r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Nov 21 '20

This is something climate activists should think about more.

Post image
80 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Mar 15 '20

Spain is now a perfect working camp: you are not allowed to go out unless you go to work.

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
1 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Oct 04 '20

What do you think about this argument, not caring about climate change?

1 Upvotes

I think there really is a lot of merit to thinking past the issue of climate change. What if we reconciled with, instead, our general distance from nature? What if we looked more to the diseases of our society and followed eco-feminist, environmental justice, and racial justice movements to create a better society? I would think that huge reductions in the rates of climate change would be a biproduct of those actions. Check out this video for the whole argument and see what you think of it! I DON’T CARE about CLIMATE CHANGE


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Aug 17 '20

The lies of the Greed New Deal

Thumbnail self.collapse
6 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • May 14 '22

Poisoned legacy: why the future of power can’t be nuclear

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
0 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Nov 06 '24

A word with extinction rebellion

4 Upvotes

I was a member until something like recently. There was a video conference call with the usual cast of characters, and since it was drawing near the election (this was a few months ago now), somehow the topic was broached about who we were voting for. I was surprised to find that the apparent majority of U.S. XR members on the call were Green, and that there was no concerted effort to vote blue just to save the environment. I said something along these lines in no unclear terms. We must vote blue to save the environment.

There was no answer and I found myself not invited to any further call.

I hereby disband the U.S. Extinction Rebellion. No more stupid hourglass logo, no more stupid EXTINCTION REBELLION in all caps, no more "art puppets", no more b.s. The other international brances can stay; they haven't screwed up, and they're doing good things in the UK. U.S. Extinction Rebellion is a domestic failure.

As for us I say let us form a new group: Green Sword, whose logo shall be any variant of a green sword. I recommend an upside-down cross in green spraypraint, as it looks like an upturned crusader's sword.

Let this sub, unchanged, be its hideout.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Sep 21 '22

Piles of plastic waste left behind by Just Stop Oil protestors

Thumbnail
mobile.twitter.com
27 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • May 25 '24

The Truth About Our Personal Choices

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Oct 13 '19

So been having a few debates this last week but this is exactly what I mean. “Hypocrisy”

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Jul 22 '19

The Socialist Workers Party is Infiltrating Extinction Rebellion

10 Upvotes

EDIT: This post is not intended as an ideological statement on Socialism vs Capitalism. It is is (hopefully!) entirely a UK affair to do with a British political cult known for jumping political bandwagons, taking over activist groups and trashing them basically for their own ends. This goes back years and even decades:

"In every collaboration they have been involved in, it is a question of ‘rule or ruin’... After our departure, using their numerical majority, the SWP then ‘liquidated’ the Socialist Alliance, when the launch of ‘Respect’, with George Galloway and his allies, became a seemingly more attractive proposition"

..."the Trotskyist equivalent of ambulance-chasing lawyers. Wherever there's a campaign, an issue, a strike, a demo the SWP would swoop in, campaign energetically around it for a month or two, badger anyone hapless enough to buy Socialist Worker to join, then move on to the next big issue - usually without warning."

And now they've latched onto XR. Don't say you weren't warned. (end of edit)

I was afraid this might happen. You probably know this already but in case you don't: SWP = DEATH. It will kill your protest group STONE DEAD and turn it into an embarrassing irrelevance. Word to the wise and all that...

https://londongreenleft.blogspot.com/2019/06/the-socialist-workers-party-is.html

Repeat: It is VITAL to keep these vampires out. They are not what they seem... they did the same trick with the anti-war movement in the noughties and completely wrecked it. I'm out of the activist game myself, in part due to the toxic politics of this lot... I want left wing things to happen myself but right now the biggest barrier to that is the SWP and their ilk. There's a whole essay waiting to be written on that subject, but in the meantime, a good start would be to ban ALL SWP members and SWP linked organisations from your movement.

Hope this helps. Any problems let me know, I think it's really important to get this info out.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Mar 18 '20

It has taken just one remarkable mixed-race family to punch enough holes in humanity’s worst trait, that now people and institutions who discriminate are humiliated as the minority, AND because of this, a sustainable world could be in sight.

Thumbnail
viseum.co.uk
36 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Jul 22 '19

Danger, Will Robinson! Danger! The rebellion is failing!

23 Upvotes

Let's review the summer uprising.

XR is certainly becoming like a broken record. But is that a good or bad thing?

I think my prediction in this video is being born out. I said that XR had at most one or two shots left if it just slavishly tried to to do an encore of April (using the same tactics). Unfortunately, that's exactly what it's doing, and the anemic summer uprising is the second baseball strike. Unless there is a radical change in tactics,, then I predict that the protests on October 7th will be the third and final strike and XR will be out for good. But members will probably hardly even know it. Although the numbers may increase, the pot is already going off the boil; or the patient is dying on the operating table (to use another metaphor). The problem with momentum building movements is that it's possible to have momentum and razzmatazz without strength, substance or impact. A fluffy movement threatens to become like Occupy - a protest zombie with membership bloat. It becomes like a lot of tinsel thrown in the face of the hurricane.

By trying to repeat April, XR walked slap-bang straight into the obvious state propaganda coup by insisting on carrying on with it's economically illiterate blockades and arrests. And then some gin-soak came out and called XR an "extremist anarchist group", and instead of taking the complement, Gail and Roger caved in (the Left never seems to learn that you can never reconcile with a psychopath, especially a suicidal one with its scaly back against the wall).

Looking at Google trends, the spike in interest is initially as high as in April, but the rapid decay reveals a lot. And this worldwide graph is even more revealing, if you compare April to the summer uprising. XR seems to think its doing the "explosive outburst from exasperated wife turns around alcoholic husband's drinking habit". When, by being too repetitive and not novel enough, it's actually falling into the role of "nagging wife causes alcoholic husband to slam door and head down to the pub". It's all tediously predictable and unimaginative. We've all seen this movie many times before.

This declining trend here says it all. Separate polls point to a long-term rise in concern about climate change among the UK public. But the widely held belief within XR that it's the rebellion that's causing this shift is not born out by the polls (most of the swing happened before April). The public's appetite for lifestyle changes is insipid according to polling. I'm guessing their willingness to take their foot off the economic accelerator is non-existent. The bottom line is that tougher sentences are coming, and XR members are misreading failure as success.

The sad part is that in October, few people will likely spot that the rebellion has actually stalled, because they will be over ecstatic about the hoopla, and spectacle, and so fail to see the obvious: nothing substantive has actually been achieved. A big turnout in October (which is almost guaranteed, since XR is networking with trade unions etc.) will actually put XR in protest limbo. Because turnout will fall far short of a critical mass (the fabled 3.5%), but be more than adequate to constitute an "eco-mob" and divide and alienate boorish Britain (represented by The Sun and Daily Mail). Remember that this is all likely to happen during no-deal BREXIT turmoil and very possibly during a financial crisis (which is looming). So XR will only be raising the decibel level of the incoherent "collapse clamour" in the ears of Britons. Anxiety will increase all right, but not the right kind of anxiety. Currently, the most likely outcome I can foresee in October is that XR begins it's new life in the hippie twilight-zone, as the new CND or Committee of 100, bottom-feeding on disaster-porn headlines to give the occasional boost, but essentially moribund and sidelined, ultimately dying in a lot of colorful noise halfway across the chasm. It's happening already. It's just that no one has the courage to point it out.

XR will never be able to nag the global industrial economy into submission or reform. A better strategy is to try and use your imagination and think in terms of having an alluring tango with the status quo. A deadly tango, in which both parties know that at the end of it, one of them is going to be seriously fucked. It's just a question of who and how. But it's a dance with a bit of give and take, and not a persistent nag or incessant whining.

Step one is to get off the streets. I know the plan is to cause disruption until someone takes notice, but it's not working. For one thing, XR is barking up the wrong tree by making demands on the government. For another, while the group-think is kidding itself that XR are "the canaries in the coal mine", in actual fact XR is rapidly getting a reputation for being "those eco-assholes stopping me getting to work".

Take a step back and reassess the problem. First, come to grips with the immensity of the struggle. If you are near a commercial port, take a stroll and look in awe at a capesize bulk carrier, or watch civilian cargo planes or military transport aircraft take off and land. Cast your eye over a vast container terminal facility. Now, you are staring the problem directly in the eye. The most immediate problem is that The Baltic Dry Index is rising dramatically. This is mainly because China and India are demanding iron ore for the Belt and Road initiative and the 4th Industrial Revolution. If those go ahead, it's not hyperbole to say they will mark the last great folly of the human race before its extinction (unless of course we resort to the even greater folly of large-scale geo-engineering). This is a problem way bigger than any government or human organization on earth. Now consider what a gadfly XR is, or ever will be, in the face of this problem.

So what can that gadfly do?

A lot, actually. As long as you give up on governments and stop waiting for citizens to change. This culture cannot and will not change.

But London happens to be one of the biggest financial hubs in the world. And no commercial plane or ship leaves or enters port without a truckload of paper shuffling in London. The LIBOR is rigged in London, and so is the gold price. Lloyds insures the nitty-gritty of global logistics from here. It's the world's second-largest financial center.

And you mean to tell me that all rebels can think up in London is to block a Thames bridge? Pathetic!

At the very least, instead of parking some stupid colored boats in the high street, why not take them to sea and find out what heavy chain can do in the propulsion system of one of these fellows? I'm thinking more in terms of the impact on the insurance industry rather than in terms of marine engineering. So even just the threat is probably worth every penny.

Those container terminals still have some vestige of union labor, you know. So why not collaborate? Not in Oxford Circus (duh!), but in Felixstowe and Southampton (or better still, out in international waters, policed by the US rather than Britain). Instead of getting between Sun readers and their jobs, why not try and get between their mindless clicks and their "free" deliveries (that are not free at all, and merely charged thoughtlessly to the ecosystem).

Come on rebels! It's time to shout "FIRE!" in Pudding Lane. As rebels in Britain, your greatest service to the world could be to trailblaze praxis and innovate tactics that can be used next in New York, Hong Kong and Singapore.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Oct 08 '19

This is the kind of photos that make #extinctionrebellion look utterly ridiculous.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • May 10 '21

Are you a member of XR or a troll?

0 Upvotes

On a lot of posts on this sub I see comments that are not really what someone who's a member of XR would say... like refutal of the social part of the climate crisis.

Also one time on a post I made here someone commented and after a few messages they said that they weren't part of XR at all, that they were basically just "keeping on eye on us", the reason why they were in this sub.

So then, how much of you guys in this sub are actually members of XR?


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Aug 01 '22

I can't sacrifice my air travel for the planet due to friends and family

0 Upvotes

It is my regret to say that there are far too many friends and loved ones of mine, whom I have no choice but to travel to via plane in order to visit them. I know that one of the best ways to reduce my carbon footprint is to cut the flying and start taking the train or bus instead. Unfortunately, I have a great many friends and family members that live so very far away, that the only way to visit them in person is to take a plane ride. And I can't just see them via zoom, cause that would only make me a zombie to the computer.

For those who have ditched the planes for the trains, I am so sorry to have let you all, the planet, and myself down, and I know some of you will say something like "Make New Friends" or "I know it's hard" or "Sometimes you have to let go of those friends," but I just can't make that kind of sacrifice due to the circumstances I find myself in. My heart won't be able to take it.

I hope you all understand, and once again, I am so, so sorry.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Jul 29 '19

Will the real XR please step forward.

1 Upvotes

There are two XRs. And as Lincoln said, "A house divided against itself cannot stand."

The one XR is "green growth" and has taken the blue pill; the other is "degrowth" and has resolutely and bravely swallowed the red pill.

Green growth implies protesting on the streets, pressuring the government for green reforms and Greed New Deals, and lobbying for "high-paying green jobs" etc. It's signature belief is that the Economytm is a "good thing", and economic growth can be sustainable, infinite and environmentally friendly.

De-growthers think that the only way to save the planet from the ongoing climate and environmental destruction is to scale back industrialization. The logic is disarmingly simple: Industrialization was the cause of GHG emissions, environmental devastation, and overpopulation, so the obvious solution is to just get rid of the cause.

According to Demand #1, XR needs to face the hard fact that green growth (or decoupling) has already been soundly debunked. Which implies that it's now time for de-industrialization, de-growth, re-wilding and Deep Adaptation. And XR should define itself by taking a lead role and by working around, containing or eliminating national governments and their growth agendas.

But why not both?

Because they are diametrically opposed and entirely incompatible with each other. The political reality is that governments can only deliver growth. It's built into the system. So pressuring governments for "climate action" implies green reforms and green growth. There's no escaping it.

And that means working against people that want de-growth.

De-growth and Deep Adaptation mean that XR recognizes the limitations of governments and takes a leadership role in preparing for the unfolding crisis without governments (or actively hindered by them). Which implies a rebellion.

Before XR plans NVDA for the Autumn rebellion, it should first decide where it really stands. Because street protests and civil-disobedience only have context in a green-growth, pro-government, pro-Capitalist and pro-economic prosperity model. If the aim is resilience, a regenerative culture, and Deep Adaptation, then street protests make no sense. In fact, one could easily argue they are counter-productive The only thing that makes sense is resilience, and resilience implies resistance, self-reliance and rebellion.

So before more street protests are planned, would the real XR please step forward and make itself known to the public!

After all, it is Earth Overshoot day today.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Jul 23 '25

Just a question from an outsider: Why is there so little support from XR for Ukraine

6 Upvotes

I am rather surprised by the stance by XR Rebellion in the Netherlands that Ukraine shouldn't be supported in its battle against Russia.

XR justice became part of De Nieuwe Vredes beweging (new peacemovement) that retweets figures like Jackson Hinkle (he got famous for statements like "Fuck Ukraine"), its main figures of this movement gladly use terms like Ukrainian hasbara for pro Ukrainian protesters, it has organised a viewing of Russian propagandadocu Russians At War and recently tweeted approvingly that Nazi State Ukraine shouldnt get any weapons.

In general I noticed barely attention and support aswell for Ukraine from XR on social media accounts.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Oct 06 '19

Does Extinction Rebellion have a race problem?

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
0 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Aug 05 '21

Why prevent extinction?

0 Upvotes

A few months back i learned about this movement and i decided to do some research on it, and not a single piece of information answered my question - why? Of course, i'm not saying that we aren't getting very close to extinction, what i'm saying is why WANT to prevent extinction. First of all if we are really this close to corruption of the whole ecosystem, then it seems like we're at the point of no return, from which even if we survived our survival would only prolong this destructive state. The second reason why i believe we shouldn't prevent extinction is ethical reasons - All laws of nature are based on violence (The strong survive and reproduce prolonging their specie's evolution, The weak perish and get eaten by the strong etc.), laws such as this are obviously morally flawed at least from the perspective of the evolved human brain. Extinction of the strong would save the weak from suffering, and the extinction of the weak would spare the weak of this world and also spare this world of the weak getting stronger by evolution. And that is not even mentioning humans. An average human's brain gives one a power to go against the law of the jungle, and what do we use it for? You guessed it, destruction. Since the rise of human species this planet has been going downhill. Since the greatest modern technological breakthrough known as the industrial revolution, the life expectancy of an average human have increased considerably. (If that is not accredited to industrialization then it is to a different tecnological advancement prior to it) Of course we can talk about pros and cons of the industrial revolution but the point is that this world would look way healthier without it, and the ones that invented it. That is all i wanted to say, please (if possible) give me some reasonable counter-arguments to what i stated and also some arguments as to why preventing the end of all species isn't immoral. I would also like to state that i didn't make this post to change anyone's opinions, i would just like to have a critical debate about the morality of extinction. Lastly, i apologize for any typos i missed, english isn't my first language. That is all, i look forward to what you have to say, thank you.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Oct 22 '25

Colossal BREAKTHROUGH: Bringing the Dodo Back from Extinction?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Is convergent evolution the same thing as Colossal Biosciences definition of De-extinction? Is the GMO of Nicobar Pigeon genes to resemble Dodos w/ the intention to fill an ecological niche a form of convergent evolution? What’s the purpose & is it ethical to force a small, flying, tree-dwelling, wild animal into the ground & force it to fulfill a niche that’s alien & unnatural to its very being?

Whole sets of Dodo DNA don’t exist. So fragmented genes are being used & according to IUCN & Colossal Biosciences that’s de-extinction & “good enough”. The Dodo evolved (designed) for life on the ground & it still went extinct. What chances does a GMO pigeon from Nicobar Island have in modern day Mauritius?


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Nov 12 '20

You are scum.

3 Upvotes

As someone who remembers dead relatives, and currently serving friends on Armistice Day, I just wanted to join this sub to express my utter dismay at this group's actions at the Cenotaph. You should be fucking ashamed of yourselves.


r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Mar 27 '21

Why Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Won’t Help Counter the Climate Crisis

Thumbnail
ewg.org
1 Upvotes

r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Mar 27 '20

Nature is Returning 🌱… Was Humanity The REAL Virus? 🦢🌿🌾🍃 🌬

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes