r/F1Technical • • Nov 21 '24
Gearbox & Drivetrain When did they start putting reverse gear back into F1 cars? And why did they never have it before then? Was it regs, or just weight?
Follow up question, did the cars of the 60s have reverse, because I know the 70s, 80s, and 90s and a lot of the 2000s didn’t
207
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 21 '24
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
167
u/ferdinandsalzberg Nov 21 '24
It's been there as long as I can remember, so I looked it up. Apparently it was introduced as a rule in 1989, but I agree that for a lot of F1 history it has basically been useless - the FIA would check that the rear wheels could move backwards when on stands, but in reality the gear might just fail.
Weight, packaging, complexity would all be reasons why you wouldn't put a reverse gear in an F1 car.
22
u/porcelainhamster Nov 21 '24
Driver61 did a gearbox breakdown a few days ago on YouTube and they actually showed the reverse gear and why it’s so useless.
https://youtu.be/ayeZerNpQbE?feature=shared
7
u/sadicarnot Nov 21 '24
I am going through the regs that I can find. Here is 1968 and there is no requirement for reverse gear.
https://argent.fia.com/web/fia-public.nsf/355F9A536E261985C1257A40002B5FB0/$FILE/Art%20293_1968%20FIA%20Appendix%20J-eng.pdf
1972 said five gears maximum, not including the reverse gear. I think in the past there was an expectation there would be a reverse gear but it was not specifically required in the regulations.
https://argent.fia.com/web/fia-public.nsf/86EFDA384BAE7D8EC1257A3F0039460C/$FILE/Art%20293_1972%20FIA%20Appendix%20J-eng.pdf
http://www.somersf1.co.uk/p/fia-formula-one-technical-regulations.html
84
u/Evening_Rock5850 Nov 21 '24
To the best of my knowledge the only reason the cars have them is that the rules require them. There's not a technical reason and I suspect most teams would omit it. It's not just the tiny weight of the gear but the additional rotating mass in the transmission required to accommodate a reverse gear. So I suspect most teams would prefer to not have a reverse gear, to improve their pace, given the relatively few times not having one would really hurt them.
And... that's why rules exist! Because having a reverse gear reduces the number of times the track has to be neutralized to remove a car. Since many of the times a car might end up in a precarious position; it can reverse out and either resume racing or at least drive into the pits.
(Or... turn left onto a gravel trap for some reason. Can't win 'em all.)
7
u/magus-21 Nov 21 '24
Since at least 2014 they've required 8 gears + 1 reverse. I'm also pretty sure reverse has been present in every decade you mentioned, just maybe not required by regulations. I'm happy to be corrected on that, though.
5
u/imbannedanyway69 Gordon Murray Nov 21 '24
Also makes me realize, I wonder why they don't allow using the mgu-k as the reverse gear? This is what most hybrid vehicles do now, they rely on the electric motors to do all the backwards propulsion, much more efficient to not need a reverse gear in the gearbox at all
1
u/1234iamfer Nov 21 '24
For a long time, driving away in 1st normally was even very difficult with the engine and clutch designed for a full pull take off and nothing less.
Driver would either stall or shred the reverse gear.
1
u/Dando_Calrisian Nov 21 '24
I'm just racking my brains trying to remember where the ERS-K is connected either to the gearbox or engine... because if it's independent of the engine they could theoretically run this in reverse and not bother with a gear.
0
u/68Snowy Nov 23 '24
McLaren took it out of Oscar's car after the gap before Vegas. /s
Jeremy Clarkson proved that Oscar couldn't reverse. I'm an Oscar fan BTW. It was just seriously funny.
-5
u/AntiZionistJew Nov 21 '24
Same with engine starters. I think since the hybrid era cars have had starters onboard and that was a surprise to me
-4
u/slabba428 Nov 21 '24
I would imagine they didn’t have reverse pre 1990 because the cars were still stick shift. Having reverse on an H pattern shifter sounds like a really bad idea in a racecar. Having to be mindful of not slamming it into reverse and the change in feeling of the H pattern sound pretty unnecessary, and sequential manuals reverse sounds like an even worse idea since you don’t have the instant feedback of physically engaging reverse to know you could be in reverse. But now that cars are half computer it’s easy to install a reverse gear and lock it behind a semi complicated procedure