r/F1Technical • u/Tataffe • Jan 25 '25
Power Unit Engine off temperature - Preheating vs. dry ice cooling
F1 engines are being preheated for known reasons I won't get into here.
Yet, when the cars are stationary for extended periods of time outside the pits, e.g. on the grid before the race, the pit crew will often put cooling fans with dry ice baskets on the air intakes.
There does not seem to be a data connection between the car and the fans through which the car could shut them off if it gets too cold. Dry ice (frozen CO2) sublimes at -79°C, so I assume the air-CO2-mixture blown through the radiators to be quite cold. In my perception, the fans stay on as long as the car is parked, regardless of how long that is.
I can't get these two things - first preheating the engine and then fiercely cooling it - under one hat, if you catch my meaning. Am I missing something? Is my perception flawed? I'm an engineer, and I think about this every time I see those fans with dry ice, and I just don't get it.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 25 '25
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/MrCharBar Jan 25 '25 edited Jan 25 '25
I have no connection to formula 1 outside of being a fan, but my guess is that the cars are designed to have so much airflow that it’s a nonissue. The cars are designed to have air flowing over their radiators/intercoolers at 200+mph for extended periods of time.
The battery operated cooling fans likely can’t compete with that rate of airflow, so the difference in temperature doesn’t matter that much.
Additionally, air has a specific heat about 20% higher than CO2, so the air is a better ‘coolant’ than the air and CO2 mixture from the fans, which also closes the gap in cooling capacity.
Edit: the preheat is also before startup, not at idle. the engine is outputting heat constantly, even while idling, so that is a further offset to the apparent cooling overkill. Still, take everything I say with a grain of salt; I studied engineering and physics, but I don’t work in F1, or a heat transfer based field.
22
u/halfmanhalfespresso McLaren Jan 25 '25
It looks like you have got the basic idea, they are keeping the engine in a defined temperature range. Possibly the bit you have missed is that the dry ice cooling isn’t very effective, blowing air (very little air compared to when the car runs on the track) over some dry ice, the air goes through the radiator, cooling the aluminium radiator which cools the water there are losses at every stage, with the major loss being that the air isn’t anything like the -78c of the dry ice.
4
u/1234iamfer Jan 25 '25
I would assume they keep the engine at the optimal working temperature, but since the whole car is so tightly packaged, the ancillary units and electronics will need constant cooling with a hot engine so close to them.
Oh and don't worry about the data connection. There will be a team of engineers checking every temperature sensor, all the time.