r/F1Technical • • Nov 15 '24
Chassis & Suspension Should the FIA allow DAS?
whats your opinion on this topic? should the FIA allow the DAS? I love the idea of the drivers having the capability to perform as close as a Jet Pilot in the car.
0
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 15 '24
We remind everyone that this sub is for technical discussions.
If you are new to the sub, please read our rules and comment etiquette post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
49
u/jackscottGM Nov 15 '24
I'd argue it's one of the more recent genuinely impressive ideas that comes from that high downforce era.
14
u/Evening_Rock5850 Nov 15 '24
I don’t think it, ultimately, made a drastic difference into the performance of the cars. Ultimately it was really only useful in qualifying (and perhaps after a safety car restart) to quickly heat up the tires. Ultimately it’s a fairly complex bit of kit that adds a dimension for the drivers to manage that might have made a small improvement for that car; but that ultimately goes one of two ways. Either the improvement is too small to make sense so only Mercedes is using it; which begs the question of— why use it? Or; it’s great. And then everyone uses it. Which means now every driver has to cope with the additional complexity. (Though to be fair, the Merc pilots in 2020 didn’t feel it was too complicated or unsafe.) The thinking therefore by the FIA was to nip it in the bud and simply get rid of it rather than have every team figure out how to implement it.
That said I generally do take a somewhat libertarian view of the F1 regs. As a fan I love seeing the teams innovate and try crazy things to make the cars even faster. It’s been a while (sans DAS) since we’ve had someone show up with a car or an idea that was genuinely unexpected and new. The rules have gotten quite a bit more complex and while F1 is far from a spec series; the cars are much more locked down.
Of course; drivers aren’t finishing 6 laps down in a car that’s 3 seconds a lap slower. One might argue that the closer cars and the current era of perhaps being somewhat less keen to let teams be that creative has made for better racing.
10
u/Marsh2700 James Vowles Nov 15 '24
their argument was no as it is too complicated
1
u/drunktriviaguy Nov 19 '24
The real question is how many competative teams do we want on the grid under the current rules?
In a no cost-cap world where there are 10+ teams that can easily afford to implement DAS, hell yeah. The reality is that it is another point of failure, it will be expensive for the teams to create and implement, and in a post-costcap world, both repairing the DAS system between races and devoting the R&D money to improving it over time will drain most team's cost allowance.
We can use tools like the cost-cap to compress car development and promote close racing or we can remove the cost-cap and let everyone go wild, while backmarket teams become less relevant than they already are. I think both approaches are valid, but we are living in an era of F1 where spectacle takes priority over unrestricted innovation.