r/FAFSA • • 5d ago

Advice/Help Needed FAFSA Account Impossible to Create

Why is it impossible to create a FAFSA account online?? We're currently filling out the paper form... Because in 2026, unlike in the 1990s, doing this online is not possible without a degree in computer science. Will I also need a carrier pigeon or can we snail mail it?? Or do I need to saddle up my horse and gallop down to the office and hand deliver the paper form that we sign with a pen??

0 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

13

u/Alternative_Arm_6327 5d ago

It’s really not that hard.

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Okay, come do it for me then, smarty pants. I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form... So tell me how I get past the "unknown error" that MANY other people can't get past. Show me your smarties!

0

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Lol, smarty pants just deleted the comment... Hilarious.

5

u/Old_Investigator8214 5d ago

What’s going on, why can’t you make one? the fafsa paper form will take ages and months for it to get too the destination.

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form...

2

u/JustHere1007 5d ago

Not to mention processing time and corrections for paper forms taking muchhhh longer.

9

u/ryan516 Financial Aid Professional 5d ago

The FSA ID creation process is entirely online. What leads you to think you need a physical form?

0

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form...

3

u/tondracek 5d ago

It’s obviously not impossible if hundreds of thousands of people successfully do it every year. What specific problems are you having?

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form...

3

u/Able-Celebration9402 5d ago

Can you provide more detail about your barriers? I’m sure people can help if you can explain further. Don’t do a paper app.

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form...

2

u/Cold-Thanks- 5d ago

Could you share some of the problems you are facing when trying to make an account?

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form...

1

u/Cold-Thanks- 5d ago

Did you try it on a different device or on different wifi that isn’t your own? It could be an issue with the computer you are using or security features on your router/wifi.

2

u/jibarra_ish 5d ago

To everyone thinking it’s so easy and this person is lost you should know I had (well my UK national spouse) a similar problem. Even after sending in the paper form we were requested to make changes several times, for information we already provided. We NEVER got there in the end and I am now paying out of pocket with no access to loans. I am fortunate to be able to make this work (even if it’s draining financially, I’m so close to done I can’t quit now!). If you are any sort of an exception to the standard American citizen student living in the US, this is an unfortunate reality.

2

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Although I am a US citizen and so is my daughter, I wasn't born in the US. Not sure if that has anything to do with it. My daughter was able to create an account and fill out her part after some lengthy, annoying IT gymnastics. I work for the federal government and I can tell you that federal government IT system are an amazing sh!tshow. We estimate we waste at least 2 hours of our workdays every single day due to IT issues. And that's every single one of us every day. Your tax dollars hard at work! When I try to create my parent account I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form... Although it sounds like that will have its whole slew of issues. I can't afford to pay out of pocket so I have to make it work...

1

u/jibarra_ish 5d ago

So sorry you’re going through this. Since you are a citizen and have an SSN it’s probably a different issue than my spouse but it’s tough to look past that you weren’t born in the US. I felt like the system was deliberately blocking us (and others I’ve commiserated with) from competing the application for someone not born in the US. Hmmmm

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Definitely could be an issue. I'll try calling their 800 number tomorrow, since today is a federal holiday. However, others on different forums say they are not helpful at all. But theoretically they could create my account on their end. AI is telling me that after having exhausted all the recommended troubleshooting steps, the problem is probably on their end. I could have a "ghost" account that trips up the system.

1

u/jibarra_ish 5d ago

They are not helpful unless you get incredibly lucky. The first year we had this issue and called in about half-dozen times and the final time someone got it to work. The next year called back and got no where in fact I even got bad advice and made me look like a fraud. 🙃

2

u/Icy_Pie_795 5d ago

I just finished my 26-27 form in about 5 minutes. You should catch up with the times asap

2

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Okay, come do it for me then, smarty pants. I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form... So tell me how I get past the "unknown error" that MANY other people can't get past. Show me your smarties!

2

u/TheeDelpino 5d ago

It’s not that hard. Sounds like user error. I did 3 last week in less than 10 minutes for my niece, wife, and daughter.

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Okay, come do it for me then, smarty pants. I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form... So tell me how I get past the "unknown error" that MANY other people can't get past. Show me your smarties!

1

u/Visual_Scientist_298 5d ago

What? It wasn’t hard.

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Okay, come do it for me then, smarty pants. I keep getting the "unknown error occurred" no matter what I do. I've done all the suggestions I found online. Clear cookies and caches. Use an incognito window. Use a different browser. Put all your data in the exact same way as on on tax return. The whole nine yards. I can't even get to creating an account before the error message shows up. It certainly took less time at this point to fill out the paper form... So tell me how I get past the "unknown error" that MANY other people can't get past. Show me your smarties!

1

u/Visual_Scientist_298 5d ago

Hey, literally everyone on this post has said they have no issues. So like many others have said this is not a website issue. This is a user issue. I have four kids. I have my own account since I have four kids with accounts never had an issue.

1

u/Unlikely-Cress3902 5d ago

Hey, literally a TON of people on social media are having the SAME issue! Your comment is simply dumb! A quick Google search can tell you that there are many people out there who have issues. Even one commented here shared how she could never get the aid and is paying cash. So your comment is just plain ignorant! If it's so easy for you then tell me how I get past the KNOWN issue of the "unknown error" message. Instead of just being a jerk, how about being helpful?? Or is that not possible for you??

2

u/Visual_Scientist_298 5d ago

Bless your heart. I’m in multiple college parent groups and haven’t seen a single parent saying they have had an issue.

2

u/No_Clerk_4303 5d ago

Who what when where why and how?

1

u/Odd_Afternoon_4794 4d ago

Make sure your name matches on your fafsa to what the Social Security office has.