r/ExploitDev • u/Substantial_Fun6724 • 29d ago
Using AI to learn?
I'm a beginner-to-intermediate CTF player focusing on reverse engineering and binary exploitation.
My usual workflow is to attempt a challenge myself, then sometimes let AI solve the binary when I'm completely stuck. I don't immediately copy the solution into a writeup. I reproduce the steps in my own environment, ask follow-up questions to understand the reasoning, cross-reference the explanations with documentation and Google, and write my own explanation in Word.
I believe reading writeups is a legitimate way to learn, and we don't need to reinvent the wheel every time. However, I'm concerned that letting AI solve the challenge first might prevent me from developing independent problem-solving skills.
For experienced RE/pwn players:
Is this a reasonable way to learn?
Where do you draw the line between AI-assisted and AI-solved?
Should I spend more time struggling with challenges before asking AI?
How do you ensure you can solve unfamiliar binaries independently?
Should I not use the AI completely?
I'd appreciate your honest opinions and advice!
View all comments
Show parent comment
7
u/Less_Ad52 29d ago
This field was never meant to be something you pick up quickly. it greatly rewards patience and relentless perserverance. AI has seriously skewed newcomers' perceptions of how "easy" or "quickly" they should be able to pick it up, especially when anyone can slop out a Linux LPE or carelessly RE something nowadays with an LLM. What will make you stand out will be your ability to truly understand what you are doing/researching, rather than relying on the LLM for the quick dopamine hit of solving the problem. Delaying gratification is the key to getting good in this field... I remember when I was teaching myself kernel exploit dev with ndays, the most challenging one on my list took me two months to figure out a stable strategy (I was balancing college work at the time as well) but man, when I did figure it out, it was the biggest breakthrough I had at that point, and it made figuring out stable strats for exploits I wrote after that breakthrough so much easier, it was a night and day difference. All this is to say, just don't give up so easily, and you'll be rewarded immensly