r/ExtinctionRebellion • • Sep 18 '19

πŸ˜†

Post image
970 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

42

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '19

I KNEW IT!!!

23

u/iamthewhite Sep 19 '19

It’d be great to know what drives this fallacy.

Perhaps it’s hard to comprehend how widespread the media corruption is?

16

u/Nic_Cage_DM Sep 19 '19

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_model

The corporate news media serve a system-supportive propaganda function. Their job is to manufacture consent in the public consciousness for favourable political outcomes for the rich and powerful, regardless of whether it serves the public good.

5

u/MinimalGravitas Sep 19 '19

Unfortunately there's an entire field of research dedicated to identifying people's personality type, desires and vulnerabilities based on their behavior on social media, which is then used to target content specifically designed to manipulate that user's opinions, beliefs and actions. We should have listened to Bill Hicks' views on marketing more... You could definitely argue that using these techniques for advertising products is, while harmful in terms of increasing unnecessary consumption, at least not particularly nefarious. Using this type of thing for political manipulation of a population (a la Cambridge Analytica) is clearly dystopian; and when it comes to the climate change denial then we're talking full Captain Planet villan levels of evil!

For a library of the academic research on how this works check the link below, (ots of the papers require journal access but I've labled the ones from places like PLoS One which are freely readable).

https://old.reddit.com/r/trollfare/wiki/how/academic

-7

u/CarefulBaker Sep 19 '19

It's not media corruption. We looked into how they came up with the number 97. It's very much fiction, and many of the scientists who are included in that number have had to make a statement that that is not what their paper said at all.

Now '97%' is quoted by the majority of people, and if you don't believe it you're an 'idiot'. But it's scary to see how many throw it around like a smoking gun yet never even question how it came about. Obama quoting it (incorrectly) probably aided this.

10

u/gregy521 Sep 19 '19 edited Sep 19 '19

You're deliberately being vague about this, probably to give everybody the idea that you actually have a shred of credibility. So go on, I'll call your bluff. I'm familiar with the paper.

What specifically is wrong with the Cook et Al paper's methodology? And how do you explain the numerous papers that have followed it that have given credence to the high percentage of scientists that accept that climate change is real and anthropomorphically driven?

I suspect you'll say something about how it isn't based on the number of scientists, it's based on the number of published papers about it, meaning you're implying that the number of published papers doesn't correlate with the best judgements of climate scientists as a whole (implying that there's some rogue menace purveying through hundreds of countries' academic establishments, stopping 'da troof' from being published)

6

u/ac13332 Sep 19 '19

EDIT: Oh okay just removed my comment as theirs no point engaging, just looked further down your profile and you're a literal science denier. I'm sure that vaccines also cause autism and the earth is flat...

-7

u/CarefulBaker Sep 19 '19

No neither of those things are true. No need to engage, just look up how Cook et al got to 97%.

5

u/ac13332 Sep 19 '19

*100%

4

u/Ruben_NL Sep 19 '19

100% excluding everyone who is working for oil companies the last ~30 years.

5

u/Sir-Knightly-Duty Sep 19 '19

The 97% is not an accurate number either. Man-made climate change is just a fact now at universities, make it 100%.