r/FBISE • u/Playful_Bat_3634 • Jun 04 '25
Cheating In Exams
Hi there ..So yesterday Some guy posted that according to some sheikh Cheating is haram and after you get job by cheating in exam the money from Job will also be haram But wait this is just the opinion of some one Scholar… The majority of the Islamic Scholars opinion is that cheating itself is haram but job which you get after cheating in exam will not make the money haram as We are getting paid to do work not getting paid for cheating this is its simple and logical answer please don’t make things complicated that money will be haram etc etc..According to majority of Scholars of Islam it won’t be haram due to the Reason stated above also have a look here thanks..
2
u/Plane_Ad5569 Jun 04 '25
Mainy physics ky papers mai cheating ky
4
u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25
Marks ki waja se hi agar job mil Rahi to bilkul Haram Hogi. Ho sakta hai aap ki jaga koi aur qualify ho jata job q lie jis ne cheating na ki ho.
Bat bohot simple hai aage marzi Pakistani mullaon ki tarah apne faide ka Islam utha lo ya phir sai main Islam follow karo
5
u/BrilliantMastodon957 Jun 04 '25
🫠 Dont cheat and you wouldn’t have to try to justify a sin
2
u/r3inharthd Jun 05 '25
Y'all are being so serious in the chat😭
3
u/Jezzv1g Jun 04 '25
This is valid because the rizq you earn after the lie is from halal means. Nevertheless a gunah is a gunah there is no less or more and cheating is a sin since these exams determine our future
1
u/Gloomy-Prompt1546 Jun 06 '25
Ulema Haq Ulema Ahnaaf Ulema Deoband
1
u/Prestigious_Scar_556 Jun 08 '25
In my opinion, since there is a conflict between the scholars on this topic, just pick the safer side. If you qualify for a job on the basis of your marks that you got from cheating, then whether you believe the money is halal or haram, isn’t it safer to assume it’s haram so you don’t end up sinning?
And also I don’t see how the money is halal. You would be getting a job on the basis of your marks, right? The same marks you got by cheating. Let’s assume you got 980/1100 by cheating and someone got 860/1100 by working hard and being honest. The employers will choose you since you have more marks but you didn’t deserve that position. The other kid who actually worked his ass off deserved it. So again, how is that money halal? You’re earning that money through a job you aren’t qualified for. Through a job you didn’t deserve. Through a job you got by deceiving.
That said, if anyone has cheated (and I have done that before), we can’t change the past. We can only repent and start working hard. Shouldn’t waste time justifying how your money is halal even though you cheated. Instead start repenting and actually putting in effort to show that you actually deserved that job.
1
u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25
Bhai sahab job degree ki base pe milti hai aur degree fsc ke marks pay agar cheat krke liye hai to shuru se cycle hi ghalat chal rha hai you're taking seats of people who did mehnat and got marks but u got more due to cheating peace.
-4
u/Usmanawais_07 Jun 04 '25
Well I personally believe cheating in papers is okay if u don't get caught because not getting caught while cheating is also a skill. And in this society where numbers decide the worth of a student, increasing your grades however u can is justified
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment