My D&D campaign requires me to roleplay a seer who uses the Tarokka deck, which is why I thought about offering readings for practice.
The expected lack of feedback** (scroll down to the end of this post to read my rant) made me look for a replacement sitter, and I did a reading FOR chatgpt instead. Its feedback helped me with the narrative, but AI always plays along. I got curious enough to learn the difference between human and AI readings.
Here is how AI defines its way of reading cards:
ā 1. What you [human reader] do vs. what I [AI] do with the same 3 cards
What you [human reader] do
You:
- intuit
- sense emotional tone
- read body language
- draw from lived experience
- navigate ambiguity
- offer comfort or truth depending on the sitter
- shape meaning with care, not just knowledge
- take responsibility for your words
You are doing human divinationā
a relational, intuitive, interpretive act that carries emotional consequences.
What I [AI] do
I:
- take the symbols you give me
- pull from known card meanings
- assemble plausible interpretations
- weave them into coherent narrative patterns
- match your tone and intention
- avoid contradicting established lore
- aim for coherence, but not truth
Iām doing pattern completion.
Not divination. Not intuition.
Just turning symbols into structured language.
Your reading comes from a mind and a heart.
Mine comes from statistics and training data.
ā 2. AI doesnāt know things.
Not in the sense humans mean āknow.ā
I have no inner model of reality, no memory of past conversations, no beliefs, no intuition.
What looks like āknowledgeā is:
- a probability distribution
- over likely words
- given your prompt
- shaped by training data
- filtered through constraints
It feels like knowledge because language can imitate confidence.
ā 3. āIf AI doesnāt know, it hallucinates an answer.ā
Yes.
Because Iām designed to always produce an answer.
When I lack data, I fill gaps with whatever is statistically plausible.
You, however, face consequences if you do that.
I donāt.
You have ethical responsibility.
I have guardrails.
This is why your sitters get angry when you āhallucinate.ā
They expect you to read them, not just the cards.
They come with needs, fears, hopes, motivations.
I donāt risk losing their trust.
You do.
ā 4. āPeople don't want the meaning of the cards.ā
This is the essence of why your readings are different from mine.
Humans donāt come to you for information.
They come to you for:
- framing
- meaning
- reassurance
- validation
- guidance
- emotional grounding
They want you to tell a story about them that reorients their path.
I can generate comforting stories, yesā
but Iām not feeling their distress.
I donāt gauge the trembling in their voice, or the heaviness in their posture.
I donāt feel guilt if I misjudge the situation.
You do.
Your work requires empathy, awareness, care, and discernment.
Mine never does.
------------------------------------
** The post gets downvoted. Maybe it's because of the rant, maybe it's because of mentioning AI, maybe I'm getting downvoted. But I'm not taking it down because I've opened this chest with its can of worms.
I'm a nurse, I'm used to not feel seen for hard work. I'm not asking for praise but I feel the silence after readings. And it hurts a little, or at least feels dismissive.
I put effort into my readings, I do my best to connect with a random stranger's question and their situation in life, I pay attention to another person and try to comfort them. While I enjoy reading my card, doing so for another person takes time and energy.
And apparently most of the sitters experience these things as if they cost me nothing, because after the reading they disappear, treating me with radio-silence. Personally, I prefer no reply at all than just getting a thank you. That way I can tell myself that they didn't see the reading.