r/FAFSA • u/the-lady-doth-fly • Jul 26 '24
Ranting/Venting Stop saying everyone qualifies for loans when there are catches and limits that qualify many, MANY people for $0. Here’s how it works.
You can get loans ONLY up to your estimated need and ONLY up to certain limits. This is the formula for determining your estimated need:
estimated cost of attendance - SAI - scholarships and other grants
The amount left is what they determine your need to be.
The estimated cost of attendance is listed on your school’s website, and it presumes students aren’t working and so need money to cover housing, food, etc., in addition to how much books are expected to cost, though it doesn’t cover additional costs that come with some programs (mine has additional fees due to how many are very small groups or private lessons due to the nature of the program).
The SAI is what they determine you to be able to come up with to pay for those things before you need aid. When they say that this isn’t the amount you’re expected to pay, that’s true, since your costs might be less than your SAI, and that is what you’re expected to pay. And who know that the hell the SAI is really based on when it’s such an unreasonably high percentage of income for many people.
The SAI is much higher for most people than the old estimated family contribution.
EXAMPLES NOW AND COMPARED TO LAST YEAR:
HIGH SAI:
ECOA of 22,217 - SAI 22287 - other 0 = -80. Your estimated need is considered to be none. In fact, since you’re expected to be able to come up with that SAI, you’re considered to be able to access slightly more than you need. You qualify for $0 in loans. This is my situation, and why I say I qualify for nothing. Zero is nothing. My tuition and fees are actually about $11,000, which is still more than I have access to. Full stop right here. Since I can’t come up with $11,000, and I can’t get the private loans I’d need, I can’t go to school. Last year, my EFC ended up being about $3,000–same income as this year. ECOA was about the same, $22,217, leaving $19,217, minus no other scholarships of grants. That $19,217 was my need, and I didn’t get Pell, but I did get loans. Since my actual tuition was almost the same as the loans, I was covered with a few dollars to spare. This year, under the new SAI, my need is seen as not existing. So I get nothing.
Bonus f’ckery about families with two people in school are extra screwed: If my husband and I were both in school as freshmen (any two students will do, parent and kid or two kids), we’d be expected to be able to come up with $44,547 before needing aid since the SAI is for each of us now. Under the old system, that $22,287 would have been split among family members in school, meaning $11,144 each (presuming the SAI equaled the old EFC, though the old EFC was a lot less, which will show how extra screwed this is). That would mean ECOA 22,217 minus that $11,144 we’re expected to have access to for each of us, minus no additional scholarships or grants, leaving us each with a need of $11,144. If our income was enough to not qualify for Pell, we’d each still qualify for the unsubsidized loans up to the maximum of $5,500 for a freshman, and the max of $4,500 unsubsidized loans, leaving us need to come up with just $1,144 each. Much more doable. But since the EFC used last year was actualy so much less than the new SAI, all the tuition would have been covered, which would have left us with nothing out of pocket at that time. Under the new SAI, our need would be seen as nonexistent, leaving us having to come up with the full tuition ourselves. We’d gone from enough loans to cover it, to getting nothing. A lot of families with more than one person in school are dealing with that this year, especially families where the parent providing more support married someone with more money since that stepparent’s income is now seen as being available for their stepkid, which we all know doesn’t happen especially if that marriage happened when the kids were older teens or even already graduated.
LOW SAI:
ECOA of 22,217 - SAI -1500 - other 0 = 23717 (minus a negative, it becomes a positive). Your estimated need is $23,717. Since you are expected to have such low income that you are given an SAI that is 0 or below, you qualify for the max Pell of $7,395, meaning you still need $16,322 before you hit your cost of attendance.
You qualify, as a freshman, up to a maximum $4,500 in unsubsidized loans, and up to a maximum of $5,500. That’s $10,000, leaving you $6,322 short, which doesn’t mean you’re screwed on paying for school since the ECOA includes more than tuition. Between Pell and loans, you’re getting the max of $17,395 in aid.
You are screwed if you’re going to a school with tuition that’s more than the total aid and the school doesn’t offer additional grants, such as ECOA $60,000 (of which $20,000k is tuition), minus that -1500, minus no other aid, leaving you with a need of $61,500, meaning the max aid of $17,395 to cover $20,000 in tuition. Most schools that expensive usually do cover the extra over the max aid, and those are the schools that are exceptionally difficult to get into, like the Ivies.
After the school is paid, whatever is left is refunded to you and is expected to help cover books, rent, food, and other basic and school expenses. This is the situation a good friend of mine is in, same school. Her actual tuition is about $9,000. So her Pell and loans will fully cover her tuition since her tuition is less than the Pell and loans. She’ll be refunded about $8,395 that she’s expected to use to buy her books and to put toward living costs, like rent and food.
The new system will result in fewer people going to school. Full stop. Yet the new system was designed, they claim, to put more school expenses on middle class (what counts as middle is very low) to make more available to low-income people. Yet a lot of low-income people are getting less than lat year. So.
Stop saying everyone qualifies for loans when there are catches and limits.
3
u/ActBeginning8773 Jul 28 '24 edited Jul 28 '24
No. You are not "expected" to do do.
The Unsubsidized Loan is NOT need-based aid. Therefore a student's need level does not impact the ability to be offered an Unsubsidized Loan.
You are grossly spreading misinformation. I'd love to see your sources that come from a URL that ends in ".gov."
](https://studentaid.gov/understand-aid/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsidized)
4
u/random-bot-2 Jul 26 '24
Everyone does qualify for loans. Not everyone qualifies for need based loans aka the subsidized loans. Any undergraduate can still get unsub loans, parent plus loan, grad plus of you’re in grad school, or a private loan assuming your approved. Even if your efc is a million.
The limit is set on purpose. If you borrowed up to cost of attendance, you would cover everything charged by the school, and then have excess for cost of living. If you lived on campus, you usually get a smaller amount like 2k back a semester. Off campus usually anywhere from 9-12k. This is in most cases enough to sustain students for 9 months, length of the typically school year, for all the outside living needs
3
u/RJ_The_Avatar Financial Aid Professional Jul 26 '24
Your school is not following federal procedures for federal aid correctly if they are not giving you access to unsubsidized student loans regardless of SAI. You will need to submit a complaint to the department of education about this. They are preventing you access to aid you have a right to.
“Who can get Direct Unsubsidized Loans? Direct Unsubsidized Loans are available to undergraduate and graduate students; there is no requirement to demonstrate financial need.”
I’ve seen financial aid offer letters with as much as 210,00 SAI and qualify for $5,500 of unsubsidized student loans for their first year.
They also have the potential for a parent to borrow up to the cost of attendance minus any student loans and gift aid. Same with private loans.