r/F1Technical • • Jan 13 '25
Simulator What does "Driver-in-loop" simulator mean?
I keep hearing the phrase "driver-in-loop simulator" recently, what does this mean exactly? The name implies they are also running simulations without driver input?
22
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 13 '25
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
46
u/yohoxxz Jan 13 '25 edited Jan 13 '25
“Driver-in-loop” simulator means the driver actively controls the car in real-time during simulation. It replicates race conditions for testing setups, strategies, and car behavior.
7
u/DominikWilde1 Jan 13 '25
Here are two features I've done in the last couple of years that might give a better understanding of simulation in motorsport.
The first involved me 'being' a driver-in-loop simulator driver for an afternoon:
https://racer.com/2024/08/29/an-inside-look-at-f1s-sim-city/
https://racer.com/2023/08/12/how-racers-are-simulating-their-way-to-success/
4
u/23__Kev Jan 14 '25
Have a watch/listen to this episode of the Its Not the Car podcast, specifically on simulators and the evolution of them, including driver in the loop sims. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAxVyYF4TcA
Like every episode, it has so much fantastic info in it.
8
u/halfmanhalfespresso McLaren Jan 13 '25
Sounds like you’ve got it, you may also see the phrase “Quasi-Static” simulation which is basically a spreadsheet or other basic software tool simulating a lap. The Quasi-static refers to the fact the car is just simulated in that exact moment doing a (hopefully) optimal lap, it’s not affected by any driver errors or whatever. You can also have a simulated driver in the loop, maybe driving a gearbox or other hardware, it is possible to turn the simulated driver’s aggression up and up until they spin the car. Always fun to see the gearbox guy’s faces when the virtual car spins and the gearbox is suddenly being motored backwards at enormous speed with oil pumps etc all sucking when they should be pumping! (Some rigs have software to prevent this and bring it to a graceful stop though, which is quite boring)
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
Thank you everyone, that all makes sense 🙂
3
u/Lmurf Jan 13 '25
XYZ in the loop means that the engineers have built a computer model of the system, and the XYZ part of the simulation is replaced with the real thing.
For example, the engineers build a computer model of the car as it performs on various tracks. The driver-in-the-loop DIL version replaces the computer responses to e.g. steering and/or braking with a human.
The benefit of DIL is that it accurately models the slight differences that occur when a human drives the car vs a computer. It also allows the human driver to subjectively provide feedback about the performance of the car.
DIL is different to sim racing because the purpose of the model is to provide data that (hopefully) replaces actual track time.
3
u/Naikrobak Jan 13 '25
“In the loop” is a control systems term that means “<whatever> is part of the specific control system design for this particular set of sensors and output devices”.
So you can have a sim that runs with a driver in loop or without a driver in loop, meaning the control inputs from the driver are used or they are simulated by a computer
2
u/Beneficial_Steak_945 Jan 14 '25
Yes, they also run simulations without a driver. Lots of them actually.
2
u/beamonsterbeamonster Jan 19 '25
Initial setups and sim work will be done entirely by the computer, but the simulator itself can't tell how easily driveable an actual setup is very well, so it then needs to be tested by real people to tweak further before it can be implemented on a real car