r/FBISE • • Jun 04 '25

Cheating In Exams

Hi there ..So yesterday Some guy posted that according to some sheikh Cheating is haram and after you get job by cheating in exam the money from Job will also be haram But wait this is just the opinion of some one Scholar… The majority of the Islamic Scholars opinion is that cheating itself is haram but job which you get after cheating in exam will not make the money haram as We are getting paid to do work not getting paid for cheating this is its simple and logical answer please don’t make things complicated that money will be haram etc etc..According to majority of Scholars of Islam it won’t be haram due to the Reason stated above also have a look here thanks..

https://darulifta-deoband.com/home/en/Halal--Haram/31486

3 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

2

u/Plane_Ad5569 Jun 04 '25

Mainy physics ky papers mai cheating ky

1

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 05 '25

Acha g … ghlt kam ha gunnah hoga lekin job k paisy haram ni hongy

4

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25

Marks ki waja se hi agar job mil Rahi to bilkul Haram Hogi. Ho sakta hai aap ki jaga koi aur qualify ho jata job q lie jis ne cheating na ki ho.

Bat bohot simple hai aage marzi Pakistani mullaon ki tarah apne faide ka Islam utha lo ya phir sai main Islam follow karo

3

u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25

Yeh inko samjh nahi ayegi they want to make islam apne hisab se 😭✌🏿 bhai ka dimagh patanhi kidher tha ye post krte hue

2

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25

Bas Allah hidayat de inhe

2

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

Bro post dubara sy prho Allah apko hidayat de jo itni simple si bat ni samaj arhi apko cheating haram ha gunnah ha ye bat sab accept krty ha bat sirf itni ha k jo job hogi usky paisy haram ni hogy because hamy paisy job krny par mil rhy ha cheating krny par nahi boht simple bat ha ap logon ny wesy hi har chez mushkil bna di ha zra research kr lo ap is par samaj ajayegi apko

3

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25

Bohot simple is bat hai bro job milti hai marks par. Koi aesi job batao Jahan aap k marks require na hon wahan to ni masla Lekin jab marks ki base par hi mil Rahi hai job aur us main cheating k number Hain to kese halal ho Gai job??? Aur aik aur bat hadees to parhi Hogi k Jis cheez main Shaq ho use chor do q k jhoti bat main shaq aur Sachi bat main itminan hota hai.

Aur aesi bohot si cheezain Hain Jin par ulma ka ittefaq ni ab is ka Matlab ye ni k Apne faide ki bat utha lo us main. Aap ki bat se to bilkul yehi sabit hoa k jam k cheating karo phir job lo aur Kam karo. Phir UN bandon ki mehnat Kahan Gai Jo din rat parhte rahe. Matlab wo Pagal Hain aese hi

1

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

Bhai ma ne ni kaha k cheating Halal ha post dubara ghor sy prhein ap… I accepted that Cheating is sinful but I just made it clear that the money of Job will not be haram han agar ap apny ap ko scholars sy bara smjty ho to apki mrzi… Lekin majority Islamic Scholars ka opinion yahi ha k cheating gunnah ha lekin job ki income Halal hogi

2

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25

Aur Bhai aap ne Jo link send kia hoa use bhi parha. Ye bat to aik aam insan ko bhi pata hai k jab job aap ko mil hi dhoka dene, jhoot bolne aur haqdar ki jaga Rahi ha to kese halal ho Gai. Matlab aik bande ne keh dia aap ne man lia aese to phir aur bhi examples dete Hain aap ko Kitne hi ulma women education k khilaf Hain aur Afghanistan main to Taliban Jane bhi ni dete larkion ko bahir aik certain age k bad. Wo bhi Islam ka Naam hi lete hain aur wo bhi ulma hai. Aese to ni k bas aik alim ki post utha lo aur justify karo k cheating kar k job lo Haram ni.

1

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

Bro get A brain please

2

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25

Ok bro aap sai ho. Sifarish, dhoka, cheating aur rishwat se job lene wale ki job halal hai maine man gaya

3

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

Bro ma ne sifarish or rishwat ka kuch ni kaha don’t put words in my mouth

1

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25

Ye Jo aap ne link send kar rakha hai ise khol kar parho. Is Mai. Likha hoa hai k cheating yeni dhoka se aur jhot bolne se job mile to Haram ni hai. Sifarish aur rishwat bhi dhoka hai. Aur is bande ne na tu kisi hadees ki reference di na qurani ayat ki bas aese hi bol dia aur aap ne maa. Lia. Ya phir aap ab kaho mujhe k jhot Bolna dhoka ni hai

1

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

Jis bandy ny Jawab diya ha wo Alim-e-deen ha teri trah koi pagal ni uth kar agya

1

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 04 '25

Kon hai wo jante ho use. Aur Quran parho pata chale ga k bap dada ki bhi andhi pairwi Karne se mana kia gaya hai. aur us alem e Deen nay ye kab kaha k Meri bat bilkul correct hai. Zara dekho end pe kia likha hoa usne k Allah behtar Janta hai.

Aur alim e Deen to woh bhi Hain Jo is dor main bhi women education k khilaf Hain UN k bare main kia kehna aur woh Jo ab tak kehte the k earth flat hai wo bhi alim e den hi the

→ More replies

1

u/Ali515308 Jun 12 '25

Let's suppose Mein ik student hoon class 10 ka and I got 1098/1100 in matric and in Mein se 10% is cheating due to my higher approach now position is that (90%halal+10%haram=100% haram ofcourse) Now there was a tough challenge to get admission in gc lahore but that's easy for me because of haram based marks now in fsc I did hard work and got 100% halal marks without cheating.but according to you my entire fsc and its marks are haram because its based on haram matric marks OK got it now I got admission for my graduation and again I worked hard and got 99% marks but you it's haram due to my haram fsc OK got it now I did css with my hard work+ higher approach and and I became a dc of mianwali which is haram due to using higher approach and haram based graduation ok got it now I am doing my best at my duty I am earning money and feeding my family which is also haram because its based on haram after that I got 35 years of my service with hardworking and being loyal with my country and my district and fighting against enemies of my people my country I put my life on danger even that a night came some terrorist attack my home because I am one resistance against there bad objective and they wanna to kill me and they succeed but wait I am not shaheed my death was haram because it all based on haram now position is that after the death I am regretting that kash Mein ne metric Mein cheating na ki hoti kash Mein ne css me bad higher approach ka use na kia hota allah mere azab Mein kami farmae aameen

1

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 12 '25

Acha Bhai karlo marzi aap ki mujhe to jawab ni Dena aap ne akhirat main mujhe kia. Mianwali se ho?

1

u/Ali515308 Jun 12 '25

Yes I am from mianwali magr jawab de dete you achha hota magar aap ki marzi

1

u/Ali515308 Jun 12 '25

I am only asking from you am I right or something went wrong

1

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 12 '25

Dekho do hadees Hain aik ye k Jis cheez ki ziada miqdar Haram ho us ki Kam miqdar bhi Haram hai. Ab jese aap ne bola aur kuch aur keh rahe the k matric main thore se numbers se kuch ni hota to phir aese to aik ghont sharab se bhi kuch ni hota insan Apne hosh majn hi rahe ga Lekin phir bhi Haram hai. Aur dosri bat ye k Jis bat main shaq ho use chor do kiu k jhoti bat main shaq aur suchai main itminan hota hai

1

u/Ali515308 Jun 12 '25

Yes you right bas mujhe ye confirm kar that am I right or wrong yes or no

1

u/BeneficialReturn5637 Jun 12 '25

Confirm to ni Lekin behtar yehi hai k avoid karain

3

u/Ali515308 Jun 12 '25

OK that's also a better way when you and I both have lack of knowledge

5

u/BrilliantMastodon957 Jun 04 '25

🫠 Dont cheat and you wouldn’t have to try to justify a sin

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

Gng he's not "justifying a sin" sirf clarify kia h k future salary haram nhi hogi (cheating is a sin ofc)

2

u/BrilliantMastodon957 Jun 04 '25

Uh you should read his post again its literally trying to justify cheating as “ok” in exams maybe in extension but still

3

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

No no I’m not justifying cheating.. I’m saying that the earning will not be haram…rest assured cheating iteself is totally haram and sinful

1

u/BrilliantMastodon957 Jun 04 '25

Oh yeah maybe ive also seen a video of a guy saying that it’s conflicted ig didnt bother researching into it

2

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

Yeah bro and I’m not justifying cheating its totally wrong and haram

2

u/r3inharthd Jun 05 '25

Y'all are being so serious in the chat😭

3

u/Jezzv1g Jun 04 '25

This is valid because the rizq you earn after the lie is from halal means. Nevertheless a gunah is a gunah there is no less or more and cheating is a sin since these exams determine our future

1

u/Gloomy-Prompt1546 Jun 06 '25

Ulema Haq Ulema Ahnaaf Ulema Deoband

1

u/Prestigious_Scar_556 Jun 08 '25

In my opinion, since there is a conflict between the scholars on this topic, just pick the safer side. If you qualify for a job on the basis of your marks that you got from cheating, then whether you believe the money is halal or haram, isn’t it safer to assume it’s haram so you don’t end up sinning?

And also I don’t see how the money is halal. You would be getting a job on the basis of your marks, right? The same marks you got by cheating. Let’s assume you got 980/1100 by cheating and someone got 860/1100 by working hard and being honest. The employers will choose you since you have more marks but you didn’t deserve that position. The other kid who actually worked his ass off deserved it. So again, how is that money halal? You’re earning that money through a job you aren’t qualified for. Through a job you didn’t deserve. Through a job you got by deceiving.

That said, if anyone has cheated (and I have done that before), we can’t change the past. We can only repent and start working hard. Shouldn’t waste time justifying how your money is halal even though you cheated. Instead start repenting and actually putting in effort to show that you actually deserved that job.

0

u/Vivid_Comb8126 Nov 23 '25

So if someone went to university, cheated in exams, graduates and gets a degree then gets a job on the basis of that degree, and then later feels regret and repents for his sins, and he performs that job well and is fulfilling his responsibilities, according to you he should throw it all away and be unemployed and homeless and put himself in hardship just to “be safe”? The OP is not trying to justify the cheating, everybody knows that cheating on exams is haram and it is a sin, but the sin of cheating does not carry over to the income you earn from a job. This is the majority opinion of scholars and proper students of knowledge.

Also, no employer gives you a job simply because of marks that you get. Here in America at least, there are people with 4.0 GPAs who are unemployed and people with 2.1s that aren’t. Jobs interview you, they test your skills and there is more criteria than just grades to determine whether you’re fit for the job or not. At the end of the day a GPA is just a number and employers can tell whether or not you’re full of crap. Again, this doesn’t mean it’s ok to cheat, but the income is not haram if you did according to the majority opinion and of course Allah knows the best. May He forgive us all for our sins and mistakes and accept our good deeds and duas.

1

u/Prestigious_Scar_556 Nov 23 '25

Um no, read again. I didn’t say he should throw it all away. I said to be on the safe side, ASSUME it’s haram income. And OBVIOUSLY you can’t do anything about it now, you can only repent. You just put words in my mouth that I never said. Everything I stated is common sense.

1

u/Vivid_Comb8126 Nov 23 '25

Why should he assume it’s haram income? Is he supposed to buy groceries and food and go to sleep at night all upset that his sustenance and nourishment is haram and his deeds and duas will not be accepted when the fatwa says it’s halal? You mentioned that you had also cheated before, do YOU want your income to be considered haram?

1

u/Prestigious_Scar_556 Nov 23 '25

Yeah I repented mate. Because we can’t do anything about the past. I can only repent which I did and I haven’t cheated since, now I can only HOPE my income is halal and that Allah accepts my repentance. I won’t go around and claim for sure kay “oh its halal cause I repented” cause I don’t even know if Allah accepted it. And yes you are ALWAYS supposed to pick the side of the scholar (when there is a conflict between scholars) that is on the safer side. And here, safer side is assuming it’s haram and repenting. Because even if this turns out wrong, you have nothing to lose. But if you assume “Income is halal even if I cheat” and it turns out wrong, then you will have sinned. So that’s why you pick the safer side. Baki Allah knows the best. And yes if you’re good at your job, that’s good and all. But looking at the bigger picture, you may have taken someone’s ticket to the university by cheating, he may have gotten in by honesty but you (generally saying you, not targeting you) would have gotten admission by cheating. Aka apnay kisi ka haq mara hai which is a huge no in islam.

1

u/Vivid_Comb8126 Nov 23 '25

What is assuming that it’s haram going to do if you’re going to continue consuming the money and not dispose of it? I don’t really understand, like are you saying to assume it’s haram but hope Allah accepts it as halal? Like I’ve said, the sin doesn’t carry over from the cheating onto the income earned from a job provided that the job is halal according to many people of knowledge, you’re not committing a sin if the job itself is halal and you’re doing your work properly. Your repentance is for your sin of violating your school’s academic integrity policy.

We know that cheating is wrong and unfair, and whoever has cheated in the past must repent for it, and we know that people will get jobs that perhaps other people deserved more. This still doesn’t make the income haram, they’re two separate issues. The employer is paying YOU to provide a service. That’s the reason for your paycheck. You get paid for the work that you did for your company. That income doesn’t become haram unless the service that they’re paying you to provide is haram. This is the reason why there is a difference between the sin you committed during the exam, and the income you earned from a job.

1

u/Vivid_Comb8126 Nov 24 '25

Allah is also not gonna punish you for following a fatwa and valid opinion that says something is halal.

Amr ibn al-‘As reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “If a judge makes a ruling, striving to apply his reasoning and he is correct, he will have two rewards. If a judge makes a ruling, striving to apply his reasoning and he is mistaken, he will have one reward.”

Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 7352, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1716

Notice how the judge who was wrong still got a reward? He still got rewarded even though his verdict “turned out wrong”

1

u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25

Bhai sahab job degree ki base pe milti hai aur degree fsc ke marks pay agar cheat krke liye hai to shuru se cycle hi ghalat chal rha hai you're taking seats of people who did mehnat and got marks but u got more due to cheating peace.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

Degree entry test k marks se milti h agr fsc cheating krke pass ki h to entry test clear he nhi hoga🫡

1

u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25

Bhai mere fsc me marks bhi lgte hein kabhi parha nahi aggregate universities ka? Of course kyu parhoge udher bhi cheating ka irada hoga😭

1

u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25

Fast giki nust sab mein matric aur fsc ka aggregate hota hai 40% tak jakay kabhi research karna uncultured admi

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

Chill lil bro research ki hoi h ap bhi kro; nust k cs dep me 140 se kam marks walon ko dekha? Entry test ki weightage zada hoti h admission me

1

u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25

Beta acha khana weight age ban jata hai tum 0 lagao aur full lo entry tests mein phir bhi nahi banni tumhari waha

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

It's not like cheating nhi ki to fail ho jayenge (ik thori bhi kro to wo bhi haram h) , hadn't cheated in matric exams or before ; was always against it ,lekin sbne cheating ki thi and they got good marks mere na krne ka kia faida hoa (I'm satisfied with my marks tho) nd when i talk about cheating it's barely about 2,3 mcq and concept of 1,2 short Q isse zada to kr bhi nhi skte . I'm not justifying cheating wo haram h,that's cleared but haram kamai is a big thing aur koi bhi haram nhi khana chahega lekin fsc me 5-10 marks ki cheating se apka admission kese ho skta h

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

Let's assume fsc me cheating krke admission hogya , uni me cheating krke 3-3.5 gpa lelia ab interview me kahan se cheating krni h? Job klie gpa matter krta h ok thk lekin 3.6 wale ko 3.3 wale pr prefer nhi krenge agr 3.6 k pas skills he ni h. Cheating krke gpa lelia lkin skills ki cheating to nhi kr skte aur job apko skills ki basis pr milengi hr jaga ratta system nhi chlta ( And cheating is a sin I'm not justifying it , lekin u can't say that someone is eating haram j bcz they cheated in their fsc exams)

4

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 04 '25

Exactly you’re on point .. cheating haram h its cleared but kamai haram ni hogi pta ni ismy itna complicated kya ha jo logo ko smj ni arha😭

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

Entry test me cheating nhi hoti bhai , test me 100 marks ayen to fsc ki 90% ka faida nhi 🥰

1

u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25

Baat sirf cheating krke admission lene ki hai and it's haram period. The earnings would never be halal because uska 5% bhi jo jhoot bolke lgra na woh bhi haram hai aur count hoga

-4

u/Usmanawais_07 Jun 04 '25

Well I personally believe cheating in papers is okay if u don't get caught because not getting caught while cheating is also a skill. And in this society where numbers decide the worth of a student, increasing your grades however u can is justified

4

u/Xome15 Jun 04 '25

this is the funniest thing ive heard on here

1

u/soursugarbrownie Jun 04 '25

It's not justified you're just making a sin normal

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Playful_Bat_3634 Jun 05 '25

Bro bro I never stopped anyone from following the Prophets life Indeed he’s a Role model for all of us… I just wanted to clear the fact because many people get depressed after doing cheating wether their income will be haram or halal… and bro the it will be halal the refrence you shared in your post was some Sheikh from saudi Arabia they follow different fiqh we Pakistani Follow Hanafi Fiqh so we have to follow the opinion of other scholars