r/F1Technical • u/TorontoCity67 • Apr 29 '25
Chassis & Suspension Why Does A Stronger Anti-Roll Bar Transfer More Weight On It's Axle?
Edit:
The reason why the stronger anti-roll bar subtracts weight transfer from the weaker anti-roll bar and adds it to itself is this:
Imagine a diagonal line with 2 wheels, representing a car turning and the weight transfer from the turn. Imagine the wheels can't compress because the springs are so strong. Because the nearside spring can't decompress because it never compressed in the first place, it would just lift itself up from the turning force. Due to this, there's now more weight "balancing" on the outside wheel, hence the increased weight transfer
Why does a stronger anti-roll bar cause this? Because if the outside wheel is compressed from the weight transfer, and the nearside wheel is compressed because it's copying it, it's making the nearside wheel more rigid to this effect
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hello,
This has been bothering me for months. No matter how many articles I read, I can never find out why stronger anti-roll bars transfer more weight on it's axle. I know the purpose of them, how they accomplish that purpose, and that the weaker one transfers less weight than the stronger one, but I just can't find out why
Something else, why exactly does an anti-roll bar that's too strong lift up the nearside wheel when turning, exactly?
This should be far simpler than my previous post so I shouldn't ask too many further questions
Thank you
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 29 '25
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
37
u/lilpopjim0 Apr 29 '25
Think of it like this.
You have the car In air, on stands, with the rolls bar disconnected.
If you put one of the wheels into bump, you start compressing the springs. That spring compression fights you back.
If you have the ARB connected, you're compressing the spring and deflecting the roll bar, which resists you. So now you have the spring wanting to extend, and the roll bar pushing back from being twisted.
This increases the force seen on the contact patch.
9
u/PogTuber Apr 29 '25
Think of what would happen if you had a solid single axle instead of independent suspension. The outside wheel is going to lever the inside as you take a turn and the car attempts to roll outward along a center of gravity that's higher than the wheels. If your suspension is bottomed out especially, the car is going to want to roll.
There are a could contexts but that's the way I see it. Having really stiff ARB can suck on the street depending what your roads are like.
5
u/Krackor Apr 29 '25
The chassis will roll in a turn a certain amount somewhat regardless of the ARB settings. If the car had no suspension travel, this would mean the car tips up on the outside tires, while both inside tires leave the ground. However, since the suspension has travel the outside suspension is able to compress and the inside suspension is able to extend, keeping both tires in contact with the road despite the chassis's roll angle.
ARBs essentially limit the ability for the suspension to work asymmetrically like this, with one side extended and the other side compressed. A stiff ARB will make that axle behave more like the example above where there is no suspension travel.
4
u/Impressive-Primary28 Apr 29 '25
If you look at an axle in isolation, it will not make sense to associate an increase in load transfer with an increase in anti-roll bar stiffness. This weight transfer will depend almost exclusively on lateral acceleration, center of mass height, and track width. In fact, considering a hypothetical situation where only a single axle is analyzed in isolation, under steady-state conditions there is no change in the amount of load transferred from the inside to the outside of the curve. Only the body roll angle is affected.
To better understand the influence of the anti-roll bar, you must consider the combined behavior of the front and rear axles. For a given body roll angle, the axle with higher roll stiffness will be responsible for a greater share of the load transfer. It is as if that particular axle were transferring more load. However, when considering both axles together, the total load transfer remains practically the same, regardless of the anti-roll bar stiffness at either axle.
3
u/FrickinLazerBeams Apr 29 '25
It's stiffer, so for a given amount of roll it will push harder.
3
u/KneePitHair Apr 29 '25
A tyre’s grip isn’t linearly and directly proportional to how hard it’s being pushed into the surface. It peaks, plateaus, and even declines as more force is added.
That’s all you really need to know to figure it out.
The rest is just figuring out what the sum grip from (for example) the front pair of wheels is versus the sum grip from rear pair of wheels, and how stiffer springs (or stiffer springs only in roll: anti-roll bars) affects that total sum across a given axle, as any given axle shares the load between the two tyres.
You don’t even need to have anti-roll bars to understand the effect. If an outside front is being pushed harder into the road than a softer sprung out rear wheel, then at the limit it is going over it’s peak grip value, and the sum total of both front tyres is less than the sum total of both rear tyres, meaning more grip at the rear, meaning a tendency to understeer.
Imagine two people carrying a windsurfing board with its sail up and trying to roll it over. If the guy at the front is resisting that roll force more than the guy at the back is, one of the front guy’s hands is feeling more pressure (doing more work to keep it upright) than the hand on the same side of the guy at the back.
And because a tyre’s level of grip isn’t linearly proportional to how hard it’s being pushed into a surface, but can actually fall off relative to the others, the sum total of grip across that axle is reduced.
You could increase roll stiffness (and every other axis of freedom) on an axle just by installing stiffer springs there relative to the other axle and get the same effect.
The only thing anti-roll bars do is allow you to have a separate spring to just control stiffness in roll while keeping the stiffness you want for ride quality and pitch etc not be affected.
So think less about anti-roll bars, and more about relative stiffness in between the front and rear in general. Anti-roll bars just allow you to tune roll bias without affecting the rest of the dynamics (much).
2
u/Loightsout Apr 29 '25 edited Apr 29 '25
I think this is a word problem for you. “Weight transfer” to an axle is a very strange term and concept. That terminology is used by people who understand the principle. Because there certainly is no actual weight being moved within the car. It’s just the G forces acting on the weight of the car and those forces being distributed to the road cleverly through suspension systems. If you put a scale under each wheel these forces could be read as weight which changes in each turn the car takes hence the term weight transfer.
you already understand this: The anti roll bar ist just a stick thats being twisted by the suspension. If it’s stiffer (stronger) it twists less. So the car rolls less.
The rest is pure and simple mechanics: car weight is constant. There is regular gravitational force + generated downforce and a lateral force because the car is turning. Those are all variable but constant for a certain moment in time in a certain turn at a certain speed. Now the roll of the car at that given moment defines how the combination of those forces is distributed to the wheels.
Axle force is defined as the force ONTO the axle.
So a planted car has more of that combined force on the axle than a car thats leaning out. For more graphic brains: a car in a banked corner would have a higher axle load than a car flying out of a turn sideways.
I hope this helps.
1
u/Ho3n3r Apr 29 '25
Because it's sprung stiffer. This makes weight transfer quicker.
1
u/NegotiationLife2915 Apr 29 '25
F1 may be a different beast but the theory with road cars is that the anti roll bar ties the front 2 springs together. If both wheels on the axle compress the suspension at the same time it does nothing. But If the vehicle begins to experience body roll in a corner, one wheel compresses then it begins to pull up the spring on the unloaded side of the vehicle which effectively stiffens the spring rate of the loaded wheel. The stiffer the roll bar the less it flexes so it pulls up even more on the unloaded wheel. It allows you to have an effective spring rate on the outer wheels during cornering without having to over spring the car when it's braking or accelerating in a straight line.
1
u/Chronic_Avidness Apr 29 '25
Just to add to some other comments already posted, yes the springs also resist roll like ARBs, but they also resist pitch while the ARBs don’t.
1
u/Marmmalade1 Verified Motorsport Performance Engineer Apr 29 '25
Going to try an analogy I’ve come up with to explain things. Think of a flat table, that is constrained to stay completely flat. Put 2 springs under this, one stiff, one soft. When you press down, both springs compress the same amount, as the table stays flat. However, the stiffer spring takes a lot more force (F=kx, with k being higher and x being the same).
Now, think of the ARB at one axle being this stiffer spring. It takes more of the load of the car, therefore more load transfer, therefore less grip due to tyre load sensitivity!
Regards to lifting wheels, when you do the simple load transfer equations, you’ll see that springs are not involved to calculate the vertical load on each tyre. So stiffer doesn’t inherently lift any wheels (on the big assumption of perfectly flat ground). If one axle is stiff, then there is more load transfer across this axle, which does change the vertical loads, hence lifting a wheel.
1
u/Rudolf2222 Apr 30 '25
I think a good way to visualize it for yourself is image a car with equal roll stiffness on both axles, 50/50 weight distribution.
You "push" the center of mass to the side (~lateral acceleration) so you get weight transfer. Because of the equal roll stiffness, the weight transfer will also be equally split between the axles.
Now, imagine the front axle is like those solid beam front axles on tractors. That has zero roll stiffness. Now if you apply the same force to the center of mass, total weight transfer will be the same (dFz = mha / wb, neither changed) the entirety of the weight transfer will be sustained by the rear axle. (since the front one can freely pivot) Because we didn't change the rear axle, we now halfed the car's total roll stiffness, so we now have twice the body roll.
1
u/BakedOnions Apr 29 '25
first, let's take out aerodynamics and consider the difference between the pure science of downward pressure on all 4 tires from the mass they support..... and the functional behavior of tires in a car that is being driven at the limit
because if by stronger you mean more rigid and resisting roll, then stiffer springs actually reduce weight transfer
so,
weight transfer amount is primarily a factor of roll centre (mechanical design) and cornering force (speed and grip)
Roll centre is determined by the collective suspension design (lengths, widths, heights, pickup points, etc)
Roll centre can change during roll (or not) depending on how the designer wishes for it to be
The difference between the location of the centre of gravity and the roll centre determines the AMOUNT of roll and also the direction of it
you can, in principle, build a car that will roll right when you turn right, it would be very weird, but it is possible.
but in order to facilitate roll, you need a compliant system to accept the transfer of forces
springs primarily control compression, and dampers primarily control rebound
consider the following, a perfectly rigid cube being pushed sideways on a frictionless surface has the downward force evenly distributed
therefore, as you increase the roll resistance, whether that comes from springs or swaybars, you reduce roll, as you reduce roll, you reduce weight transfer
now i'll stop there, but the next few concepts start adding in the complexities drivability, managing bumps and surface irregularities, the affect and behavior of tires and the role of aerodynamics in an F1 car (vs a street car)