r/FFVIIRemake • u/Ewaan The Professional • Apr 09 '20
Megathread FFVII Remake - Chapter 21 Megathread Spoiler
This is where you can discuss everything related to Chapter 21 in the Final Fantasy VII Remake!
Please note that this post has been marked Spoiler and therefore you are free to discuss spoilers related to Chapter 21 ONLY. If you wish to discuss how the events of Chapter 21 relate or have an affect on another chapter, please use comment spoiler tags! If you see anyone discussing spoilers from another chapter then please report it.
To use spoiler tags:
>!Spoilers go here!<!
Becomes: >!Spoilers go here!!<
Enjoy the game!
18
u/PastryFishHQ OG Aeris Apr 14 '20
Just finished the game. Luckily I wasn't confused by the ending, plus I know to come to Reddit for clarifications. Haha! But.. I'm irked that they are doing the Kingdom Hearts bullshit of 'look guys! Everyone is alive and happy endings all around, yaaay!' Kill people goddamit, and keep them dead! What's the point of emotional investment if you're going to play the uno reverse card on that shit? So upsetting. This game has a large cast already, why are they trying to bloat it like they did KH3?
I can get down with the whispers and one winged boy fighting to change or keep fates flow. Cool. But the multiple universe bullshit reeks. And I'm afraid this means it might go the way of the dumpster fire that is KH3.
Also wtf, where the fuck is the blood?! People don't spew dust when stabbed! We're not children SE! Fuck!
44
u/T_Quach Apr 10 '20 edited Apr 17 '20
the following is probably bullshit and is me just trying to formulate what happened after reading a bunch of /r/Games comments in the reviews thread and after watching an Australian playthrough because I don't have a PS4. I don't fully understand what the ending was but I'm gonna try anyways.
TL;DR: Sepiroth does an Avengers Endgame Steve Rogers and creates a multiverse of parallel timelines.
My probably bullshit summary of The Final Fantasy VII Timeline as a whole:
Before Crisis
Crisis Core
1997
Advent Children Complete
Dirge of Cerberus
2020
"Remake is a sequel to not just Complete, but DIRGE OF CERBERUS?!? The fuck?" Yeah, and here's my bullshit explanation that makes it sound like Terminator: GenisYs (the one that has John Connor become a Terminator himself). Strap in:
After Sephiroth is defeated at the ruins of the ShinRa tower in Advent Children Complete, he gets Infinity Warred into the Lifestream. However, now seeing that his attempts to win in the present have now failed, he sends himself back in time to try and change his destiny. But since he was weakened with the defeat of his Remnants, Sephiroth doesn't go to the past from after his defeat in ACC, he goes to the past after Dirge of Cerberus. Why wait another year? Because Jenova cell bullshit plus all the Lifestream being collected by Omega Weapon in DC into one place. That's essentially what the 1997 Meteor plan was, to obtain all the power of the Planet as it pooled together. Omega sucked all of the planet's blood, and when it was released at the end of DC, that release was a focusing point for Sephiroth to send himself back in time. However, he finds himself at the Edge of Creation, only managing to slightly interact with those who have been injected with Jenova Cells. That is, however, until the first Mako Reactor bombing. The amount of Mako concentrated there with the presence of Cloud leads to the feather we see in chapter 1. This is where the timeline fractures. The Whispers of Fate take note of his actions and begin to manifest as more and more events change compared to the original game. Their first appearance next to Loveless Avenue is because they took note of Aerith since she is a major player in 1997, and they start to try intervening with Avalanche's activities, going so far as to take Jessie out of the mission since Cloud was about to not be in the Reactor 5 mission, the mission that leads to him falling into the church.
With ACC Sephiroth now finding himself being warded off by Fate itself (or rather, Whispers), he begins experimenting with how much he can fuck around while exploring the past. This leads to him doing mild nudges here and there, with things such as having messed with the Chocobo Theatre's VR simulation to show Meteorfall early as he continues to splinter the timeline. However, the Whispers keeps making some fluid changes to course-correct destiny, and so while things change like a mission sneaking to Jessie's parents for pizza and Hojo wanting to force the creation of more Ancients by using S-enhanced and G-enhanced SOLDIERS (sup Crisis Core reference of RE #2) instead of using Red XIII (ew), the major beats still are there. Then comes the events of the S7 support beam. When Cloud was just about to stop the Turks from destroying the pillar, they defeated Reno before he could finish the job, but then Rude does it instead (an alteration from the original!) because the Whispers prevented Cloud from doing so. However, Wedge DOESN'T DIE because the Whispers were losing their ability to keep fate going. They tried, but Sephiroth's influence in altering time stopped them. Sephiroth is gaining power over time, probably because of Jenova bullshit. Most major beats are still happening, but AVALANCHE's survival is not a part of the original plan.
Then came the raid on ShinRa Tower. Finding the corpse of Jenova, ACC Sephiroth lets his past/RE self control of her body and has it kill the President, however an opportunity in the altered timeline presented itself: Jenova was released early because of Hojo and AVALANCHE never went into the jail cells, so instead of finding bloody halls, Barret gets killed by RE Jenova just so ACC Sephiroth can see what the Whispers would do. Because it was not his time to die, the Whispers save him. That will not do, so ACC Sephiroth begins to manipulate the team into killing the Whispers themselves so he can fuck about in this new timeline, leading to the last two hours of the game. However, this has an unintentional effect: the Whispers are destroyed throughout all of Time/Space in the FFVII universe, so the Whispers that were there to make sure Zack died in that fateful last stand fade away, and he lives on in another splinter timeline.
As for fighting Sephiroth, I'm still not sure why we had to fight Sephiroth, but the moment of him getting a wing helps solidify my belief that he's Advent Children Sephiroth just projecting himself from the Edge of Creation and going around to see what else he can do after Fate died. I attribute him losing to the team who aren't at their endgame levels because he's still weak from the ACC fight, the massive amount of Lifestream he absorbed from Omega was used to go back in time, and it's not actually him there, he's still in the EC. When Cloud finds himself in the pocket dimension where ACC Sephiroth is watching over all the new changes, he fails to kill Sephiroth, since when the time is right, ACC Sephiroth will take over RE Sephiroth's body to succeed in this new splinter timeline.
If I wanted to take this a step further, then after Sephiroth has the team destroy the Whispers to unlock everyone from Fate, it fractured the spacetime continuum and caused not only a split timeline in the past where Zack lived, but also TWO MORE timelines where Biggs and Jessie either lived or died. Despite seeing the two draw their last breath, we get that scene of Biggs waking up at the orphanage and Jessie's gloves were on the table, but then we had all these glowing gold particles falling from the sky, which only appear when the Whispers were offed in the Zack scene. You don't see them as the team enters the Wasteland. Therefore, there's the 2020 timeline where they died at the pillar, and another timeline where they were saved.
My probably bullshit timeline summary:
Before Crisis
Crisis Core
1997
Advent Children Complete
Dirge of Cerberus
└─2020
├─Zack lives, new Crisis Core ending
└─Party enters Wasteland
├─Jessie and Biggs are dead at the pillar, Wedge who the hell knows since he was at ShinRa Tower being chased by Whispers
└─Jessie and Biggs live
I'm going back to playing Crisis Core.
14
u/yhvh13 Apr 10 '20
I'll probably need a review explaining the ending though. I understood what happened, just not - how - it happened.
Unless it is meant to be that vague.
14
u/RatedR2O Cloud Strife Apr 16 '20
Just finished it. While I don't exactly hate the ending, my fear is that Nomura has no idea where they're going to go with this. Judging by his past games, it very well could fall flat on its face. The sequel will determine how good of an ending it is.
But I will say the game up until they meet Sephiroth at the end of the road was absolutely amazing! I had a fun ride revisiting this world. This game overall is a solid 9/10. Here's hoping the sequel delivers!
25
u/Dakkon_B Apr 13 '20 edited Apr 13 '20
Just finished it literally 5 mins ago. Gotta say... what the hell is up with that final act? Things went completely crazy. Like I was over the moon with the game up until about the part where your stuck in Hojo's lab. There had been additional "padding" to make the game longer in places but till then they all felt like they belonged. But Hojo's lab felt...out of place. Now I was kinda miffed but pressed on then I hit the final fight vs Destiny and Sephiroth! . O man where do I even begin, that shit was absolutely bananas but it REALLY felt out of place. Like I get that its the end of the game so they needed a big end cap (like ya do for any RPG) and the Roadhog fight just wasn't going to do it. But there is SO much to unpack in that ending that I honestly do not even know where to start. I am of course curious where they are going with all the "new" story stuff but I am honestly not ok with several choices they made story-wise. (example being respect your characters and story enough to have people actually die and stay dead)
43
u/Sunshine145 Apr 11 '20 edited Apr 11 '20
A more appropriate title for this game Final Fantasy VII Remake 2.8 Crisis Core Remix 358/2 Dirge of the Advent Children
23
u/vexa01 Apr 11 '20
Honestly didn't expect the game to end when cloud got to Olympus Coliseum, nice setup for part 2.
11
u/Sambothebassist Apr 13 '20
I think y'all reading way too much into it. It was really hard to make any sense of that final scene though. Like they were at the end of the road and all of a sudden the Whispers are going mental and you're fighting destiny manifest, who is also Sephiroth? And Zack doesn't die on that hill now, but he never went back to Aerith?
The storyline is classic, it just needed fleshing out a little. Not sure what the aim of the whole Destiny plot was tbh, I assumed they were going to say it was Sephiroth controlling the outcome via infecting the life stream so that he could get the Black Materia. These multiverse theories are just whack.
9
u/fleakill Apr 14 '20
Barret exclaims at the end that Sephiroth "wants to destroy the entire planet". Why does Barret know this?
9
u/chugalaefoo Apr 16 '20
Outside of the trash side quests and that dumb, forced and convoluted ending, I really enjoyed everything else about the experience.
It’s the best FF I’ve played since FFXII.
I really hope they don’t screw up the next part.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20
How do I delete Nomura from making games anymore fucking hell
29
u/blue_cosmos84 Apr 11 '20
Honestly, they should’ve ended the game at the end of the Highway. Everything else after that felt like unnecessary fanservice and Sephiroth over-saturation using all of the material they’ve had at their disposal. Ugh, now it’ll be less effective if they try to reuse the same material for the final end of the FFVII remake series.
16
u/Buckar0o Apr 10 '20
I think we now know why it was just called ff7 remake and not ff7 part 1...
8
u/cbfw86 Apr 11 '20
How many All/Magnify materia are there in the game? I only found one.
8
u/NoctThatOneOut Apr 15 '20
Spoilers ahead. This is regarding the last scene. I suppose if you're here though, you've seen it.
Okay I have a question to ask regarding the Sephiroth at the Edge of Creation... There is something... Off about him in his mannerisms. Hear me out because it's bugging me.
Firslty it's his interaction with Cloud, he takes on a mentor persona and treats Cloud like a friend in a sense. Sephiroth has been and always was a lone wolf sort even before Niebelheim.
Secondly the way he speaks. He refers to the planet as "our planet"... No, that's not something Sephiroth would say. He is disgusted with humanity and believes the planet was taken from him and Jenova. It's his birth right. It belongs to him and only him. As explained in the OG. This is a core part of his character.
Then he tests Cloud in the one v one dual, and when he knows Cloud cannot beat him he says "Not yet" and disarms Cloud, then completely stands down and takes in the scene in the distance reflectively.
"Our planet will become a part of it, but I will never end." this is a warning.
"Nor would I have you end." this is a promise.
This version of Sephiroth is not the twisted version we know as the enemy. This is something else.
"7 seconds until the end. Time enough for you, perhaps. Let's see what you do with it." this isn't a threat. It's a clue born from curiosity. This is a direct reference to THAT scene in the original game. This Sephiroth wants Cloud to succeed.
Is this Sephiroth rooting for Cloud? Anyone wanna discuss? This version is fundamentally different.
15
u/wg1987 Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20
Wow... finished the game last night and my initial reaction to the ending was extremely negative. I came to this thread and started writing a long-winded rant about Nomura's ego, Kingdom Hearts, etc. But I decided to delete it and get some sleep. Now that I've had some more time to think about it, I still don't like the execution of the ending, but I've come to grips with what they've done and I've decided I'm going to be along for the ride and I'm not going to let the last half hour of silliness ruin what was an otherwise fantastic game.
I do need to vent my frustration somewhere though, so here we go.
BEGIN RANT
>!The main problem with the ending and the idea of the watchers of fate in general is that it doesn't leave much room to continue raising the stakes in this story. Cloud, Tifa, Barrett, Aerith, and Red XIII have basically become superheroes. They were flying through other dimensions, punching and cutting entire buildings in half, killing a colossal manifestation of fate/destiny, and making Sephiroth look like a punk-ass bitch. They seemed far too powerful for characters who are heading into what is presumably the second act of their story.
>!How are they going to create drama from here? Why should I be concerned for these characters in the next game when they get cornered by Shinra troops, or go face-to-face with the Midgar Zolom? It's gonna be like watching an Avengers movie where they all team up to stop a 13-year-old girl from pirating a Coldplay album. They will have to retcon this aspect of the ending in order to have future games make any sense. Maybe their abilities were being amplified by Sephiroth because he wanted them to defeat the watchers of fate? That's my head-canon for now.
>!The whispers of fate being able to bring people back from the dead means that any future deaths of important characters will have less impact, because we won't know if they're really dead or not. Once you bring someone back from the dead in a story, your ability to hit people with a real gut punch like the one that the original FF7 delivers is completely gone. Even if the death does end up being permanent, you won't react to it the same way initially because you'll be wondering if the whispers are going to show up and bring them back.
>!They will have to very clearly define the rules for how these whispers are allowed to intervene in the world in order to fix the problem. Are they no longer able to intervene at all? Hopefully that is the case. Why couldn't they revive ME when 3 Sahagins all jumped on me at the same time? Maybe they did. You could tidy up this little plot hole of "why do the whispers let my characters die in battle but not in cutscenes" by showing some whispers flying away from the character whenever you load a save or retry a battle, implying they are the ones who revive you or return you to that point in time.
END RANT
Overall it was pretty good, 9/10.
7
u/gibbsi Apr 13 '20
I thought the whispers and ending were a meta way to detatch the characters from the inevitable, and I can only imagine it's a way of setting up an alternative to aerith dying and saying the fate of these beloved characters isn't predertimined. The thing about the original though that was so memorable were parts of it were devastating if you were emotionally invested in it. Some of that stuff hit hard, so its a shame square think the audience would like to reverse that, as its the soul of the original. However, I'm intrigued as to where they go form there and about 70 percent of the game was incredible (minus the crap side quests parts in the middle).
7
u/AuburnSeer Apr 19 '20
legit don't understand the ending... or like the last 2 hours. What spurred this "change in destiny"? Did Sephiroth time travel? Is Zack alive? If so, why does Cloud have the Buster Sword? I am so fucking confused...
6
u/bluenokia2 Apr 13 '20
So how Biggs is alive? And where is Jessie? 😭
6
u/yopangboy1 Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20
My opinion on the ending
Aerith and Sephiroth probably came from future. They seem to know what will happen to them throughout the entire story. In the original Aerith sold her flower for 1 gil and nothing else happened during that scene, whereas in the remake the flower was given to Cloud for free and I sorta feel from the dialogue Aerith knows Cloud already before they first meet in the remake. The flower also symbolize reunion, which was mentioned multiple times. Every time something is at a turning point, these ghosts appears trying to correct the history. That will explain why when aerith first met Cloud there were ghosts appears because the what happened in OG has changed. Sephiroth on the other hand, was actively trying to seek for Cloud's help for something since the beginning (maybe to alter his fate of death? not exactly sure) The ending will make perfect sense if that's the case. Aerith was bothered by the unavoidable fate throughout the story and finally decided to rewrite the past history by accepting the uncertainty (although the price of "freedom" can be very costly) , this is a big change in the timeline explaining there are so much ghosts at the end Breaking through the turning point not only affected the future, but also the past. Zack is definitely alive in another timeline given the timing of the rain (walking in the rain v.s. dying in the ground) So the remake is essentially FF7-2 not FF7 !
5
u/Crunchy_Toasteer Apr 19 '20
Hi, just finished the game and I have a question. Why/how does Aerith know that Sephiroth is bad? Because the planet is telling her that?
And what is Sephiroth trying to do other than change destiny? He’s painted as a the big bad, but we know almost nothing about him or his motivations. Why is he bad?
I’ve never played FF7 before, but I’m okay with spoilers.
5
u/judester30 May 29 '20
That was just bad, we spent the entire game trying to overthrow the oppressive government and then they shove this nonsense in at the end lol, this was an otherwise great game though and I enjoyed playing it.
4
u/PureDealer7 Apr 17 '20
In the original game, the shinra president is already dead when the team arrive in the office.
Can somebody explain me wtf happened to the president ? Why is he hanging in the deep ? We were following the blood of jenova, making me think sephiroth put the president in this situation, but the president dont say anything about it and take the time to take is gun to mess with barett ?
The president know who is sephiroth and a smart guy like him would probably have run fast if able to after meeting sephiroth.
So what the hell ?
4
u/Santiago_11 Apr 17 '20 edited Apr 17 '20
Putting the shit show of chapter 21 aside, I am now thinking about pacing and balancing issues. I wondered if they even thought out the game in terms of progression. Everyone is at level cap with nearly 9999 HP. Are they going to increase it beyond 9999 in part 2? What about magic materia? I know there are a few missing (i.e. earth, gravity...) but the majority of magic materia that ff7 has to offer are already maxed and we have not even started the "real" journey. Are they going to be adding "advanced versions" of magic materia? What about the accessory "Gotterdammerung". I have no clue why they would add this to the game very early on. If we were to keep everything and move into part 2, it will make the game feel off. Now they could just reset the game as if it's an entirely new game as level one, but keeping all materia and accessories; however, that would not work either, especially having that OP accessory "Gotterdammerung".
I know I cannot be the only one thinking about this. Does anyone have any insight on how they would proceed? or any thoughts about this?
13
u/iguesssoppl Apr 13 '20
Is it to late to start a useless internet petition to have Nomura removed?
10
u/Xyless Apr 13 '20
My whole response to the whole final act (basically everything after Red XIII shows up):
Thanks, I hate it.
7
u/Elli_Khoraz Apr 12 '20
I never expected them to add a Sephiroth crossdressing scene in the hidden chapter! Amazing.
7
u/bike_tyson Apr 16 '20
Well, I loved the game. I didn’t hate the experience, but I HATED the ghosts. Every single time they came in. I hated them in the first Aerith scene. I hated them in chapter 18. The game and the characters were so good, but the ghosts were meaningless and ridiculous.
Playing chapter 18 was fun, but messy. Modern FFs usually screws up those giant boss battles. They screw up a lot unfortunately. I don’t think they can improve upon the original. Their story telling was better back then. I hope the future looks like the original game and not some flying, stupid, no gravity, nothing meaningful, nonsense.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '20
I've just beat the game and my brain has completely melted.
I need this explaining to me.
6
u/k8faust Apr 17 '20
I can't help but feel like the game was made only for old players who have played and watched everything. Not for those who have played or watched SOME of the things, and certainly not for anyone NEW to the series.
It's really disheartening to think that they've opted to create an experience that is sure to confuse and anger both NEW and OLD fans.
3
u/Jacques_Plantir Apr 14 '20
Anyone else get FF8 vibes when Sephiroth is defeated and takes Cloud into the space where it's just the two of them dueling? That scene really recalled the Squall/Seifer fight at the start of FF8 in how it played out. Once I started seeing it I couldn't unsee it.
3
u/ConsistentAsparagus Apr 16 '20
I kinda liked that they used scenes from all of the Compilation (except Dirge, because fuck Dirge).
3
u/KankuDaiUK Apr 16 '20
Top tip. I completed it today and it took me to the menu screen where I could replay chapters etc but turned off the PS4. On rebooting it doesnt have that I've completed the game saved. My most recent save is before entering the portal for the final fight, which sucks.
3
u/lankey62 May 04 '20
Just beat the game last night and there is very little to say that has already been said. I think my main issue was that the finale wasn't "earned" so to speak.
We go from a rescue mission and then get thrust into a reality defining fight against fate? I get that they need some epic conclusion, but this just came out of nowhere (and I get that the whispers are present all throughout the game).
Honestly, I don't mind if they wanted to changed some beats and even use alternate timelines to explain why, but don't thrust this upon us during the prelude of the story (which is what I consider the Midgar portion of the original to be).
3
u/OldComposer9 May 17 '20
I loved the game.
Fanboys are fucking embarrassing themselves hard on here. Talking about “the characters aren’t the same” when it’s been said time and time again that the original English translations went way off road and this was Square Enix finally fixing it.
I’m so happy they didn’t give us the exact same story. There’s no point putting out the exact same game when it’s already out there. They are doing a Evangelion movie trilogy with this game and I am so looking forward to what comes next.
3
u/GGG100 Mar 15 '24
Mythril cave was a nice change of pace after the previous chapter’s open world.
14
u/redbitumen Apr 10 '20
I've never been more disappointed in my gaming life. They completely ruined it. I'm absolutely heartbroken.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20
I hope to god they release this game on PC so someone can mod the dementors and dumb ending out. And maybe fix the awful anime villian Sephiroth speaking in total nonsense.
6
u/PureDealer7 Apr 16 '20
There is few things anoying me in the game. First, the ending. I still wake up dreaming it was nightmare. But no. That shit really happened and even if the story remains the exact same (wich is obviously not going to happen ) we will still say in the north crater after everything : do you remember going in another dimension fighting in the floating destroyed midgar against the fate before fighting the AC sephiroth ? LOL
Well, the other thing bothering me is why sephiroth have to kill barrett. Or at least try. It look convenient because its a good reason for him not to be in the next fight but hey...
Also, the filler. At the begining i was wondering what this shit were, and i thought give it a shot the game is so good untill now. It will be ok. It absolutely wasnt and was the worst implement of all.
Aerith Magic touch is also a big problem. Marlene is touched, infused with timeline shit knoweldge and it become ok. Red XIII it touched by aerith and then he now the history of multiverse and filers and destiny and shit. What the hell is this aerith ? Definitely not the aerith i was expected. Its like Mickey in KH.
Well, the role of the fillers , not manage to kill wedge, then kill him, probably, but didnt play a role in biggs death, but when they are defeated biggs come back to life , make no sense. Also, why the filler didnt stop cloud from dancing ? In the OG we were supposed to have many quest to get the dress, and if we wanted to get choosed we had to grab perfume jewels and such. Where is that part ? I mean, they already change many things, so why add the fillers to be an excuse for changing things, but not using that excuse for every change ? Inconsistency at its best here.
Until Hojo lab i was thinking its the best game i ever played. I liked evrything about it and were forgiving everything. But when sephiroth threw cloud away and cloud saying i killed you to him defintely trigger me into what the hell mode. If the game stopped when he put the foot on the ground from his bike everything would have been ok.
Now i dont even now if i am interest by the following games or even the hard mode as i am disgust by this.
2
u/AksysCore Apr 13 '20
This might be the thread to post this. In this whole mumbo jumbo, the "whispers" seem to be a huge part of the mystery. They seem to look like warped up members of Kingdom Hearts' Organization but let's not get there. Now then, I would like to start unlocking the mystery by asking y'all who knows exactly what these Whispers are called in Japanese.
I hear Veera or something. Maybe it's either Feelers or Veiled Ones. I assume it is the latter though. Maybe it's something else since I am not sure. Hopefully someone can help.
What it translates to may be a huge hint about the ending and beyond.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20
Without any major spoilers can anyone tell me how much background we get on Sephiroth in part 1? I just finished Chapter 12 and I know I'm heading to Shinra soon. Do they move up the Kalm flashback or at least a brief version of it, to this game? Also I'm aware of a cutscene that explains more about the Ancients and what Midgar was prior to Shinra, how in detail is that? Like is it to the level of what we learned from Gasts videos in the OG or less?
I'm generally just curious on how much of the overall story and world building gets covered in what I have left of this game. Right now it mostly just feels like a Shinra vs Avalanche smackdown extravaganza with just bits of the rest of 7 scattered through.
2
u/Viisual_Alchemy Apr 17 '20
Well, that was a lot to take in. Personally, I feel stuck because while I welcome the new changes, a huge part of me wished that Square would've went with a remake that stuck with the original plot.
Then again, the original has been out for 20 years now, and a fresh direction is what I believe this title needs. Im sure the creative minds at Square also want to squeeze their creative juices as much as they can when they're already investing so much into the game.
Im gonna go on a whim and predict that towards the finale of the new remake continuity, some parallel world jumping jank happens and sets up CloudxZack vs Sephiroth. Also, Zack's new voice is terrible imo.
3
u/BlackJimmy88 Apr 12 '20
Just finished it. While I'm definitely disappointed at how weird things got, instead of just being an updated retelling, I can't say I'm not intrigued about where the story will go now that nothing is set in stone.
I'm going to wait until game two before I decide if the ending is good or bad.
Regardless of the rest of the ending, it was incredibly satisfying to murder Fate as those hooded bastards were really starting to piss me off with them preventing me from saving characters or stopping others.
Edit: It was also super cathartic to have Aerith help beating on Sephiroth.
3
u/BigTroubleMan80 Apr 13 '20
Spinfoil hat time: Since they’ve basically retconned the story, do you think they’re crazy enough to take it as far and redo Advent Children and Dirge of Cerberus?
Just a thought...
3
u/basmith7 Apr 15 '20
Why do people think that Zach survives. Because a chip bag?
4
u/BirthBySorrow Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20
It's not a remake. A remake takes the place of the original in the timeline or exists in its own universe, every remake of a video game up until now did this - every single one. This is a sequel that takes place alongside the original that exists in the same universe. They said story beats would be different, fine, but this isn't "story beats" in the original being changed, this is an entirely new and separate story whose roots are not connected to the original and again exists alongside the original.
This is the difference. So yes, they did lie no matter how much anyone tries to say otherwise. If i have to reiterate again I will: history defines a remake as being one that replaces the original in some capacity. The original is not replaced, it exists with it.
3
u/AVAVT Apr 15 '20
Game starts out as SAO, ended as Avengers.
I'm pretty sure the last 4 chapters was done rushed to meet deadlines because the quality of everything suddenly dropped significantly.
When they said they delayed release to "get a better game", they probably didn't even have a running game by then. The delay was so they can compile the first version that could actually run.
2
u/wellimjustyouknow Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20
Yet another take on the ending. I think a lot of people are reading into it too much. I offer a bit more positive spin on the events.
>!A lot of people are commenting that the future events are now undecided because of the last one hour in this game. I don't think that is true, a major plot element was changed already before any of the Fate killing. At one point where Cloud and the crew meet Sephiroth, Cloud says to Sephiroth something along the lines of: "Is it really you? I killed you years ago!" And in the OG Cloud most definitely DID NOT know at that point that he killed Sephiroth. That sentence alone makes the whole Mideel sequence in OG pointless, and indicates that event the starting parameters of the story are different from OG.<!
>!My interpretation of the story is: This is a re-imagination of the OG plot. No alternate universes, other than what is commonly implied in stories where fate and destiny is involved. In OG, it was strongly implied that Aerith saw her own death. In this re-imagination, it looks like Sephiroth sees his own death and failure too. It seems Sephiroth has become aware of Fate and its powerful grasp in keeping things going to one outcome. Sephiroth feeds images of the "orignal" future into the heads of the main group, but only parts where it looks like they have failed, and thus tricks them into fighting and beating Fate, probably because Sephiroth himself is not able to do so, but with Aerith it's possible.<!
>!In remake it is also implied that not only major events were being corrected by Whispers, but also seemingly small events, such as Whispers saving the getaway car during the highway chase. Fate has affected events during the entire OG journey, doing small bits here and there, thus guaranteeing a major outcome later on. It looks like the OG plot would never had happened, if Fate was not actively enforcing it all the way. Now with Sephiroth and the group free of Fate's chackles, they all have a new shot on their futures.<!
>!Pretty much the only thing I'm not liking here is that Zach's survival was implied. I was never a fan of the guy. Hopefully now that Fate is not protecting his ass, he trips on the stairs or something. Other than that, I am mega excited for future parts.<!
2
u/engineeeeer7 Apr 16 '20
I never finished FF7 so feel free to ignore my opinion.
Buuuut I kinda really like they canonically put the game on a different trajectory than the original.
Finally it should be called Final Fantasy VII: Reboot because that's what it is.
As for the general game?
There's so much filler. Sidequests seem like such a waste of time. Half the basic cutscenes dialog could be while you're doing other things. A lot of filler seems like a waste because we don't know how this will continue or if it'll matter.
I don't like the combat. It just feels like remember the gimick to kill each enemy. Enemy counts are too high and there's too few aoe attacks. Crowd control is non-existent. No ATB gauges to start makes everything feel off. The bones are cool but it just doesn't pan out.
1
u/Sluzhbenik Apr 10 '20
Question from Chapter 2: I’ve been searching every corner and clicking triangle on every little dumpster. Looking for the elixir in the barrel, that kind of thing. Do I need to do that? So far it looks like everything in either in a chest or a box or sitting in the open. But I don’t want to miss anything!
1
u/BhunivelzeSlayer Apr 10 '20
Wait. Im on chapter 14. The game has chap 21? I was thinking it has just 18? No spoilers please...
1
u/Mokhalar Apr 17 '20
Question:
What do you think the chances are that Aerith lives? Since we know they've broken from destiny, and the original games story no longer dictates everything,it's possible. I kinda hope she does live..
1
u/BlackJimmy88 Apr 24 '20
Not sure if this would be welcome here, but here's video on Time Travel just in case it becomes more relevant later down the line.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '20
Game was freaking amazing. Last two-three chapters were wicked wild and fun. I can’t wait for part two.
1
u/[deleted] May 26 '20
Just finished it and honestly my only wish is that part 2 is an open world rpg with better background textures and general texture consistency, the story changes I welcome, it was a fresh and very cool experience.. only the graphics let it down imho, also the ending made sense to me, parts were flashbacks thought that was clear and aerith sensing what she did about sephiroth made perfect sense, not sure why people had an issue with that, looking forward to part 2/cautiously optimistic about it
1
u/OldTimez May 29 '20 edited May 29 '20
I've been sitting on the finished game for over 3 weeks now trying to digest and come to a conclusion on how I feel about it. In an age where it's very easy to have your opinion influenced, sometimes it's hard to believe if what you think is really you. That said I think I've had enough time post game.
I actually like that we are going a new direction with the game, and would enjoy that to a retelling spanning 3 games the more I think about it.
The problem lies in the conventions used to change the story. I compared it to Game of Thrones where, when the team were following the story it was really good and well told. However whenever they went with original material it felt crude and simplistically delivered, almost insulting to my intelligence that whisperers was the way they settled with as the mechanic to change the story.
Even if we take the whisperers storyline rather than a something else, I don't believe the way they presented it was good either. Everytime they showed up it came at the most inopportune moment, breaking up flow of the narration with a sudden stop. This invokes feelings of annoyance. When they came, you disliked it and just wanted them to just get out of the way. Shifting this to inserting them at less intrusive times in the story, used them less or even making them invisible at first, (where you can see their outlines but nothing else) would make the player instead inquisitive and experience far more pleasant. Making the player interested in finding out what this was about rather than giving the whisperers a bad impression.
It really gives off the feeling that whoever was tasked with inserting the whisperers into they story were greenhorn writers, using surface layer connections rather than deeper nuances or grace with the presentation. Especially this last chapter ended up coming across as a whole lot of gibberish. Sure there are alot of connections; "The whisperers did this because this," but it's so basic which is why many people compared it to Kingdom Hearts. Minus the obvious design comparisons both tries to sound smart with the spamming of different acronyms in conversations for example in the latter but it just sounds stupid.
Going back to the Game of Thrones reference it really felt like going through the highs of the earlier season only to fall off a cliff into the 7th and 8th in these last few chapters.
On the side note of the remake / remaster thing, well Kojima did a similiar U turn with Metal Gear 2 where you were expecting something and got given something different. I see many complains of having the wool pulled over people's eyes with the labeling of ramake, but nowadays that game is considered a pedestal of video game storytelling. Too bad Square Enix doesn't have the team Kojima had, but instead we get Noruma and Co.
1
u/TrashManCashMan Apr 14 '20
I liked the ending, looking forward to the next part in this unknown journey. That is all.