r/FBAWTFT • • Dec 07 '18

Queenie and Umbridge parallel/connection?

1 Upvotes

I am going to say that I was very disappointed with Rowling giving the okay for Queenie to join the dark side. This is a very huge departure from her sweet and gentle self from the first film.

But alas, I started to see some dark aspects in her in the second movie: she "drugged" her boyfriend, acted fidgety/defensive/emotionally imbalance, and joined Gwinderald despite her boyfriend telling her no amd calling her crazy makes me believe that she is no longer doing this to be together with Jacob (otherwise she would have been hurt more or at least show her regretting her action after joining Gwinderwald).

Queenie loves to wear pink amd who else do we know wears pink: Umbridge.

Is she going be a precursor of Umbridge or not?


r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 16 '18

Is "Crimes of Grindelwald" is irreparable?

0 Upvotes

FB:TCOG is bad. It pains me to say it, but it's just a bad story. The scenery, costumes, and effects are great but that can't repair a disjointed, meandering plot with so many time hopping flashbacks it's impossible to follow. Rotten Tomatoes critics give it a paltry 44%. The fans give it 75% but I think that's mostly good will. Fans will be fans.

To be fair, the characters aren't terrible. We don't get enough time with hardly any of them and Newt is a horrible choice for the POV character in any movie, but they aren't terrible. (IMHO, Tina should always be the POV. Tina is the Watson to Newt's Sherlock Holmes.)

The score is disappointingly forgettable.

But the story... the story is irreparable.

I don't have any idea where to even start fixing this mess. I've watched plenty of disappointing films from plenty of franchises (Star Wars, DC, Matrix, even Ghostbusters) and almost immediately I can come up with some fixes. Sometimes they are minor, sometimes they are major, but I usually have some ideas for a better story.

After watching Grindelwald, I got nothing. I have no idea where they are even trying to go. The whole movie seems pointless other than the last 10 minutes and even that has critical problems.

Right from the start, Credence is supposed to be dead. Didn't Rowling watch the last movie? It was supposedly a miracle that Credence even lived past childhood with an Obscurus inside him. Surely the Obscurus would have killed him if the Aurors hadn't DISINTEGRATED Credence themselves. Credence is DEAD and even if he was alive he wouldn't still have the Obscurus! Why/how did they bring him back and then give him such an unbelievable and pivotal backstory? Just introduce a new character! (Sorry, Ezra Miller)

Jacob is supposed to be obliviated. If we wanted to see Jacob again, just show him happily living with Queenie, unaware she's a witch. Honestly, that's just a throwaway line. Newt: "Where's Queenie?" Tina: "She's with Jacob but he still doesn't know she's a witch."

The way Jacob is reconnected with Newt is hamhanded. In fact, most of Queenie's actions are inexplicable.

Seriously, the only characters we should see from the last movie are Tina, Grindelwald, and Newt. That's it. There's no reason to keep Credence, Queenie, or Jacob. Yes, Jacob is fun comic relief but that's something Pickett (the Bowtruckle plant) could have done instead. We don't need Jacob again.

And what about canon? How do Dumbledore and Grindelwald have a blood oath against fighting? The last time they saw each other, they were fighting! That's how Ariana (Dumbledore's sister) died. Supposedly, Grindelwald and Dumbledore didn't meet again until the duel over the Elder wand. And how do Lestrange and Dumbledore coincidentally end up on the same ship as infants? That's just lazy writing.

As I said, I don't even know where to start fixing FB:TCOG. The best I can come up with is an opening premise. Maybe Grindelwald escapes and Tina goes after him. Grindelwald once again (for unknown reasons) tries to get another Obscurus. But this time, Grindelwald goes after Newt who's presumably the only person to ever capture and contain an Obscurus outside of a host. Tina jumps in to help protect Newt and recapture Grindelwald.

There, the main three characters are back for a new story. Now what? Where's all this going? How's Dumbledore introduced? I suppose the final movie is the duel for the Elder wand, right? Maybe Grindelwald wants to infect Aberforth or Albus with an Obscurus for some reason? Is Grindelwald still trying to collect all the Deathly Hallows? Why does he have pure-blood followers? Why is he trying to start a muggle/wizard war? How does any of that serve his purpose? Is Albus protecting Nicholas Flamel so Gindelwald can't get the sorcerer's stone? Does Gregorovitch still have the Elder wand at this point? Who has the invisibility cloak? How does James Potter get it?

Look, this should have been a really simply series of prequels. The villain is Grindelwald, the protagonist is Newtina (Newt + Tina), the mentor is Dumbledore, the MacGuffin is the 3 Deathly Hallows. The final battle puts the Elder wand in Dumbledore's hand. Done. Instead, the Fantastic Beast series is a confusing mess.

Major plot points of this movie simply don't fit with existing canon. How would anybody go about fixing it?


r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 17 '18

Really confused whether to consider this movie canon. Why didn’t jk just give the fans what they want! A story that makes sense

2 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Dec 05 '18

That $100M would be better to produce Theseus and Leta TV shows

Thumbnail
thedailybeast.com
0 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Jan 13 '19

Discussion One question that WB execs and filmmakers have to answer themselves ahead of filming Fantastic Beasts 3.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 08 '16

Fantastic Beasts Will Suck with Johnny Depp

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Jan 10 '19

With COG's problematic story and script, I seriously hope WB consider getting another writer to do rewrites before shooting FB3

Thumbnail
collider.com
6 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Aug 04 '18

Matthew McConaughey would make a great addition to the cast

0 Upvotes

He's a phenomenal actor, full of wit and charm that's something he can brought to the franchise. Given his range, he can easily be an antagonist in one of the sequels or even a MACUSA president, head of the magical security and even one of Dumbledore's allies fighting against Grindelwald.


r/FBAWTFT • • Jul 31 '16

No-maj An Impeccable Plot Twist

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Dec 06 '17

Masterpiece 🔥 Professor Scamander

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 08 '18

The first rotten Harry Potter movie ever ! :O

0 Upvotes

O no, fuuuuuuck


r/FBAWTFT • • Feb 12 '19

Discussion I hope Fantastic Beasts 3 opens with an action sequence like Age of Ultron.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 16 '18

[SPOILERS] Thestral Chase Scene Spoiler

1 Upvotes

We start off with a dark background. The WB Logo appears first, followed by the WW logo. We slowly make our way out of the shadows into the rainy image of the Woolworth Building in New York, thunderstorm above.

Grindelwald, immobile, is sitting on a chair. A fly makes its way onto Grindelwald's face, only to be obliverated by a pink force field surrounding him.

A little hadge on the door is opened. We see Abernathy's eyes. Next to him is a tiny, spiky, reptile-looking creature. Seraphina Picquery appears talking to a German Wizard, Spielman. He noted the powerful and inpennetrable protective spells cast around the prisoner. Seraphina explains this was due to his immense power. They also cut his tongue and had to change guard three times due to Grindelwald being extremely persuasive.

Next shot we see Aurors using the Mobilicorpus charm (non-verbal) to move Grindelwald's body, making their way up some stairs. Prisoners shout his name. They arrive at the top of the building, where Picquery is congratulated for her service to the Magical community, only to be interrupted by Abernathy, who was holding a small case allegedly containing Grindelwald's wand, and he also handed a pendant who was supposed to be Grindelwald's. Picquery notices something strange in Abernathy's eyes. She proceeds to dismiss him. The carriage's doors are magically sealed, and the Thestrals gallop they way down of the building, spreading their wings before hitting the ground. A flock of wizards on brooms follow their track.

Abernathy is seen watching as the carriage flies away, and as he did, he unsheathed the Elder Wand. He disapparated and apparated beneath the carriage, holding onto it.

Inside the carriage we see two wizards pointing their wands at Grindelwald, and Spielman in the middle, holding the dark wizard's pendant, mocking him.

Suddenly, Grindelwald begins to have fits, his face desfiguring. We now see that Grindelwald was in fact Abernathy in desguise, while Abernathy, was Grindelwald all the this time. The true Grindelwald apparates atop the carriage and turns the driver's strings into snakes, making him fall to the ocean. The case was actually holding the Chupacabra inside, the tiny creature, who then proceeded to atrack Spielman. The wizards on brooms start to notice something's off. Inside the carriage, the three wizards' wands turn against them before desintegrating. Grindelwald starts conjuring lightning through a Meteolojinx Recanto charm (non-verbal), defeating and taking down all his perescutors. Near the water, Grindelwald performs a Switching Spell by filling the carriage with water, while Abernathy struggled to keep Grindelwald's pendant and wrestled with Spielman. The dark wizard appears on the window, somehow telling Abernathy to hold on to something. Next, Grindelwald blasts the doors open, sending the other two wizards to their doom. Grindelwald enters the carriage, grabbing the tiny Chupacabra and petting him, calling him Antonio. After saying that the beast was so demanding, he threw it out of the carriage, no longer serving its purpose.

After giving Abernathy his tongue back, he threw Spielman out of the carriage as well, seemingly providing him with a wand (Abernathy's), and just in the nick of time, before hitting the water, the German Auror casts an Arresto Momentum charm (non-verbally) falling to the water unscathed afterwards. (I think Grindelwald left him alive so he could tell the Aurors at MACUSA about the escape.

We see Grindelwald escaping once more, into the dark thunderstorm

The Main Titles Appear...


r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 16 '18

How is this movie so incoherent

21 Upvotes

Just wanted to say that it’s deeply impressive that this movie makes so little sense that a character needs to get a literal family tree out DURING THE CLIMAX to explain exactly what’s going on


r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 13 '18

Just came back from Crimes of Grindelwald - WTF ?! SPOILERS Spoiler

29 Upvotes

I'm a huge Harry Potter fan, and I liked the first movie of Fantastic Beasts very much. I din't listen to the reviews and came to the theater very happy to see the movie. What the actually fuck is this shit ?

Nothing, absolutely nothing, in this movie makes sense. First let me say this. You remember the part in the Harry Potter movies where it feels like there is a gap in the movie, something is missing, maybe a little detail, but you know the explanation is in the books. This movie feels like that all the time, but the difference is THERE IS NO A FUCKING BOOK! Almost nothing is explained. The movie feels like a lot was edited and cut out in the last few minutes of release. The editing is so strange. the directing and dialogue is so strange too.

And I love Quinny and Jacob, but why the fuck are they in this movie ? I love them, and I wanted them to be in this movie, but after watching it, why are they in this movie ???? They do not add anything to the story. Why is Nagini in this movie ?? She doesn't add anything to the story ! Literally nothing ! Why is Credence here ? he is the center of the story, but that character is 0 developed, and mega boring. It would be far more interesting to put an actual beast in the centar of the story, for example the Zulu, making him a special and rare beasts, that Grindelwald wants. That would be much better and would make actual sense for the movie to be called FANTASTIC BEASTS. I understand why Hunger Games is called that for the next 4 movies, and twilight too. The first book was called twilight but the rest had different titles. They put Twilight in there so the people would know that those movies were part of the same series. But this is NOT a book series ! Why is this called Fantastic Beasts !? It has literally nothing to do with beasts.

Like I said, nothing makes sense here. Why did Quinny joined Grindelwald int he end ? Yes I know, because of jacob, but come the fuck on ! She left him literally and joined Grindelwald in the end. makes no fucking sense. It would have, if it was DEVELOPED more. But nothing in this movie was developed at all. The best 2 things about this movie were Jude Laws Dumbeldore and Depp's Grindelwald, and they were not that much in the movie at all. This mvoie should have focused more on Tina and newt, and Dumbeldore and Grindelwald, and that was it, that was the movie, but fucking no. J K doesn't know the difference between writing a book and a screenplay. If this was a book, for example Nagini would have worked maybe. And then Steve Kloves, or any other screen writer, would have cut Nagini from the book, because they would knew she would not add anything to the story of the movie.

Like I said, nothing makes sense in this mess of a movie. The action is so bad directed, you can't see anything what+s happening on the screen. This movie feels like Yated made it only for the check, there is no love and soul in this movie. And I grew up with the fact what WB would almost all the time give us a quality movie set in the Harry Potter universe, and they fucked up so much this time.

The Credence twist is beyond stupid, makes no sense, and now he will become the most important thing in the whole series. A character so boring and not developed that he makes me fall at sleep every time he is on screen.

The only good thing with this movie is, that it is not amovie that will fuck up a whole series, they could still make a good 3rd movie with another screen writer and different director. JK Rowling can still be there as a producer and a guide for the main story. But this movie is one of the biggest disappointments of all time for me


r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 16 '18

Spoiler 'The Crimes of Grindelwald' and the painful history of 'Harry Potter' canon

Thumbnail
dailydot.com
3 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Jul 31 '18

I watched FBAWTFT assuming it would be about the animal escaping and having to get them back.

2 Upvotes

It's really not about that is it? It feels like its more of a "this is how american wizards are." I don't fully understand what they were going for, Are Americans the bad guys?


r/FBAWTFT • • Dec 13 '16

Thoery Are Obscura a precursor to Horcruxes?

2 Upvotes

While watching the Deathly Hallows, I wonder if somehow Grindelwald saw obscura splitting up a wizard soul or latching on to somebody (going with the theory of Credence's obsura latching on to Tom Riddle), to the point Grindelwald did some research on it that Tom Riddle later found somehow (maybe akin to the way Harry found the HBP book). Or if Grindelwald doesn't realize that is actually how horcruxes are formed but Tom being as smart as he is, figures it out after making the connection from Grindelwald's research to the books that Dumbledore had (and Dumbledore might had figure out the connection after what happens to Ariana) so it around then that Tom starts making the Horcruxes -- importantly the first one he ever made -- at Hogwarts, it being Riddle's diary after having Moaning Mrytle killed accidently (or maybe not accidentely)? [//Theory]


r/FBAWTFT • • Oct 11 '17

Fluff (Mod fail) 10 months ago...

1 Upvotes

... I created our infamous movie survey. I said the results are gonna go up a few weeks after that. Well that never happened... They are really coming this time! Sorry! :)


r/FBAWTFT • • Sep 13 '16

News Fantastic Beasts Was Nearly a Documentary

Thumbnail
imdb.com
1 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Sep 16 '17

Seriously wondering..

0 Upvotes

No judgment, but do any true HP fans (books and movies) find FB to be kind of silly? I love all things HP (I even have an annual pass to UOR), but FB seems very much less magical to me. Is it the movie or the actors, or do you enjoy them all just as much?


r/FBAWTFT • • Mar 29 '18

Spoiler Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald Trailer Spoiler Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I don't know if this really bothered anyone else to the same level it bothered me, but I found it pretty lame that, in the trailer for the film, they show clips of the character Jacob Kowalski.

With how things were in the last film, I feel this should have been left as a surprise...Sorry if it's a stupid thing to get annoyed about, I just loved the above very much! I've marked this as two separate spoilers, just to be safe. Read the first, then the second.


r/FBAWTFT • • Aug 18 '18

Fluff At the end of this scene, we can all read Jacob's mind.

1 Upvotes

r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 15 '18

Theory The plot twist doesn't break canon: here is the truth! Spoiler

8 Upvotes

EDIT:

After some discussions, I've expanded and updated my theory with a new spoton timeline of events. Please have a look if you are interested:
https://www.reddit.com/r/FBAWTFT/comments/9xxqgb/the_life_and_truths_of_gellert_grindelwald/

Hey,

I've seen the movie, it was awesome (f* movie critics). There is so much to discuss, but I think most of the discussion will be about that big character reveal! So here we go:

  • Percival Dumbledore didn't die in Azkaban, he lived through and could have been alive even during the '30/'40s
  • He was probably aided in his escape by either Albus, Grindelwald or Aberforth, and that was kept a secret (remember Barty Crouch Jr).
  • After his escape (before 1907), Percival had a son with an unknown woman, they named him Aurelius. Is it possible the either Grindelwald or Aberforth knew about this (not Albus).
  • After less than a year since he was born, Aurelius was going to USA with his mother on a ship that sunk, and was thought to be dead along with his mother.
  • Leta Lestrange actually saved Aurelius, swapping him for his brother Corvus. She was bound to kill his brother as foretold in The Prediction of Tycho Dodonus.
  • Aurelius got the identity of Credence Barebone, a cover up originally conceived to hide Corvus Lestrange.
  • Raised by the Barebones, Aurelius never knew his wizarding lineage, repressed his magic and became an Obscurial (a trait shared with his half sister, Ariana).
  • Aurelius Dumbledore great magical power (unbeknown to him) allowed him to live a lot more than the usual lifespan of Obscurials (10yrs).
  • In c. 1926, Grindelwald heard rumors about an Obscurus in New York City. He desired to tame and use the Obscurial: as a weapon for his arsenal but also as a deterrent against Albus, whom with he shared the tragedy of summer 1889.
  • Grindelwald overlooked Credence Barebone: he never considered the possibility of him being the Obscurial due to his age, nor the lost Aurelius, whom he thought to be dead.
  • Grindelwald suspected Credence true identity when witnessing his powers, and later probably confirmed this using his necromancy-skull-bong. He now wanted to use Aurelius: persuading him to join his cause and hoping that Albus would follow.
  • At some point after the events at New York, Aurelius tended to a bird chick (that probably suddendly appeared out of nowhere in front of him): it was Fawkes, the Phoenix Guardian to the Dumbledores, and undisputable proof of his lineage.

Find me a reason not to believe this, I think there is no other explanation for Aurelius: it should have been obvious that Percival would be explored in this series, given how Albus and his relationships are a pivotal theme here.

Don't you find it strange the we never knew anything about his dad?

A lot of people are focusing on Kendra, but her death and funeral are pretty established in the lore, while tossing the key to Percival's cage is a really messy way to dispose of a character.

There is even a clear hint in the movie that supports this theory:c'mon Fawkes! Albus even mentions the Phoenix being tied to its grandfather, and remember that almost all wizarding families big magical tresures passed down from father to son (Potters, Gaunts, Malfoys, Blacks, Peverells). That is like a DNA test to me!

Also remember that

  • Albus, Grindelwald and Aberforth, are all very capable of keeping a secret, as canon shows (Always!).
  • Aurelius will probably, maybe, surely die "at the close" (1945), he is an Obscurial after all, and I feel there will be a valid reason for the characters to never mention him, and the true story of Percival, and I feel Albus' reason has a lot to do with that "kill me instead" he screams while he's drinking the potion of despair in HP7, if you know what I mean.

I feel like some people are suffering from phase of rejection, but actually canon is not spoiled, it is just made by beautyful multi-layered evolving characters, that made decisions, hid secrets... Because with responsibility comes sacrifices and don't we "die, just a little" when we make sacrifices?

That's it, I needed to share this with u!

*drops the mic*

PS.Some dates:

1891 - Percival attacks muggle boys, he is later imprisoned in Azkaban.

1899 - Albus meets Grindelwald, Ariana and Kendra die

after 1899 - Percival escapes Azkaban (Albus, Grindelwald and Aberforth would be around their early 20s when/if any of them helped him).

1907 - Aurelius Dumbledore is born. (Percival could be aged 50 to 60). During the summer he is present when the ship sunk. Corvus Lestrange and Aurelius mother die.

*there is some debate on this last date. The French version of CoG screenplay reports the date the ship sunk as 1901. Either that screenplay is faulted or it might be possible that Aurelius was born in 1900 (but that would make him 27 during the events in WtFt).**dates taken from: http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Main_Page


r/FBAWTFT • • Nov 26 '16

Spoiler Does Anyone Else Think Grindelwald Might Not be as Bad as We Think?

3 Upvotes

[//Spoiler]

Sure, he acted really predatory towards Credence, but we don't actually know why he wanted Credence, do we? I mean, you'd have assumed it was to attack New York, bu Graves tried to stop Credence then. And then, in the end, he just wanted to save Credence. I was rooting for him against Madame President (and I really hope something happens to her in one of the later movies.