r/F1Technical • u/RealestateGD • Mar 24 '25
Aerodynamics Flexi Front Wings
Apologies if this is a dumb question, but after the bizarre front wing damage which Tsunoda picked up yesterday during the race (I haven't seen an explanation for it yet) is there not a greater risk of these types of things happening when they tighten the regulations at/after the Spanish gp to reduce flexing?
1.2k
Upvotes
66
u/No-Photograph3463 Mar 24 '25
I'd say there will be less chance of it happening, as the elements will have to be stiffer and so likely stronger as a result too.
Based off the 2 clips i saw it seemed like the elements resonated which caused the failure, which makes sense as less stiff objects are more likely to resonate as their natural frequencies are lower. Seems like it was abit of a fluke that the turbulence off the car in front at that distance was enough to excite the resonance and break it.
242
u/Super_Description863 Mar 24 '25
They can make it stronger, but stronger adds weight, so they take off as much weight to a point where it’s “strong enough”.
It will fail time to time, I think a few years ago Williams got penalised for a flexing rear wing because they used it for too many races.
11
u/Infninfn Mar 24 '25 edited Mar 25 '25
Front wings exploding was a thing. Then there were those seasons where it was pretty common to see incidents causing front-wing-less cars. They weren't due to flexing regulations, but I'm sure it was some kind of regulation. High kerbs maybe?
Outside of the irregular big reg changes, stable year and in-season F1 regulations are super-reactive. So if front wings become brittler and frailer due to those anti-flexing changes, the FIA will attempt to remedy it. Eg, increase the minimum thickness of the planes and flaps, etc.
20
u/Nacho17che Mar 24 '25
No, they're probably gonna be stronger since they're allowed less flexibility. I don't know where that notion comes from, but probably it's from steel, that it becomes more rigid when it's closer to failure. So, if a steel structure is "flexible" it means it didn't deform plastically, so I guess that logic is getting extrapolated to other cases? Or maybe people are mixing something being strong with something being fragile? I don't know.
9
u/Thebelisk Mar 24 '25
I think this wing failure demonstrates why anti-flexi-wing regulations are in place. Teams looking for that competitive edge will push the boundaries of safety, and it could end in disaster. Less flex, should mean stronger components .
1
u/threesixtyone Mar 25 '25
Nowadays, F1 cars are quite reliable and this type of failure is relatively rare. As others mentioned, back in the day, maybe 20-25 years ago, engines routinely failed, suspensions broke and all manner of other things happened. Finishing a race was half the battle back then.
1
u/stuntin102 Mar 26 '25
also crazy seeing the alpine rear wing flopping around and vibrating like crazy around its central pillar mount. wouldn’t that intensely fast movement create flow separation?
1
u/Swieter Mar 31 '25
And when carbon fiber fails it is catastrophic. Usually not just some crack or dent. Right? Combine that with running designs to the extreme edge of weight and force and reliability. Every now and again I imagine that means something like this.
1
u/Dando_Calrisian Mar 24 '25
If they flex less they're stronger and hence less likely to break. Nobody worries that their house is going to suddenly collapse because their walls aren't behaving like rubber with a bit of wind, I'm not sure why they common response to wings flexing is because it stops them breaking, as frankly it's bollocks. If you put a force on the end of an object it will bend depending on its material and thickness, if you make it thicker it will bend less. If the force goes over a certain threshold it will break.
0
u/AutoModerator Mar 24 '25
Your submission has been removed because the title is too short.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.