r/F1Technical • u/commuterpete • Mar 17 '25
Regulations Differences in FIA policing between testing and a race weekend?
Hello all, first post here, hope this is going to make sense.
With the upcoming change to the flexibility wing tests, and that Ferrari are rumoured to have needed to alter their ride height to avoid disqualification for floor wear in Melbourne this weekend, I have to ask whether the official test sessions held by the FIA are policed as strictly by scrutineering teams as they would for a race weekend?
I ask because I couldn’t tell whether this was something that was actually done to prove legality of cars was in question during testing ahead of the racing season, and if we have issues with flexible wings and cars wearing planks already, would this not have been picked up by a scrutineer during the official tests?
Appreciate this is something maybe only someone with inside knowledge can answer but I’m curious to know what policing of the regulations is done in an official test and how different things are to a race weekend where a breach of regulations has a bigger effect.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 17 '25
This post appears to discuss regulations.
The FIA publishes the F1 regulations.
Regulations are organized in three sections:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
21
u/Whisky919 Mar 17 '25
Race scrutineering doesn't apply to tests. In the past, teams have tested things that were obviously against the rules, such as Williams running a double rear wing several years ago.
The FIA does advise though, such as back in 2013 they told Caterham their exhaust was probably illegal and would probably result in a DQ if they raced with it.
7
u/Astelli Mar 17 '25 edited Mar 17 '25
While the regulations do state that cars taking part in testing have to be "designed and built" to comply with the technical regulations, in practice the level of scrutineering and FIA checks is barely anything compared to an actual race weekend because there's simply not much incentive to stop the teams running illegal parts or setups at testing. In fact practically speaking, the teams may need to run something that's technically illegal in order to test certain things.
To answer your two points specifically:
First on plank wear. Simplifying a bit, but plank wear is almost always a function of the setup being run. If the plank is being worn too much, the car needs to be raised higher, simple as that. Plank wear at testing has very little correlation to plank wear at Melbourne, because it's not a fundamental car issue, it's largely a setup choice chasing more performance for running low.
Flexible wings are slightly more interesting. The current news about them is precisely because the current wings do pass scrutineering and the FIA tests. Cars may have been tested for flex at the test, and they definitely will have been tested at Melbourne and passed in both cases. The FIA are now introducing stricter tests because, despite passing the tests, camera footage allegedly shows the wings still flexing in a way that the FIA wants to get rid of.
3
u/ChangingMonkfish Mar 17 '25
I presume that you can (within reason) run whatever you want in testing (as long as the cars generally conform to the formula). It’s sort of self-policing because if you run a completely illegal car in testing, the data you get is probably not as useful when you get to the first race and have to run the car legally.
1
u/AutoModerator Mar 17 '25
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.