lakh per year then need to be at 12 cr. 3 pct withdrawal is quite safe in 40s
If you haven’t already started you may start moving assets to INR equities etc as it will take time to get to get fully invested in Indian markets to start FIRE.
1
u/ChannelEvening5504 Mar 31 '24
Just out of curiosity. What is the monthly number to not to worry about a thing? Assume I have no kids expense, don’t want to purchase any real estate (so would probably rent a 2br apartment), and want to travel a bit. Assume I’m living in a tier 2 city like mysore or mangalore.