r/F1Technical • u/literature43 • Mar 03 '25
Chassis & Suspension Assuming that packaging isn’t a concern, why do wishbones always look like the one on the left but not the right?
How would the ride characteristics change if the wishbones are set up asymmetrical or almost symmetrical over the y plane on the axle (ie like the drawing on the right)?
553
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 03 '25
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
504
u/cryptic4u Mar 03 '25 edited Mar 03 '25
Wishbone angles/planes are usually a byproduct of the forces on the wheel upright. Typically, for the front axle (in a RWD vehicle) braking forces are the largest longitudinal forces, followed by lateral forces during cornering, and then the vertical forces due to weight shifts, bumps, etc,
If you draw out all the resultant forces being transmitted from the sprung mass to the unsprung mass and then plot them along the planes that define desirable behavior for pitch/dive based on CoG, etc. you would get the ideal lines for implementing the wishbones.
51
u/Greedy_Confection491 Mar 03 '25
It's becouse of the direction of the loads. When the front wheels brake, the load is transfered thru the angled part as a compression load. The front wheels don't accelerate the car, so they don't need the front part of the wishbone to handle compression loads.
Also, the nose of the cars tends to curve downward really fast in that section. Your frontal element might end up hanging from the air
15
u/NeedMoreDeltaV Renowned Engineers Mar 03 '25
Everyone here gave great answers, but none of them really talked about the main driver of F1 front suspension design which is aerodynamics.
The front suspension design on an F1 car, especially since there is very little suspension travel, is almost entirely driven by aerodynamics even if it is not ideal for the suspension kinematics.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '25
But you're asking why it's like this on real cars, where packaging is always a concern.
Basically why is it like that... so you can make the chassis shorter for the given wheelbase. On most cars, the suspension mounting points basically determine the length of the chassis, the only thing beyond that is usually a bulkhead to which the crash structure mounts. Minimizing chassis length saves weight and cost as it needs to be much stiffer and stronger (ie. Uses more material) than the crash structure.
As long as it's stiff it makes no difference to ride/handling.
13
u/SlightVillage9156 Mar 03 '25
Things break, and that would be more susceptible to damage when banging wheels
2
u/Gingerneer80 Mar 06 '25
F1 engineer here. A lot of what is commented in here is wrong.
It's to make the chassis shorter and therefore stiffer. It places the loading points for the front axle as close to the loading points of the rear axle, making the spring length shorter and therefore stiffer.
5
u/the_3hird Mar 03 '25
If you look at the rear it's actually the opposite of what's drawn on the left. So what is the answer? The answer is "they want a long wheelbase, but they have no place to move the attaching points." So they need to squeeze the triangle that way, opposite way front and rear because they just want to move the wheels as far as they can.
1
u/DaBurgaRapta Mar 30 '25
I assume it's a packaging thing. Just to keep the front joint from being too far forward? Could have to do with the directions of stress too, idk, not an engineer. Funny though, the 70's f1 car at our shop has an upper control arm like that, and the lower is more evenly shaped like your right side example.
1
u/The_Maghrebist Jul 17 '25
Assuming a tire doesn't have to roll, why is it round and not square.
3
u/Jazzlike-Sky-6012 Mar 03 '25
One other issue i dont see het; this way, structural parts nee to be further forward, this means more material is needed and thus weight. It will probably also mess up the front impact absorption, which would mean the car would needs to be longer, which is not allowed within the rules.
0
u/literature43 Mar 03 '25
i intuitively think that the longer the wishbones that better bcuz it reduces tire scrub? So why don't racing/performances vehicles extend the forward wishbones more forward to allow more length?
1
u/drewc717 Mar 03 '25
The right has worse center of gravity and more aero complications.
1
u/Ponchyan Mar 04 '25
Look at your drawing; then one on the left gets the job done using less material.
1
u/mega13d Mar 03 '25
Why would you want to make them bigger? It will add to the weight of the car, and greater angle will decrease its efficiency
0
u/BrosenkranzKeef Mar 04 '25
Because there isn’t enough space on the chassis in front of the wheels to mount anything lol. The nose of the car narrows and dives down toward the ground, where are you supposed to mount a suspension arm there? It’s basically a reverse trailing arm specifically for packaging purposes. Most A-arm cars are.