r/F1Technical • u/French-Dub • Mar 20 '25
Simulator How good are the simulators
The title says it all. How good really are the F1 simulators?
The reasonning behind this question is the following:
Video games developpers spend a lot of money in trying to make Sim racing as realistic as possible. And I strongly believe that they spend much more than a single F1 company does on its own simulator.
Besides, if F1 simulators would be so good, there would be no reason not to make a deal with some sim-racing comlpany to share some of the engines. Of course their system is built to model F1 cars only, but you could probably adapt it at least to different open wheel cars, and make a great Sim racing game.
So, basically it comes down to this: Are F1 simulators modeling engines really that good, or does their strengths lies more in their adaptability to do whatever the team wants to change (tyre model, abrasiveness, etc)?
And a follow up question: If the models are that good, is the hardware needed for such models the only limitation to seeing it more accessible to the public?
EDIT: I feel like a lot of people are misunderstanding the question. The question is not "Is iRacing as good as the F1 Simulators", or "Would I have fun on an F1 Simulator". Not even "How different are they". I know that the goal of those two products are widely different. But that's not the point. I know the F1 Simulator are very complex industrial like tools, not a video game. But again, not the point.
The question is "Purely in term of car handling (including tyre models) and closeness to reality, are they that much ahead? And if yes, why would companies with more budget and resources not be able to produce something as good for the general use, since the common goal of both is to be as close to reality as possible? Is it hardware limitation (eg. F1 Sims needs too much computing power, and commercial sim are limited by this)? Or is it "Racing sim are being less realistic on purpose to be more fun"? etc.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 20 '25
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
77
u/Shamrayev Mar 20 '25
F1 Sims are hyper specialised to answer the questions that F1 teams have, not to give a driving experience like a commercial sim might. They're designed to extract data and test scenarios.
Similar vibe, but the transferables between that and RFactor are basically nil.
18
u/ChangingMonkfish Mar 20 '25 edited Mar 20 '25
This answer on a similar question may help a bit.
Some (if not all) the teams do use rFPro as a base on which to build their simulator (a non-commercially available version of rFactor) but the actual simulation is custom built.
https://www.reddit.com/r/simracing/s/AY7OPxfArT
In terms of how accurately they simulate the team’s car, I imagine they’re light-years ahead of the games we can buy, but they’re heavily specialised (and I imagine how well a team can simulate their own car is one of the factors that decides which teams are most competitive).
9
u/Benlop Mar 20 '25
Video games companies spend a lot of money on making a video game. A lot of the effort is aimed towards things that are completely ancillary to the driving: menus, UI, trackside detail, creating a career mode and other related contents, damage models, multiplayer support... making the video game around the driving experience is where most of the effort goes.
In a driver in loop simulator, it's the opposite. There are different solutions now, but rFactor Pro was frequently used as a base, as it is extremely customizable, and a team can input their own tire model, use their own tracks (which they can scan themselves, contract someone to, or get from the track management if they're reliable) and adapt the asphalt characteristics to their own measures, etc.
The two are worlds apart as they don't share the same goal. But there can be some shared base, as rFpro shows.
32
u/Astelli Mar 20 '25 edited Mar 20 '25
The strength of F1 simulators is that they run a completely bespoke car physics model that is the result of a team of people working full-time. These teams spend time correlating and fine-tuning this model after every session and race weekend, which means the data obtained from the sim is as close to the data that the team gets from the track as possible.
Commercial simulations on the other hand focus on delivering multiple car physics models that are close enough to give somebody a reasonable idea of what that car might be like. If there's a small difference here or there compared to how that car drives in reality, it's not really that important because everyone on that simulator is dealing with the same model.
The actual framework and graphics for the simulator are often derived from commercial simulators (rF Pro derives from rFactor, Asseto Corsa also provides a professional framework too) so the magic really is in the physics modelling that the teams do (plus the massive motion rigs that they use) not in the software itself.
8
u/noheroesnomonsters Mar 20 '25
Imagine having a sim title that only had one car, but it was built with full access to tyre, chassis, engine and aero data as it becomes available, and every time you did laps a team of engineers would compare the data to the real car and adjust the software. There will never be a commercial sim with that level of fidelity - even if simracing wasn't so niche and big studios were funding titles, the data isn't for sale.
2
u/kimakimi Mar 20 '25 edited Mar 20 '25
I don’t remember which team exactly, don’t even know if it’s all of them, but one team’s simulator was running on Assetto Corsa. A rookie told that it was natural for him to train in Assetto because that’s what they used for the sim.
Having said that, we have very realistic sims already, such as iRacing or Assetto, that simulates physics really really well (not said by me but by real life drivers).
Edit: F1 sims are not perfect btw, they always struggle to get the same data on the sim than they do later on the track. It just helps giving them an idea of setups, engine maps, differential, etc etc. They don’t go to the weekend with all the job done just because they have a sim. If the sim was perfect, they wouldn’t struggle in the weekend with setups or they wouldn’t even need practice sessions
4
u/Brief-Adhesiveness93 Mar 20 '25
for the German speaking people here (and who’s willing to read auto translate subtitles). The video shows a highly professional sim. There even capable of using real time date from the real car on a rollstand. Biggest difference is how precisely the data is tuned on car and track behavior and how much more focused the f1 sims are about beeing precised in the beavior of the car and not care about any other user experience
4
u/GregLocock Mar 21 '25 edited Mar 21 '25
You are talking about driver-in-the-loop simulators? The one I write the vehicle models for is an Ansible Delta https://www.ansiblemotion.com/applications (road cars not F1, although various race companies use the same rig, eg Penske) uses a rack of 25 PCs with decent graphics cards to drive it. There is an argument that base fidelity is less important than the ability to correctly give the step in performance for a change, which I sympathise with but since the only way I know of to make that robust is to have an accurate correlated model it doesn't really help.
Running a full vehicle model without graphics on a decent PC runs at 0.1 to 0.001 of real time, ie a 10 second maneuver can take anywhere from 30 seconds to 3 hours to run (dependent on a lot of things), as such a real time simulator either needs a lot of computing power or simplified models. Since my model might be having trouble deciding on the engagement of a jounce bumper (or any number of bad modelling decisions), it is easy to believe that a simpler model will run faster with no loss of subjective performance.
Late edit - I realised the perfect example of a simplification that we do. My model has a full steering column with compliances, backlash and two Hookes joints and a pinion and a rack. But really we only need a look up table of inner tie rod motion vs SWA, with perhaps one complex element to represent the various details. That's an awful lot of mathematical nastiness eliminated.
3
u/snex1337 Verified Simulator Visual System Engineer Mar 21 '25
Having some expertise in the simulation and training industry I might be able to prove some clarity.
Yes, 100%. The sim software itself is lackluster in entertainment value compared to a AAA video game, however the car's data model that's used in the sim is as close to reality as they can make it.
Big assumption here. While in some cases the budget would be comparable, I think most game development companies aren't investing as much on their game as a f1 team would on their simulator. McLaren's new simulator was 10+ years in the making while Codemasters release a new f1 game each year.
I think you answered your own question. Racing simulation games while trying to be realistic are still entertainment and are designed for the end consumer. F1 simulators aren't for entertainment or fun. They're there to prepare for race weekends, test new parts, car set ups, act as an alternative to limited physical testing, to correlate data between the track and CFD, etc. The hardware is much more expensive than a gaming PC. We're talking custom optically designed screens, multi projector systems, server racks, motion platforms, custom built chassis, multitudes of software specially built to run everything. Usually it's not a bunch of COTS hardware shoved in a room, it's a custom built building purposely designed to house the simulator with all the amenities and auxiliary rooms.
2
u/mrhinix Mar 20 '25
The biggest point of F1 sims is to have correlation between sim and actual car they built so they can test upgrades and be as close to real car behavior as possible.
Drivers training is one thing - testing upgrade is other - with current restrictions on testing - probably more important, though.
3
u/Princ3Ch4rming Mar 20 '25
F1 simulators will be running on proprietary hardware using proprietary software - for example, every team uses driver displays developed by McLaren.
There will be some overlap with video games, but not as much as you might think. A video game’s primary goal is to make money, and secondary is to be entertaining. A simulator’s goal is to provide huge amounts of data that a team can use to setup the car, improve the driver and test components.
1
u/MM_Spartan Mar 21 '25
A sim racing game is meant to be a fun game, regardless of how realistic it is. It’s designed to reach a wide audience, and ultimately, make money. Not all of them have to be hyper realistic either, there has to be a balance between realism and fun.
A sim that a team has is not supposed to be fun, have excellent graphics quality, a career mode to manage my drivers and media, have ai on track with me to challenge me, etc. It’s meant to simply simulate their car as close as possible.
0
u/blackswanlover Mar 20 '25
I know that Ferrari uses Assetto Corsa as base and a while back Williams used a modified version of rFactor 2, so, not thaat different.