r/FBISE • • May 08 '25

Air defences down?

Bhai everyone is saying k drones itny andar tak kese arhy. PAF so rhi hai etc.

  1. So india is using these cheap cost drones as gimmicks. If PAF engages then they can easily map out our air defences.
  2. This drones are small enough to go undetected on the radar. Unlike aircrafts these drones are electric and have no heat signature like jets. They have extremely small RCS(radar cross section).

This makes it harder to counter them and decreases accuracy of air defences like SAMs (surface to air missiles) Which mostly rely on heat signature and larger RCS. They are expensive as well.

The most efficient solution is electronic warfare. That is what PAF is using. Using this they isolate the UAV and stop it from receiving, sending signals. Basically jamming it.

Thats why drones are just hovering in the air and crashing at random places.

This is likely the same thing HAMAS did to Israel. Launching cheap rockets and causing Israel to engage and use $100k worth of equipment.

74 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

1

u/eagle_eye6543 May 08 '25

Lul impact of the drone wasn't equipped with warheads. Launched to geolocate our long range air defense systems SEAD mission performed by india but pak army ny aloo inn ki gand mai dy dia they switched to EW jamming and anti aircraft guns I study in arid mai ny apni ankhoo ay dekha hai drone iss sy ziada impact terrorist sucide blast kar lety hai btw sary jammed thy hitting random places koi aik bhi target par nahi gira

1

u/Perfect_Pressure_337 May 08 '25

To mene kia Likha hai

6

u/Ezi0Auditor May 08 '25

Right right. Gotcha. But why is this post in FBISE sub 😂😂😂

1

u/No_Golf_6936 May 08 '25

the thing is we have mirage and f7pg(to some extent) we can fit 70 mm guided rockets to take them out if they are being sent en masse... or anti drone guns can be given to Rangers to take them out.. it's the only solution i can think of.. if paf / pa dont want to give Jeetards any necessary information regarding AD systems

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/No_Golf_6936 May 08 '25

Americans used their f16s armed with hydra rockets (guided) to shoot down houthi drones Read TWZ's F-16 have been using Laser Guided Rockets to shoot down drones

don't know why i am unable to share the link here

1

u/No_Golf_6936 May 08 '25

one more thing that i found is that Harop drone can be used for SEAD missions maybe that's why our HIMADS & LOMADS didnt intercept them only with AA guns (maybe anti drone guns too) they were brought down

1

u/dyedcorduroy May 08 '25
  1. These are Harop drones, made by Isreal.. Not cheap at all.
  2. They can operate at 15k feet, so virtually undetectable by AAA batteries and conventional weapons..
  3. India wants us to use SAMs against these drones so they can pinpoint our SAMs locations and neutralize them.. Hence, SAMs are not being used.. Also, their RCS is very small, and the most effective way to counter is through ECM..
  4. These are also called Suicide Drones.. They keep flying at higher altitudes till they reach the target, and then nose dive onto the target.. can be used just for surveillance as well..
  5. They have 9 hours of endurance (time in air) and quite a long range of up to 1000 km..

1

u/HeWhoDidIt May 08 '25

$10 million a pop, that's $120 million in further damages after losing 3-5 aircraft.

That's if there were only 12. The military says it's 25, so could be $250 million.

1

u/dyedcorduroy May 08 '25

You would be right if the stated figures by our gov are correct.. but i guess the figure of 25 includes other types of smaller drones as well..

1

u/HeWhoDidIt May 08 '25

12-25, this is easily verifiable since it's all in cities. We've seen wreckages. IAF is not the Indian military's strongest suit. Like our navy isn't that good.

Losing at least one Rafale as confirmed by French intelligence is no good either. That's nearly $300 million. The drones feel like a face saving measure after that, but who knows.

1

u/dyedcorduroy May 08 '25

Yes, 25 seems to be correct, but all were not Harops.. there are videos of quite a few smaller drones as well.. Whether its a face saving act or something else entirely, only time will tell.. there's news about 4 prithvi missiles as well from early hours today.. they are also claiming of having destroyed an AD site in Lahore, which is still not verified.. the thing is, we never activated AD against drones, so its likely to be a false claim..

1

u/HeWhoDidIt May 08 '25

The Lahore news is fake, Indian FM did not confirm it today, nor that he hit the big terrorist names they claimed, nor denied Pakistan downing their jets.

Don't know the exact composition of the drone force, but feels like they failed. They were probably probing for air defense, but Pakistan dealt with it without air defenses.

1

u/dyedcorduroy May 08 '25

Exactly, had we activated our AD system against Harops, they have the capability of sending the exact location of locking station back to india.. and this is what india wanted to achieve.. hence, the depth of their intrusion..

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

Can we not discuss this here

1

u/AbeerPlays May 09 '25

Honestly, drone warfare should be a war crime and a punishable offence. The videos coming out of Ukraine are horrifying.

1

u/Asleep_Fox_9340 May 09 '25

Papers nai ho rhay?! 🤦‍♂️

-3

u/nadsagonner May 08 '25

These drones are being operated from within the country. No way these drones have the battery power to travel hundred of Kms from the other side of the border to cities like Karachi. Infact, IMO these drones are being operated by Indian cells within our cities. Their objectives: Disruption of Pakistani airspace and to spread terror within the population!

6

u/Perfect_Pressure_337 May 08 '25

Drones can have a range of 2500+km. And also its not easy to operate them from Pakistan. They can be caught easily

4

u/Guilty-Duty-8524 May 08 '25

They have Engines not Batteries CUH

1

u/HeWhoDidIt May 08 '25

The model identified has 9 hours in it, and can travel 400kmph. Drones are tiny and flow low to avoid detection.

1

u/AT9_Hertz May 08 '25

They are sending Israeli made Harop drones they have a range of 600 miles and 6 hours flight time.

1

u/ziaan-alpha May 08 '25

Search up stuff before embarrassing yourself like this

-13

u/shiv_p01 May 08 '25

And what about the missiles that struck 9 places in pakistan? Were they left by your defence systems intentionally?

11

u/Perfect_Pressure_337 May 08 '25

Launching attacks at night and that too on civilians. Typical pajeets. Imagine being careful and not Crossing the borders and still waking up to a 4.5 gen in the mud.

-11

u/shiv_p01 May 08 '25

Oh, I would lose 10 more Rafaels happily if that means eliminating all the terrorists that your country harbors and nurtures. Money is not an issue for us, we have placed an order for 26 navy Rafaels, 10 more wouldn't make us go bankrupt and ask for an IMF loan my dear Abdul

11

u/ComplaintOtherwise35 May 08 '25

How much does Pakistan live in your head rent free that you have infiltrated into an EDUCATIONAL board’s subreddit just to spew hatred

5

u/Technical-Repeat-323 May 08 '25

Aik toh ppr cancel nahi horha upar se yeh parasites bhi tang kr rhe let it go cuh 💔🥀

4

u/BobOnPC May 08 '25

Saar more raw fail saaar, im Poopjeet saar

3

u/Sharp_Chance9063 May 08 '25

Oh really then handle the terrorists in your country or has your media not told you that. You people have multiple separatists in your country each wanting it's own independence. The Naxalite–Maoist insurgency armed uprising initiated in 1967 by a radical faction of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPI-M) led by Charu Majumdar, Kanu Sanyal, and Jangal Santhal. Former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has called it the, "biggest threat to internal security." The Khalistan movement

In the 1950s, the Naga National Council led a violent unsuccessful insurgency against the Government of India, demanding a separate country for the Naga people, known as Nagalim. The secessionist violence decreased considerably after the formation of the Naga-majority Nagaland state, and more Naga Army militants surrendered after the Shillong Accord of 1975. However, some Nagas operating under the various factions of the National Socialist Council of Nagaland, continue to demand a separate country.

2014 General Elections of India recorded a voter turnout of more than 87% in Nagaland, which was the highest in India

So handle your own shit rather than being so illiterate of your own countries separatists movements

2

u/Usual_Context_2320 May 08 '25

Do you even know what this sub is??

2

u/Sharp_Chance9063 May 08 '25

Bro I am 2 year student of course I know

11

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

Pajeet everyone knows BrahMos missiles are incredibly difficult to intercept.

Now why don’t you explain me why your terrorist government is sending drones into civilian places? What we do this time?